\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sleepyserpent/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: OFF
184 Public Reviews Given
196 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I aim to give a bizarre little meld of creative and technical pointers. My behavior always goes for being thoughtful and polite. If someone says: "I'm brutally honest/I say it like I see it," I think they're misinterpreting what it means to critique something. At the same time, I want to try and see if I might give advice that can make a writer stronger and not just sugarcoat things. We're writers, we make mistakes! But there's just a teenie weenie bit of difference between constructive criticism and having an inferiority complex! Bare in mind also that I am learning and if you think something I address is incorrect, by all means, please bring it up! We're here to learn from each other!
I'm good at...
- Spotting typos and maybe going over some basic rules of writing. - Tossing ideas on how to expand your tale (if you want that) - Using the ol' BS Detector, though it did backfired once and ate a friend's fictional rug.
Favorite Genres
Horror, Science Fiction, Slice of Life (prefers but not limited to if there's a supernatural twist), Speculative Fiction, Comedy, Action/Adventure
Least Favorite Genres
Fanfiction, Political
I will not review...
Not Erotica as a whole but more along the lines of it bordering on a fetish I'm uncomfortable with. Don't feel deterred, we'll discuss it.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- 3 ... Next
26
26
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Alright, this is definitely a great opening.

I like that you put in a lot of hints from the overall world, some amusing facts, like the wheat, as well. I'm looking forward to seeing what else this world has. The, uh, bandersnatchi you've mentioned sounds amusing. Wait, are we gonna get crab monsters?!

At first, Elam sounds like a typical loner. Certainly can't blame him some days, being alone by yourself is something I yearn for often sometimes. Bender's touches makes him want to retract further which is understandable--to say the least. The hook at the end was placed wonderfully, showing that your main character is as much a mystery as the murder.

Just a couple of notes:

Malcom Bender, sprawled in the adjacent seat, having settled there despite the fact that all of the other thirty-eight seats were empty. --Reminds me of a time when a guy sat awkwardly close to me on a bus. Later on he offered me herione. I should have guessed as much since he wore shades at 11:00 o'clock at night. So glad I have a car now.

He (understood understand) the ancient technology well enough without appealing to superstition. --A repition in wording from editing?

Well, I have to admit I've never read a mystery before. This will be interesting! I'll go and take a crack at the next chapter soon!

Take it easy, Max.
27
27
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Well, I wasn't expecting that!

I like how the reader is led to believe that this leather-faced monster is out for blood--but actually, he's got a much more mundane job. There's something nice about seeing a positive light in the creepy realms of our imaginations. I could see this piece working well as an introduction into another world.

Either way, thanks for sharing and keep writing!
28
28
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (3.5)
You've got an interesting world here. I like the idea of some giant tree that this structure is built around. A group of friends that work together as security detail helps the idea of character exploration. A little cleaning and I think you have something quite fun!

Now, there's some advice I'd like to give. Spacing is your friend. Whenever you use one character's dialogue and it ends, please hit that Enter key twice and space it out. It does wonders at making the text easier to read.

Also, you've chosen present-tense. Now, it's not hard to fall back into past-tense, so please bare that in mind when you're proofing your work. I rarely use present-tense partially because it's real easy to strike those keys, look away at the dog barking outside the window, and then default to past. There's a couple of hiccups here.

Yes, I gave the tree a nickname. Don’t judge me.--This is a good window into the main character's personality. Very good. Never forget that using first-person awards you a quick and RELATIVELY easy way to show your character's personality via their thoughts. Third person can do the same, but it's not as immediate.

Now, you like painting visuals of beauty and relaxation. That's good, you don't need to be dark and dreary like me, but the ultimate problem lies in your reliance that the reader will fill in the blanks.

Behind us, tourists from towns all around the coastline pile in, many with various souvenirs,...--You don't have to tell us every single knickknack these guys have, but tell us a little bit. Is there a little boy with a wind-up fox toy? Maybe a Sophomore girl has a t-shirt with the city's name on it. This is a great way to quietly express some of the culture in the world you've built.

While Nir, Cherry and I talk about girl things through the ride,...--There's a missed opportunity for character establishment. Maybe Cherry's concerned, overworked, tired, maybe she's facing a dilemma at home. It can be something positive too, maybe she has some beautiful roses in bloom, some great compliment from one of her superiors has her swimming with delight. Filling in the blanks helps the reader feel more invested--and it tends to be a lot of fun, too! On a personal note, I understand the "talk about girl things" usually just means that it's casual talk, but it can also come across as a little dismissive, like they're just chickens, clucking their way through life.

The Great Crystalbloom (stood) guard, her massive branches sprouting small formations of (coloured glassy rock). When the rays of the warm sun shine through one, I see the (myriad of colours) separate within and behold as it’s warm rays sprout through the other side.--You're going to want to switch stood to stand to keep up with present tense. Now, again, you're showing us this beautiful scene, but what colors is the reader suppose to see? Is it a refraction of the sunlight without the prisms being altered in color? So, golden and yellow hues? You have a good vocabulary, but when you're writing a scene that a character is awe-struck, try to be specific.

I see Snow pout a bit and giggle, resting my hand on his.--Now, you've painted Snow as a broody type, a tad agitated when the main character sneaks up on him. This lines makes him appear much more playful--and that's not bad, but I think the main character would probably comment (in her thoughts or vocally) on his current, more laid back position. It's the giggle more than anything that makes me wonder this.


Over everyone, (I hear) a little girl gasp and (see) her tug at her mother’s sleeve(s), pointing at the crystal lanterns that hung from the web of vines over the ground floor.--Often times in writing, we often rely too heavily on stating what our characters SEE and HEAR. The image becomes...almost like a flash to the character, then at what they're reacting to, then back to the character and back at the action. Don't completely throw out sees, hears, tastes, ect., but always consider the thought of eliminating such words if they pull the action away from the reader. Look at this adjustment:

Over everyone, a little girl gasps and tugs at her mother's sleeve, pointing at the crystal lantern that hangs from the web of vines over the ground floor.--I wouldn't say the edit is flawless, but it's much more immediate. The reader understands that this story is in the first-person, your character relays information effortlessly. She sees the little girl right off the bat, she hears her. And, it's a cute visual, but she's not really grabbing both her mothers sleeves, is she?


Well, those are my thoughts. Keep up the writing! Please only use what you agree with, after all, this' just one idiot's opinion!

29
29
Review of Ode To Melanie  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Bloody disgusting!

And I friggn' love it. I've always been a little nervous about writing poetry into my own writing. Sure sets the mood though.

Off topic fact, Keats is one of my girlfriend's favorite poets. I've been meaning to get to him for some time now. Thanks for the head start!

I like the fact that the story appears to start in third-person, but rears to first as Melanie interrupts the scene. It's ALL about Melanie after all! And you drove it home so well.

30
30
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
You know, I've seen this scam before on places like Amazon. When Christmas shopping, you can net some dumb, cute triceratops plush for one dollar. Oh, and the shipping is ten dollars. At least it didn't claim to be FREE, I guess.

Well, now I know where they got the idea from.

Like usual, great writing. Makes me sad, you wrote this story the year before I graduated from high school.
31
31
Review of The Gatekeeper  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This is really something!

I enjoy the subtle nature of this piece. I have to confess, Amraiel's thoughts about how sunsets appear with their vibrant, reddened colors does make me think of violence. That's some great insight, to take something that most are in awe over and bring about an alternative perspective.

Also, when the dark-haired man comes in, I like that you showed and didn't tell what his baggage was. I would have probably failed in this regard, feeling the need to state things which is a bad habit of mine. Great job!

The ending sends home the monotony of Amraiel's work, a short time later and she's back at square one.

I could see this being a much longer story if you ever felt the need to revisit Amraiel, but I'm a sucker for shorts, so it works wonderfully just by itself.

Wonderful work and thanks for sharing!

32
32
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Well, that certainly had a beautiful ending!

I like that you don't spell out much. I think I would have been a sucker and gone for explaining what Colt's crime had been. You give enough background information in Colt's head to let us in, but there's still a tantalizing little mystery about what happened to the eight men and Miss Kara--or rather, what specifically pulled these people together in this violent act. We're stuck with Colt's vague memories, and he's probably been replaying it back in his mind so much that he's not in the mood to be specific anymore. In a way, Colt greets this final execution. He's nervous, but things have been so bad for him, he's not terrorized by the thought of death, even if there's a chance he's going to a Hell. Instead, there's curiosity.

It's not until he's about to be hanged that there's a surge of panic. Once more, it's not that he's panicking, begging for this not to be, it's the obsession with what's next. It's interesting that in his judgment, he's here because of self-defense. Unfortunately, what time that gave him was mostly in a cell thinking about the end.

As I've alluded, the ending was great! He's where he is now and that goes beyond words. You know, I've always thought about the idea of writing a piece where a character dies and then the meat of the work is their journey into the afterlife. Great work, indeed!

Okay, here are some edits I would suggest. However, by all means, only take what works for you. You got this work published! So it's pretty darned evident someone with a lot more authority than I didn't have a problem at all! They're not bad at all, either, just maybe a slight more tightening. Either way, no pressures and it's most important that the writer only uses suggestions that they think aids the story, not changes or harm it.

It’s little compensation for his present state, but he’ll take what he can get, for as long as he can, which isn’t going to be (very) much longer at all right now.--I might think of cutting out very. I know people seem to look down upon the use of the word(outside of dialogue), saying it's unimaginative (though take a few steps back and you'll find it used quite a bit in past successful novels) so, really, just question to yourself if the flow of the sentence works better or worse without the word.

Behind him (is) Sheriff Parker and his deputy, both with rifles at the ready, telling the people to stand back.--I think you might want to switch is to are. You're referring to two men.

A little further along he looks up to the right, where (he sees) Miss Kara standing on the balcony of the run down saloon.--This is a great scene, but I think if we cut out he sees, we'll get closer to the action. We're aware in the first part that he's actively looking around his environment.

Thanks for sharing this piece, and keep it up!
33
33
Review of Cloudstepper  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
Oh wow, I really like this poem! It makes me ponder a bit. I think I may have visualized a person or creature just skipping on clouds while during a flight at one time.

Originally, it made me think of this creature (shoot me, I can't remember its name) from--you guessed it--Lovecraft. It was something like a giant cloud creature that moved like a blimp. I wrote a short on it some time ago but never published it.

I like the casual tone you set in this. The only thing I might suggest is changing a word in one of your stanzas.

Water (vapour) or whatever,

Suspended in (vapour,)

I would consider changing one of the two vapours just because one questions if it's vapour while the second just goes along that it's vapour and the repetition doesn't feel lyrical or create a rhythm.

Still, it's a fun and unique poem! Thanks for sharing!
34
34
Review of Finding Plot  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Ah! Like usual, you hit out of the park, Max. This is quite informative and, dare I say, essential for anyone out of the know for plotting out any kind of work, fiction--or probably otherwise.

When I was younger, I heard of the Three Act Structure, but (forgive my youth) I suppose the word ACT being used, I thought it was only meant to be used for films and plays. Yeah, pretty erroneous of me.

I watched a video about plotting fiction by Brandon Sanderson and it helped to give me some idea of the concepts.

This article and the examples you've broken down with the formula has made my wet cemented foundation harden quite a bit more and I thank you deeply for doing so.

I'll be using the three act play for a new work, and always a handy tool to turn to for future pieces.
35
35
Review of The Wooden Sphere  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Fascinating. I think calling this piece "otherworldly" would be like calling fiction fiction. I like where it all sprouts from: the normal, everyday thing you see. What happens when you pay a little more attention to it? What stories may it convey to you? And, as the story unfolds, what will it change in you? I always did like the idea of being able to find an unknown world trapped in plain sight. The story hints that it may well all be in the narrator's head, but who really knows?
36
36
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Things seem to be continuing quite nicely. I've found no typos and none of the dialogue seems off. Haakon confusing Nathan for someone else apparently tied to something Haakon is familiar with makes me ponder if Haakon is in a much earlier timeframe than he knows. It's interesting and gets the reader thinking.

On a side note, when Nathan is thinking back about his experiment and the argument that his instructor had posed; is it technobabble or is it from your own understanding? I know from your biography that you teach the kind of math that would leave me crying. And yes, I'm smart enough to know of quantum physics, I'm just curious.
37
37
Review of Pinky the Rat  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Geeze, that was horrifying. I like the short and sweet nature of this tale. Rats tend to be...almost decor to horror and rarely ever the focal point. I love that about this story. There's a fair amount of humor to boot, like when the narrator admits that Pinky was in the trash and his violent injury is swept under the rug by his son. Good stuff, always good stuff, Wilcox.
38
38
Review of The Candle Maker  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I really love this piece. The flow of the prose were so relaxing even during Caroline's solemn suffering. Travis was a very warm and comforting character. His soft spoken words are limited, giving the reader just enough answers to relax and take in the world. I felt a little saddened at the end, but I'm guessing Caroline no longer needed the candle shop.

Thanks, Mike. I needed the little pick me up.
39
39
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
I suppose Haakon has his work cut out for him. This' very entertaining. I liked as the conversations go back and forth, that Haakon is slowly reaffirming his suspicions to a more dire problem (at least for him) than the current people surrounding him. There's a great sense of relief when he returns to the present day, despite the polluted air, and while he brushes off any concern that the brewing storm may have, it's pretty much signaling that his work is far from done.

I think I caught some minor typos, but please remember that I'm not knowledgeable about the colloquial dialogue you're using.

"(I'm) returned from my mission to Iceland, only to find evil has fallen on this land."--I think you were going for (I've.)

Haakon strode forward and handed the waif off the woman, who opened her arms in a caress. (...handed the waif off (to) the woman,) I believe.


Thanks again, Max. Until next time.


40
40
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
That's one heck of an introduction. The flow of the writing works extremely well. I'm not at all familiar with the time and locaiton, but despite that, it still kept me going.

The techs at Control had disguised it to look like a Celtic cross suspended on a rope about his neck.--this is creative, along with the sentence afterwards. You're giving a lot of details that aren't simply info dumps.

Maybe his next assignment would be in a time that had less gnarly haircuts.--This makes me want to see how he feels about what he'll be wearing next time he jumps to a different period.

"I've been on another assignment, in Kadesh in 1258 BCE. It's been over two years in personal time for me."--It might seem obvious, but I enjoy that no matter what Haakon is doing in any time period, his own time (whether he's even mortal or otherwise) ia passing him by. I could see if maybe less stable time travels in Haakon's field could become lost and lose their true identities.

A gang from the twenty-sixth century infiltrated the Pharaoh's entourage (was there) and tried to sabotage talks."--this feels off. I'm not entirely sure if this is a typo or I'm just not seeing something here.

The final sentence, when Haakon knows something is off, it made me smirk. Yeah, those aren't the kinds of horses he was expecting.

Culturally, I'm curious if Haakon and all others of his craft that we're currently privvy too are chosen partially because it's less likely they would impregnate someone and cause a time paradox.

Either way, I'll get to the second chapter soon. Excellent work, but you don't need me to tell you that, Max.
41
41
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
God, this' awesome! The constant bickering works so well. The jabs of the owner, originally sounding caring, makes for great punchlines. The back and forth feels natural, showing (and I know the piece is apart of a contest where you can't use saids) how you can make a great dialogue with little to no saids at all. This concept could make for a pretty awesome longer short. Great job!
42
42
Review of INTO THE BONEYARD  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
This' interesting. I think that the beginning could use a little more show than tell. Perhaps the girls sat in their seats, admiring Billy from afar, some even drawing little hearts with his name in the center. We get a decent glimpse of Billy, but other than Tracy being short and stacked, we don't get much of a look on her.

The prose are a quick blur and I'd say there is a bit of merit to it. It made me think of when I was younger and just all that sexual energy making life feel quick and almost life-threateningly bold.

Some things didn't really make sense to me, however. Why would Billy be so keen in hopping into an open grave even with a hot girl he's chasing after in it? I wouldn't argue that he wouldn't do such a thing, but a little coaxing on her end would have helped. Also, it's day when they left school, right? The boneyard felt like it was relatively near, so the cut to it being night was a little disorienting without stating the drive taking some time.

In the end, I think you do have a cute, sultry little tale that with a couple of edits and more descriptions would make it even more fun to read!
43
43
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This was very good! I enjoy the quick ride it gives, from the girl, her perspective and how she slowly pulls you into her web. As the reader, I felt when the reveal came that there was a sense of hopelessness. I was trapped and whatever that girl is, I'm going to regret finding out. Great writing!
44
44
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Interesting! Ghosts being what we want, what we desire and what we hope to become is quite haunting. It's a very intimate feeling with writers and all other artists. Especially those who always felt they could make art but never gave it the chance. That existential dread of: "I'm sure I can do it... I'll just do it later, I guess."
45
45
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Good work! This is a strong piece. The writing style holds well as it dives into the mindset of a child. The fear of Miss Pink and Miss Bell to the narrator and his town is a fascinating mythology built on old memories, gossip, and speculation.

The narrator's speech patterns make him believable and the fright of not knowing how old he is and how long he's been down there adds a painfully complex fear as he thinks of his mother and if it's only been a month or years and years.

I wouldn't mind seeing an expanded version of this tale if ever you felt the interest. The only thing that SLIGHTLY confuses me is when the narrator uses the term beckoned when describing Mikey's encounter with the witches right after saying that Mikey reads books without pictures. However, the narrator could simply be repeating what Mikey said, or his own parents could have a good vocabulary. Either way, very minor and easy to explain away complaint. Again, great work!
46
46
Review of First Contact  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
A nice quick and to the point tale. It's hard to make a complaint here. The dialogue sets everything into motion. The punchline's a gimme, but I can use it these days alright. I think the dialogue written for the "twitter guy" worked and tells us all we need to know and to reveal his name would have been too on the nose.

The only thing I think I would have changed was when you used the parenthesis: "Earth! The other losers who call themselves leaders(and are doing a terrible job, by the way!) are a sham!!"

I don't THINK you can use parenthesis in spoken dialogue. I know his tweets are filled with parenthesizes, hence why you used them, but just like the character never being mentioned by name, it translates well enough without it. But that's all personal opinion! Good job!
47
47
Review of Halloween Special  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (3.5)
Due to the shortness of this piece, I can understand the murkiness of the situation. It also helps to paint a dream-like state. I liked it and it all being a prank leaves a playful tone, reminding me of the "trick" part of the holiday season. Admittedly, when she touched her mother and the mother fell over all the way to when she set her mother's head in her lap, the visual I had was that the mother had been dismembered and the daughter sat a detached head in her lap. Still, 150 words is difficult to weave a tale in with a beginning, middle and an end and I think your work was a pleasant surprise!
48
48
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
I like the harrowing experience this paints. I remember heading to a school bus once after school had let out and saw a "greenish witch-like colour" in the sky. The visual was reminiscent of that. The final line is powerful, reading it from the viewpoint of a child not fully realizing that that storm and tornado has just affected his life in a permanent way.
49
49
Review of Next Right Thing  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is a unique story and the existential dread really helps to paint a picture of what Laura is going through. It's nice to read a story where the main character is a mother, a lot of fiction really tries to focus on younger characters and while that's not necessarily bad, this piece is a nice reprieve from it. Laura's just dealing with the realization that she takes everything one day at a time and doesn't have an entire picture, making herself feel small and meaningless. Good job with the prose!
50
50
Review of The Uninvited Hat  Open in new Window.
Review by S. Serpent Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Fantastic! I love your prose and how gross they can be. This is one of those tales that's short and sweet and doesn't need a single word of backstory pried in there for good measure. I always admire a piece where the supernatural creature that haunts you ends up being the least of your concerns.
56 Reviews *Magnify*
Page of 3 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sleepyserpent/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2