Mike,
Well, you certainly have adapted the term "tall tale!"
The overall themes of repression, helplessness, power, and revenge are approached in an interesting way. Let's a take a blow-by-blow look at these sections of the story and see how well they work. I'll add up the stars as we go and see where you land with a final rating. Fair enough? Here we go.
Reviewer's note: In order to keep this cleaner and less eye-daunting, I have used "dropnotes" in this review—the blue text below that has little triangles next to it. These are expandable sections. Click on them to view what I have written in that section.
Themes
Repression: ▼
There are several indicators at the beginning of the story that Mabel is repressed in her marriage. In fact, it is vaguely hinted at that she is in a mentally or physically abusive relationship.
Mable. Any time she feels she has not served or performed adequately for her husband, she becomes nervous and apologizes.
~ perhaps he hadn't been talking and she shouldn't feel guilty about not listening. But out came an apology anyway.
~ accidentally drop the box on her husband's foot. "Ow!" he exclaimed. "I'm sorry! I'm sorry! I'm so, so sorry!"
Eric. Eric, meanwhile, enjoys his wife's nervous submission.
~ "Don't apologize," he said, wagging his finger, "Nothing to apologize about. Not this time, anyway."
~ Her husband jokingly banged an end table with his fist.
~ Eric took the car home, traumatized. (Of note in this line is the powerful becoming powerless; in the model of an abusive relationship, the abuser losing his control over the abused and becoming fearful in return.)
Eric, the flip side: Curiously, Eric also shows signs of support and concern in the story as well. The reader is not sure if he simply enjoys a cruel sense of humor by making his wife nervous (which is some low-key emotional abuse, don't be fooled) or if his behaviors need to be tightened up in the writing to show he's not about to beat the $#!^ out of her for not paying attention to him or for apologizing too much.:
~ He embraced her tightly, caressing her carroty locks.
~ He did as he was bidden.
~ "You know I love you, Mabel, right?"
Helplessness: ▼
Mable shows signs of physical weakness that mirror her emotional weakness. These feelings of helplessness, when squeezed ever more tightly with repression and/or oppression, breed some seriously destructive emotions in people. Examples can be seen in the sudden outlash of violence in US postal workers in the '80s, young-adult suicides, and rampant school shootings.
Physical:
~ "Books in that white box?" she asked...She carried it across the room. Her strength eventually failed her...
Emotional:
~ But out came an apology anyway.
~ "How do I do that?" she asked desperately...
~
Power and Revenge: ▼
Mable. Mable begins to understand that her height transfers the power dynamic to herself. She begins to take action instead of waiting to be acted upon. The cycle of abuse begins to re-emerge as a theme as Mable uses her newly discovered strengths to the detriment of others.
~ "This. I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry..."
~ Now Mabel stands at 80 feet tall. She coerced workers into building her a fortress
~ Whatever she wants is hers.
The vindication at the end still does not break the cycle wherein the oppressed becomes the oppressor, the abused becomes the abuser.
Writing:
Mechanics:     ▼
For such a fantastical piece, your mechanics are spot-on. I don't see a bunch of spicy commas—my personal term for commas appearing frequently in random place.  Grammar is appropriate, paragraphs are separated correctly—including dialog being broken out as new paragraphs. That really helps the reader keep track of who's talking, and it relieves the writer from having to add "Mable said" or "said Eric" after every bit of text in quotes. Good job on the mechanics!
Vocabulary:     ▼
The vocabulary you selected for this story is perfect. It's simple without being simplistic. Casually friendly and sprinkled with some unusual humor, the reader is very much at ease reading this.
Introduction:    ▼
The intro to this story is well-written. It is uncomfortable, but it rather has to be to set up the logic for the rest of the story, explored in the sections above. The only problem with it is that it is very, very short. We start getting into action in just a few sentences, before we have any other background or definition around the characters, directly or indirectly.
Flow:    ▼
The flow could be better. Everything happens very fast. Granted, it's a short story, not a Stephen King novel. Still, the action flows from normal to odd to fantastical with whiplash rapidity. That having been said, the search for a cure to Mable's "biggitis" is a good tool to slow that roll somewhat.
Cohesion:    ▼
I'm just not sure on this one. The problem I have with the cohesion of this piece is the power dynamic. As I've mentioned, we see an abusive power dynamic set up in the beginning that shifts and fades uncertainly throughout the story. Yet, we see direct signs of it on the role reversal at the end. The fact that that key relationship is unevenly written is problematic for me.
Logic:     ▼
Look, it's a fantasy story, of course it's going to be illogical. However, every fantasy story has to have a reality on which to build itself, and I think you covered the bases on this. For instance, the family reacts pretty strongly to Mable's growth—I like the way you offered them the explanation of a magic trick. And when she really sprouts, the family reacts appropriately by screaming; the two young nephews being unphased is a nice nod to modern children's desensitization of absurd. The search for an answer is actually a great part: they try to figure it out themselves first, at the beginning; then they consult science and get nothing; then even the mystic offers nothing useful. (That concoction was a great potion by the way, creative and horrifying!) Like many diseases (which Mable originally thinks this is), there's simply nothing anyone can find to be done about it. And in the end, the possibility of being hunted down and killed for her freakish and dangerous size is contemplated as a reality, which it certainly would be. Again, my only problem is the rushed pace. So actually, good job on the logic.
Conclusion:   ▼
The conclusion is not bad. It's also a bit rushed, though. For example, we don't have any evidence of anyone oppressing Mable other than Eric. Why has she suddenly gone out and enslaved random people? The reader is offered only two points of closure: 1) the reassertion of the cycle of abuse and violence; 2) validation of Mable's "equality" in that she never has to apologize to anyone ever again. On this last point, though, the reader is a bit divided. Sure, she never has to apologize again, because no one can force her to. However, Mable is quickly racking up offenses for which she should apologize. But "she is through with apologizing to anyone," again displaying the selfish, strength and certainty of an abuser.
Overall Opinion:    ▼This was a weird fable exploring the cycle of abuse and the danger of suddenly acquiring power without ever having been "trained" to wield it. (Kind of like the lottery winners that are broke in a year!) There seems to be a glut of shrinking or growing woman stories lately. I'm not sure what the attraction is, if there is one, beyond the extraordinary and seeming incontrovertible power dynamic. Personally, it's not my cup of tea. I just think there's better ways to tell that fable.
Final score:    
I appreciate your trust in me to give an honest opinion on your hard work, Mike. I'll read more of it in the future, no doubt. Until then...Write on!
--Jeffrey
|