David,
When a parent makes a sacrifice for their children, that's being an everyday hero. This story about a father taking a backseat was warm-hearted, fulfilling, and instructive; it reminds us that the children are the star of the show, no matter what the show is. They're the main actors; we're just the supporting cast..
Here's my thoughts on your work, organized so I don't ramble all over the place, which is my wont:
Introduction     ▶︎The first paragraph is comfortable, allowing the reader to ease into the story and relax along with Noah. Some stories need to jar the reader to get them into the story. This type of story didn't need it, didn't do it, and the opening is stronger for it.
Setting     ▶︎ The Living Room: Sparingly described, the reader gets to immerse himself, in his imagination, in any room he's ever been in in real life. The lack of specifics, aside form the couch and the video game, allows the reader to focus on the emotion (which is the action) of the scene.
The Library: Excellent job describing the line of people waiting to have a book signed. It put the scene into a very visual context for the reader.
The Gymnasium: While the story focuses on Noah, Noah focuses on Isaac. We are encouraged to watch the young boy through the eyes of a parent, to feel the pride and fulfillment. We are also encouraged to feel Noah's anonymity, to remember that we're just one person among many, and we're not always the star of the show— and that's the way it should be.
Characters     ▶︎ Noah: The father figure in this story is depicted well. He is nurturing, but self-aware enough to know that, in this event, he runs the risk of overshadowing his son. It is gratifying to the reader that he decides against being his son's partner. Modesty is a lost art in the real world, it often seems.
Isaac: Isaac is a loosely defined character. He is used in the story more as a means to drive the main character's (Noah's) parental journey through a pivotal moment in his child's life. You use him sparingly, allowing (ironically) the focus to remain on Noah. This keeps the reader on track and prevents the story from wandering. Good choice.
Andrew: A potential competitor, Andrew represents an obstacle or conflict for Noah to overcome psychologically. Does Noah snatch away this mentor from his son so he can have all the glory in his son's eyes? Or does he allow his child to develop by reaching beyond the four walls of his childhood and growing in confidence and experience. As Noah makes the "correct" choice, the reader is once again relieved.
Plot/Arc     ▶︎The arc of this story was excellent. It's a great story organized into three distinct scenes of the requisite elements: introduction ("dad will you help me"), conflict (potential jealosy of someone else helping), and resolution (Noah watching proudly from anonymity). Outstanding.
Mechanics     ▶︎Impeccable mechanics. Puntuation, grammar, spelling, sentence structure, organization: I couldn't offer any suggesstions or criticisms if I tried.
Conclusion     ▶︎As mentioned, the conclusion of this story is both fulfilling and important, as it reminds the reader to just be the coach a lot of the time, not the star hitter. There is much more satifaction in watching our children win at their own endeavors than borrowing the win alongside them.
Constructive Comments ▶︎I wouldn't change a thing. Not even the wine chosen for the occasion. 
This was a thoughtful, engaging, and well-written story that was a pleasure to read.
This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
  " The Power Reviewers Group"  
 ![Power Review Image - Triple Guitar [#2194837]
~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~ ~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~](https://www.writing.com/main/images/action/display/ver/1770755738/item_id/2194837.jpg) Image # 2333342 over display limit. -?-
Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.
|