*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/elfindragon/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
436 Public Reviews Given
465 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 5 ... Next
51
51
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
I usually have a whole review set that I use. But after reading this beautifully made song all I can say is that it made me smile. Not only made me smile, but it made my soul sing. If you had actual music with it I would probably be singing right along with it.

I'm so happy to have decided to read this song. Thank you for writing it. *Smile*
Elfin Dragon


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
52
52
for entry "Ending in Darkness
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*Leaf2g* Good Points:
It's an interesting beginning and concept for a story. I've always loved black holes and all the different theories behind them. So many ways a story could go with one involved.

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
The only thing with the grammar I would note here is to condense. For instance. in your first paragraph when you're talking about the black hole. Instead of saying, "Powerful enough to pull the light out of any star." You might say, "Powerful enough to pull the light from nearby stars."

The other sentence which puzzles me is..."The light burning the eyes of those four ..." It's an oddly worded sentence. I get the idea that you have four people in a field and then the gods and goddesses show up. But this first sentence needs to be better formed.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
Since this first "chapter" is so short I have difficulty forming an opinion of characters and world view. There's not a whole lot to grasp onto here other than a vague impression of Greek mythology.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
I'd like to see this chapter developed a little more. Perhaps start it out with the four people and what their asking their gods help for? Give the reader a little bit of insight to the characters before introducing them to the gods and what the gods want from the characters. At least that's what I would like to see first.

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
As I mentioned at the beginning, all of my comments here are only my opinion. I do like what you've started here and would like to see it developed more. It certainly has a lot of potential.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
53
53
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:

yes indeedee the little ditty gets a one from me.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
54
54
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
yes, yes, I'll give you the one. *Smile* all for the room.. or is it roam?



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
55
55
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.5)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
I'M SO TORN *Headbang* *Ha* *Rolling* I was all set to give you a one and yet you surprised me with a roaring good line! My fingers slipped and went to five. (um point five) So, blame that spamuccini line.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
56
56
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
I was going to give you one and half but the last was just too much. So a single star you've earned for such bad use of "Mamma Mia".


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
57
57
Review of Spammed Insanity  
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
We're definately bending to new levels of SPAM depravity. *Smile* One more star handed out to a worthy opponant of SPAM poetry



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
58
58
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
I don't know if this one is good or bad, but I'll give it one star for the roasting it had. *Wink*




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
59
59
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
different, unsual, qeer and worth the one star for all of that. *Smile*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
60
60
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
even though you're late you've spun an amusing little ditty worthy of SPAMINESS. *Smile*
one gold star for you. Glad you came to the show.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
61
61
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (1.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
I've not seen the like, perhaps I will again. But certainly deserves the one star and I hope your kitty rises again. *Smile*




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
62
62
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* SPAMINESS:
While the poem was indeed on the "SPAMINESS" side and could be called bad...For me it seemed a little more "good". There is definate rhyme and scheme as well as tone and it wasn't half bad.

You've put all the elements of the caves into the poem, as well as our resident SPAM. But I'd just have to say that I like it a little too much for just one star.

I do think my favorite line in it though is:
"A wraith bartender spam ice shaves"

Very clever use of words for our spam use. *Smile*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
63
63
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*Leaf2g* Good Points:
Certainly an interesting beginning and the first few sentences are "grabbers" for the reader. Exciting and humorous.

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
No grammar issues, very well written, and I have no issues.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
The overall character and world view is consistent and actually surprising. I love that when it starts out with the fact he's a wizard you're then surprised by the "bone-witch" throwing modern day items at him. A good twist to place the story as a modern fantasy.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
My only issue with this story, at least this first chapter, is that its reminds me a lot of the "Harry Dresden" novels. With a wizard in the modern world who is taking on evil on the fly (so to speak) and usually gains the upper hand. He has a bar for wizards he frequents (although I'm not sure about Milty's bar). And there's usually something/someone following him. Not to mention the coat.

I'm not sure if you've read any of the "Dresden" novels, but I would suggest it.

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
As mentioned, anything I've stated is just my opinion. I did like the first chapter in general, and feel there's certainly some worth to the character. A good beginning to a story.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
64
64
Review of The Sound  
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*Leaf2g* Good Points:
I found this story just searching for something to read and your title and description caught my attention. Due to my own Problems with tinnitus (and other things) I can relate to sounds driving me crazy. Certainly a great way to hook readers.

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
I could see no grammatical problems and it was a great read overall. There was nothing of note to cause me to stumble over. *Smile*

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
I loved the character of Fred and how you described his world around him. You got into the details and plot without losing any storyline. I even loved how his dad sent everything that was his from childhood on up. That was a lovely little twist. LOL I wouldn't have expected it. And I loved at the end when the sound started up again.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
The only suggestion I have is regarding Fred's state of mind and his being prone to accidents that you mention. When he went to the ER and came back you mention that he was at the ER 3 months prior, that he was prone to accidents. And later you mention his family thought he was crazy? It makes me wonder about his background. But then I have an incredibly curious mind.

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
I do love the story as you've written it. It's funny, has a few dramatic pieces in it, and hope for romance. I would like to see Fred in some of his previous predicaments though. I think it might make for an interesting, longer tale.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
65
65
Review of Whispering Walls  
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | N/A (Review only item.)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*Leaf2g* Good Points:
Never believed in actual curses myself. Perhaps that's what drew me to this particular story. The description of it, and the title. I like when people set out to disprove anything.

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
Of course I couldn't find anything which jumped out at me and said "hey, here I am!" You're a wonderful writer and now problems presented themselves to me. A great write.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
I truly enjoyed the overall characterization and world view. I loved how Flint was so adamant about the fact he'd never been to the house before and the way the spirits kept welcoming back. It led to the suspense of the whole tale. And the fact the spirits were jealous of Flint. It also made me wonder more about the whole story in general. Now I want more. LOL

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
There was one thing which did cause me to pause. At the beginning of the story you said that Flint's great-great grand daughter ran the sideshow but when Flint gets to the house it sounds as if Flint's never met Kathleen before by saying, "We know your name, Flint Trent" and his reply was, "How I never told you." But if he knows she's his great-great grand daughter, Flint would then know her, wouldn't he? Even if he's never actually been to the house before (in his mind).

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
I really did enjoy this little tale of horror/mystery. It actually left me wanting a bit more. Like when did the whole thing actually go down. If he's been going in and out of the place for 200 years (or more) what was the scene like then? What was the party for? why that particular room? What sort of room was it then? oooo so many questions. *Laugh* It could make for a good little novella. *Smile* or even something longer if all the characters were flushed out. I'm so evil.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
66
66
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*TeaB* Title & Imagery:
The title certainly sets the tone for the poem. With regards to the imagery, sometimes I have a little trouble with it. The poem starts of well, but I immediately wonder how we got from maiden to bride. To me it seems some lines are out of order.

Then further on down there's the mention of his illness being "one of many people". Are you trying to say he was only one of many who fell ill? If so, the word people is sort of redundant. I'm also curious about why he was buried with honor. Was he some sort of knight? or perhaps a feudal lord? You could just say he was buried immediately.

The last thing which gets me with the imagery is the unfinished portrait. You don't say anything about it at the beginning of the poem and so I assumed the portrait was complete. Especially since you state, "whose face one could not forget". And with the last bit you also make it seem as though the portrait was not of her but of her husband. When did that happen?

*TeaR* Form/Rhyme:
I know I'm probably getting picky here. But even with the punctuation (for me) the poem is a little difficult to read in it's present form. I like to see the structure with the Rhyme. And with this poem, since there doesn't seem to be an actual form to it, the Rhyme gets lost in it at times.

*TeaO* Flow/Rhythm:
The flow and rhythm is also tough for me. I can just barely hear the rhythm of the poem and then there's an odd sentence which breaks the flow of the rhythm. As I mentioned in the previous paragraph, if I could see the form of it, I might understand the flow of it a little better.

*TeaV* Style/Tone:
I see where you're going wit the style and tone. It shows very clearly in the poem and I do like how you've used it throughout.

*TeaBr* Word Choice/Spelling/Punctuation:
I think I'll leave my previous statements with regards to word choice among the "Title & Imagery". You're spelling and punctuation are on point.

*TeaP* I especially like the following line(s):
"Her mind was lost in memories
And pain of some regret"

I think these two lines sum up what many of us often feel and we wear that pain on our faces as we look back on our lives. You've really said it beautifully.

*Yinyang* Overall:*BigSmile*
Remember I'm not an expert in how poetry should be written, I think we all have our own muse. I hope only to advise a bit.

Overall I think it's a lovely poem, if a bit mixed. I do love the choice of words for they take me back to the renaissance period. And, of course, you were able to use all of Stormy's words. Good luck in the contest.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
67
67
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*Leaf2g* Good Points:
I liked the tie-up at the end with the title. And you could feel the plight of the young girl.

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
There were a few places where you forgot to finish the word, or forgot a word altogether. And there are a few places where words could be dropped. The other item is, I feel there are too many short sentences which could be combined.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
You've definitely set up the scene with a girl which could use some help in the world and a strong, young man who is more than willing to help her.

For me, the story lacks depth. If both people are new to the school, how is it that the entire school seems to know the problem of the young girl? Is this a transition from Junior High to High School and not from a high school to high school as you suggest? Also, kids don't fall in love in half a day. Even those with autism. Which, for me, makes the story seem like it's lacking a large part in the middle.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
I think I only have a couple suggestions. Remember to read and re-read to catch those strange little grammar errors which pop up now and again, as well as for flow of the story itself.

The other is just to think about either expanding the tale or to think how the two might interact a bit more, or less. Also consider the sign language aspect. Most people who use sign language will not spell everything out. Not even their names. They might spell it once, but then they'll tell the other person the sign for their name. So you may want to do something like....she signed "I'm hungry"...instead of the spelling out.

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
I think you do have a good story here. I like the concept, it reminds me of the movie "Benny & Joon" with Johnny Depp.

Thank you for asking me to review this interesting story.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#2037372 by Not Available.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
68
68
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


*Leaf2g* Good Points:
As promised, here I am. I like the premise of this tale. Where the parents found the girl is definitely interesting. It begs the question of her being related to dragons.(at least for me)

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
There were some grammatical problems. Most have to deal with punctuation. The first couple of paragraphs have a lot of run-on sentences without any commas. A good re-read of this tale will show where you can make a better story just by using a few extra commas and periods.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
I do like the overall characterization and world view you've built up in this first part. It's not often you get strong women characters. I think you have a good baseline for this story.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
My only suggestion would be to consider switching scenes. i.e. Introduce Analia before she ever went to her uncle's school. Have her at home and then the elders of the village throwing her out, then the school, then the prince almost getting killed, then the cave. Flashbacks are fine and you've certainly done it well here, but sometimes progressive storytelling works better for a reader. If it works cool, if not, keep it as is.

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
As mentioned at the beginning, anything I've said is a suggestion only. I do love the way you've presented us with a new fantasy tale. I would like a little more telling of what the dragons are and how intelligent they are. At the moment they seem like only slightly more than average intelligent beasts, I like my dragons more like companions. (but that's me) I'd also like a little more on the school itself with a little more on the Prince. If he's going to be in the tale that is. Well, I guess that's about it. I'll read more later. *Smile*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#2037372 by Not Available.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
69
69
for entry "GOD SPOKE YO TO ME!
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
I share your sentiments but just a thought upon wording in your first paragraph...

A man can be bare chested and wear workpants ..
But, can a woman bare her chest in workpants?

I know what you want to say but the second sentence reads a bit awkward. I have this vision of women's breasts in pants. Yes really weird, to say the least. I think what you meant to say is - But, can a woman bare her chest while wearing pants?

I'm just glad you didn't write bear her chest. *Laugh*


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
70
70
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*


I saw this poem posted on the Newsfeed and it caught my eye, I couldn't resist reading it.

*TeaB* Title & Imagery:
Both were astoundingly beautiful. I'll say the poem most likely caught my eye because of the title. Because my own father was in the Navy, I've been on ships and boats many times and listed to the language of sailors. The poem made me feel back on the waves of a ship, hearing my own father and his friends laugh and joke with me and my brother. You really caught the essence of what it is to be both at sea and one who loves it dearly.

*TeaR* Form/Rhyme:
The rhyme in this was elegant and well thought out. The form was great as well. Though for me (only opinion) I might have used four stanzas instead of two for each verse. But as I said, it really is great the way it is.

*TeaO* Flow/Rhythm:
the flow and rhythm of this poem is beautiful and elegant as well. It rolls off the tongue easily. I flowed through it with ease and without stopping. Well almost, there were simply parts I wanted to re-read because it was reminding me so much of my own childhood. *Smile*

*TeaV* Style/Tone:
I love the style and tone of this poem. I think you already know why by now.

*TeaBr* Word Choice/Spelling/Punctuation:
No arguments from the peanut gallery here.

*TeaP* I especially like the following line(s):
"He was hailed a rugged man, by those who knew him well,
but here’s a little different story, that only I can tell."
There are many other lines in this poem I love, but I think these two really sum up the whole of it.

*Yinyang* Overall:*BigSmile*
A great big, lovely, elegant, flowing poem. A grand epic to be proud of. I only hope that when my own father actually passes I can do him such justice.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#2037372 by Not Available.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
71
71
Review of My Uncle John  
In affiliation with Dark Dreamscapes  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*

THIS IS A Game Of Thrones Surprise REVIEW

*Leaf2g* Good Points:
This is a heart felt and good story about how I imagine someone committing the act of suicide may view their own death. We, as outsiders, cannot see what goes on in their minds and often wonder why they do it and as I read this story it seems like a very plausible reason why. I love the tenderness and the effort you've put into this tale.

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
There are a few problems but they're mostly with word choices. The spelling and punctuation seem to be fine. When I get to my suggestions section I'll show you more what I mean.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
As I've mentioned before, how you've placed this character and the world view is just wonderful. The fact the character is so heartbroken I'm imagining that the text he received is probably a very old reminder which has popped up on a very specific date. Perhaps the one in which his love was to return from the island in the first place. I mean weirder things have happened. But to him it's a sign she's returned to him.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
ok, here's the nitty-gritty of it. In the dropnote below you'll find...Red, means delete, Blue, means add, and Green, means suggestions or questions.
Dropnote Suggestions

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
ok, I know when you look at the dropnote suggestions you're going to see a lot of red's and blue's. But for the most part it's just removing a whole lot of "that's". Sometimes when we re-read things we realize that any one particular word can be removed from a story and not take away from it's meaning. I will say that my favorite part of this whole story, though I suggest some word changes, was the last sentence of the story. It was very well done. Again, a very eloquently written story from the viewpoint of someone wracked with grief.


Elfindragon ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
72
72
Review of Stuck  
In affiliation with Dark Dreamscapes  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*

THIS IS A Game Of Thrones REVIEW

*Leaf2g* Good Points:
Hi Shara, this is such a good tale of being stuck in one of the worst camping trips ever. And I love the colloquialisms used. It reminded me of two "good 'ol southern boys" having a rough time of it. It also reminded me of a few camping trips of my own that I've been on. *Laugh*

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
I only spotted one or two spelling errors but with the colloquialisms used sometimes it's hard to tell if they were done on purpose or if they are actual spelling errors. But a good re-read would help you to determine which words you really want to use.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
I love the Characterization and world view here. Each character was true to life here. I love that the ranger accepted the poison ivy story but still wanted a fishing license from Jimmy and when he couldn't produce took his fish away. It just added to the wonderful bad luck story. And of course it just seemed the bad luck wanted to follow Jimmy wherever he went.

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
You mentioned there was no way to get skunk smell out of clothing or self. Well a whole lot of tomato juice actually does the trick, for the most part. Most "good 'ol boys" will know that. But your campers probably didn't pack for that ill fated venture. And for the weather, unless the boys were sleeping in gortex sleeping bags and had a heated lamp in their tent, that tent should be pretty cold. I know, I've woken up on camping trips and not wanted to get out of a warm sleeping bag because the tent was cold. And if there were icicles on the zipper of the tent, there would be ice on the rest of the tent. So why didn't it collapse? Was it a sturdy canvas tent? Or was there just not that much ice? I know, I know, I'm asking too many trivial questions. But my mind sometimes gets ahead of me in cases like this. *Facepalm*

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
I really did enjoy this lovely little story of misadventure. It's a reminder of how sometimes a little bad luck becomes something a lot larger and sometimes it's better to quite while one is, well not ahead in this case. And lastly, I want to apologize that it took me so long to do a proper review on this piece for you. And I'd like to say keep writing, you're doing a great job.


Elfindragon ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
73
73
Review of Minor Key  
In affiliation with Dark Dreamscapes  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*

THIS IS A Game Of Thrones REVIEW

*Leaf2g* Good Points:
Hi, This was definitely an interesting story about how we view life and what we think we want out of it. Then we find we've missed something along the way in the end. A good Story of morals. Though I'm not sure why you titled it "Minor Key".

*Leaf2r* Grammatical Problems?
For me there are a few issues with word usage but no actual grammar problems. In the beginning you say the "boy raced along the cliff top..." This seems strange to me because most cliffs are the top. It might be better if you say, "the boy raced along the top of the cliff..."

And in the second paragraph you repeat "cliff top". we now already know where he is and I think just saying "the cliff was carpeted.." would be enough. My only other issue with the second paragraph is when you say, "Rock pools of clear tidal leftovers..." I've been to many tidal pools and every one of them have had rocks surrounding the pools in some fashion. And I'm not really sure what you mean by "tidal leftovers". Do you mean the fish, starfish, jellyfish, crabs and other creatures which get caught in the pools or that actually make the pools their homes as the tides go in and out? Or do you mean the seaweed and sand which gets caught in the pools? Or do you mean human trash which may have floated in? It may be just me, but I'm confused by this statement.

*Leaf2o* Overall Characterization and World View:
The overall characterization and world view is interesting. You start out with a young boy who is vibrant and full of life and imagination. And throughout his life you turn him into someone who suddenly starts having bad luck, bad marriages and a terrible time of it all. All because he turned down the offer to help the mermaid protect he cove. And when he returns to the cove, humanity has changed and "polluted" his sanctuary.

As I mentioned at the beginning certainly an interesting tale in the morals department and a statement for people to not miss those opportunities which only come once in a lifetime. But for me the story has some plot problems and only because of the way you describe the boy in the beginning. I'll put my say in the "suggestions".

*Leaf2br* Suggestions:
Ok, you have a boy who's bright, imaginative and eager for new things. He's a fighter for what he believes, by his right, is his alone. To me this is a boy who would do well in school have a very few close knit group of friends and continue to be imaginative and bright. His parents would certainly not shun him for being different from his siblings but encourage him to do what he might feel like doing, maybe writing or art. Maybe teach it.

If you want the shy, secluded boy who believes he's outcast from his family; the boy should be more melancholy at the beginning. Yes, he's exploring and he finds interest in the cove but he wants it more for the solitude than for the exploration of it. Perhaps have him bring a book or two with him so he can relax and enjoy the sound of the waves lapping at the rocks while he reads or walks among the tidal pools. This is what would make him more shy as an adult.

*Yinyang* Last but not Least:*BigSmile*
I hope you take my suggestions for what they are, simply that. I did love your story as you've written it. I thought it insightful to the ecology problem we're facing today and a nice fantasy solution to what could be done about it. As Hamlet once said, "There are more things which are dreamt of in heaven and earth than in your philosophy.."

Keep writing and I look forward to reading more of your work.

Elfindragon ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
74
74
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*RainbowL* Just a reminder I am here to review and give suggestions. Any of which are my opinion and you can use them or not. Both are given with reverence for your style of writing and hope to help not just you but myself as well. If you have any questions about the review or suggestions don't be afraid to reply, email, or IM me in response. We are all learning to be better writers, including myself. *Smile*

THIS IS Both a Review for Artisan's Village Music Contest AND
A Game Of Thrones REVIEW


*TeaB* Title & Imagery:
First I will say I'm glad you included a youtube video of the song with this poem. Since I'd not heard the song before it helped me understand the poem better.
Second, Though you're using the prompt of the song for the poem I think (personally) you could have titled the poem something else with a caveat as the song as the inspiration for the poem.
Last, Imagery...Beautiful. The first time I read through the poem without hearing the song and though not truly knowing why, it was still good. With the song it becomes far more magical.

*TeaR* Form/Rhyme:
I'm not good with types of rhyming schemes but I can tell there is one and you used it well. The form of the poem also stands up well with the rhyming. I'd say you did a good job with both here.

*TeaO* Flow/Rhythm:
The flow and rhythm are pretty good. For me there are only two points where it stutters a little and it's mostly because of word choice. One word may be simply a spelling error. So, because of that I'll get to those a bit later on. For the whole of the poem itself, you've done a great job with the flow and rhythm of it. I'm taken along quite nicely to the end without any problems.

*TeaV* Style/Tone:
I like the style and tone of this poem, especially after hearing the song you chose for your prompt. With both the music/melody of the song and the words of your poem I'm taken on a trip of emotional sorrow and new awakening with this young woman. Hmm, perhaps I should have said that in the "flow/rhythm" section? Anyway, a good job in both.

*TeaBr* Word Choice/Spelling/Punctuation:
To the word choice and spelling. In the first stanza, last line, you wrote..."She tries to calm to inner storm."....Perhaps you meant to say, "She tries to calm her inner storm?"
The other place which seemed a little odd to me was the last stanza, last line. The reason is, it seems incomplete. You wrote, "She'd feel clean, covered in snow." Perhaps if you'd make it a little clearer how she'd feel. A sentence like, "Now she'd feel clean, pure as the snow." or, "...., covered in pure snow."
Sometimes little changes like a word here or there can make a big difference in a poem.

*TeaP* I especially like the following line(s):
"Now, she found her favorite tune
Though not a necessarily happy jam
Every time it's as if she's slammed
But words and thoughts and lonely blues"

I know how this woman feels. Sometimes lonely songs are the best ones. A favorite tune either which you just heard or from a very long time ago.

*Yinyang* Overall:*BigSmile*
A good poem for a song prompt. I like how you used the tune to bring memories to the forefront. I think we all need to be reminded how music makes us feel in that particular moment and why we feel that way when we hear it again. Good luck in the contest and I hope to see you in many more. *Smile*


Elfindragon ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
75
75
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
I love this poll. I find it interesting that Jean-Luc is actually ahead of Kirk by about 10 votes. Mostly for the different command styles. When the Federation was just really beginning was Kirk's heyday. Kirk really had to make some of the toughest choices, I think, between the lives of not just his crew but sometimes the entire Federation. I just finished watching an episode on MeTV where Kirk had to make a decision between the lives of several million on a planet vs. the several billion of the rest of the Universe. I can't remember any like that for Picard except when the Borg showed up. But then it became a war. I don't think it was the same thing.

Picard's style, by this time the Federation was in full swing, was diplomatic. He wasn't as rough & tumble as Kirk. I think my favorite character in Next Gen was always Data or even Counselor Troy. There was far more interaction going on for the growth of the characters.

Well, I guess that's my take on the two captains. Again, I love what you've done here and find the results interesting. I think I might hang around here for awhile. *Smile* I certainly never miss an episode on MeTV on SciFi Saturday Nights.

Elfin Dragon ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
125 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 5 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/elfindragon/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3