Monika pushed you onto your back, down onto the cushion while the other girls stared at you hungrily. You tried to sit back up, but you were stuck, almost like you were glued there.
“It’s time for the ‘whose butt is best' competition! With special guest judge Y/N. Now, who wants to go first?”
Eyes darted to other eyes as they tried to figure out who would go first, only pausing to look down at your small body laying on the chair. You tried to protest, but no sound would come out.
“I think we should go youngest to oldest,” Natsuki asserted. With a few paces of her short legs, she was already standing over you, giving you a glimpse up her skirt to her panties. Her legs started to bend, and you prepared for impact. A hint of cheek popped out as the pink-haired girl aimed her ass at you. She came down slowly, savoring the idea of putting her full weight on you again.
“Wait.”
Yuri said it calmly. Natsuki froze above you, annoyed.
“What!? Can’t you see I’m trying to do something here?”
Yuri blushed at the small girl’s little tirade, but she was getting more and more used to it as they spent more time together. Still, she didn't like being confronted. Regardless, she gathered herself and said what was on her mind.
“Wouldn’t it be more fair if he didn’t know who was sitting on him?”
There was a pause as they all considered that. Natsuki straightened up, relieving you of the threat of her butt for now, but her arms were crossed. She clearly felt like Yuri had ruined her fun, but didn’t want to show it. Monika brightened up at the idea.
“That would be a better way to do it. We don’t want his opinion on who’s cutest influencing his choice for best butt! Let me go grab something to blindfold him.”
The girls stood around idly, all staring down at you. Natsuki looked down at you with eyes furrowed, no doubt believing that she should be sitting on you already. Yuri’s eyes seemed to express a more primal hunger. She had barely gotten a taste of feeling her ass on top of you before she had to relinquish you. Sayori meanwhile thought that you liked getting sat on, and you currently weren’t in a position to convince her otherwise. Finally, Monika returned, holding four straws and a ribbon. She still had her usual ribbon in her hair, so this one had come from somewhere else.
“I’m back. First, let’s get this tied around the little guy’s eyes. No peeking!”
She wrapped the ribbon around you. The ribbon was thin enough that it covered your eyes and nothing else, but it was very effective as a blindfold. You were now in complete darkness, awaiting a gauntlet of asses to smush you into the chair.
“And then we can draw straws to see who goes first!”
You heard some shuffling about. The sound of straws being pulled reached you, and you felt your heart start to beat slightly faster. There was a long pause as you listened to the girls silently compare sticks.
“We have our winner! The rules are, each of us will sit on him for ten minutes. To make sure he really gets a good, honest feel for our butts, we’ll lift our skirts up when we sit. Since this is the literature club, we will all read until the ten minute timer expires. Any questions?”
Nobody responded. You could make out the sound of shuffling legs, and although you couldn’t see, you felt someone’s presence above you. It didn’t take them long, in just a moment, a colossal, soft weight crashed down onto you, completely smooshing you into the chair. There was no way this was anyone but Yuri.
The minutes passed by incredibly slowly. Yuri seemed content just to mash you into the chair with her incredible weight, sitting calmly. You felt like you were being crushed into a paste by her. Alright, maybe the blindfold wasn’t as useful as I thought. Monika’s voice echoed in your head. But you better take notes on each butt. It’d be a shame if we had to do the competition over again because you couldn’t come to an informed decision.
Even though it was humiliating, you took Monika’s advice and started to ‘evaluate’ Yuri’s butt. It was heavy, completely crushing you, but it was also pillowy soft, completely wrapping around you in a way that the other girls’ asses really didn’t. A downside to this though, is that it was really hard to find even a pocket of air.
After what felt like much longer than ten minutes, an alarm sounded from a desk nearby. Yuri stood up off of you, and you were able to recover your breath for a little bit while the three remaining girls picked out their straws. After another few steps, you were buried in butt again. This one was smaller, but not incredibly so. You crossed out Natsuki; the girl on top of you was too heavy to be her. But you couldn’t quite figure out if this was Monika or Sayori on top of you. After a few minutes, you were able to figure it out. She was quite energetic and could barely sit still. You started out under her cheek, but after a bit of her maneuvering, you were now buried in her crack. The smell was…less than pleasant, but it was warm and almost cozy. You endured much more of this shifting, somehow never leaving the cleft of Sayori’s panties. It felt like it had been much longer than ten minutes again.
But finally, the alarm sounded and you were free. Cool air washed over you, and you enjoyed it while you could, knowing it wouldn’t last long. The last round of drawing straws went quickly. This girl crashed down onto you while you weren’t expecting it. She was much lighter than the previous one, so you knew immediately that this was Natsuki. That was doubly confirmed when she tried to make up for her lack of size by grinding you into the chair. Her butt was small, and almost bony, but that didn’t stop her weight from crushing you though. That being said, even with her actively trying to smush you as much as possible, she wasn’t nearly as effective at it as the other girls had been.
This time you counted the seconds in your head. By your count, it had actually been 19 minutes! As Natsuki stood off of you, Monika’s voice entered into your mind again. Actually it’s 20 minutes. You count a little slow. She giggled faintly before stepping over you. This does ruin the surprise, but I’m kind of glad you know it’s me. I think that since I make the rules here, I’m going to set the timer for two hours. Don’t worry, it’ll only feel like ten minutes to the other girls. Have you ever been able to control time? You should try it!
And then, Monika came down on top of you with a resounding Plop!. You realized quickly that her butt was quite a fair bit bigger than Sayori’s now that you had more experience with both. It was more than big enough to cover you, but soft and warm enough to make it not that uncomfortable. Ooooh! It sounds like you might have a favorite! Let’s make that three hours then as a special treat for you.. God her reading your mind was getting annoying.
You didn’t count down the time, but you had no doubt that Monika was telling the truth. It felt like you spent an eternity beneath her before the alarm finally saved you and you were allowed fresh, clean air again. You breathed in heavily, realizing you were sweaty from sharing body heat with your cruel captor’s ass for so long.
Your blindfold was removed, and the girls were all looking down at you expectantly. Monika winked at you before speaking.
“So, which butt was best. One, two, three, or four?”
It's okay if mine isn't actually your favorite. It'll be fun for me no matter who you pick.
What happens next?
1) You pick a girl, and they get a reward. (Possibly you?)
2) You hesitate too long before picking a girl. One of the girls decides they all need to redo the competition.
3) Before you can answer, one of the girls says that getting sat on isn't the only thing you should judge best butt by. They come up with a new competition.
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
Community Newsfeed
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
More by this author
