\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ajmorgan4db7/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
283 Public Reviews Given
283 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 ... Next
51
51
Review of Roots  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Cool poem, kk Author Icon! I noticed you listed 'Dark' as a genre, and I agree it is dark but not depressing. I like the way you describe things like "decay of my past life sustained me' and 'my soul's own venom I twisted down'. Very expressive!

Great job!
Alex
52
52
Review of walls  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi, Charlie Carrol Author Icon!

Your writing brings out your pain in the words and it is palpable to the reader. Great job! I think we all have felt like we're walking around in circles, hitting brick walls, or having ocean waves smash us in the chest.

Great metaphors, too!

But as I was reading: "Maybe I am destined to go mad...same potholes that I know are there...same walls I see coming..." I was thinking "If you do what you've always done, you will always get what you've always gotten."

I know. Easier said that done.

Great job, Charles!
53
53
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi, 🌖 HuntersMoon Author Icon! I saw your comment in the Newsfeed about your "Adult" section so I decided to check it out. I'm glad I did!

I enjoyed reading your story! My first reaction was to turn on the ceiling fan. Hot!

I like writing and reading BDSM stories and this one is great! I look forward to reading more of your work.

Alex
54
54
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi, FireWriter2012 Author Icon! If this is your first attempt at mystery, I think you did a very good job! I enjoyed reading it.

One thing that I noticed about the writing is it tends to go back and forth between showing (good) and telling (not good). Your first paragraph is showing, with a great hook, which is what got my attention!

Then the second paragraph went into telling, like someone was reading the story to me instead of seeing it through McAllister's point of view. Instead of telling us he was a great detective with a gutsy reputation, show us. Perhaps after "I like it as detective." think about: "I didn't get a gutsy reputation by playing it safe."

Overall it is a great mystery, and I hope you continue writing mysteries like this.

Are you familiar with Daniel Silva? He writes spy novels and his main character is an art restorer so famous paintings and art theft are usually part of the focus of his stories.

Write on!
55
55
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi, Seuzz Author Icon!

I really enjoyed reading your story. It started with a great hook and moved at a "page-turning" pace. Great job!

I did note one inconsistency or maybe it's just my confusion. *Blush* In the first scene, the story mentions Duke's body in the corner, with the back of its head blown off. In the second scene, Fokke recalls he put two slugs into Duke Winslow's face.

My favorite part was the final scene where we see Fokke as thinking he is still alive, but isn't. Great descriptions and great writing!

Alex
56
56
Review of A Walking Shadow  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Hey, Max!

Great story here and what a twist at the end. I was expecting some sort of "Hotel California" scene. *Laugh*

And I learned a new word today: ichor

Question: The story mentions Enoch is safe while it is light, but it is still light when he enters the control house just ahead of the grue?

One minor thing: Footfalls thumped in the distance.

Alex
57
57
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Hey, Max Griffin 🏳️‍🌈 Author Icon. This is a sad story, but you have managed to capture the sadness of the garrison at the end. Even though Marushka seems to be the only one wanting to preserve the spirit of Christmas, everyone is affected.

Couple of questions:

The departing garrison had left behind a year’s worth of rations and other supplies. Sacha and his team could survive for a decade or more, not that he expected they’d need to.

They can survive for more than a decade on one year's rations? It sounds like a two fishes and a loaf of bread type scenario. *Smile*

The next question: How long does Sacha plan to stay on Cabot's Landing? Since everyone has abandoned the planet, are they part of a permanent outpost or do they expect to leave at some point?

Great story!
Alex
58
58
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (3.5)
Title:
 Attack of the blobwoman  Open in new Window. (E)
Carole dreams of conquering the world. Could some outer space goo make it a reality?
#2247379 by Alextrax52 Author IconMail Icon


Author: Alextrax52 Author Icon


Hi, Alextrax.

Thank you for inviting me to review your story. My first impression is that this reads more as a comedy, rather than spooky. The scene where Carole is eating her way through the food in her refrigerator was funny! If you lighten up the tone a little bit, I could see this working as a children’s story. *Smile*

The most important issue I noticed is the telling instead of showing. I made a comment after the first paragraph with a suggestion on how to “show” versus “tell”. I made additional comments throughout the story below.

The plot is fine. With science fiction, anything goes. *Smile* I did not notice any plot holes or inconsistencies.

Another thing I noticed was the use of passive voice, instead of active voice. “She was wondering…” instead of “She wondered…”

Remember these comments, suggestions and feedback are my humble opinion only. Take what advice you like and ignore the rest. This is your story!

Carole Williams loved science. It had been a passion of hers ever since she was a little child. She’d spend hours a day trying to create a project that would serve a good purpose to the world, but she hadn’t quite managed to achieve one.

Her passion for science led to her to train for a teaching role at a school and she quickly proved popular with the class. They felt that Carole really knew her stuff knowledge-wise and how to use the equipment physically wise [This sounds rather sexual. *Shock*]. While her personal ambition hadn’t quite been fulfilled Carole was happy enough with her life and job.

That was until the day of the announcement….

[The beginning needs to hook your reader so they want to keep reading. This is mostly telling, like someone is reading the story to me. I’d rather be shown that Carole loves science, that her passion led her to teaching.

Think about: Carole Williams smiled as she walked to her classroom, eager to convey her passion for science to the young minds.

“Today’s lesson will really blow their minds,” she said to herself. “After this, I’ll be more popular than ever.” Other authors can word it better than me, but you get the point. *Smile*]


“You wanted to see me boss” Carole reported to her Supervisor Melanie

“Yes Carole I did, please take a seat”

Melanie Carole sat down in her office chair and looked a tad regretful and long faced

Carole tried to put a brave face on the decision but as she left the office to pack her stuff her mind was burning burned with rage.

Had she looked back she’d have seen Melanie crying her heart out at having to make that decision. She believed Carole was her best teacher and she was simply too expensive to keep on…

[Again, this is telling. If Carole cannot see Melanie crying or does not know it, the reader cannot either. Remember we are in Carole’s point of view. *Smile*]


As the thought passed through her mind however she noticed that it wasn’t a star at all, it was actually a meteorite and not only that she also saw that it was heading into the area close to her car. The meteorite flew into the big forest of trees and crashed into the woods right next to the road Carole was on.

Carole drove into the parking area at the woods entrance and investigated where it landed. Switching on her torch she waded her way through the thick mossy branches and patches of wet mud which got her hands and clothes quite muddy until at last she reached the crash site. The ground was venting vented smoke and the meteorite had appeared to burn up into a small rock crater, which was now a brownish red colour because of its fiery entrance. Carole was just about to touch it when suddenly it started cracking and then burst open into small pieces. Carole ducked behind a bigger rock to avoid any injuries.

When she regained her courage, she poked her head out to see what remained, and she was amazed. Revealed on top of the only remaining piece of the meteorite was a small glowing blob of light green goo, which seemed to be a little sentient as it was moving around on its own slightly.
[What does Carole see that makes her realize the blob is moving on its own? Does it move upward, against gravity? Does it change shape regardless of the space it is in?]


“This is so cool and exactly the sort of thing I need to achieve my dreams, I’d better get this home quickly”

Without hesitation, Carole scooped up the blob using a stick and carried it all the way back to her car where she placed it in her lunch container. She vacated left the area, intrigued with her find and what it might do...


The blob slithered its way across Carole’s bed all while making sure it didn’t touch her body as the cold feeling would surely wake her up. It made its way up to her mouth and it was a wise choice as Carole not only snored loudly but also with her mouth wide open. The blob waited for the opportunity and jumped into the wide hole presented to it. The blob had done it, it had got itself inside Carole’s body.

[Carole would wake up if something cold touched her skin, but not if it jumped inside her mouth?]

The blob flew down the neck and windpipe, passed by the rib cage protecting the heart and didn’t stop until it reached Carole’s stomach. It then merged itself into the stomach acids and became a part of Carole’s very DNA.

[This might rile up some human physiology geeks. Going from stomach acids to DNA is a big leap, so you might want to ask if any of your readers can guide you through this section. It really seems glossed over.]

This meant that it took on her persona and could feel everything that she did. In its actions it felt that this was going to be a deadly combination.

As the clock struck midnight the blob was ready.

[What is significant about midnight?]


The blob looked around the living room for something to wake Carole up and that’s when it saw a footrest by the sofa. The blob placed it in the centre of the room and ran up towards it.

[If the blob is inside Carole, how does it move the footrest?]

Carole was trying to gather her thoughts when she suddenly heard a sinister laughing shake through the room

“Who’s there? Show yourself”

[Is Carole frightened to hear a disembodied voice laugh? She seems to be more curious than scared.]

Without a moment’s hesitation, Carole ripped open the refrigerator and devoured everything inside before following suit with her freezer, her cupboards and the fruit bowl. She ate everything in sight including:

2 cartons of grapes
A pack of 6 sausage rolls
6 packs of biscuits and crisps
6 Bananas and 5 Apples
2 big cartons and 10 small bars of ice-cream
4 pizzas
2 bags of chips
6 packs of noodles
And so much more

[This looks like a recipe. You do not need to list what she ate so meticulously. You can just say she ate everything in the refrigerator and include a few items. Or you could say she raided the refrigerator and freezer, even consuming four frozen pizzas. JMHO.]

“What’s up Caz? We need to find more food” the blob cried almost impatiently

[Is Caz a nickname for Carole?]

Suddenly Carole felt the blob swirling around in her stomach and giggled as it pushed against her skin as it caused a tickling sensation. Eventually it died down and Carole suddenly felt a strange feeling. A feeling as if her stomach had suddenly been made out of elastic. Crucially the feeling of wanting to burst was no longer there.

[“Crucially” is an odd word here. Do you mean “importantly”?]

“One second, I shall get myself looking presentable”. “I can’t go out in just my PJ’s but thankfully I bought something in case this ever happened”

[She hasn’t grown out of her pajamas?]

Despite the increased ballast slowing her down, Carole had made it out of her apartment building with little problem. Helped further by the fact that because it was 2 in the morning, no one was up to see her.

[Despite being woken up by her stomach’s gurgling a little earlier? *Laugh*]

Just about squeezing her monstrous girth through the tiny door, Carole saw that there was no one at the counter or indeed in the shop at all.
[It is 2am. Does she expect someone to be there?]

With one eye now normal and the other still glowing green the 2 two entities cried simultaneously…

“It feels good doesn’t it Caz?”. “Your You’re almost ready to conquer the planet but first I believe we have a food court to ravage”

59
59
Review of Doomsday?  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Sci-fi Writers Guild  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Title:
 
STATIC
Doomsday? Open in new Window. (13+)
Dreamweaver Anthology: An asteroid heads towards earth, the stranger brings a solution.
#2252773 by LightinMind Author IconMail Icon


Author: LightinMind Author Icon


Hi, Light.

I enjoyed your short story. Will there be a follow-up? So many questions that need answers, and you left your readers with a great cliffhanger. Keep ‘em wanting more!

The main thing is to avoid telling and rely on showing the reader what is happening. A lot of this sounded like narration, as if someone was reading it to me. I pointed out some areas where this was prevalent, and offered some suggestions.

Black as the night, its igneous surface melted by the heat of another sun the asteroid hurtled towards the light and out of the darkness of deep space. For thousands of years, it had kept this trajectory, its purpose clear. This was a planet destroyer, and it was bound for earth.

Great opening! It is the hook that captures your reader’s interest. Here it sounds as if the asteroid is an intelligent being or at least has some instinct, and it is targeting Earth for some nefarious reason. In the story below, it sounds more like an asteroid whose path is unluckily on a collision course with Earth.

I made some more suggestion/comments below, but remember they are my humble opinion only! Take what suggestions you like and ignore the rest. This is your story!


The brown-cloaked hooded stranger jumped the eight-foot-tall electric fence landing quietly in the grass beyond. He waited a moment looking directly at where he knew the cameras to be. They broke off their hinges and crashed to the ground without getting any good pictures of him.

[Why did the cameras break off their hinges? Did he cut them off with his broadsword?]


His target was the billionaire owner of Blue Space, on the second floor of the mansion, playing on a gaming console in front of a 292-inch TV screen that filled one of the walls of his room. He had just sent his kids to bed and was now alone there. He walked into the room and greeted the billionaire politely. The man looked startled by the sudden entry and reached for a phone to alert his security. This mysteriously moved away from his hand as he did so. Confused and a little frightened by that the billionaire turned to face the intruder.

"Mr. Besk, it is my pleasure to make your acquaintance," the stranger said in perfect English. It was just one of his many languages. After 2000 years on this planet, he had learned all the major ones.

[A lot of telling here, and not much showing. For example, does the stranger know that the billionaire has just sent his children to bed? If the pov character cannot see it or does not know it, then the reader can’t either. *Smile*

Think about: The stranger crept up to the second floor and peeked inside a large room. A 292-inch TV screen completely filled one of the walls. The billionaire sat, playing on a gaming console.

He is all alone. He must have sent his children to bed.


Then, when he speaks, is there a reason that we need to know that the stranger speaks in perfect English? Perhaps he has features that would make someone think he did not?

Think about:
“Mr. Besk, it is my pleasure to make your acquaintance,” the stranger said. (Insert Besk’s reaction here)

“You speak perfect English,” Besk replied.
“It is one of many languages I have learned after 2000 years on this planet.”



"My name does not matter and do not be too harsh on your security guys. They could not have stopped me." {uThe stranger saw the fear in Besk's eyes.

How about: The stranger noted Besk’s wide eyes, darting around as if he was panicking.
Other authors could word it better, but as long as you’re showing, and not telling *Wink*


The bureaucracy involved would be far too burdensome.

[SO TRUE! Great line!]


"We can improve the processing power of your navigational computers so that they can deal with objects even as small as few centimeters in width. We can also improve your scanning capability to be able to scan the mineral content of whatever you survey. Effectively, when this is over, you will have a workable rocket design that could take you anywhere in the solar system. That with a vastly improved asteroid mining capability and a significant head start in that industry. I am reliably informed for instance that the target asteroid includes thousands of tons of gold and platinum. If we can shift the trajectory of the asteroid to hit the moon, it will shatter on impact. Mining its content would then be easy pickings for you."

[Is the stranger offering rockets to Besk to evacuate Earth or to mine the moon after impact?]

"Yes exactly, but the rocket will need to be five times the size of your current one and weigh ten times more. Also, the design of the main capsule will be constructed with a view to causing a maximum impact on the asteroid. Our navigation software and new scanning capabilities will precisely calculate the best point to strike the asteroid, to divert its course into the moon."

[Soooo…not exactly. *Laugh*]


Besk looked puzzled at the sight of such an ancient-looking weapon following such a hi-tech conversation but he nodded, nonetheless.

[Perhaps: Besk gave the stranger a puzzled look.

“It looks a little ancient for someone so hi-tech,” he said.]



Besk had his Chief Engineer and his accountant assembled in the conference room. The brown-cloaked figure in the corner stood hooded, his eyes scanning the room and otherwise silent and still.

"Have you checked out the specifications for the navigation array and scanners?" Besk asked his Chief Engineer.

"Yes, they check out, the software is twenty years ahead of anything on the market today. May I ask where you got this? The computer language they are using includes code libraries and possibilities that simply do not exist yet."

"You can ask but you will get no answers, do you really care so long as it works," said Besk glancing at the hooded man. "Can you build it?"

The Chief Engineer noticed the glance but was too excited by the technology to really care how Besk had obtained it and to follow on with that line of questioning.

[Establish the point of view in the very first sentence. I have been scolded about this many times. Since Besk is the first one mentioned, let’s keep it in his pov. Then, Besk cannot know that the Chief Engineer was excited unless he says so, or if you give us a description of the engineer to show he is excited. Perhaps:

As Besk turned back to the table, it appeared to him that the Chief engineer had not even heard the answer. He watched with amusement as the engineer peered intently at the computer screen, as if oblivious to the world around him.

Also, do the Chief Engineer and the accountant have names? It isn’t necessary, but it is kinda obvious to the reader.]



Turning to view whatever it was he noticed two cloaked men. One wore a black cloak and the other a brown cloak. They were fighting with broadswords before the rocket. A third man, similarly attired, joined them shortly after. He did not take part in the fight and just guarded the rocket itself.

[How close are they to the rocket? They must be right next to it, because the third man joins them, but guards the rocket instead of taking part in the fight.]

As the cameras zoomed in the swordsmen left the ground fighting while levitated. Flying at each other at great speeds and doing impossible somersaults through the air.

[The strangers are Jedi knights! *Shock*]

"This is coming to you live from the Blue Space center in [Insert city’s name], Texas. We are viewing two apparently supernatural swordsmen fighting in front of Mr. Besk’s Top Secret new rocket. The identity of these men is unknown."

As he spoke three Apache helicopters flew overhead. They began firing, concentrating their fire attack on the black-cloaked figure.

[The black cloak and the brown cloak are close together, so it would not be apparent from the reporter’s point of view that the helicopters are focusing on only one of them.]


A global audience gasped in horror as they started to make out the dark menacing shape of the asteroid. It was ten miles across and being mainly metallic completely deadly.

[How does the audience know it is mainly metallic if it is dark? *Wink*]

The navigation software refined the precise place to strike the asteroid, as it approached, factoring in a reading of the mineral composition and mass. Finally, it slammed into the asteroid at some 30,000 miles an hour, its 1000 tons of mass just enough to cause a jolt to the asteroid's trajectory. The asteroid shifted course and just minutes later slammed into the moon.

[If the camera in the cone of the missile is destroyed, are there other cameras available to show the impact and the collision?]
60
60
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Title:
 XLQ, the fashion mag for the Big Man Open in new Window. (13+)
The story of XLQ, THE fashion magazine for the Larger Man
#1180951 by fat_hiker Author IconMail Icon


Author: fat_hiker Author Icon

JMHO:


I thoroughly enjoyed your story about XLQ. I laughed out loud in several places. Great job!

My favorite parts were the areas where it sounded like a fashion review or a gossip column. For example, the bulleted points starting with “brilliant jewel tone tees…” Also, the mention of leading sumo wrestlers.

I was confused by the term “house organ”. I’m not familiar with that. In its context, does it mean limited distribution?

I could figure out what BHM meant: …gay men wanting subscriptions for their BHM partners. But I couldn’t figure out SSBHM earlier.

Thank you for the laughs!

Alex

Some more favorites:

Taglines like "Once you'd had fat, you'll never go back," are now turning up in memes, movies, songs, ... and women's desires.

*Laugh*


Roger immediately set about 'improving' his weight to the 800 pound level

*Shock*

Big Adventure's expanding, upscale line of eye-catching, super stylish, yet rugged and challenging clothes for the sporty bigger man, the "Biggest Adventure" line.

- brilliant jewel tone tees, football jerseys, and sport shirts in body-skimming cuts
- pants and shorts in spandex-enhanced stretch fabrics that ride closely over massive guts and thighs
- heavy cotton rugby shirts in richly toned horizontal striping or colour blocking, that really emphasize the size of chests and shoulders, with canvas rugby shorts and chinos to match (all with stretch panels, of course)
- body-hugging athletic spandex shorts and jerseys in rich shades and dayglo colours,
- and rugged workwear, in vast sizes for comfort and practicality.

Bernie soon backed up his choice of Roger as top model by hiring a stable of young SSBHM supermodels,

Coleman, a young cousin of Cindy, who at just 15 years old was already an awe-inspiring 450 lbs,

*Shock*

while the back cover featured Coleman, in searing neon yellow striped spandex muscle top and electric blue shorts, body and gut seemingly suspended in the air,

XLQ has its detractors, of course, who refer to it as FQ - Fatso Quarterly. But, frankly, who cares what Richard Simmons, Paris Hilton or the US Surgeon-General think? Certainly not the women and men who read XLQ! Its mix of fashion-forward pieces, fat-positivism, sports reporting (on sports for the larger male), news items on bigger guys and even male-focused recipes gives it a unique flair. Advertisers have been flocking to it.

[JMHO. I think this paragraph works better without the last sentence. *Smile*

61
61
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Title;
 I still got the Blues for you Open in new Window. (E)
A man faces his memorires of life before an alien invasion
#2253695 by macwriter Author IconMail Icon


Author: macwriter Author Icon

Plot:

Devin is one of the last human survivors of an alien invasion by the Charr. The war has finally turned in favor of the humans but at a huge cost. He is with a unit that is advancing upon the last known hive of the aliens. He remembers his wife, the last time he spoke to her. The song I Still Got the Blues for You continues running through his mind.

His last thoughts are of her as his unit is given the orders to attack.


Great story, Macwriter!

I like the hooks in the first paragraphs with the smells and tastes Devin is experiencing. It gives the reader a notion that something bad has happened without telling us. My favorite part is how you let the story unfold at its own pace so we don’t get a lot of information at once, and it also lets the reader adjust to Devin’s point of view.

And you did all that in less than 1000 words! Awesome!

Comments/Suggestions:

I made some comments and suggestions below, but remember they are my humble opinion only. Take what suggestions you like and ignore the rest. This is your story!

Devin kept his eyes closed as he breathed deeply. The smell of a burnt out city ran it’s scented fingers under his nose. He tried to breath through his mouth but the taste was almost as unbearable as smelling the foul air. The smell wouldn't have been so disheartening if it wasn’t one of hundred reminders of that day. It would almost have be bearable if it didn’t remind him of the days times that followed after that day and the many horror filled days that followed.

[There are a lot of repeated words here. Consider synonyms like “inhaled” instead of “breathed”. “Stench” or “odor” in place of “smell”. “Days” is hard to substitute so I made a suggestion for the final sentence. JMHO!]

He pressed the barrel of his laz-rifle to his forehead. He let out a slow deliberate breath. His mind raced and yet always found it’s its way back to the last phone call.

He could feel the presence of other soldiers. Each one going through a similar ritual of closure. In moments it would be all over. The last nest-hive wold would be assaulted and destroyed.

He wasn’t sure of it was a cruel twist of fate, an omen of things to come, or just a cosmic coincidence. He remembered it like it was yesterday. He was a money manger manager back then.

Today was the day. The last of the Carr Charr(?) Lords would be destroyed. Humans had won. They had survived the invasion. They survived Armageddon. They won because of greed.

The final lord hit hid inside it’s its hive-nest with it’s its defenses prepared.


62
62
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
Hi, Pure. I came across your story in the Please Review page.

Title:
 You Were Only a Human Open in new Window. (18+)
Shya may only be in control of the other humans there. But she wants more than that.
#2250735 by PureSciFi Author IconMail Icon


Author: PureSciFi Author Icon

Plot:

Shya lives on a planet that is controlled by the Octons, who force the humans to collect Colvian.

She wants to be like the Octons and challenges them to elevate her to their status.


They give her a chance to but I’m not sure about the outcome. Did she succeed?

I was also confused about the Colvian. The humans are forced to gather it, like a harvest, but then it turns out it is some form of currency? Kackim and Viloni have kept some of the Colvian and have built spaceships. Or is Colvian a sort of natural resource they used to build the spaceships?

Do the Octons live in luxury? What is it about them that Shya wants to be treated like one?

What was the chance the Octons gave Shya? In the last section, she’s suddenly in a spaceship? We don’t know if she succeeded because the story switches to another spaceship with Kackim and Viloni.

Those are some gaps in the plot that could use a little explanation to help your story read easier.
*Smile*

Comments/Feedback:

I made some suggestions and comments below, but remember these are my humble opinion only. Take what advice you like and ignore the rest. It is your story.

Shya bobbed her head to the left to avoid one fist to her face. Instead, she got another one to her head from behind her. Her head only bounced slightly forward before she stiffened her arms away from her and grabbed both Kackim and Viloni by their shirts and pull pulled them to within an inch of her.

["Her head" is repeated three times in close proximity. Think about using pronouns or synonyms such as"noggin" *Laugh*]

This last sentence is a little long. Consider splitting it into two sentences. Perhaps making the part where Shya is pulling them to her its own sentence?]


“They aren’t making us do anything,” says Shya Shya said. “It’s just easier for us to collect it because we are humans.”

Shya released Kackim and Viloni from her hands. “Now get back to collecting. We are still behind on the amount that we need for today.”

#

“You saw that fight,” said Shya. “Didn’t you? Kackim and Viloni are always fighting against each other. They have been for longer than I can remember.”

“They aren’t the only ones, though. Almost all of us humans feel the same way that they do,” continued Shya. “Why should we be collecting your Colvian instead of you?”

[Establish who Shya is talking to at the beginning. Consider: “Shya stood in front of three Octons seated behind a half-circle table. She stood with hands on hips.” Then she can start speaking. “You saw that fight…” *Smile*]

Shya relaxed a little bit. But she was still standing up straight with her hands in fists beside her in front of the three Octons behind a half-circle table. She looked at each one of them separately. Bounc was in the middle. And slightly behind him were Dancun to his right and Isani to his left.

[Shya fixed her icy stare first at Bounc, seated in the middle. Then she directed her gaze to Dancun, to Bounc’s right and Isani to his left.]


Bounc glance glanced at Dancun and Isani when Shya did it.


“I have already decided what to do with them,” said Shya. Shya said. “That’s not why I’m here. I’m here to show you one of the reasons why we aren’t going to get the amount of Colvian
that you want us to get today.”

#

The faceless head with long hair of Bounc turned toward Dancun and Isani. Dancun and Isani’s heads only slightly moved forward until they were touching Bounc at the line where their hair began. Shya's upper body leans leaned forward a little to hear what they were talking about. But she can’t hear them. All she can hear is their mumbling. could only discern the mumbled noises they made.


“What do I have to do to get ahead in life on this planet?” Shya asked herself as she paced around her small one-room living place.

[Good! We know that Shya is talking to herself rather than someone else who we have to wait to find out who it is. *Laugh*]

After she finished preparing her food, Shya placed it on a small table next to her sleeper. Then she uses used her Sleeper as a Seater to start eating that food. “How am I supposed to prove that I can be as good as them if they don’t give me a chance to do it?”

#

The next day instead of going to one of the Colvian Collections Shya went back to Colvian Command. And she’s about to place her hand in the three large fingered indented hand on the entrance to acknowledge her being there when she hears Bounc, Dancun, and Isani talking.

[Think about: “Before she could place her hand on the three-fingered indention at the entrance, the sound of familiar voices reached her ears. She pressed her ear against the door and recognized the unique mumbling sounds of Bounc, Dancun and Isani.” JMHO. *Smile*]



“There’s nothing wrong that I know of,” answered Shya. “I was just on my way there when you contacted me.”

[Did they?]

Shya stood straight with her hands clasped behind her back. “May I ask why you contacted me?”
[This is the first time Shya mentions that she was contacted by the Octons.]

#

A few hours later and Shya was on her way to Colvian Collection. “So, they think that we are doing it.”

“We aren’t,” continued Shya. “I’m sure that it’s some of the Octons who have been taking the Colvian. If that’s true, then all I need to do is prove it.”

“I just don’t know how I can do that yet,” said Shya. “But I do know one thing. I’m not going to get any of the other humans here killed by taking this chance.”

Shya sighed. “I know that the Octons said I could use any other humans that I want for this chance. But the only reason they said it was to get rid of as many of us as they can if this doesn’t go as planned. I’m not going to let that happen, though. Because I’m doing this alone.”

Suddenly Shya smiles. “I know how I’m going to prove that the Octons are taking the Colvian. All I need to do is finish this chance alive. And I’m going to do it. No matter what I must do to do it.”

[Is Shya talking to herself here?]

#

“I’m not going to be here for the next few days,” said Shya to a large group of about a thousand other humans in front of a large opening into a huge mountain behind that.[Behind what?]

“I want to go too.”

“So, do I.” a female pushed her way through the others to stand beside the male.

Suddenly, more than half the other humans there stepped forward saying similar comments. Shya puts put up the palm of her hands to stop them. “Thank you for you wanting to help
me. But I need to do this alone.”

[Are they volunteering to help her or wanting to have the same chance as Shya?]


#

Shya glanced at the large monitors on both sides of a huge one that showed nothing but Space on it. The two large ones are showing showed the Colvian scattered all around those very
big-looking rooms. Then she looked at the control panel in front of her and the huge monitor. “The Colvian appears to be still okay.”

“I’m almost to the second Octon planet,” continued Shya. “And I haven’t seen anyone who wants to take it from me, so far.”

“I don’t think that I will see anyone,” said Shya. “If nothing happens to this Colvian, then the Octons can blame us on the rest of it that has been taken.”

Suddenly, the darkness on the main monitor in front of Shya became a large spaceship similar to the one that she was on. Only that one was about four times bigger than hers.
“Maybe I’m right about the Octons.”

“I still don’t think any humans are doing it,” said Shya. “But it may be another race behind it besides humans and the Octons. After all, six other alien races can be taking it.”

[It’s difficult to follow what is going on here? Is Shya participating in a simulation? Or a video game?]
#


The images of Kackim and Viloni suddenly appear on the huge monitor in front of Shya. “Because we helped you to put it in your spaceship,” answered Kackim.
[Aren’t Kackim and Viloni her children? Are they leaving her on the planet?]




63
63
Review of Possession  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Very creepy story, W.D.Wilcox Author Icon. I always enjoy reading your work!

I can’t help but like Tony, but when he continues into the darkened ward after finding the body of his co-worker, I really wanted to smack him upside the head. *Laugh*

Your descriptions in each of the scenes was amazing, and I did not have any trouble imagining what I was reading.

Again, great story!

I had some questions for clarity, comments, and suggestions in the story, but remember they are my humble opinion only! If you like any of my comments, great! If not, just ignore them. This is your story! Only you know what is best!


Within the deep trench of night, in the rain-soaked town of Ripley, a lone policeman watches watched the dim yellow streetlights blink three times and then go out.


“Yeah, well you just wait until those lights start blinking again, and then you’ll see. The whole damn place turns into a regular mad house.” [As opposed to an irregular mad house? *Laugh*]


She shuffled toward the door, her silver hair in disarray, clumps of it sticking out comically as if she had just seen a ghost. She was only twenty-eight, but looked twice that age. Her eyes were as dark as black water and set deeply into her skull against pale and pasty skin. She was horribly frail—weak looking, as though she had never slept a day in her life. As she came forward, she stuck her index finger to her lips, “Shhh,” she whispered. “Let’s keep our voices down, okay, Tony? I’ve just put Elizabeth to bed. She’s been so cranky of late.”

[Tony isn’t looking at her directly, but can he see her out of the corner of his eye? In the next paragraph, she is looking around, so he would at least be able to have some sort of way of seeing her. *Smile*]


Tony looked down at the two shiny eyes cupped in his hand. They looked almost real, as if they were staring up at him. He would have to tell the doctor that Miss Grange popped them out again. She had been doing so well, too. This doll had lasted nearly four months. FIve years ago, the woman had done the exact same thing to her real two-year-old daughter, Elizabeth.
[Ick!]


Tony didn’t like the dark, hated it since he was a little kid, but he sighed heavily, slid his chair back, and stood. Feeling carefully along the wall, he inched his way out of the break room and down the hallway until he found the door to the stairwell. He opened it and slipped inside, blindly grabbing for the steel guide rail. Slowly, he started up the steps in the pitch black.

[This would probably ruin the mood, but would the building have emergency lights that would come on in case of a power outage?]

Something rolled busily across the floor—heavy, and made of metal.
[How does Tony know it is made of metal?]

With his mind roaring, he stood, stepping over Ray’s body, and entered the ward.
[I would have run out of there so fast, I would have created a vacuum!]

Startled, Tony fell back, dropping the flashlight. It exploded with the impact, batteries rolling across the floor and leaving him in pitch dark.

[Cheap flashlight! *Laugh*]

The huge dark eyes held him. Tony could not turn away.

Another one approached from the side. It touched Tony’s temple with something and his body went numb, the flashlight dropping from his hand with a thud and clatter.
[Just an observation. If Tony could not turn away from the creature, he would not be able to notice another one coming from his side. Perhaps he could hear it approach?]


“Shit, man, you don’t look so good.” Charlie led him toward the elevator. “Come on, I’m gonna get you out of here before the police show up.”

[Does Charlie suspect Tony is involved?]

Much later, back home and after a long sleep, Tony awoke with a start. The little lamp next to his bed lit up the familiar surroundings of his bedroom and he sighed with welcomed relief. His body shook with chills, his joints ached, and his mind was a blur of terrifying images. Shivering, Tony slipped deeper into the bed, pulling the covers up around his chin like a frightened child.

There was laughter and barking coming from downstairs. It was Luke, his son, playing with their dog, Bosley. There was a wonderful aroma of food cooking, and Tony knew that Karen, his pregnant wife, was preparing his favorite dish. It was as if everything were back to normal again.

[Is it day or night? Not that it matters, but I would think he would have a lamp on during the day. *Smile*]

But it wasn’t.

Tony couldn’t shake the feeling that something bad was going to happen, a growing dread within him that the nightmare wasn’t over, a gripping fear that his family was in terrible danger.

His eyes went to the bedside lamp beside him. It blinked three times, and went out.

[I guess it is night! *Laugh*]
64
64
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Peer Reviewers  Open in new Window.
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Title:
 INHERITANCE: & revenge is Sweet Open in new Window. (ASR)
Revenge is sweet. THE PROMPT ME CONTEST
#2252808 by dogpack saving 4premium+ Author IconMail Icon


Author: dogpack saving 4premium+ Author Icon

Plot:

Fran is waiting for her friend Nancy to help her move some papers out of the basement. The house is spooky and the darkness in the basement seems to be alive.

She waits outside until Nancy arrives. When they go into the basement, the light bulb bursts and leaves them in darkness. In their attempt to escape, they fall down the stairs.

They hear breathing and a voice speaks. Fran recognizes her Uncle Frank, who transferred the house over to her.

He says he’s been lonely and has been waiting for them. He walks up the stairs.


Scary tale! I did not notice any plot holes or inconsistencies, but it might flow better with some clarification in places.

In the second paragraph, Fran crosses the room and peers into the blackness. I did not realize until later that it was the basement. I originally thought there was a hole in the floor. *Laugh*

Fran never does explain to Nancy why the papers have to be retrieved that night and could not wait until morning.

I’m not quite sure I understood the ending. Uncle Frank has been living in the basement and when Fran and Nancy fell down the stairs, he’s going to leave them down there? He set a trap for them so he could escape?

Characters:

The main character is Fran. She owns a dilapidated house, but is scared to go into the basement. It is her childhood home and she has great memories growing up there.

Nancy is her best friend and has left a party reluctantly to come to Fran’s aid. She knows Fran’s background and that is one reason she has agreed to help.

Uncle Frank is a sinister presence living in the basement. I don’t think he needs much more description, because he is scary enough!

Voice:

We are in Fran’s point of view throughout the story, and I did not notice any head-hops.

In the beginning, you give Fran an accent of sorts: “do’no” and “I’m not a goin’ in there” but then she loses it. Consider carrying the accent for the entire story. Just a suggestion.

Setting:

A creepy old house. It has a basement that is dark and foreboding. I like the part about the creaking stairs to the basement and the father-built wooden steps out front. I think the contrast here is great! *Smile* The innocent vs. the profane.

JMHO!

What I liked best was the way you build up the suspense with Fran peering into the darkness, but then becoming so scared that she has to wait outside. The reader knows there is something about the basement, which I think many readers can relate to!

I really enjoyed your story, Dog pack! I hope you do well in the contest.

Comments/Suggestions:

I made some corrections, comments and suggestions below, but remember they are only my humble opinion. Take what advice you like and ignore the rest. Only you know what is best for your story!

This is scary. I do’no, what is in this darkness. I’m not a goin’ in there no matter what. She thought as he she crossed to the window.

[At first I thought she had a boyfriend or husband with her. *Wink*]

Taking in a deep exasperated breath she crossed the room again and peered into the blackness that if she went into it, would swallow her it seemed forever.

[Consider adding something here so the reader knows she’s looking into the basement. Perhaps: “…and peered into the blackness of the basement…”]

Nancy should behave arrive any minute.” Her slight smile wained waned as the wind blew and rustled the items down below. She shivered and moved quickly away from the dark as it seemed to reach out to her. “I’ve got to get outside and wait for Nancy. It makes sense.” With a shaking hand, she opened the door and found that the sun was lower than she thought it wasand the sky was grey.

Fran looked deeply into Nancies' Nancy’s eyes. “No, Nancy this is important.”

As she made her eyes wide, Fran opened her her eyes wide, she deliberately spoke in a serious tone. “No, it feels strange and I could use your help carrying the boxes. After all, we did this together in the first place.”

“Yeah, It was easy to convince your uncle to transfer ownership of the house over to you after your dad died.” She smiled a gentle smile gave Fran a gentle smile. I’m sorry to keep you waiting. It’s just that I was enjoying the party.”

Giving an (I told you so expression), Fran started down the creaking stairs.

Instead of parentheses, think about putting this into quotations or hyphenate them: Giving an “I told you so” expression; Giving an I-told-you-so expression. *Smile*

Slipping and knocking Fran down they fell into a deep depression hollow (or maybe ‘hole”?)

They heard deep breathing approaching. “Welcome, I’ve waited for you for a very long time. For many years I’ve had the time to prepare this place especially for the likes of you.” He took in a deep breath letting it out slowly. “No trespassing and no invasion of privacy. Can’t you read the signs?”

[Are there signs? Fran does not mention them.]

“Uncle Frank, is that you?” Fran barely managed to vocalize.

“It’s nice having long-time guests, I’ve been lonely. Our family is together again.” He chuckled and walked up the stairs. “Yup nice to have company for as long as I like.” His laughter boomed throughout the dilapidated house.

[Nice!]
65
65
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Hi, PuppetMaster

My comments below are my humble opinion only. Take what advice you like and ignore the rest. Only you know what is best for your story!

I enjoyed your story with the “happily ever after” ending. My only critique is a lot of telling, rather than showing. Show us what Ronnie is seeing instead of telling us.

The first paragraph takes the reader out of the story and it reads like a narrator is talking to us.
But the paragraph starting with “The next day, it rained…” is a good way of showing rather than telling.

Be careful of the adverbs, especially similar ones like “fortunately” and “luckily”.

Alex
66
66
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Crosstimbers Novel Workshop Gr...  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
Title:
 The First Summer of My New Life Open in new Window. (18+)
After over two years in a coma, Tina came out of it. It was a Summer she won’t forget.
#2252554 by PureSciFiPlus Author IconMail Icon


Author: PureSciFiPlus Author Icon

Plot:

Tina has come out of a two-and-a-half-year coma. Mitch bumps into Tina while playing volleyball. Tina isn’t upset but her father is, who comes over to grill Mitch.

Tina gets embarrassed and screams at him when they get back home. She blames him for her not making new friends. She goes into her room and her mother tells her that she will make new friends here.

Then Tina is back in the hospital in another coma that lasts six months.

Then she’s out of it and back on the beach, talking to Mitch.


At first I thought the second part with Tina in the hospital was a flashback to an earlier time, but re-reading, I realize that it isn’t.

Am I correct in thinking: Tina used to be in a 2 ½ year coma which is what she tells Mitch. Then later that day, she collapses and goes into another coma, which lasts for another six months. She comes out of this second one and Mitch tells her that he and his friends visited her every day while she was comatose?

Wouldn’t it be winter by then?

Characters:

The main character is Tina, who is 10 years old and has been in a coma for a while. She does not have many friends but meets Mitch, so things are looking up for her. *Smile*

Her parents Victoria and Jackson are typical parents who want the best for their daughter. Not much description here but probably not necessary.

Mitch is the guy Tina meets on the beach. Perhaps a little more description of him? What does Tina see when she is watching him play volleyball? Is he cute? Is he blonde or dark-haired? Tall? Plenty of opportunity here! *Wink*

Setting:

The first scene is on the beach in the summer. I think we can imagine what a beach looks like?

The second part is in the hospital.

The last part is back on the beach.

Voice:

For most of the story, we’re in Tina’s head. I did notice a big head-hop and mentioned that at the end of my comments below.

JMHO:

You have a good story here, but I’d like to know what happens between Tina and Mitch. Are you planning to write a sequel or follow-up? If you smooth out the transitions, it’ll be great! I only noticed two times where you went into present tense from past tense, so good job!

Comments:

I made some suggestions and comments below. Remember that these are my humble opinion only! Take what suggestions you like and ignore the rest. It is your story!


Running backward, Mitch almost fell on Tina. Wwho [Put a comma here after “Tina”.]was sitting on the beach watching the volleyball game that Mitch was a part of.
Only her standing hands and arms behind her stopped her from falling.

[I’m not sure what “standing hands and arms” means.]

Instead, Mitch rolled off her to a sitting position too. Just in time to catch the volleyball heading toward him.

[Isn’t Tina standing?]

Tina looked at Mitch and smiles smiled. “That’s one way to meet a girl.”

“Why not?” Mitch asked. “We know you have been watching us. Is it because you are new to our area? And you are shy about making new friends.”

[Consider making this into a question: “Are you shy about making new friends?” JMHO.]


“Of course, he isn’t. And nothing is going on here,” said Tina Tina said. “He just came over to invite me to join their volleyball game.”

“I HATE YOU, I HATE YOU, I HATE YOU,” Tina screamed as she left the living room. “I HATE YOU.”

[How old is Tina? I thought she was a young adult, but sounds like she is 12 or 13?
Also, since this part is in Jackson’s point of view, start in his pov. Perhaps: “Jackson smiled at Tina as she left the living room, screaming…(?)]


A few minutes later Victoria knocked on Tina’s bedroom door. When she didn’t get a ‘come in’ because of all the bellowing, Victoria enters entered anyway.

“I know,” said Tina as she sat up next to her mother. Wiping tears from her eyes as she did it. [Separate with a comma.]

“Of course, she does. She’s ten,” answered Victoria.

[Okay, got it! *Laugh*]


Victoria smiled. “That was easy. All I had to do was to remind her that she still had friends from where we used to live. In fact, she’s talking to some of them right now.”

[Is Victoria deliberately lying to her husband here? Why does she not tell him what she really said?]

“We don’t know Mr. and Mrs. Peterson,” answered Hanna. a voice from the computer monitor said. Jackson and Victoria noticed that Tina’s friend was looking at them from the screen.[Again, JMHO. *Smile*]

Hanna was now on a sideways turned computer screen on the floor next to Tina. “One second we were all talking. And the next she was on the floor looking dead.”

[Is Hanna worried about Tina. She doesn’t sound at all scared for her friend.]


Victoria double held one of Tina’s hands. And Jackson did the same thing with her other hand.
[This is a little abrupt, because Victoria and Jackson (Oh! I get it now! Victoria Jackson! She’s one of my favorite comediennes! *InLove* *Laugh*) were standing outside Tina’s room, and now they are at her bed. Think about: “Victoria entered Tina’s room and clasped Tina’s hand with both of hers.]


Jackson patted that hand. “Everything is going to be okay,” said Jackson.

“Of Course, she is. Now that we know what is wrong with her,” said Victoria.
[They do? The doctors just said they did not know what was wrong with her.]


Victoria took her eyes off of Tina to look at Jackson. “I’m starting to get worried about our little girl too.”

[She’s not already worried?]


“Don’t be embarrassed,” said Mitch. “It hasn’t to all of us at this age.” [I think there is a word missing here.]

Tina looked at Mitch and smiled. “By the way, you may know everything about me. But I don’t know anything about you. Not even your name. What is your name?”

[Wait a minute. If Tina doesn’t even know Mitch’s name, then the reader cannot either. We are in Tina’s point of view for most of the story, so we have to see things through her eyes. You could refer to Mitch as “the cute guy” or something for Tina to call him since she doesn’t know his name.*Smile*]
67
67
Review of Twisted circus  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Title:
 Twisted circus Open in new Window. (13+)
A fairy circus that has a dark evolving humans
#2252227 by I'm in the book now! Author IconMail Icon


Author: I'm in the book now! Author Icon

Plot:
Amanda is kidnapped by fairies and forced to perform in their circus.


It is a strange story, but you have it listed as “non-fiction”. *Wink*

There are some gaps in the storyline, so consider transitions when changing scenes or introducing new characters.

Characters:

The main character is Amanda. I get the feeling that she is a young girl, because you mention she is in school. Later, we realize that she is deaf. When she wakes up after being thrown into a cage, she wishes she could hear what they are saying, but then she responds to them in sign language. It is contradictory, so maybe Amanda can read lips?

Setting:

We’re in Riverside at the beginning of the story and it is wintertime. Then the scene moves to a circus, because we see tents.

You can do a whole lot with this setting since we’re in a fantasy world! Show us what Amanda is seeing! Are there unicorns? Do the trees look the same? What colors are the tents?

Use your imagination and create a fantastic world!

Voice:

Since Amanda is the main character, we remain in her point of view throughout the chapter, but as I mentioned before, if she is deaf, she will not be able to hear what the fairies are saying. At least not until they restore her hearing If Amanda doesn’t know what they are saying, then the reader shouldn’t as well.

Grammar/Spelling/Punctuation:

There are a lot of run-on sentences here that make understanding what is happening difficult. Also, you switch back and forth from past tense to present tense. Try to remain in only one. I prefer past tense, but you use whichever one you are most comfortable with.

JMHO:

This could be a great story with some edits and re-writes. It seems as if this is the first chapter of a longer work? Are you planning to continue this story? We’d like to know what happens to Amanda. *Smile*

Comments:

I made some comments and suggestions below, but remember they are just my humble opinion. Take what suggestions you like and ignore the rest. This is your story!

She follows the smell in the distance a Fairy smiles for it has lured her into a fairy ring. Amanda starts to feel dizzy and falls to the ground and blacks out. When she wakes up and sees a bunch of strange looking people in strange clothing they were bidding on stuff suddenly she was roughly thrown into a cage.

Here is one place you switch from past into present and run-on sentences. Consider: She followed the fragrance for a short distance, until she spotted a fairy sitting in her path. With a big smile, she ran toward the fairy, but it vanished. Only then did Amanda notice she was standing in a fairy ring…. *Smile*]


“She’ll do nicely thanks Pip,” said a man with pointy ears dressed up in ringmaster’s attire. Amanda wished she knew what he was saying so she could scream at the man to free her. She fumed.
“Why so silent? Most people I buy fresh from the human world screams and shout at me”

Amanda uses sign language to say, “Gee I don’t know, maybe it's because I'm deaf!” [Amanda wishes she could hear what he was saying but then she understands him? This needs to be clarified as to how she understands his second sentence.]

She said with pure seriousness. The man was laughing. She gives him an annoyed look and walks away. Amanda wanted out of her cage. She tries to escape but fails when she realizes the door was unlocked the whole time and facepalms.

[If the door is unlocked, she should be able to escape, right? *Wink*]


“That's why he shouldn't disobey”She said watching the body chasing the loose head Amanda was very confused the woman looked at Amanda [Run-on sentences.]

“WHY CAN’T ANYONE UNDERSTAND I'M DEAF!” screamed Amanda she was so frustrated she kicked a bucket.

[So Amanda can talk?]


Assuming he hasn't seen her she remains where she was suddenly someone drags her behind some crates she looks at them it was the doll boys body it was holding the doll boys head, she looks the pulley system he had replaced his head with a watermelon and a wig on the contraption “your You’re pretty brave for wandering around here at night” he whispers. Amanda, still bewildered that she could hear now responds with

[If you have any questions or need clarification, just let me know.*Smile*]
68
68
Review of Meeting Him  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Crosstimbers Novel Workshop Gr...  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Such a wonderful poem, Jim! It sort of took me back to being young and believing in Santa Claus (still do, of course!)

My favorite line is where the narrator is crushed by a hug from Santa. We should all be so lucky.

You have a great way of bringing joy to your poem and your readers!

Thank you!
69
69
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
What a fun crossword puzzle, Robert! Thank you for posting it!
70
70
Review of A New Dawn Ch.1  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Title: {biem:2237614}

Author: Zachary Wright Author Icon

Plot:

Raijin and his twin brother Darius, were abandoned by their parents because they couldn’t afford to raise them. Raijin is a rare kind of witch. He is practicing his magic by duplicating a gold ring. He is successful, but loses control of his magic and causes an explosion. Darius saves him by knocking him to the ground and shielding him from the blast.

They run to a training ground for the first day. Raijin is pitted against Samuel, who apparently is not a good person. Raijin choses swords for their combat.


Although we are introduced to a new fantasy world, the story is rather easy to follow along, with new settings, new characters, etc. There does seem to be a connection with our current world since Raijin references Japanese and Polynesian deities.

There did seem to be an abrupt shift in the middle. After the explosion, Raijin says his ears are ringing and he does not hear what Darius said. Darius doesn’t pause to make sure Raijin isn’t hurt before he’s running off to class. Does Raijin’s hearing return right away? It just seemed to me that Darius cares more about class than his brother.

Characters:

Raijin – a rare kind of witch that can do all the types of magics other witches can do, but has trouble controlling them

Darius – can manipulate lightning and protective of his brother.

Samuel – the Prince of the Archangels and a bully

Metatron – their training instructor. He is about 500 years old, and has a dark beard streaked with gray.

There isn’t much description on these characters right now, but I’m sure we’ll get to know them soon. *Smile*

Setting:

We are in a magical realm Zora, with entities that can perform different types of magic. The story opens in a castle where Raijin is practicing his magic. Consider a little more description of the room: how big is it? Is it cluttered with books? Is the sunlight from the windows the only source of illumination?

Also, show us the trip to the training ground. Are they in a forest? Or plains?

You can do so much here that will bring your story to life!

Voice:

There is a lot of ‘telling’ in this chapter and not much ‘showing’. I understand the need to narrate when you’re creating a new fantasy world, but it is okay to jump right into the story without the need for an introduction. *Smile* Your readers will catch up.

Consider starting with Raijin trying to duplicate the ring and then slowly include their back story.

JMHO

I enjoy a good fantasy story and I think you have the beginnings of one here. You captured my interest and I am looking forward to the next chapter! I mentioned earlier about ‘telling’ vs ‘showing’ so if you have questions about that, please let me know.

I’m excited about your novel.

Comments/Feedback:

Remember my comments are just my humble opinion. Take what advice you like and ignore the rest. This is your story!

Ever since The High Flame found us, we became servants.

[Servants of whom? The High Flame?]


My brother would say that we are treated better than servants at least we get an education. I do appreciate that but we have to start our morning serving breakfast, then clean certain parts of the castle, then go to classes, then serve dinner, and then bed, but before lights out we have to find time to study whenever we can or we do not get to study at all that day.

[This is a rather long sentence. Consider breaking it up. Think about ending it after “and then bed.” And the next sentences: Before lights out, we have to find time to study, because we do not get to study during the day. (JMHO)]


I feel so cheated. The children of these deities are treated as royalty, as for us we are treated like slaves.

[This would be a good place to explain why Darius thinks they are treated better than servants, but Raijin thinks they are treated as slaves.]

I shook the cobwebs out of my head and slammed my hands on the oak desk. This ritual spell needs all of my concentration. In order to win my match in class today I need to be prepared. The first thing I need to do is make two duplicates of this gold ring, that I swiped from Samuel, the most privileged of the children here, and placed the ring in the center of the table.

[A little confusion here. How about: The first think I had to do was make two duplicates of the gold ring I swiped from Samuel, the most privileged of children here. I placed the ring in the center of the table.]


There was a small flash of stunning white light where the ring was placed on the table.

[A flash of white light surrounding the ring stunned me.]

After the light faded there were a total of three gold rings laying in front of me. A quick peek around to see if I was still alone.

Nothing outside the windows other than sequoias and pine trees, the leaves casting shadows on the study’s carpet. Nobody in the doorway, and the keeper of the books was still on lunch.

[Good description! This is ‘showing’ instead of ‘telling’! *Smile*]


I finished the ritual circle with a lemniscate in the center of the inner circle.

[I had to look that up! *Laugh*]

Heat began radiating from my hand as I poured my magic power into the spell. The ritual circle began glowing a dull golden brown, but the ring shined a brilliant gold. The colors dimmed and I cut the flow of power to the ritual then placed the ring in my second burlap sack.

[This is another good section!]

“Raijin! What are you doing?” the voice yelled from the opening.
I turned to see Darius, my brother.

His amber eyes wide with shock.

[Yes! Good! You did not have to tell us he was shocked. You showed us he was by his expression!]


I love the outdoors, the sun, the sky, the trees, and the different types of animals. All of which are fascinating.

[What kind of fascinating animals does he see? We’re in a fantasy world here so be creative!]


Samuel and I were handed bamboo training swords. We faced each other, holding the hilts of our swords at chest level.

“Are you ready for an embarrassing defeat?” Samuel asked.

“You wish.”

[Perhaps a little more excitement for the hook to be sure the reader wants to go to the next chapter. Perhaps: Without warning, Samuel lunged at me, with his sword aiming directly at my heart.]
71
71
Review of Fairy Nuff  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Crosstimbers Novel Workshop Gr...  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi, Beholden Author Icon. I found your story listed on the Fantasy Newsletter this week and admit I was drawn in by the title "Fairy Nuff" (Fair Enough *Laugh*). I'm a sucker for puns. My interest was further captured when the main character arrives at the "Snot Fayre" ('s not fair! *Hysterical*).

You could have included comedy as a genre, because the conversation between the main character and the ticket taker was hilarious.

One thing I'm a little curious about. Did Fairy Nuff put some sort of spell on the main character? Was that her way of 'passing the torch' so to speak? I re-read it to be sure she wasn't given a potion or something to ingest. Just wondering.

Also, might I suggest describing Fairy Nuff when the main character wakes up? She's probably very old now, beyond the middle-aged when the MC first encountered earlier in the day? JMHO! *Smile*

Great read!
72
72
Review of Medusa  Open in new Window.
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Crosstimbers Novel Workshop Gr...  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Title:
 
STATIC
Medusa Open in new Window. (13+)
A convicted criminal is stalked by a monster he helped to create...
#2250569 by TCF519 Author IconMail Icon


Author: TCF519 Author Icon

Plot:


Carter is a teenager, who has committed a terrible crime, and he has become an outcast from his community, including his parents. He is called a “rapist” at one point in the story so that must have been the crime. His girlfriend Nadia at the time told everyone what he had done and then killed herself.

Carter is given a slap on the wrist for his transgressions and the community becomes outraged.

He experiences strange noises on the roof of his car one night, but can not find the source. He discovers scratches on the roof of his car. The next day, he goes jogging in a park and something that he cannot see chases him back home in terror.

The next night after leaving work and trying to get something to eat, a monstrous beast attacks him. It is a Medusa-type creature with Nadia’s face. She is back from the dead to take her revenge on him. She turns him to stone.

I did not notice any holes in the plot, problems with continuity, or any other errors in the story.

Grammar:

I didn’t notice any misspelled words or punctuation problems. Watch those adverbs! *Laugh*

Setting:

The town is not named in the story, but it sounds like Anytown, USA, a small community where everybody knows everybody else’s business.

Voice:

There was a place where the omniscient narrator took over and I made a note of it below.

Overall impression:

I really enjoyed this story, Kirby! I think it has great scares in it and I would definitely like to read more of your work. *Smile* Good job! Your descriptions of the monster are quite creepy, but you did that throughout the story.

I made some wording suggestions in my comments but remember they are only my humble opinion. Take what advice you like and ignore the rest. It is your story! *Smile*


Comments:

It was 4 AM when Carter finished his shift at the grocery store, and the streets were painfully silent as he made his way home.

[I suggest using active voice here. Consider: Carter finished his shift at the grocery store at 4AM and drove home though the deathly silent streets.]


A heavy thud on the roof of his car shook him from his musing, and Carter nearly drove off the road in shock. He glanced up and wondered what could have possibly hit him, as there were no trees along that stretch of Market Street. As he slowly pulled over to the shoulder to check for any damage, he heard a scratching sound that sent chills down his spine. Though he tried to reason it away, he could not shake the sickening feeling building in his stomach that something was very wrong.

[This is kind of repeating what we already know. You did that very well. I suggest something like: Though he tried to reason it away, he could not shake the building sense of dread in his stomach.]


When he came to a stop, so did the scratching, and he briefly wondered if he ought to just get back on the road rather than investigate

Carter slid out of the car and hoisted himself up so he could see if anything had hit his roof.

[What kind of car is Carter driving? If he had to hoist himself up, perhaps he’s driving a van. If it is a typical sedan, he would just have to stand up. *Wink* Also, I’m thinking that maybe he takes a cautious peek on the roof, just in case something untoward is up there? Or perhaps he steps away from his car, maybe to be our of range of what might be on the roof? JMHO]

When he glanced back down the road, he could see nothing, though he doubted he would have found any evidence even in the daytime. Whatever had caused the damage was long gone,

[Hmmm…it seems like it has been only a few seconds since he heard the thump and the scratching. Does he not think that whatever it is might be hiding nearby? Remember it is dark and something could be hiding in the shadows.]


The drive back home was thankfully uneventful, though Carter kept his eyes and ears open the whole way should something else happen.

***

It was noon the next day when Carter woke up and trudged downstairs to make himself some food--cereal, since he did not have the stomach for much else.

[Passive voice. Consider: Carter woke up the next day at noon…]

Then, as he tightened his laces, there came a new sound from behind him: it was a deep, rough growl, but it did not sound like any kind of dog animal he knew.


As he scanned his surroundings for the source of the snarling, he noticed that the other sounds were silenced. The birds stopped chirping, the fountain shut off, and the mowers in the distant grew quiet, leaving only the disembodied growl.

[Can Carter see the fountain? Did it really shut off or did he just perceive it stopped?]

He vaulted over the backyard fence, sprinted to the back door, and slammed it behind him, and only then did the growling stop. Carter pressed himself up against the door as if to block off whatever had been chasing him, but nothing happened; nothing slammed against the door nor scratched at it like his car. His hand shakily rose up and lifted the blinds open just enough for him to peer through, only to find there was nothing outside.

[How about: He lifted the blinds, with hands shaking, just enough for him to peer through…?]

Satisfied, Carter let out a sigh of relief and slid into the driver's seat, just missing the sound of large wings flapping overhead.

[Since we are seeing all this through Carter’s point of view, if Carter doesn’t hear it, then the reader should not either. It takes the reader out of the pov of the character and becomes telling rather than showing. I know this is meant to add a bit of horror to the story, but consider having him hear the wings and slamming the door shut in fear. JMHO *Smile*]


Just when he thought he was in the clear, he heard a sickening growl that made him jump in his seat and slam on the brakes.

[Kind of a jump here. We don’t see him starting the car, and already he’s hitting the brakes. Is he out of the parking lot? Is he back on the street from last night where the first incident happened?]



"Let me just get a couple scrambled eggs, three sausage links, and some hash browns," he requested, which the waitress committed to memory.

"Be out in just a few, hon," she hummed before sauntering back to the kitchen.

[The waitress does not recognize him?]

As he stormed back to his car, he could feel the staff glaring at him from the window, judging him just like everyone else in the world. His whole world was getting smaller and smaller by the day, and he wondered if it would get to the point where he could not even leave the house. The scorn he suffered on a daily basis was unbearable and

Carter rocketed down the street, his foot firmly planted on the gas pedal and his teeth grinding against each other. All he could see was red as vVisions of Nadia danced through his head, tormenting him the only way she still could.

Just as he spotted a gas station down the road, something crashed down on the roof of his car with such intensity that the ceiling all but caved in. Carter jolted in his seat and slammed on the brakes before coming to a screeching halt on the shoulder of the road. He looked up to see that whatever landed on the roof had missed him by mere inches, but before he could reflect on that, he was alerted by a hideous screech from above. [I’m thinking that if he is still in his car, he won’t be able to see anything on his roof, right? Also, consider: “A hideous screech from up above shook his soul (or something similar).” *Smile*]

[Does the gas station play a part in the story? If not, just take it out since it is not mentioned again.]

But the most disturbing of all--the part that held Carter captive in his fear--was that a bed of snakes rested atop [“rested” makes me think of snakes curled up, but in this case they are very active. How about “…a writhing bed of snakes topped its head…] of its head in place of hair. The mess of serpents slithered and aimlessly writhed about in every direction, their hisses louder than a swarm of cicadas.

He did not ponder how Nadia could have come back or if that was even her to begin with. Instead, Carter turned and sprinted down the side street faster than he thought possible--even faster than when she chased him from the pond. Unfortunately, the outcome was the same as the day before, for though he broke all of his previous records, there was no outrunning the abomination Nadia had become. All he could do was pray that he found some shelter so he could have a chance to think and plan his escape from her.

[Maybe the gas station? *Laugh*]


When she peeled him from the sidewalk street, tears mixed with blood and he choked out, "Nadia...please, stop."

The body, meanwhile, was found by a jogger on the grounds of an apartment complex

[Perhaps: “Meanwhile, a jogger found a fallen statue where none had been before]
. After the city trash collectors said they would not dispose of it due to it exceeding the weight limits for bulky item pickups, the complex's maintenance crew brought it back to their workshop and broke it down over the next several days. They had no reason to believe it was anything besides some ugly statue, and so they took their sledgehammers to it and brought the pieces to the community dumpster. Carter was laid to rest in a mountain of garbage, his body scattered across the landfill and lost to time amid so much refuse.
73
73
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with Crosstimbers Novel Workshop Gr...  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Interesting crossword, Xiea. I had to google some of the answers. Just a heads-up though. The answer to 3 across is "Basilisk" and it shares the second letter of 2 down which is "werewolf". Unfortunately, that makes the spelling of 2 down as "warewolf".

Thanks!
74
74
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Max,

I don’t understand the third paragraph, starting with “He’d chosen his own appearance…” It reads as if Sigurd is a hologram i.e. ‘chosen his own appearance’ ‘send a message about his personna’ ‘construct an image’?

Was there any interaction between Sigurd, Elam Vandreren and the Sector Auditor on the trip to Cabot’s Landing? Were the occupants of the Zuiderkruis in suspended animation or long-term sleep? Or were they awake for the entire time? It sounds as if faster-than-light speed is available in this setting so did passengers and crew get to interact during the trip?

I like the camaraderie that seems to be growing between Elam and Sigurd. The closing line adds a little bit of intrigue…is Sigurd interested in Elam? Hmmmmmm….

As I mentioned in the second paragraph, perhaps a little more information on how the ship is able to move from solar system to solar system. Faster-than-light travel? Or suspended animation? It doesn’t need to be too science-y but some idea on the technology in this story.

Great job!
75
75
Review by Alex Morgan Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
I like the Prolegomenon to understand what the setting is. Is there a larger view of the map? I was trying to see where Lansbury was but couldn’t find it. There is a mention of an entry for bandersnatch but I couldn’t find it. I’m also not clear on what the ghostships are.

I feel I know Bender better than Elam after this chapter, but I’m get the sense that Elam is going to be the main character here. Bender sounds like a stuffy, stiff-upper lip, by-the-rules type of guy, but still likable. I didn’t get the feeling that he is gay although he put his hand on Elam’s knee, but that he seems rather fatherly to Elam. Is there a large age difference between them?

Elam Vandreren is an enigma. Apparently, he is fleeing an uncomfortable situation or a checkered past?
He’s not a friendly type.

Great beginning!
81 Reviews *Magnify*
Page of 4 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ajmorgan4db7/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3