\"Writing.Com
SPONSORED ITEMS
Daily Flash Fiction Challenge
Enter your story of 300 words or less.
Beachcomber
She's lost. Will he find her this time?
Example Quiz: Writing.Com History Trivia
An example quiz about Writing.Com that uses Correct Scoring.
Writing.Com Images For Upgraded Members
Need a new look? Grab a Writing.Com image to spice up your posts and emails!
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Quicksand Weather
She's been living in a hole in the ground
Year 2121
It is unsafe outside
Things I've made.
A list of things I've made.
The Ghost Thrust
A flaw during construction ends up revealing something we never thought possible
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sindbad
Review Requests: ON
2,788 Public Reviews Given
2,797 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I want an honest opinion
I'm good at...
I am sensitive to minor details.
Favorite Genres
Any
Least Favorite Genres
Horror and erotic
Favorite Item Types
Science fiction
Least Favorite Item Types
Erotic
I will not review...
Religious, or illogical.
Public Reviews
<   1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  ...   >
1
1
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This is an intriguing chapter that effectively shifts the scale of the story from a personal dilemma to a high-stakes supernatural conspiracy. Below is a detailed review of Chapter 2.4 - The Plan.
## Overall Impression
This chapter serves as a pivotal "bridge" in the narrative. It successfully transitions the reader from the ethereal, abstract world of spirits into a more grounded, tactile setting by using the "Aaru" simulation. The dialogue is heavy with exposition, but it feels earned because it’s framed as a secretive initiation. The shift in Vero’s character—from a standard mentor to a potentially subversive revolutionary—adds a layer of tension that keeps the reader questioning the true motives of the "Divine Crusade."
### Key Strengths
* Sensory Grounding: The description of Zarad inhabiting a human body for the first time is excellent. Phrases like "the very density of moving a physical body... akin to wearing a really thick and uncomfortable coat" provide a wonderful contrast to the spiritual existence previously described.
* The "Secret History" Trope: Revealing that the Elder Council is "tone-deaf" to the Presence is a classic but effective hook. It immediately complicates the morality of the world—if the leaders aren't actually being led by the divine, then the status quo is built on a lie.
* Pacing and Atmosphere: The transition from the clinical, expanding hallways to the cozy, human-like dwelling with a fireplace creates a sense of intimacy and "hushed tones" appropriate for a conspiracy.
### Character Analysis
Vero: He is the standout here. His "wet wood" analogy is a bit patronizing, but it fits the mentor archetype. However, the reveal that he is keeping secrets from the Elders and encouraging Zarad to do the same makes him a morally grey figure. Is he a liberator or a manipulator?
Zarad: His vulnerability is his greatest trait in this chapter. His desire to be reunited with Aloli makes him the perfect target for Vero’s "secret deal." His internal monologue about the loss of 360-degree vision and telepathy helps the reader empathize with the "clumsiness" of being human.
### Suggestions for Improvement
* The "Wet Wood" Metaphor: While the analogy is clear, Zarad’s reaction ("Are you comparing me to a wet piece of wood?") is a bit on the nose. You might consider making the dialogue a bit more subtle, or have Zarad feel the sting of the comparison internally rather than speaking it aloud.
* Technical World-Building: The "Fugue for the soul" is a terrifying concept. Expanding slightly on why it’s considered barbaric—perhaps a brief flash of a memory of a "broken" soul—would heighten the stakes of what Zarad is avoiding.
* The Medallion Reveal: The transition to Vero offering to teach Zarad the symbols feels a bit fast. Given that these symbols are "only known by the Elders," the gravity of Vero sharing them could be emphasized more to show just how much of a risk he is taking (or claiming to take).
### Summary of the Conflict
The chapter sets up a classic Internal vs. External conflict:
* External: The mission as Caretaker and the looming "War of Shadows."
* Internal: Zarad’s loyalty to the system vs. his personal love for Aloli and his trust in Vero...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
2
2
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega


This is a compelling and atmospheric chapter that effectively bridges the gap between the ethereal and the high-stakes celestial politics of your world. You’ve managed to ground a very abstract setting (the spirit realm) with relatable emotional stakes: the fear of loss and the pain of being separated from a loved one.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the chapter:
Strengths
1. World-Building & Sensory Detail
The description of Tartarus as a "spirit grinder" is visceral and terrifying. It creates an immediate sense of danger that keeps the spirit realm from feeling too "safe" or airy. I particularly liked the detail of the crescent-shaped table containing a miniature moving universe; it visually reinforces the Elders' scale of power without needing a long exposition.
2. Character Dynamics
The contrast between Nariphil (stern, authoritative) and Cyra (empathetic, maternal) provides a classic but effective "High Council" dynamic.
* Vero’s behavior is also a highlight—his nervousness and the way he "shrinks inward" when Zarad defies the Elders humanizes him and shows that even powerful guides have stakes in this hierarchy.
3. The "Uncanny Valley" of the Elders
Describing the Elders with identical, featureless faces and black slits for mouths is an excellent choice. It makes them feel truly "other." By stripping away human expression, you force the reader to focus on the weight of their words and the "colors" of their energy.
Areas for Improvement
1. Dialogue Pacing
In the middle of the council scene, there are moments where the Elders exchange lines very rapidly. While this shows their unity, some of the dialogue feels a bit "on the nose."
* Example: "So ungrateful," another one said.
* Tip: You might vary these reactions. Instead of just speaking, perhaps one Elder’s light flares or pulses with irritation. This uses your established "energy signature" rules to show emotion rather than just telling it through dialogue.
2. The "Ribbon" Introduction
You mention several times that manifestations "introduce themselves" or "explain their purpose."
* Critique: This is a cool concept, but if used too often, it can feel like a "video game" mechanic where every object has a tooltip.
* Suggestion: Try to weave these "introductions" into Zarad's sensations. Instead of the beams "explaining" they are shields, perhaps Zarad feels the immense pressure of the void pushing against the walls and senses the beams' "stubborn defiance" in response.
3. Zarad’s Probing Subplot
Zarad’s mental wandering into the room with the "red being" is an excellent hook. However, the transition back to the council is very abrupt.
* Tip: Give us one more lingering thought or "after-image" of that red face. It creates a great sense of mystery—is that a prisoner? A different species? A "dark" soul? Ensure the reader feels Zarad’s lingering curiosity.
Technical Observations
* Formatting: The use of Earth Dates and Locations provides a necessary anchor for the reader.
* Pacing: The chapter moves well from the horror of the void to the awe of Aaru, ending on a "ticking clock" mystery (the danger of the void "tasting" his light).
Overall Impression
This is a strong "Call to Adventure" chapter. You’ve successfully moved Zarad from a passive observer to a character with a difficult choice: Personal growth vs. Romantic attachment. The Soul Sphere job sounds like a fascinating "lonely watchman" trope that provides plenty of room for character development...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
3
3
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega


This is an intriguing second chapter that does a lot of heavy lifting for the world-building of Soul Census. It successfully transitions from the personal grief of a "broken bond" to a much larger, cosmic scale.
Here is a detailed review of Chapter 2.2 - Spirit Animals.
Overall Impression
The chapter excels at metaphysical atmosphere. The concept of "Ethereal Artisans" creating simulations of Earth to teach lessons is a clever narrative device. It allows you to ground the abstract "Spirit Realm" in sensory details—the smell of grass, the cold texture of stone—while maintaining the eerie reminder that these things are just "machinations." The pacing is steady, moving from a personal dialogue to a philosophical lesson, and ending on a high-stakes hook.
Key Strengths
* World-Building Mechanics: The "density rings" and "transference rings" that introduce themselves are a great touch. It suggests a realm that is sentient or programmed with an inherent logic that even the inhabitants find slightly tedious but respect.
* The Deer/Leopard Sequence: This is the highlight of the chapter. It provides a concrete example of "The Cycle" and "Life Contracts." The deer’s lack of resentment toward its predator is a powerful way to show the difference between human ego and spirit-level understanding.
* Vero’s Characterization: Vero feels ancient and patient. Using the "monk" visage provides a clear visual for the reader and establishes him as a bridge between Earthly religion and Ethereal reality.
* The Hook: Ending with a promotion to the "Elder Council" and a trip to "Aaru" raises the stakes perfectly. It shifts Zarad from a passive victim of fate to an active participant in something much larger.
Areas for Improvement / Observations
* The "Purple Blot" Visual: The purple mark signifying ascension is a strong visual, but the dialogue about it feels a bit repetitive. Zarad mentions he didn't know how he got it, then Vero explains it, then Zarad realizes it again. You might benefit from tightening the dialogue where they discuss his "Restoration Specialist" work to make the revelation feel punchier.
* The "Sex" Dialogue: The transition into the conversation about sex felt a bit abrupt. While it serves to show Zarad’s lingering "Earthly" attachments, the dialogue: "Sex is not a requirement for progression" feels a little clinical compared to the poetic nature of the rest of their talk.
* Clarifying "The Fugue": You mention "The Fugue" toward the end. Since this is Book 1, ensure that earlier chapters (or the very next one) define this clearly. If it's the "forgetting" that happens during reincarnation, it’s a great term, but it’s dropped in here quite quickly.
Thematic Analysis
The central theme here is The Conflict of Attachment. Zarad is a spirit, yet he is grieving like a human.
> "We invariably bring it all here, sculpting from memory that which we covet from Earthly existence." This quote is the thesis of the chapter. It highlights the irony that even in "perfection," spirits still yearn for the "imperfections" of Earth. This makes Zarad a very relatable protagonist; even though he is a glowing spirit, we recognize his heartache.
>
Technical Breakdown
| Element | Rating | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Pacing | 4/5 | Moves smoothly from the hill to the lesson to the departure. |
| Dialogue | 4/5 | Vero’s "typical teacher" questions are well-written. |
| Imagery | 5/5 | The crescent-shaped canyon and the translucent deer are very vivid. |
| Clarity | 4/5 | The metaphysics are complex but explained through action rather than just "info-dumping." |
Final Verdict
A strong, contemplative chapter that deepens the lore of your universe. It successfully moves the plot forward while giving the reader a "soul’s eye view" of how life and death function in your world...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
4
4
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This excerpt from "Soul Census - War of Shadows - Book 1" is a poignant, high-concept introduction to a metaphysical world. It successfully blends the "cosmic" scale of reincarnation with a deeply personal, relatable tragedy: two people growing apart, quite literally by nature of their own evolution.
Here is a detailed review of the chapter:
### 1. Concept and World-Building
The mechanics of the "Spirit Realm" are the highlight here. Using colors (yellow, green, purple) to represent spiritual advancement is an effective visual shorthand for the reader.
* The Celestial Pool: This is a strong narrative device. It establishes the "catalog of time" and the idea that lives are chosen rather than accidental, which adds weight to the characters’ choices.
* The Fugue: Introducing "temporary amnesia" explains why characters don't have these realizations while on Earth, setting a clear boundary between the spiritual and physical planes.
* The Conflict: The idea that "leveling up" spiritually can actually destroy a relationship is a tragic and unique hook. Usually, advancement is seen as purely positive; here, it’s a barrier.
### 2. Character Dynamics
The interaction between Zarad and Aloli feels ancient and lived-in.
* History: The mention of the 1252 Mongol invasion gives the reader a sense of the immense scale of their history. It grounds their ethereal forms in human trauma and experience.
* Tone: The dialogue starts playfully—with the "gender switch" and "ethereal foreplay"—making the sudden "repelling energy" feel much more shocking. It moves from intimacy to isolation very effectively.
### 3. Pacing and Style
The pacing is steady, moving from world-building to the inciting incident (the failed union) with good momentum.
* Strengths: The sensory details—the "marbles of blue energy," the "tinkling flakes," and the "green energy flow"—make a very abstract setting feel tactile.
* Areas for Polish: Some of the internal monologue regarding Zarad’s realization ("He knew immediately what had happened") is a bit repetitive. We see him suspect it, then confirm it, then mourn it in quick succession.
### Suggestions for Improvement
* The "Council" Mention: The mention of "The Council" feels a bit like a "namedrop" for future plot. It might be more impactful if we had a tiny hint of why they wouldn't allow a soul to slow down (e.g., is there a cosmic quota? A war?).
* Show, Don't Tell (Emotions): You describe Aloli as being "upset" and having "negative energy." Since they are spirits, perhaps her light could flicker, turn a jagged shape, or emit a discordant sound to show that distress more viscerally.
* The Ending: The final image of the "dying candle flame" is beautiful. It perfectly captures the loneliness of a soul who has literally outpaced his partner.
Overall Impression
This is a compelling start. It takes the "soulmate" trope and adds a layer of biological/spiritual "compatibility logic" that creates immediate stakes. It leaves the reader wondering: Can Aloli catch up, or is Zarad destined to move on to a higher plane alone?

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
5
5
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This chapter of "Soul Census - War of Shadows" is a sharp, atmospheric blend of 1930s noir and high-concept science fiction. You do a great job of grounding "cosmic" stakes in the gritty, cynical perspective of the protagonist, Maddock.
Below is a detailed review of the entry, broken down by its core elements:
🟢 Plot & Worldbuilding
The worldbuilding is the standout feature of this chapter. The concept of Census as a bureaucratic bridge between the living and the dead is fascinating, especially with the 1933 setting.
* The Soul Census Monolith: Using Roman numerals to track "Lost" vs. "Recovered" souls is a clever way to quantify the stakes. It gives the reader (and Maddock) a clear "scorecard" for the mission ahead.
* The "Rapture" Reimagined: Linking the Black Death (75 million dead) to a technological/spiritual crash of the "Soul Sphere" is a brilliant historical revisionist twist. It moves the story from simple "ghost hunting" to a larger-scale sci-fi mystery.
* CycleCon: The vertical light system (1–5) is a classic sci-fi trope that works well here to establish the "health" of the afterlife, adding a sense of ticking-clock tension.
🟢 Characterization
* Maddock: He is a quintessential noir lead—irreverent, observant, and unimpressed by authority. His dialogue is dripping with period-appropriate slang ("gum bumping," "hooey," "bearcat"). His cynicism serves as the perfect "everyman" lens to explain complex concepts without the scene feeling like a dry info-dump.
* Wolfe: He plays the "straight man" perfectly. His frustration with Maddock’s nicknames (Wolf-ee, four-eyes) provides good comedic relief and establishes a "buddy-cop" dynamic that will likely carry the series.
* Director Black: Though she appears briefly, her "no-nonsense" attitude sets her up as a formidable foil to Maddock’s chaos.
🟢 Pacing & Tone
The tone is consistent throughout. You have successfully maintains a "Hardboiled Sci-Fi" vibe. The pacing is handled well through the use of a "walking tour," which allows the environment to change (The Atrium, The Galley) while the characters exchange vital plot information.
* The Séance Scene: This was a highlight. It provided a brief, haunting glimpse into the "Caretaker" and the "Timeless Dimension," showing rather than just telling how the Soul Census operates.
💡 Tips for Improvement
* Slang Density: While the 1930s slang adds flavor, it occasionally borders on "cartoonish." Using "doll," "skirt," and "bimbo" all within a few paragraphs makes Maddock feel a bit one-dimensional. Softening the frequency of these terms might make his rare moments of sincerity (like catching Wolfe's glasses) hit harder.
* Formatting "The Voice": When Akshat (the Caretaker) speaks through the static, consider using italics or a different indentation to make the "otherworldly" nature of the voice stand out more visually on the page.
* Physics of the Sphere:
Maddock deduces that the Sphere is in New York because of the "unlit" area on the globe. It might be helpful to clarify why it's unlit—is the Sphere's presence creating a "signal jammer" effect for soul signatures?
Final Impression
Soul Census is an imaginative take on the afterlife. By combining the aesthetic of The Twilight Zone with the grit of a Raymond Chandler novel, you have created a unique hook. The mystery of the "Caretaker" and the danger of the "lost souls" provide a strong narrative pull for Book 1.
Overall Rating: 5/5 Stars

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
6
6
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This is an punchy, atmospheric opening that effectively blends 1930s noir aesthetics with high-concept science fiction/fantasy. It establishes a strong "fish out of water" dynamic while maintaining the gritty voice of its protagonist.
Here is a detailed review of the chapter:
1. Tone and Atmosphere
You’ve done a great job capturing the Hardboiled/Noir voice. The use of period-appropriate slang—"dingus," "pasting," "heaters," "java," and "ciggy"—roots the character of Maddock firmly in 1933. This creates a sharp, engaging contrast with the "Soul Sphere" setting, which feels sterile and futuristic (onyx floors, smoked glass, "rubber-like" walls). The clash between the Great Depression era and this metaphysical bureaucracy is the story’s strongest hook.
2. Character Dynamics
* Maddock: He comes across as the classic "tough guy" with a chip on his shoulder. His reaction to stress—resorting to physical violence—is consistent with his background. His internal monologue about "bubs" and "pretty hazel eyes" further cements that 1930s pulp-fiction persona, though it borders on the trope-heavy side.
* Black: She serves as a solid foil to Maddock. She is authoritative and unimpressed by his bluster. The power dynamic is interesting because while she holds all the cards (the ability to send him back to the streets), she clearly needs his specific skillset.
* Wolfe: He plays the "antagonistic colleague" well. The bickering over the "three conditions" adds a touch of much-needed humor to an otherwise tense scene.
3. Pacing and Action
The pacing is brisk. Moving from the "Orientation" room to the hallway via a supernatural physics interaction (the wall caving in like rubber) is a clever way to show, not tell the strange properties of this world. It breaks up the dialogue and keeps the reader engaged with the environment.
4. Areas for Improvement
* The "Third Condition" Logic: The banter about whether "java and a ciggy" counts as one or two things is funny, but Maddock’s third condition (the suit) feels a bit rushed. It’s a great character beat—showing he wants to belong or at least look the part—but a few more sentences of him admiring the suits earlier might make the "demand" feel more earned.
* Sensory Details: You’ve nailed the visuals (onyx, sea shells, matte white). You might enhance the "Noir" feel by leaning into the smell and sound—the hum of the Soul Sphere versus the silence of the hallway, or the lingering scent of ozone.
* Formatting/Typos: There is a minor typo in the line: "...rather unexpectedly lent him a hand up." (Should likely be "lent" or "offered").
Overall Impression
This is a high-energy "recruitment" scene. It successfully transitions the protagonist from a man with no future to a man with a "spiffy suit" and a supernatural job. The mystery of the "War of Shadows" is hinted at just enough to make the reader want to see Maddock’s first "on the job" assignment.
Final Rating: 5/5 Stars — A stylish, fast-paced entry that promises a unique genre mashup...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
7
7
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Redtowrite

This is a powerful, emotionally resonant piece of historical fiction that tackles the grim reality of racial injustice in the American South through a multi-generational lens. By framing the story as a struggling writer discovering a hidden past, the narrative bridges the gap between the 1930s and the present day.
Overall Impression
"The Weight of Hate" is a poignant exploration of how past traumas linger in the physical and emotional landscape of a community. The contrast between the "superficial beauty" of the Mississippi town and the brutal history of the noose in the oak tree is striking. The story excels in its character-driven perspective, particularly through the voice of Eleanor Swift, whose letter provides a chilling look at the complicity of "good" people in systemic violence.
Strengths
1. Compelling Narrative Structure
The use of a "story within a story" (the writer discovering the letter) works exceptionally well. It allows the reader to process the horror of the lynching through Eleanor’s retrospective guilt, which adds a layer of moral complexity.
2. Vivid Imagery and Atmosphere
Your descriptions of Dunbar create a strong sense of place. The juxtaposition of the "sweet smell of country ham" and the "fresh as a flower" victim against the "gurgling noises" of the execution is gut-wrenching and effective.
3. Emotional Resonance
The character of Majesty Lawson provides a beautiful, peaceful counterpoint to the violence. Her contentment and connection to the land offer a sense of grace, and the act of cutting down the rope serves as a necessary, symbolic resolution for both the characters and the reader.
Tips for Improvement
1. Refining the Pacing of the Intro
The first two paragraphs focus heavily on the narrator’s career struggles and writing habits (coffee, turnovers, Miles Davis). While this establishes the narrator’s "everyman" persona, it feels a bit long.
* Suggestion: Consider tightening the opening to get to the "Mississippi article" faster. This ensures the reader's attention is gripped by the central conflict sooner.
2. Showing vs. Telling in the Conclusion
In the section where the narrator meets Majesty, there is a paragraph beginning with "I told her she had made me think about life..." that borders on being a bit "preachy" or "on the nose."
* Suggestion: Instead of the narrator explicitly stating that "there is still racism in a lot of America," let the imagery of the KKK still being active in the town and the rope still hanging in the tree carry that message. The reader will feel the weight of that truth more deeply if they arrive at the conclusion themselves.
3. Dialogue Tags and Flow
Some of the dialogue and internal monologue could be smoothed out for a more natural rhythm. For example:
* “I am sure finding those letters was like extracting gold for the journalist that wrote the story.” * Adjustment: You might try something more active: "To the journalist who found them, those letters must have been pure gold."
Technical/Historical Context
The story accurately reflects the grim statistics of the era. Between 1882 and 1968, there were 4,743 recorded lynchings in the United States; of those, 3,446 victims were Black. Your portrayal of the "sham trial" and the lack of due process aligns with the historical reality of the Jim Crow South, where the legal system was often used as a tool of intimidation rather than justice.
Final Thoughts
The ending is incredibly moving. The image of Majesty passing away with a "content smile" after the "weight of hate" was removed from her ancestral land is a masterful way to close a dark chapter. This is a story that stays with the reader long after the final sentence...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
8
8
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This is a strong, atmospheric opening that does a lot of heavy lifting in a short amount of space. You’ve successfully blended historical fiction, noir, and high-concept sci-fi/paranormal elements.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the chapter:
Detailed Story Review
1. The Hook: The "Nightmare" Prologue
The chapter opens with a classic "cold open." Starting with the SPAD XIII dogfight is a smart choice because it provides immediate stakes and character depth.
* The Emotional Core: We learn that Maddock isn't just a tough guy; he’s haunted by a specific trauma—the accidental death of a comrade. This gives him a "ghost" that will likely drive his decisions later.
* Technical Detail: Your use of period-accurate terms (Boches, Fokker D VII, SPAD XIII) adds a layer of authenticity that makes the transition to the strange "Soul Sphere" even more jarring for the reader, in a good way.
2. Atmosphere & World-Building
The shift from the "icy knives" of the cockpit to the "onyx and smoked glass" of the Reflection Room is excellent.
* The "Life Replay": This is a standout sci-fi element. Describing a man in the desert in "clearer color" than anything Maddock has seen perfectly highlights the technological gap. It suggests that Maddock's captors possess a technology that perceives the world—or perhaps the soul—differently.
* The "Water Bubble" Wall: This is a great visual. It’s evocative and "alien" without being over-described, allowing the reader’s imagination to fill in the physics.
3. Character Dynamics
* Maddock: He feels like a true 1930s protagonist. His internal monologue ("Where the hell am I?") and his reactionary aggression ("cracking heads") are consistent with his background.
* Agent Wolfe & Director Black: You’ve established a classic "Good Cop/Bad Cop" (or in this case, "Crass Agent/Professional Director") dynamic. Wolfe provides the snarky friction, while Black provides the plot-propelling authority.
* The Dialogue: The dialogue is snappy. Maddock’s use of "dame" and "caper" anchors the 1933 setting, while Black’s clinical tone sets her apart as something "other."
Suggestions for Improvement
* Pacing the Revelation: The transition from Maddock waking up to being offered a job happens very quickly. You might consider adding a moment where Maddock tries to find a physical exit—pushing on the glass or the "rocky" wall—to emphasize his feeling of entrapment before the wall "pops" open.
* Sensory Details: You’ve nailed the visuals. Adding a specific smell to the room (perhaps something ozone-like or unsettlingly sterile) could further contrast the "filthy clothes" and alleyway grit Maddock just came from.
* Formatting Tip: In the dialogue section, ensure you keep the 1933 slang consistent. Maddock’s reaction to the "bubs" comment feels very much like a pulp-novel protagonist, which works well for the genre.
Final Verdict
5/5 Stars. It’s an engaging, professional-quality start. You’ve successfully moved the protagonist from a recognizable world into a mystery, and you've given him a personal burden (the war guilt) that makes the reader want to see him find redemption...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
9
9
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This is a compelling opening chapter that effectively blends the gritty atmosphere of 1930s Noir with hints of speculative sci-fi. Below is a detailed review of Soul Census: War of Shadows – Chapter 1.1.
Overall Impression
You’ve done an excellent job establishing Willem Maddock as a classic "disillusioned veteran" archetype. The transition from the rain-slicked streets of New York to the traumatic "flashback" of the Great War is seamless and provides immediate depth to his character. The pacing is tight—moving from internal reflection to physical action, and finally to the central mystery—keeping the reader engaged throughout.
Strengths
1. Atmospheric World-Building
The sensory details in the opening paragraphs are top-notch. Phrases like "dilicapidated buildings shook," and "the sky retreated away as if distancing itself from the scum on the ground" set a moody, oppressive tone. You successfully capture the "Great Depression" era feeling of hopelessness.
2. Character Voice
Maddock’s dialogue and internal monologue feel authentic to the 1933 setting. His refusal of the "good meal" and his cynical outlook on "Uncle Sam" make him a protagonist the reader wants to see challenged. The "brass knuckles" vs. "Jessie the revolver" detail is a great way to show his financial desperation without "dumping" information on the reader.
3. The Hook
The introduction of Agent Wolfe and the "Plan B" abduction creates an immediate "inciting incident." The mention of a "stun gun" (a technology that shouldn't exist in 1933) effectively signals to the reader that this isn't just a historical drama—it’s something much more unusual.
Tips for Improvement
1. Tightening the Action
The fight scene is clear, but some of the descriptions could be punchier.
* Example: "He felt and heard the chin music of a loud crack signaling a broken jaw."
* Suggestion: Consider removing "signaling a broken jaw." The "chin music" and "loud crack" already tell the reader exactly what happened. Letting the reader infer the injury usually feels more visceral.
2. Dialogue Punctuation & Grammar
There are a few minor "copy-editing" spots that would make the prose even smoother:
* Conscience vs. Conscious: In the line "he was no match for his own conscious," it should be conscience (the moral sense of right and wrong).
* Breath vs. Breathe: When Maddock says, "Relax... Breath," it should be Breathe (the verb).
* The "Dame" scream: You mentioned the lanky hood was "screaming like a dame." Since "dame" is used several times in the chapter, you might swap one instance for a different period-accurate descriptor (like "canary" or "broad") to keep the vocabulary fresh.
3. The "Flashback" Transition
The moment where the thunder triggers the memory of his SPAD XIII is beautiful. To make it even more jarring (in a good way), you could emphasize the sensory contrast: the smell of ozone/rain in NY vs. the smell of oil and cordite in the cockpit.
Final Rating & Summary
Rating: 5 / 5 Stars
This is a professional-grade opening. You’ve balanced the "tough guy" exterior of your lead with a haunted interior, and the cliffhanger ending ensures the reader will click "Next" to find out who "Auntie Sam" really is...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
10
10
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
AJVega

This is a compelling snapshot of a high-concept Urban Fantasy/Historical Fiction hybrid. Based on the summary and chapter structure provided, here is a detailed review of the premise and presentation of Soul Census — War of Shadows.
### The Hook & Concept
The premise is the strongest asset here. Combining the grit of post-WWI New York City with a bureaucratic supernatural organization (“Census”) creates a "Men in Black meets Constantine" vibe that feels fresh.
* The "Census" Idea: Using reincarnation as a regulated process—complete with agents and "lost souls"—is a fantastic high-concept hook. It provides a clear framework for world-building and infinite mission-of-the-week potential.
* The Stakes: Moving from "cracking heads" in haunted houses to a "Nazi agenda" and "war on heaven and hell" shows a clear escalation of stakes, which is vital for an action-adventure series.
### Character & Motivation
Willem Maddock fits the classic "disillusioned veteran" archetype. This is a smart choice for this setting because:
* Relatability: His struggle with poverty and lack of purpose makes him an underdog the reader wants to root for.
* Skill Set: His military background justifies his ability to handle the physical "head-cracking" aspects of the job.
* The "Why": The offer of coffee, a meal, and a purpose is a grounded motivation that makes his transition into the supernatural world feel earned rather than forced.
### Plot Structure & Pacing
Looking at the chapter titles, the narrative arc seems well-organized into distinct phases:
| Phase | Chapters | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| The Induction | 1.1 – 1.4 | Recruitment, "The Atrium" (World-building), and Orientation. |
| The Lore | 2.1 – 2.4 | Introducing soulmates, spirit animals, and the "Plan." |
| The Action | 3.1 – 3.6 | Specific threats (The Pooka), rituals (Baptism), and high-level entities (The Reaper). |
Observation: The jump from 1919 NYC to a "Nazi agenda" (which typically implies the late 1930s) suggests either a significant time jump or that the "War of Shadows" spans decades. If it's the latter, that’s a bold and interesting narrative choice.
### Critical Analysis & Tips for Improvement
* Genre Blending: The transition from a gritty noir/poverty beginning to a "Nazi world takeover" is a massive swing. The author needs to ensure the "Spirit Realm" logic bridges these two worlds seamlessly so the reader doesn't feel like they've stepped into a different book halfway through.
* The "Census" Bureaucracy: Bureaucratic supernatural agencies are popular (like the TVA in Loki or the Ministry in Harry Potter). To stand out, the author should lean into the specific "1920s" flavor of this bureaucracy—think pneumatic tubes, heavy typewriters, and cigar smoke.
* Chapter Entry Dates: I noticed the chapters were entered over a span from 2015 to 2021. This suggests a long development period. For a reader, this implies the author has lived with these characters for a long time, which usually results in deep lore, but requires careful editing to ensure the tone remains consistent across those years.
### Overall Impression
Soul Census has the "bones" of a successful commercial series. It offers a gritty historical atmosphere paired with an imaginative take on the afterlife. It appeals to fans of Hellblazer, The Umbrella Academy, or Shadow and Bone.
> The Verdict: A high-octane premise with a solid emotional core. The "reincarnation management" hook is unique enough to catch a publisher's (or a dedicated reader's) eye.

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
11
11
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

This is a classic "celebratory" poem. It’s unashamedly optimistic and rooted deeply in a blend of romantic devotion and spiritual faith.

1. The Rhythmic "Engine"
You’ve opted for a very consistent, driving rhythm. Each line is split by a semicolon (a caesura), creating a "da-da-DUM, da-da-DUM" feel.
* The Pro: It’s catchy. It feels like a song or a traditional hymn. It gives the poem a sense of momentum and "God’s plan" orderliness.
* The Con: Because the rhythm is so rigid, the reader starts to predict the next beat before they even read the words. When poetry becomes too predictable, the reader’s brain tends to skim the meaning to get to the rhyme.
2. The "Rhyme Trap"
This is the biggest hurdle in the piece. There are moments where it feels like the rhyme is driving the poem rather than the emotion driving the rhyme.
* Example: "A far reaching vision, we’ll handle concision" or "His efforts beg clarity, with timed regularity."
* The Critique: "Concision" and "regularity" are very clinical, technical words. They feel out of place in a poem about "Cherished Love." They sound more like a performance review or a clockwork manual.
* The Fix: Don’t be afraid to break the rhyme if it means using a word that actually describes how you feel. A "slant rhyme" (words that almost rhyme but not quite) is often more powerful than a forced perfect rhyme because it feels more human and less "programmed."
3. Mixed Metaphors
In the first stanza, you mention "fun wealth," but in the last, you mention we’ll "nickel and dime."
* In common English, "to nickel and dime" someone usually means to be cheap or to argue over small, annoying amounts of money.
* If you mean "living simply" or "enjoying the small things," you might want to rephrase that. Right now, it accidentally suggests the couple is going to bicker over the check at dinner!
4. Abstract vs. Concrete
The poem lives almost entirely in Abstract Land (fortune, health, vision, power, mercy, clarity, value). These are big ideas, but they don't paint a picture.
* Non-AI Tip: Show us the "Cherished Girl" without telling us she’s cherished. Does she have a specific laugh? Does the "knock on the door" have a specific sound?
* The strongest line you have is the very first one: "A knock on the door, we’ll reconnect more." It’s a physical action. We can see it and hear it. The rest of the poem flies up into the clouds of "blessed institutions," and we lose sight of the people involved.
The "Gut Punch" Verdict

The poem is a sincere tribute to faith and partnership. It reads like a very heartfelt anniversary card or a wedding toast.
To take it to the next level:

Try writing a version of this without the semicolons in the middle of the lines. Force yourself to write longer, flowing thoughts that don't have to rhyme every four syllables. You’ll find that your "voice" comes through much more clearly when it isn't trying to hit a drumbeat.
Let’s take Stanza 3. This is the one where the "technical" words (like ascertains, pluses, regularity) are doing the most damage to the romantic mood.
Here is a side-by-side of the original versus a "de-cluttered" version that keeps your rhyme scheme but swaps the "corporate" vocabulary for "heart" vocabulary.
The Comparison
| Original (The "Technical" Version) | De-cluttered (The "Human" Version) |
|---|---|
| Ascertains all the pluses; converts, never cusses. | She gathers the goodness; she heals what was broken. |
| Engaging the soul with God’s mercy, control… | A peace for the soul, where the Spirit has spoken. |
| His judgment’s high standing, a voice that’s commanding. | His grace is our anchor, a strength never-ending. |
| His efforts beg clarity, with timed regularity. | A love that is steady, forever ascending. |
Why these changes matter:
* Ditching the "HR Speak":

Words like ascertains and pluses sound like a performance review. By changing it to "gathers the goodness," you’re describing an action she takes, which feels more intimate.
* Softening the "Control": In the original, the word "control" feels a bit heavy-handed for a love poem. Swapping it for "spoken" gives the feeling of a gentle whisper or a prayer, which fits your religious theme better.
* The "Regularity" Problem: Timed regularity is probably the least romantic phrase in the English language (it sounds like a fiber supplement advertisement!). By changing it to "forever ascending," you keep the "R" sound but turn a boring mechanical concept into a beautiful visual of something rising toward heaven.
One Final Tip for the Whole Poem:

You have a habit of using semicolons to force a pause in the middle of every single line. It makes the poem feel like it’s "hiccuping."
Try this: Read the de-cluttered version aloud without stopping at the middle of the line. Just let the sentence breathe. It feels much more like a song and much less like a list of bullet points...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
12
12
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

This is a dense, evocative piece that feels like a "state of the union" address delivered through a fever dream. Your’s "Patriotic Spirits: Vitriolic Reckoning" captures a profound sense of institutional disillusionment balanced against a fierce, protective hope for the next generation.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the poem:
## Overall Impression: The Weight of the "Reckoning"
The poem lives up to its title. It is vitriolic in its critique of current systems (leadership, healthcare, law) but remains patriotic in its spiritual concern for the "sweet, adorable angels" who must inherit the mess. The tone is elevated and somewhat prophetic, using a high-register vocabulary to paint a picture of a society at a breaking point.
## Key Themes & Imagery
* The Failure of Authority: Chiu doesn't pull punches when describing leaders. Phrases like "intestinally shiftless" and "recklessly irresponsible healthcare providers" suggest a visceral disgust with those in power. The "preening like buzzards" simile is particularly sharp—it portrays authority figures not as protectors, but as scavengers feeding on a decaying system.
* The Vulnerability of Youth: The heart of the poem lies in the "yearning hinges of our youths." There is a recurring worry about the "teetering and withering" futures of young people. This creates a high-stakes emotional core that prevents the poem from feeling like a purely political rant.
* The Contrast of Light and Dark: * Darkness: "Wintry days," "nature’s infernos," and "collegial chaos."
* Light: "Noontides," "sweet, adorable angels," and "marvelous strength."
* The "noontide" is used ironically here—usually a symbol of clarity, it is where the "highest champions" are defaced, suggesting that even in the light of day, corruption is visible and unabashed.
## Stylistic Analysis
| Feature | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Vocabulary | High-level and abstract ("efficacy," "progenitors," "adjudicators"). This gives the poem a formal, almost biblical weight. |
| Structure | Free verse with irregular stanzas. The flow mimics a rising tide of frustration that eventually breaks into a prayer-like blessing at the end. |
| Tone | Initially indignant and sharp, shifting toward a protective, spiritual plea in the final stanzas. |
## Critical Reflections & Tips
1. The Power of "Intestinally Shiftless":
This is the standout phrase of the poem. It’s a unique way to describe a lack of "gut" or courage. In a poem full of abstract concepts, this physical, visceral imagery hits the hardest.
2. Balancing the Abstract:
The poem occasionally leans heavily on "adjective-noun" pairings (e.g., variable hymnals, precision adjudicators, vocally euphemistic). While these sound prestigious, they can sometimes feel a bit "cloudy."
* Tip: To make the "reckoning" feel even more urgent, grounding a few more lines in concrete, sensory details (the smell of the "inferno" or the sound of the "chaos") could provide a sharp contrast to the philosophical language.
3. The Conclusion:
The shift to "May God forever bless..." provides a necessary emotional release. After such a heavy critique of the world's "prosecutors" and "conspiracies," ending on "marvelous strength and wherewithal" offers the reader a sense of resilience rather than pure despair.
## Final Verdict
This is a sophisticated piece of social commentary. It captures the specific anxiety of a "hectic age" where the guardians of society seem to have abandoned their posts, leaving only the "caretakers" and the "angels" to find a way through the fire...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
13
13
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

This is an intriguing piece that uses the mechanical and social atmosphere of a bowling alley to deliver a broader message about resilience and self-worth. It balances the technicalities of the sport with a "clean slate" philosophy that feels quite uplifting.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the poem:
## Theme and Message: The Philosophy of the Reset
The core strength of this poem is its optimism. You’ve framed bowling not just as a game of skill, but as a practice in emotional regulation.
* The "Clean Slate": The middle stanzas emphasize that "low scores don’t collect and sink." This is a powerful metaphor for life—the idea that our past failures don't have to carry over into our next "frame" unless we let them.
* Separation of Worth from Performance: The line "Scores will not reflect one’s worth" is the emotional anchor of the poem. It challenges the competitive urge to tie happiness to a number on a screen.
## Structure and Rhythm
The poem follows a consistent ABAB rhyme scheme across six quatrains.
* The Cadence: The rhythm is generally "punchy," mirroring the sound of a ball hitting pins or the mechanical reset of the pinsetter.
* Word Choice: You use some very evocative, albeit slightly abstract, imagery. Phrases like "Streets on fire" and "Finding turtle" give the poem a surreal, high-energy opening that settles into a more grounded, instructional tone by the end.
## Technical Breakdown
| Element | Observation |
|---|---|
| Imagery | Strong use of sensory details ("smell sweeter," "trace that grain," "stickiness"). |
| Tone | Shifts effectively from intense action ("kicking ass") to gentle encouragement ("joy and mirth"). |
| Accessibility | Very high. Any bowler—amateur or pro—will recognize the frustration of an "abysmal lane." |
## Tips for Improvement
While the poem is rhythmic and encouraging, a few areas could be tightened to enhance the flow:
* The Title: "Such a Just Beef" is a very unique phrasing. If this is an anagram or has a specific inside meaning to the bowling community, it works; otherwise, it might confuse a general reader.
* Abstract Phrasing: The line "Finding turtle, stickiness" is a bit cryptic. If this refers to a specific bowling term (like a "turtle" slow ball), it's great, but if it’s purely metaphorical, it might feel a bit disconnected from the "Streets on fire" line immediately following it.
* Grammar/Flow: In the stanza starting with "Past is over...", the transition to "Grabbing, strutting, swerving great" feels a little crowded. Consider if "swerving" is the best verb for the "new slate" feeling, or if something more "straight" or "solid" might contrast better with the previous failures.
## Final Impression
This is a refreshing "sports-meets-spirituality" poem. It captures the unique camaraderie of the lanes and offers a gentle reminder that we are all allowed a "reset" when things go south. It’s a great fit for the "Inspirational" category...sindbad.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
14
14
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi
Norswede

This chapter of Embraced By Darkness marks a pivotal shift in the narrative, moving from external teenage angst to a more internal, psychological, and supernatural conflict.
Here is a detailed review of the chapter, focusing on character development, atmosphere, and pacing.
Plot & Narrative Flow

The transition from the "real world" of the therapist's office to the "dark world" of Emily’s dreams is handled with effective contrast.
* The Session: The introduction of Dr. Lowe provides a necessary grounding for the story. It establishes that Emily’s behavior isn't just teenage rebellion; it’s severe enough to warrant professional intervention.
* The Twist: The most compelling part of the plot here is the subconscious bait-and-switch. Emily expects to see a comforting figure (Josh) but instead sees a romanticized version of her "darkness." This adds a layer of manipulation—is this mystery man a suppressed memory, or a predatory entity mimicking her desires?
Character Analysis
Emily
Emily’s defensiveness feels authentic. Her internal monologue regarding her grandmother’s dementia is particularly poignant; it grounds her fear in a "realistic" family trauma (the fear of hereditary insanity) before the supernatural elements take over.
> Note: Her quick shift from "sarcastic/guarded" to "excited" about the mystery man at the end of the session shows her vulnerability. She is desperate for a connection that makes sense of her chaos, even if it’s dangerous.
>
Dr. Lowe
She serves as a classic "unwitting catalyst." While trying to help Emily with relaxation techniques, she accidentally opens the door for the entity to reach Emily more clearly. Her "condescending smile" makes her a character the reader—and Emily—initially dislikes, which heightens Emily’s isolation.
The Mystery Man / The Entity

The shift in perspective at the end of the chapter is chilling. Switching to his POV reveals that he is not just a dream but an observer. His possessive language ("soon they would be together forever") successfully shifts the tone from a YA romance-mystery to a supernatural thriller.
Atmosphere & Imagery
The author uses sensory details effectively to distinguish the two settings:
* The Office: High-end, academic, and safe (leather couches, mahogany, lemon slices).
* The Dream: Visceral and electric. The description of the man—silver-blonde hair and piercing blue eyes—contrasts with the "darkness" of the title, suggesting he is a "wolf in sheep’s clothing."
Strengths & Areas for Improvement
Strengths
* Strong Hook: Ending the chapter with the entity's perspective creates a high-stakes cliffhanger.
* Thematic Depth: Comparing the "hellish realm" to the grandmother's "peaceful dementia" is a sophisticated way to explore Emily's mental state.
Tips for Improvement
* Dialogue Tags: In the session with Dr. Lowe, some of the dialogue tags (e.g., "Dr. Lowe gave her that condescending smile...") are used frequently. Varying how the tension is shown through body language (fidgeting with the lemonade glass, looking at the ocean) could add even more texture.
* Pacing: The transition from Emily hating the session to "Thank you! That is a really cool idea!" happens very quickly. Fleshing out her internal hesitation a bit more might make her eventual acceptance of the "mystery man" feel even more tragic.
Final Verdict
Chapter 3 successfully raises the stakes. It moves the story beyond a simple "haunting" and into a psychological battle where the protagonist might be falling in love with her own tormentor...sindbad.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
15
15
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi
Joey Says...Where's Winter?

This is a classic "shaggy dog" story—a humorous narrative that builds up with a seemingly serious or moralistic tone, only to pull the rug out from under the reader with a sharp, irreverent punchline.
Here is a detailed review of the piece:
Overall Impression
The story is highly effective because it plays with expectations. By setting the scene in a Southern Baptist church and using a "test of faith" trope, you lead the reader to expect a story about moral failure or spiritual growth. Instead, it pivots into a situational comedy sketch. The pacing is excellent, and the dialogue feels authentic to the setting.
Strengths

* The "Slow Burn" Setup: The author spends a good amount of time establishing the stakes—Jake’s long work hours, the strain on the marriage, and the pressure from the mother-in-law. This makes the reader invest in the couple's "struggle," which makes the payoff much funnier.
* Character Voice: The dialogue between the mother and daughter feels grounded. The mother’s solution—"take him to church"—is a very realistic portrayal of a specific cultural mindset.
* The "Misdirection" Punchline: The real humor isn't that they broke their fast; it’s the location and manner in which they broke it. The pastor thinks they failed in the privacy of their home, but the reveal that they are banned from the grocery store (Albertson's) implies a much more public and scandalous "lapse" than the pastor realizes.
* Rule of Three: The story uses the "Rule of Three" beautifully. Jake describes three temptations: the laundry, the vacuuming, and finally the grocery store. This builds the tension until it snaps.
Tips for Improvement
* Show, Don't Tell (The Fidgeting): The description of Jake becoming "fidgety" as a "sure sign of fidelity to an experienced man of the cloth" is a great line. However, the author could add one or two more physical descriptions of Jake’s discomfort in the pew to heighten the comedy of his "abstinence."
* The Transition to the Store: The jump from the house to the grocery store is a bit quick. A sentence describing their frantic energy as they tried to "escape" the house might add to the comedic desperation of the characters.
* Formatting/Grammar: There are a few minor punctuation slips (e.g., "its like he just takes me for granted" should be "it's"). Cleaning up the apostrophes and commas would polish the professional feel of the piece.
Final Verdict
The story is a delightful piece of flash fiction. It manages to be "racy" without being explicit, relying on the reader's imagination to fill in the blanks of what happened in the frozen food aisle. It’s a witty commentary on the gap between rigid religious expectations and the reality of human nature...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
16
16
Review of Mirage Part One  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi
Sethorion

This first installment of "Mirage" is a compelling blend of urban fantasy and high-fantasy portal fiction. It establishes a strong central hook: the blurred line between a teenager’s neurodivergent-coded "creations" and a tangible, magical reality.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the story’s elements:
1. Narrative Structure & Pacing
The story utilizes a dual-narrative structure that effectively builds tension. By jumping between Kyle’s internal experience in "Tresgar" and the clinical reality of the hospital, you create a "Inception-style" layer of stakes.
* The Transition: The shift from the car accident to the coma world is handled smoothly. Using the name "Keil" in the fantasy world helps distinguish the two states of being while maintaining the character's identity.
* Pacing: The training sequences (archery, fencing, magic) move quickly. While this establishes Keil as a "chosen one" figure, it risks feeling slightly rushed. However, the sudden intrusion of the hospital reality (the rising heart rate) serves as a great "pacer" to remind the reader that time is running out in the real world.
2. Character Analysis
* Kyle/Keil: He is an empathetic protagonist. His "Creating" in the real world—making stars in puddles and leaf-monsters—makes him feel like an artist trapped in a world that doesn't see what he sees. His reluctance to use "Magical warfare" in Chapter 3 adds moral depth; he isn't just a power-hungry hero, but a thinker.
* Kya: She is the most enigmatic figure. Initially presented as an imaginary friend/wish-fulfillment, her appearance as a leader in Tresgar raises the primary question of the story: Is Tresgar a real dimension Kyle has accessed, or is his subconscious mind building a complex world to keep him from dying?
* The Antagonists: Hezron and the beast Megolith provide immediate physical stakes. The snake attack at the end of Part One serves as a classic cliffhanger that transitions the story from "training" to "survival."
3. Themes and Symbols
* Escapism vs. Reality: The story plays heavily with the idea of "Creating." In the real world, it makes Kyle an outcast. In Tresgar, it makes him a savior.
* The Stone Dagger: A classic "Chekhov’s Gun." By making it a one-use item, you’ve increased the tension for future chapters. The reader will be constantly wondering if the next threat is "big enough" to justify using it.
* Physicality of Thought: The detail that Kyle can feel pain from his creations is a vital "grounding" element. It prevents the fantasy world from feeling too low-stakes.
4. Technical Breakdown & Tips for Improvement
| Element | Strength | Area for Improvement |
|---|---|---|
| World Building | The concept of "Creating" is unique and visually evocative. | The rebel base feels a bit "generic fantasy." Adding more unique sensory details about Tresgar’s environment would help it pop. |
| Dialogue | The conversations between Keil and Nicodemus feel natural and philosophical. | Some of the "Council" explanations feel a bit like "info-dumping." Try to show their desperation through action rather than just Kya telling Keil they trust him. |
| Action | The snake (Megolith) attack is visceral and high-stakes. | Ensure the mechanics of the "Portal Charm" are explained a bit more so it doesn't feel like a Deus Ex Machina. |
5. Notable Quote/Moment
> "The individual leaves fitted together into a patchwork of what looked like birds feathers... A car came around the bend and hit Kaltag... The leaves scattered everywhere and the car drove past. Kaltag came back together on the other side."
>
This is the strongest piece of imagery in the story. It perfectly illustrates the fragile yet resilient nature of Kyle’s mind before the accident.
Overall Impression
"Mirage" Part One is a very promising start. It successfully makes the reader care about Kyle’s survival in both worlds. The mystery of whether Kya is a real person, a memory of "Casey," or a hallucination provides a strong emotional core that should be explored further in Part Two...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
17
17
Review of Crypt of Flesh  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Daniel Harris Blacke

This is a visceral and technically demanding piece of poetry. "Crypt of Flesh" is a "self-elegy"—a funeral song for oneself—written from the perspective of an unborn child.
It utilizes a highly rigid, percussive structure to mirror the biological and emotional violence it describes.
Here is a detailed review of the poem, broken down by its thematic impact and technical execution.
Thematic Analysis:
The Voice of the Unseen
The poem’s power lies in its unflinching perspective. By personifying the embryo, the author shifts the narrative from a political or social debate into a personal, horrific experience.
* The Title: "Crypt of Flesh" immediately recontextualizes the womb—traditionally a place of life and safety—into a tomb.
* The Tone: There is a transition from sorrow to "malice." It begins with the sadness of a life "stripped away" and "thrown away," but evolves into a vengeful consciousness in the fifth and sixth stanzas.
* The Conflict: The final quatrains are particularly jarring, using aggressive language ("Conscious bitch!") to highlight the betrayal the speaker feels toward the host.
Technical Execution & Form
The poet provided an incredibly dense "blueprint" for this poem, and the execution of those constraints is what gives the piece its unique "heartbeat" rhythm.
1. The "Heartbeat" Meter (Quatrains 1-4 & 7-8)
The 3-3-3-3 syllable structure creates a staccato, pulsing effect.
* Effect: Because the lines are so short (catalectic), the reader is forced to pause frequently. This mimics the thumping of a heart or the gasping of breath.
* Enjambment: By breaking sentences across these short lines (e.g., “I knew my / fornicate- / hated fate”), the poet creates a sense of fragmentation, as if the speaker is being physically pulled apart.
2. The Structural Shift (Quatrains 5-6)
The shift to 6-6-9-6 syllables provides a "widening" of the lens.
* Metaphor vs. Reality: Quatrain 5 is atmospheric ("casket's made of fear"), while Quatrain 6 is clinical and violent ("slaughter, carnage").
* The "Headless" Pentameter: The 9-syllable line ("It's murder, slaughter, carnage and death") feels intentionally crowded and breathless, rushing the reader toward the "embryonic demise."
3. The "Parenthetical" Interjections
In the final two stanzas, the words in parentheses—(How can you), (while they), (I'm being)—act as a "second voice" or a subconscious thought occurring between the heartbeats. This is a brilliant use of experimental typography to represent a fractured consciousness.
Critical Impression
Strengths:
* Rhythmic Precision: The poem succeeds in its goal of "mimicking a heartbeat." You don't just read the poem; you feel its pulse.
* Internal Rhyme: The use of "slant" rhymes (like fate/genesis or fear/near) keeps the poem from feeling like a nursery rhyme, maintaining its dark, gritty atmosphere.
* Emotional Weight: The word "genesis" (meaning beginning) contrasted with "demise" (meaning end) creates a tragic arc in a very short space.
Areas for Consideration:
* Density: The technical requirements the author set (the complex rhyme scheme a, b, c, d, f etc.) are so intricate that some of the "word play" feels slightly forced to fit the grid.
* Polarization: The shift into aggressive language in the final stanzas is a bold choice. While it heightens the "emotive effect" mentioned in the rules, it may overshadow the technical beauty of the earlier stanzas for some readers.
Final Verdict
"Crypt of Flesh" is a masterclass in form-fitting function. The poet didn't just write a poem about death; they built a rhythmic machine that traps the reader in the same "cold darkness" as the speaker. It is a haunting, technically impressive, and deeply provocative piece of gothic poetry..sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
18
18
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Joto-Kai

This flash fiction piece, "Fifteen Minutes of Infamy," is a poignant study of political obsolescence and the cold indifference of the public. It captures a "fall from grace" not as a single explosion, but as a quiet, crushing realization of irrelevance.
Here is a detailed review of the work:
Overall Impression
The story is hauntingly effective. It captures a specific type of tragedy: the moment a powerful leader realizes they are no longer a protagonist in the eyes of the public, but a cautionary tale—or worse, a ghost. The contrast between Michaela’s "regal" self-image and her "feeble" physical state creates a strong emotional hook. You’ve managed to pack a significant amount of world-building into a few paragraphs, hinting at a cycle of political behavior that the public has grown numb to.
Strengths
* The Theme of Apathy: The most chilling part of the story isn't the "villainy" Michaela refers to, but the shrug of the compassionate woman. It suggests that the public hasn't forgiven her; they have simply moved on to the next crisis, leaving her trapped in her own guilt and ego.
* The Final Imagery: The ending, where people "marched through her personal space," is a powerful metaphor. It signifies that she has lost her "gravity." She is no longer an obstacle or an icon; she is just part of the architecture.
* Effective Dialogue: Her repeated line, "They are doing what I did," is brilliant. It’s ambiguous—is she warning them because she regrets her actions, or is she demanding to know why she was punished while others are spared? That nuance makes her character much more interesting.
Tips for Improvement
* Sensory Details: While the emotional beat is strong, the setting is a bit vague. Adding one or two sensory details about the "overhead television" (the flicker of the screen, the tinny sound of the news anchor) or the "mall/store" environment could ground the reader more firmly in the scene.
* Pacing the Collapse: The transition from Michaela standing and shouting to stumbling and collapsing happens very quickly. You might consider adding one sentence describing the internal "weight" of the silence she receives before she hits the wall, making the physical collapse feel like the direct result of the public's collective cold shoulder.
* Word Choice: You use the word "regal" to describe her at the start. It might be impactful to use a contrasting word at the end (perhaps "hollow" or "transparent") to emphasize how much her stature has shrunk in those few minutes.
Final Thoughts
This is a sophisticated piece of micro-fiction. It avoids the "melodrama" trap by focusing on the silence of the crowd rather than a shouting match. It leaves the reader wondering what she actually did, which is a great way to keep the story lingering in the mind after the final sentence...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
19
19
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

This is my review: "The Essential Journey"

This is a heartfelt tribute to professional bowling and the grit required to reach the pinnacle of the sport. Below is a detailed review of the poem’s structure, themes, and areas for potential refinement.
Overall Impression
The poem effectively captures the grandeur and intensity of professional sports. By framing a bowling tournament as a "legendary trek" and a "perilous wilderness," you elevate the subject matter from a mere game to a heroic quest. The specific tribute to Norm Duke’s 2008 triple-crown feat provides a solid anchor in reality, making the poem feel both like a timeless motivational piece and a historical record.
Key Strengths
* The Heroic Tone: You use strong, evocative language (unfathomable expanse, perilous wilderness, gritty focus) that transforms the bowling alley into a battlefield of the mind and spirit.
* Thematic Clarity: The message is unmistakable—success is the byproduct of "insatiable desire" and "hard work." It serves as an excellent motivational piece for athletes in any field.
* Historical Significance: Mentioning Norm Duke's three consecutive majors adds a layer of authenticity that fans of the sport will deeply appreciate.
Tips for Improvement
While the poem is inspiring, a few adjustments could sharpen its poetic impact:
* Vary the Line Rhythm: The middle section ("The Professional Bowlers Tour offering elite bowlers / Huge sums of prize monies") leans slightly toward prose. You might consider more rhythmic phrasing to maintain the "epic" feel. For example: "Where elite titans vie / For fortune and the crown."
* Show, Don't Just Tell: You use many abstract nouns (passion, love, determination, belief). While powerful, you could strengthen the poem by adding a "sensory" detail of the game—the sound of the pins crashing, the slide of the shoe, or the weight of the ball—to ground the reader in the moment.
* Formatting the Tribute: Since the poem shifts from a general "legendary trek" to the specific story of Norm Duke, using a stanza break before "Back to back, to back" could help the reader transition from the abstract concept of the journey to the concrete example of the man.
Final Thoughts
"The Essential Journey" is a respectful and polished nod to the dedication required for mastery. It successfully bridges the gap between the physical act of sport and the mental fortitude of a champion.


sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
20
20
Review of Unicorn Part 1  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
hueloovoo... a dim blue hue.

This story, "Unicorn Part 1", is a poignant blend of contemporary realism and magical realism. It uses a supernatural transformation as a metaphor for gender identity and the relief of self-actualization.
Here is a detailed review of the narrative:
Plot Overview and Structure

The story follows Brian, a high school freshman who appears to be a stereotypical "jock" but suffers from intense gender dysphoria. Feeling trapped in a body that feels like a "cage," Brian attempts suicide by overdosing on medication found in the nurse's office.
Instead of dying, Brian undergoes a "spontaneous DNA change." He wakes up in the hospital as a biological girl named Chastity, complete with a physical unicorn horn that only those who "believe in magic" can see. The part ends with Chastity starting at a new school and meeting Marie, a fellow student who can see her true form.
Thematic Analysis
1. The "Cage" of Masculinity
You effectively establishe Brian’s internal conflict by contrasting his external "bearlike" appearance with the "slender and delicate" girl dancing inside him. The description of Brian moving carefully so as not to "shatter" things emphasizes the disconnect between his physical power and his gentle internal identity.
2. Transformation as Healing

The story shifts from a dark, heavy tone (suicide) to one of "miraculous" hope. The transformation is not just cosmetic; it is presented as a medical and spiritual reset. The doctor’s acceptance and the parents' immediate pivot to supportiveness—though perhaps idealized—serve the "inspirational" tag of the story, focusing on the relief of being seen for who you truly are.

3. The Unicorn Metaphor

The spiraling horn is a clever literary device. It represents:
* Uniqueness: Chastity is literally "one of a kind."
* Visibility: Only Marie, who is marginalized by her own mental health struggles (hearing voices), can see the horn. This suggests that "magic" is visible only to those who are open to truths that society labels as "crazy" or "impossible."
Strengths
* Emotional Resonance: The depiction of the "river wearing away the rock of a chasm" is a powerful image for the slow erosion of the self when living inauthentically.
* Pacing: The story moves quickly from the inciting incident (the overdose) to the resolution (the new life), keeping the reader engaged in the emotional fallout.
* Character Dynamics: The parents' reaction is heartwarming. While many stories focus on the trauma of coming out, this story chooses a path of radical parental love and protection.
Suggestions for Improvement
* Dialogue Naturalism: Some of the dialogue, especially from the doctor and the father, feels a bit "expository" (used to explain the plot rather than sounding like natural speech). For example, the doctor's explanation of the genetic testing is very clinical for such a fantastical event.
* The "Magic" Logic: It is unclear if the horn is physical or a projection. If the mother pulls a blanket over Chastity's shoulders, the horn would likely snag or be felt. Clarifying the physical "rules" of the horn would help ground the magic.
* Transitioning the Name: The shift from "Brian" to "Chastity" in the narration happens very quickly. Exploring the character's own adjustment to the new name might add more depth to her internal journey.
Final Impression
"Unicorn Part 1" is a sensitive exploration of identity. It takes the "trapped in the wrong body" narrative and gives it a literal, magical resolution. It is a story about the "miracle" of being allowed to exist as your true self, and it sets up an interesting dynamic for Part 2 regarding who can see Chastity’s magic and why...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
21
21
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

This poem, "Just Compensation: A Legislative Magnet," is a dense, high-energy piece of political commentary that blends surrealist imagery with a sharp critique of the current American sociopolitical landscape.
Here is a detailed review of the work, focusing on its themes, imagery, and structural impact.
Overall Impression

The poem feels like a "fever dream" of a news cycle. It successfully captures the chaotic, sensory-overload nature of modern politics—where high-level legislative debates coexist with "rubber duckies" and "air guitars." You’ve managed to weave the exhaustion of the "Trump years" into a broader existential anxiety about the future of freedom and technology.
The title itself, "Just Compensation," is a clever play on the Fifth Amendment, suggesting that the "payment" for our current political state is a fractured and "emasculated" society.
Key Strengths

1. Striking Visual Metaphors
The most powerful section of the poem is the Houdini metaphor:
Houses of leadership / Acting like a Houdini, / Escaping from an underwater / Glass tank / In handcuffs / And shackles;

This perfectly illustrates the feeling of political gridlock and the "performative" nature of modern governance. It suggests that leadership is more concerned with the spectacle of escape than with actual progress.
2. Juxtaposition of the Mundane and the Extreme
You effectively place domestic, everyday images next to scenes of civil unrest:
* "Monikered housewives" playing "air guitars" while inhaling "tear gas."
* "Bathers lounge in their private tub" while "foreign manipulations" and "vengeful attacks" loom outside.
This contrast highlights a central theme: the insulation of the private citizen versus the violent reality of the political machine.
3. Vocabulary and Tone
Your use of "beefy, magnanimous outcries," "prescient lockers," and "profligate extraction" gives the poem a sophisticated, intellectual weight. The tone is urgent and slightly cynical, fitting for a piece about "pulse-pounding revelations" and "appalling, anti-American strategies."
Areas for Improvement
1. Pacing and Breath
The poem is one long, continuous flow. While this mimics the "non-stop" nature of social media and news, it can be exhausting for the reader.
* Tip: Consider breaking the poem into stanzas based on thematic shifts (e.g., one for the legal/legislative aspect, one for the social unrest, and one for the technological future). This would allow your strongest lines to "breathe" and resonate more.
2. Clarity in the "Rubber Ducky" Section
The transition to the "rubber ducky" and "private tub" is a sudden shift in tone. While it represents a retreat into privacy or apathy, it feels a bit disconnected from the "technologically advanced" lines immediately preceding it.
* Tip: You might bridge this gap by highlighting why the bathers are undeterred—is it ignorance, or have they been numbed by the "artificial intelligence" and "social media" mentioned earlier?
3. Narrowing the Scope
The end of the poem covers a massive amount of ground: women’s rights, LGBTQ+ rights, foreign intervention, and global domination.
* Tip: To make the ending punch harder, try to tie these "heavy-handed tactics" back to the "legislative framework" mentioned at the start. This would bring the poem full circle, showing how laws (or the lack thereof) directly lead to these "vengeful attacks on freedom."
Final Rating: 5 / 5 Stars
This is an ambitious and linguistically rich piece of writing. It captures the specific "vibe" of 2026—a world grappling with the scars of the past and the uncertain, tech-driven threats of the future...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
22
22
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi
Joey Says...Where's Winter?

This is a moving piece of creative nonfiction (or realistic fiction) that explores themes of altruism, the "quiet" nature of grace, and the stark realities of systemic hardship. Below is a detailed review of the story, focusing on its narrative structure, emotional impact, and themes.
Narrative Structure and Perspective
The story employs a unique and effective second-person perspective ("You"). By addressing the reader as the twenty-year-old mother in labor, you force a level of empathy that is immediate and visceral.
* The Hook: The opening imagery—the "gray-blue cheeks," the "swollen skin," and the "seventeen-month-old son lying across your legs"—instantly establishes the stakes. It isn't just a medical emergency; it’s a social and personal crisis.
* The Shift: The narrative shifts halfway through from the "You" (the patient) to the "She" (the nurse/case manager). This creates a powerful contrast between the person drowning in a crisis and the "lifeguard" who chooses to jump in without being asked.
* The Twist: The final reveal—that the narrator is actually the nurse’s husband—adds a layer of authenticity and personal pride. It transforms the story from a generic tale of kindness into a tribute to a specific person’s character.
Theme: The Definition of Grace
The central theme is the distinction between duty and grace.
* Duty is represented by the "tall, skinny nurse" who is efficient but bound by rules (not being able to give pain meds because of the toddler).
* Grace is represented by the case manager. She isn't on the clock, she isn't getting paid, and she is technically "not supposed to get involved."
The author argues that true grace is often invisible to the recipient. The young mother is in too much pain to "thank" her, and the nurse expects no recognition. This "anonymous" kindness is presented as the highest form of human love.
Emotional Resonance
The story is heavy with "dagger-like anguish," both physical and situational. The detail about the "baby’s daddy" hiding from jail and the fear of DCF (Department of Children and Families) adds a layer of grit. It doesn't sugarcoat the patient's life; it acknowledges that her woes may be "of her own making," yet insists she is still worthy of compassion. This makes the nurse's intervention feel more profound—it is unconditional.
Strengths
* Sensory Details: The "dripping of honey" to describe the slow passage of time during a contraction and the "softly beeping machine" create a strong sense of place.
* Pacing: The tension builds well as the reader feels the desperation of the mother’s isolation before the "woman of Grace" provides relief.
* The Ending: The meta-commentary at the end—the jab at social media's short attention spans—serves as a "call to action" for the reader to look for ways to make the world better.
Areas for Consideration
* Tone Shift: The ending becomes slightly defensive or cynical regarding the "people" who might find the task of reading "too daunting" or think the woman has "mush for brains." While this highlights the narrator's protective nature toward his wife, it shifts the tone from inspirational to slightly confrontational.
* Formatting: In the original text, the transition between the mother’s internal monologue and the nurse’s actions is seamless, but some readers might benefit from a clearer visual break when the "Case Manager" enters the story to highlight her as the "Proof of Grace."
Final Impression

"Proof of Grace or Something Else?" is a poignant tribute to the unsung heroes in the healthcare system. it captures a raw, "ugly" moment of human suffering and counters it with a quiet, beautiful act of sacrifice. It successfully challenges the reader to move beyond judgment and toward active, selfless help...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
23
23
Review of The Snow Maiden  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Thomas Browning

This is a haunting and atmospheric short story that blends elements of folklore, magical realism, and tragedy. Below is a detailed review of "The Snow Maiden".
Overall Impression
"The Snow Maiden" is a poignant exploration of loneliness, longing, and the thin veil between reality and the supernatural. Browning uses vivid, sensory-rich prose to transform a classic "Snegurochka" (Snow Maiden) archetype into a darker, more psychological tale. The ending is both tragic and beautiful, suggesting that the hunter’s "wish" was granted, though at the ultimate cost of his life.
Strengths
1. Sensory Imagery & Atmosphere
The author excels at creating a "chilled" atmosphere. Phrases like "icicles tinkling in the night wind" and "breath unfurling like smoke" allow the reader to feel the temperature of the story. The contrast between the "blue flame" of the lake and the "red rose" or "blood red scarf" provides a striking visual palette that underscores the theme of life vs. death (warmth vs. cold).
2. Pacing & Tone Shift
The story transitions effectively from a skeptical, grounded opening (the hunter laughing at the children) to a surreal, dreamlike middle section. By the time the maiden is "crawling like a spider" under his covers, the tone shifts from a whimsical fairytale to a supernatural thriller, which keeps the reader engaged.
3. The Ambiguity of the Ending
The duality of the ending is the story's strongest point. To the outside world (the children), it is a tragedy—a man found dead in the snow. To the hunter, it was a night of transcendence, love, and the fulfillment of a silent prayer. This creates a bittersweet "happy ending" within a tragic framework.
Critical Analysis & Themes
* Loneliness as a Catalyst: The hunter’s internal state (no wife, no food, no fire) is what truly "summons" the maiden. His desperation makes him vulnerable to the cold, both literally and metaphorically.
* The Nature of the Maiden: There is a subtle, predatory edge to the Snow Maiden. Her "spider-like" movement and the fact that she "came for him" suggests she is an elemental force that consumes life rather than a standard romantic interest.
* Symbolism of the Scarf: The scarf serves as the physical tether between the dream world and reality. It is the one item that transitions from his "dream" back to the waking world, proving (at least to the reader) that his experience was more than just a hallucination.
Tips for Improvement
1. Refining the Climax
The sequence where the maiden turns into a swan and they fly over the forest is highly imaginative, but it feels slightly rushed compared to the slow, methodical buildup in the cabin. Spending a few more sentences on the transition from the "holy shrine" to the "swan flight" could help the flow.
2. Clarifying the "Spider" Simile
The description of the girl "crawling like a spider underneath the covers" is very effective for creating a sense of the uncanny. However, since the rest of the story portrays her as ethereal and graceful, this specific image feels a bit jarringly "monstrous." If the intent was to make her scary, it works perfectly; if she is meant to be purely a "dream girl," a softer descriptor might fit the romantic tone better.
3. Dialogue Mechanics
The dialogue is poetic, but some lines (like "Not even the very flames of hell could ever melt your cold cold heart!") feel a bit melodramatic compared to the quiet, subtle beauty of the descriptive narration.
Conclusion
Rating: 5 / 5 Stars
This is a masterfully written piece of "Winter Gothic" fiction. It captures the lethality of nature and the warmth of human imagination in equal measure. The circular nature of the story—beginning with children building a maiden and ending with children finding the hunter—gives it the timeless feel of a true legend...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
24
24
Review of Mirage Part Three  Open in new Window.
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi
Sethorion


This conclusion to Mirage serves as a poignant exploration of the internal landscape of a creative mind. It transitions from a high-stakes fantasy battle into a psychological drama, ultimately revealing that the world of Tresgar is a manifestation of the protagonist's psyche.

Here is a detailed review of the final chapters.
Overall Impression
The story concludes with a strong "internal" twist. By personifying abstract concepts—Fear (Hezron), Wisdom (Nicodemus), Courage (Rameus), and Dreams/Wishes (Kya)—you’ve turned a standard "hero’s journey" into a metaphor for mental health and the escapism of a lonely creator. The emotional stakes shift effectively from "will the hero survive the snake?" to "will the boy choose reality over a beautiful lie?"
Strengths

1. The Symbolic Personification
The revelation of who the characters represent is the highlight of the piece.
* Hezron as Fear: The logic that he feeds on fear is classic but executed well here because it ties back to Kyle’s real-world anxiety.
* Kya as Dreams: Making her the "villain" of the final act is a sophisticated choice. It highlights the danger of living entirely within one’s own head.
2. Pacing and Action
The battle with Megolith is visceral and tense. The detail of the "stone dagger" being a one-time-use weapon adds a necessary limit to Kyle’s power, preventing him from feeling like an invincible "Mary Sue" character.
3. The "Dual-World" Tension
The "intercut" scenes—where Carol and the nurses are trying to save Kyle in the hospital while he is fighting in Tresgar—add a ticking clock element that heightens the stakes. It grounds the fantasy elements in a very real, life-or-death medical emergency.
Areas for Improvement
1. Dialogue Polish
Some of the dialogue feels a bit "on the nose," meaning characters explain their motivations too directly.
* Example: “I am Wisdom.” * Tip: You might make this more subtle. Instead of Nicodemus saying "I am Wisdom," he could say, "I am the part of you that knows the truth you're afraid to admit." This feels more like natural dialogue and less like a label.
2. Grammatical Consistency
There are a few typos and tense shifts that can be smoothed out in a final edit:
* "The lightening had burnt a smoldering whole in his robes..." (Should be hole).
* "You was always nice to you..." (Should be were).
* Watch for "then" vs "than" (e.g., "If he was Fear, than who are you?" should be then).
3. The "Choice" Scene
The moment Kyle chooses to return to reality is very fast. Given that Kya is offering him everything he ever wanted, the struggle could be more agonizing. Showing a brief "vision" of the lonely life he’s returning to versus the glory of Tresgar would make his choice to return to the real world feel even more heroic.
Thematic Depth
The ending message—that imagination is a "potent power" that must be "carefully handled"—is a beautiful takeaway for writers and readers alike. It validates the importance of dreams while emphasizing that they shouldn't be a cage used to escape the people who actually love us (like Carol).
Final Rating: 5/5 Stars
A very satisfying conclusion that elevates the story from a simple adventure to a thoughtful character study...sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
25
25
Review by sindbad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi
Tim Chiu

This is my review for: Allegiance to Democracy’s Souls.
This is a powerful, high-energy tribute to the military that leans heavily into grandeur and patriotic fervor. The poem functions almost like an anthem or a formal dedication, using elevated vocabulary to match the weight of its subject matter.
Overall Impression
The poem succeeds in creating a sense of monumental scale. By using words like "majesty," "peremptory," "sanctity," and "fortitude," you’ve elevated the soldier from a mere person to a symbol of national resilience. The tone is unapologetically celebratory and firm, which aligns well with the themes of military strength and "The Land of Stars and Stripes."
Strengths
* Strong Diction: Your choice of adjectives (e.g., "industrious warriors," "stately involvements") gives the poem a formal, classical feel. It sounds like something that would be read at a high-level military ceremony.
* Rhythmic Flow: While the poem doesn't follow a strict rhyme scheme, the cadence of the lines—especially in the first and last stanzas—is steady and authoritative.
* Thematic Clarity: There is no ambiguity here. The message of gratitude and the belief in the "God-given" sanctity of the nation are clear and unwavering.

The original line—"The strategic destruction / Of our horrifying enemies’ dissolution"—is a bit complex because "dissolution" usually means the act of breaking down or falling apart. If you destroy an enemy's dissolution, it technically implies you are stopping them from falling apart!
​Here are three ways to refine those lines while keeping your "stately" style:
​Option 1: Action-Oriented (The Most Direct)
​"Our peremptory resolve,
The swift dismantling
Of our horrifying enemies' ambitions
And their threats to our improving way of life!"
​Option 2: Focus on Protection (The Most "Stately")
​"Our peremptory resolve,
The valiant defiance
Of our horrifying enemies' encroachment
Upon our eminent and improving way of life!"
​Option 3: Preservation of Tone (Closest to Original)
​"Our peremptory resolve,
The resolute undoing
Of our horrifying enemies’ malice—
Preserving our eminent and improving way of life!"
​Why these work:
​Precision: Words like "ambitions" or "encroachment" give the enemy a clearer presence to be defeated.
​Flow: By changing "dissolution" to a word that describes the enemy's intent (like "malice" or "plots"), the "strategic destruction" part of the sentence feels much more powerful and logical.

Areas for Improvement & Tips
* Concrete Imagery vs. Abstract Concepts: The poem relies heavily on abstract nouns (liberties, status, precepts, sanctity). To make the emotional impact even stronger, consider grounding one of the stanzas in a concrete image. For example, instead of just "grit," you might describe the "salt on a uniform" or the "steady hand on a wheel." This contrast makes the "majesty" feel more earned.
* Complexity of Phrasing: Phrases like "the strategic destruction of our horrifying enemies’ dissolution" are quite dense. It takes a moment for the reader to untangle the double negative (destroying a dissolution). You might try simplifying a few of these longer lines to let the "punchier" words stand out more.
* Word Choice Precision: In the first stanza, you mention standing in the path of "imminent triumphs." Usually, one stands in the path of a threat. If the "triumph" is the goal, perhaps "Forging the path toward imminent triumphs" might align more logically with the "grit" mentioned in the next line.
Final Thought
"Allegiance to Democracy’s Souls" is a stirring piece of patriotic literature. It captures the "pomp and precepts" of military life while maintaining a deep sense of respect for the individual's "courage, grace, and fortitude."
Rating Recommendation: 5 / 5 Stars

sindbad


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
1,271 Reviews • *Magnify*
Page of 51 • 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sindbad