Hi, Kotaro
I'm reviewing your story as a part of my judging process for "The Pressure Valve - closed for now." . Since I am only one of the judges, this review has no bearing on where your piece places in the contest. It's just my own thoughts and suggestions with regard to your story. I hope you find some of it helpful.
THESE ARE A FEW OF MY FAVORITE THINGS:
As a fan of the Sherlock Holmes tales, I was delighted with your entry. This tale has captured the flavor of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's masterpieces, and it's a fine example of SteamPunk fiction. The plot moves forward quickly, with pertinent information largely delivered in the course of the action, without resorting to the info-dump. The characters are well-detailed, and their mannerisms and interactions all ring true. The conflict is quite thrilling and managed very well. Its resolution is accomplished fully and without dangling loose ends.
SOME SUGGESTIONS:
MECHANICS: These comments refer to typos, grammar, word usage, etc.
Very few issues, mostly of a typographical, rather than a grammatical, nature. One possible issue I will note is the following:
It was the army of clockwork soldiers, that he had crafted, marching through the streets. That had convinced him Maxwell was a danger to London, perhaps even, to Great Britain. The first comma is not necessary; also, the period after "streets" could be changed to a comma, so that this flows as a single sentence. It was the army of clockwork soldiers that he had crafted, marching through the streets, that had convinced him Maxwell was a danger to London, perhaps even, to Great Britain. This could simply be a product of my own scanning of the passage; it no doubt works as you have it, but I thought that I would offer the alternative.
STYLE: These comments refer to narrative voice, plot, conflict, characterization, setting, etc.
This is a fine story, but there are a few things I noticed for which I hope to provide helpful suggestions.
First:
I think it is unclear who actually created the laboratory-made diamonds. At first, Faraday seems to be their creator. Later, though, the ruminations of Maxwell make it seem that he was their creator. This vagueness makes me question the usefulness of Faraday, and I think it should be made more clear.
Second:
The rank of clockwork soldiers were, I think, much too easily dispatched, even without the use of dynamite. Such an army would hardly have been able to withstand a determined force of well-armed British soldiers, so any attempt to usurp London would obviously be destined for failure, even had Holmes not divined the existence of the secret city. This, I think is an issue that needs attention, for the sake of the drama.
Third:
Rasputin - if this individual is indeed the infamous Grigori Rasputin of Russian history, who was poisoned, shot several times, and finally tossed from a bridge in to the Neva River in Petrograd - was also too easily dispatched. The scene at the end when Watson shoots him in the forehead, is a bit too neat and glib to be truly satisfying. Really, there was no time in the story when I feared for Holmes's and Watson's well-being. Their extremely capable natures aside, the story's tension level suffers for the antagonists' inability to truly threaten two lone men, much less an entire city, or the British Empire itself.
OVERALL IMPRESSION:
I like this story very much, Kotaro. I hope my suggestions give you some food for thought, so that, when the contest is over, you can revise it for sharing in other venues. You are a talented writer; I wish you the best of luck in the contest and in all your other endeavors.
These comments are made with respect and the best intentions. Please accept them in the spirit with which I offer them. Embrace what you find useful, and allow the rest to trickle off into the void....
Best regards,
CeruleanSon
|
|