*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/lilithmoon/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/16
Review Requests: OFF
1,295 Public Reviews Given
1,302 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 12 13 14 15 -16- ... Next
376
376
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a wonderful and heart-felt poem. It is so inspirational. I am not even a religious person but I can feel the joy resonating through your words. Good for you!

I did see a couple of words that are questionable as to whether they are typos or intentional. Here are my examples:

"I have a God who love me," I think you mean "loves."

"Through everything else is changeable." I think this would sound better as "Though."

"He will helped me win the battle;" I think this should either be "will help" or "has helped."

You seem to have abandoned the rhyming scheme and rhythm at the end, is this a particular style of poem? I know next to nothing about poetic techniques so forgive my ignorance if this is intentional.

Overall, I think this an awesome poem I really enjoyed reading it. Thank you for sharing.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
377
377
Review of Stargazing  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is very cool. It is amazing to me how just imagining superior beings are out there watching over us can bestow a sense of inner peace. Maybe it's just me. Anyway, I agree with you, I like this very much. It is unbelievable the stories a person can tell with so few words.
378
378
Review of Disease  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Okay, I really really like the concept of this story. The idea of it is awesome. I am not going to lie to you though it needs some work. The biggest thing it needs is a good editing and cleaning up. In my opinion, this story would work better as a flash of under 1000 words. It is way to wordy. I am going to line-by-line it at least partially to give you an idea of the kind of edits I am talking about.


High above the foundations of the earth, nothing of the terrestrial world affects us up here. Surrounded by my brothers and sisters, we find peace here in the sky contrasting to that of despair and misery they hold ever so close on the ground.

Close together are my siblings, this is the highest we have ever been before. Flying, feeling the freedom that the sky holds ever so solidly. I knew it would come to this eventuallyAdverbs are great to eliminate since they seldom add anything to a sentence. but never this soon. We were once part of the grounds folk, now liberated from their restraintsI would omit this part because it is unclear and seems tacked on needlessly. The images that we saw will plague our hearts and minds forever.minds and puncture our hearts forever, at least they will mine.

The clouds grow deathlyThis is very specific are the clouds going to cause death? It sounds like overkill to me. dark overhead, the sun rays of sunshine diminished behind the blackened wall. Even so, wWe pull hold together, stronger as a unit then we are singularly.

Remembering what it was like on the land is painful, but I cannot seem to block it out. The humans screaming, always screaming but never anything worthy of a voice. Blood lined the roads casting red patterns over the footpath, washing it off was futile, it would return each by the end of the night. People did not seem to care, their faces blank from expression, no remorse held no place in their hearts, just their pure greed in their black souls.set their souls black.Maybe this caused it was this that set in motion the deterioration of my mind. I would not quite say I was clinically insane, however, I wouldn’t deny that my mind was unchanged. exactly conflict the idea that my mind is securely the same. You should decide whether are not you are going to use contractions and be consistent throughout the entire piece. In this instance you use would not and wouldn't both in the same line.

Lightning streaks across the sky, illuminating the clouds above us, greys and blacks convert into blues. There is a beauty here that cannot be found below. Shapes always appearing in the clouds, ever changing, you will never see the same figure again.Though these sentences are nice and descriptive they slow the pace and don't help to move the story along. Your goal should be for every sentence to progress the narrative. You don't want the reader to lose interest. Fear ignites in my siblings, etching it in their souls. If this storm gets worse develops any further we will be forced to return to the earth once again. Huddling closer I would use close not closer it flows better, in my opinion. together, the warmth transfers from one to the other. We know we don’t have much time. Flashing before us, lightning breaks the darkness that envelopes us.

Bitter wind rips through the middle of our little group, forcing us northward. It is futile to fight it, relinquishing all strength to the element we fly with the wind. Sleet rain rushes at us as from behind, like pins and needles piercing your essence. It is comforting somehow, Somehow it is comforting though, knowing this as our paramount hindrance contrast to that which broke the stable mind that I once had. This sentence is so confusing I really can't tell what you are trying to say with it. I would really try to make it clearer. Remember when telling a story simple is better. If there is a simple more direct way to say what you mean use it.

I was previouslyPreviously is understood. residing in a major city, I cannot remember the name, they are all the same to me, living in the gutters while the rest of the world walked on by. Humanity isn’t what it formally was. The city was drenched in shadows, thrown down by the high rises. These grey square blocks for building loomed over everything. Damp musky air wafted from the structures whenever the front door opened infusing with the smell of human and animal urine that inundates the streets. Humans have seemed to become immune to the foul odour, acting as if nothing is out of normality.
Windows shattered in the building, glass traces still seen on the footpath. Madness scratched at the edge of my mind, attacking the forces of my will threatening to break through the bounds.

I'm going to stop editing here since you get the idea. I would just be very critical when editing. If there is a more concise way to say something use it. You need to be consistent with your tenses as well as your contractions. You start out in the first paragraph using "is" then slip into using "was" I personally would stick with present tense. Remember, if a sentence doesn't move the story along or slows the pace I would delete it, no matter how pretty it sounds.

I think if you spend some time eliminating unnecessary words and consolidating phrases this will be a truly amazing story. It is a phenomenal idea for a story honestly, I wish I had thought of it myself.*Smile*

Anyway, I hope you find this review helpful and not overly harsh. I think you have the basis of a great story it just needs polished. Thank you for sharing it.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
379
379
Review of My Beauty Queen  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
I don't know alot about poetic style, rhythm, form or structure, so I can't tell you if anything is technically write or wrong. All I can do is tell you what does and doesn't work for me. Plus, my personal impressions I get from the poem.

The first impression I got from this poem is how much it reminds me of the Roy Orbison song Pretty Woman.

Pretty woman walkin down the street
Pretty woman, the kind I like to meet


You express the admiration you feel for this woman in a very sweet, innocent and almost adolescent manner that is quite charming. I applaud you.

Though at times, it seems like you are twisting the syntax to fit your rhyming structure, so it reads rather awkward. Here is an example:

The path travel her own runway

I think it might sound better in the past tense, for instance:

The path traveled her own runway

I'm not sure how that affects the rhythm or syllable count, since I'm a novice at writing verse myself. It just sounds better to me.

This is my favorite line of the poem:

Amazing what God made from dirt

This sounds very natural and unpretentious to me but at the same time conveys a sense of awe at the miracle that is this woman.

Of course there is a certain amount of artistic license allowed when writing verse but this line is worded incorrectly in my opinion. It appears to be a simple case of mixed-up possessives.

She's the one my hearts desire

I think it should read like this:

She's the one my heart desires

Overall, I think this is a very heart-felt poem that any woman would be flattered to be made the subject. My only suggestions would be to check your grammar to make sure you are saying what you mean to say. On the whole, I find your poem light-hearted and charming. Thank you for sharing and if this is a true life account good luck winning the woman you admire. :)

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
380
380
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (4.0)
I am not quite sure what kind of review you want on this piece. I think it is very well written and thoughtful, although a bit naive. It reads as more of a rant to me than a serious essay, since none of your points are substantiated.

I personally, agree with much of what you say but none of it is supported by fact. It is easy to blame all the world's problems on religion but unfortunately that is just not true. If everyone in the world abandoned religious belief today there would still be insurmountable obstacles in the way of the Utopia that you envision.

There is seldom if ever only 2 options in any scenario. Especially, given the naive, short-sighted options you leave the world with here. All of man kind does not act only in the extreme black/white ways you suggest in your Options. You cannot throw out surreal hypothetical outcomes and expect anyone to actually take you seriously.

I don't mean to sound harsh. I do understand the message you are so passionately trying convey, as I said before, I even agree with it. I just feel that when you try to scare tactics and brow-beating others into seeing your point of view as the correct one, you are doing exactly what you accuse the "superstitious" religious factions of doing to the world.

Anyway, I am not sure if this is the kind of review that you were looking for but it is the only one I know how to give. I hope it helps. In any case, thank you for sharing your thoughts and feelings.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
381
381
Review of I Like Spiders  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (5.0)
I hate spiders! But I really like this poem. It is humorous and fun. I can totally see myself reading this to my granddaughter at Halloween. I like the rhythm of it too. I almost sing it instead of read it. Sorry, I wanted to be critical of your work but I like this piece too much. Nicely done. I will have to read more of your work (sneaky) to find something less fun to critique. *Smile*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
382
382
Review of Absence  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Unfortunately, I know very little about poetic style, form or structure so I can't really speak to that. All I can do is tell your what I like and what I think works and what doesn't, for me at least. That being said, I think this poem is really good.

It tells the very clear tale of a broken heart. I love the voice and lyrics you choose, but I do have a couple of observations you may find useful. First, I think the reoccurring importance of salt and saltwater (implying tears)is awesome. My favorite line in the whole poem.

- I use saltwater as glue -

This is nothing short of brilliant. I do have one problem however, with the line:

That salt, consumed, trails out in rivers?

I think I understand what you are saying, that holding back or swallowing your tears only makes you cry more. That eventually they come out in rivers that you can't stop. Here is my problem. When I hear "salt consumed" I get a mental picture of someone licking a saltshaker. I would try a different word, maybe restrained? contained? confined? swallowed?

The only other line I had issue with is this one:

Clammy claws crawl from inside

I know this is very visually powerful but read it aloud. It sounds like a child's tongue twister. I would really try to come up with another way to express this.

Overall, I really like it. I think this is an excellent and very heartfelt poem. I think the language is rich and beautiful. I hope this review is somewhat helpful. Thank you for sharing your work.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
383
383
Review of Nights with May  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (3.0)
I have to start by giving my standard disclaimer, which goes, I know next to nothing about poetic style, form and structure. So, I can't speak on those aspects, all I can do is tell you how a poem makes me feel and my impressions. That being said, here are my impressions of your poem.

I have to be honest and say I had to look up the word insouciant in the dictionary. I had no idea what it meant. I think I have an above average vocabulary but that is not a word I have ever used or heard. Needless to say, that distracted me right off the bat. But I read on...

Then you describe some excellent imagery that convey feelings of serenity and peace. I really liked this part. I am thinking this is really going to be something special now. My hopes are high.

But then in the last stanza again, you have vivid descriptions but I have no idea what they pertain to and I can't relate to them at all. So, this is where you lose me. In the end, the poem reads very much like a riddle that I can't figure out. I am left in the dark feeling rather stupid.

Overall, I think this piece is beautifully written but just a bit too mysterious and cryptic for me tastes. Which is pretty hysterical since your info line calls this a concise perspective. I find it anything but concise. Of course, this is just one opinion. I may be overly dense, that is highly probable. Anyway, thank you for sharing your work. *Smile*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
384
384
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (3.0)
I am sorry but I don't think I can give a fair review of this poem. I am sure that is very well written but I know next to nothing about style and form of verse. It seems to have nice rhythm and structure but like I said, I am certainly no expert. I wish I knew more about poetry.

As for the concept and message, I have to tell the truth, I don't really care for it. I can appreciate how the language matches the theme though. It is very authoritative and powerful but far too commanding for my tastes. I mean no disrespect. I am just trying to give an honest review but I am not a religious person. I probably should have skipped this one. *Worry*

Again, I'm sorry I could not be more help but thank you for sharing your work.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
385
385
Review of Triad  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Well, I doubt anyone can argue this is not a powerful and imaginative piece. I like it very much. The visuals created in the last stanza of Ignorance are stunning. That is by far my favorite part.

I find the title Enema rather stark. It definitely elicits a reaction. It is just too harsh for my tastes but it does create an amazing contrast to the rest of the poem. If that was your intention, kudos!

Procurement gives a satisfying sense of resolution the piece desperately needs in response to the pleading Enema(I really dislike that title*Sick*).

Overall, I think this is an exceptional piece of work. It took me through a whole range of emotions. I really enjoyed reviewing it. Unfortunately, I know next to nothing about poetry so I hope you still find this review helpful. In any case, thank you for sharing this.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
386
386
Review of Obolus  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: E | (3.5)
I love the concept and the setting for this poem. It seems a bit too wordy for me though. That coupled with the mixture of modern and archaic language is alittle distracting. I would suggest avoiding the use of contractions since it gives the piece a casual sound that is out of place.

Overall, I think this poem could be amazing with just alittle rework. I hope you find this review helpful and thank you for sharing your work.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
387
387
Review by Lilithmoon☽
Rated: E | (5.0)
Well I said earlier that I don't often review poetry but I gave this one a peek and just had to review it. Keep in mind I know next to nothing about what makes a well written poem or not. I only know what works for me and what doesn't.

This totally works for me! I really really liked it. Halloween is my favorite time of the year and this poem reminds me of that. I can totally see myself reading this to the grandchildren over a big bowl of candy. It is just a fun poem that brought a big smile to my face.

I don't know if this review is very helpful to you but it is honest. I really enjoyed this piece. Thank you very much for sharing.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
388
388
Review by Lilithmoon☽
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
Wow, uh... let me start by saying I don't usually review poetry because I really don't feel qualified. I know nothing about structure, style or form of verse. All I can really do is tell you what I like and what I don't. So with that in mind, here are my thoughts on the poem.

This piece is FULL of powerful language. I find all of the commands written in bold almost frightening. Great if that is the intention, I will assume it is to make things easier.

The overall feel for me is very bizarre and creepy. All the candy, tongues and bug references bring images of A Nightmare before Christmas and other Tim Burton type films. It's all alittle much for me. No one can argue that it isn't effective though. *Wink*

Anyway, I hope you find this review somewhat helpful. I'm sorry that I am not better equipped to critique poetry. I did enjoy the piece and I'm sure I will enjoy it even more once I stop shaking (j/k). Thank you for sharing your work.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

389
389
Review of Belgars' Mountain  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
Rated: E | (4.0)
Nice job! This is a simple tale that is short sweet and to the point. I would even go so far as to say it is cute. I liked it very much. I have to admit I found it pretty predictable but still funny none-the-less.

You write very well and I saw no mistakes that I could find. I really like your great use of dialog. Not that I know how cave people sound but it was very believable to me anyway. It was always clear who was speaking even without monikers.

Overall, this was a fun little story that made me smile. I enjoyed it immensely. Thank you for sharing. *Laugh*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
390
390
Review of A'shufflin'  
Review by Lilithmoon☽
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Okay, wow. I'm not sure what I just read but I really really liked it. This is a very difficult piece for me to review because I can't even tell you what I like about it. It is very poignant. The feeling I get from this piece is just overwhelming tragedy. I feel just awful for the grime doctor whoever or whatever that is and I just want him to feel better. I definitely have a vested interest in his escape. I really want him to succeed and not just fall back into apathy or give up.

I'm sorry I wouldn't know how to begin to tell what to do to improve this piece. I think it is awesome. It was very powerful and thought provoking. There are no errors that jump out at me (though grammar and punctuation are not my thing). I wish I could be more help.

Overall, I think the piece is perfect. I wouldn't change a thing. I would love to read more of your stuff. As a reader I would love more insight into this character and what is actually going on here but as a writer I feel it would detract from the charm of the piece. I will keep my fingers crossed that the doctor makes good his escape. It was a pleasure reading this, thank you for sharing.
~ Lilithmoon

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

391
391
Review by Lilithmoon☽
Rated: E | (4.5)
Wow! Good job! This is a very impressive bit of flash. I can't remember the last time I was actually creeped out by a short. At first, I was a bit annoyed by the choppiness of the style. I wasn't sure if the sentence fragments were intentional or not but either way they work really well to set the tone. I really enjoyed this piece. What a wonderful example of how to build suspense and create mood.

I am by no means a grammar or punctuation master so I am not comfortable commenting too much on those areas. I will say this, I personally, believe that both grammar and punctuation are secondary in importance to story telling. So in other words, I'm sure that an English teacher would tear this piece apart but I however, choose to chalk up any questionable grammar and punctuation to your original style. *Pthb*

There is one instance of capitalization that I don't agree with though.

Don’t take the exit on the main Highway up onto the Brookfield Dean Rd.

Again, not an English teacher so this might be perfectly fine. Also, I think there is an omission in the following sentence:

Do not give into the tempting cool, country air.

Overall, I think this is a fantastic piece. I loved it. It peaked my interest enough that I look forward to reading more of your writing. It also makes me want avoid certain highways in Canada (j/k). Thank you very much for sharing it. Please feel free to call on me to review anymore of your work.
~ Lilithmoon

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
392
392
Review by Lilithmoon☽
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Should I tell someone or not? Will god forgive me? Will anyone forgive or believe me at all? That’s it. If I have to tell someone then it may as well be you.

“You did what John?”

“I’m sorry Lauren. I didn’t mean to it just...”

“John, this is unspeakable, this is unforgivable. Do you have any idea what you have done?”

“I’m sorry. It just sort of happened. She hit me and then I lost control and...”

“Do you really think crying about it is going to fool anyone? You are a monster John, you will be marked for life wherever you go. Assuming you even get manage to get out alive.” There is an extra "get" in this sentence.

“If I admit it they might let me off easy. You know what the American system is like right? They will let me go won’t they? I’m really sorry."

Who does this fool think he is? He thinks that kneeling before me and blubbering will do anything. I hope Sarah puts this bastard away for life. He has no right to be on our streets, and he should hope they give him a life sentence. Rape will mark you forever John.I find the mention of Sarah in this sentence very frustrating. If she is a prosecutor I wish you would tell me that but since this is a flash story and I never get to know who this really is I wish you would not use such an intimate handle. Why should he hope they give him LIFE? Death is not a possible sentence for rape in America.

“They won’t let you out John; ever. Now get up and walk in there and admit what you did like a man. And wipe your eyes you big baby.”

“You’re right Lauren, I have to do this. It’s the right thing, maybe eventually she will forgive me.” Unfortunately, at this point the rapist is much more likable than the person he confessed to. If this is intentional, good job, it worked!

“Goodbye John. If you ever return then don’t try and contact me or Sarah again. You have brought enough pain and suffering down on our heads to last a lifetime.” Oh,now I get it. Sarah is the victim. That was very unclear to me earlier. Maybe I am just dense.

*


“You are scum Mr. Yates. You robbed the innocence of a young woman so callously?This is very awkwardly worded. It is almost like you couldn't decide whether to make it a statement or a question. I personally think it would sound better as "How could you rob..." Get down there Yates and don’t get up until I lift my boot off of your disgusting little face, you rat.” All I can think at this point is that you are making the cop(?) out to be the criminal.

I deserve this. I am a monster.Monsters don't typically feel remorse. That is what makes them monsters.

“I hope you are not camera shy Yates. They have been looking for the nasty little creature for weeks now and it looks like he has turned up.” This is not very convincing dialog in my humble opinion. I have never anyone speak like this, let alone a police officer who has probably seen it all. Unless I am wrong in assuming this is a police officer.

I am a nasty little creature.

“Oh what’s that Yates? Are you crying? Well let me wipe the tears away with my boot. You think this is hard? Just you wait till the guys you are in with get a hold of you. You are a miserable little coward.” Again, kicking a man while he is down is not behavior typically associated with a cop... um... let me rephrase. Not typically associated with a GOOD cop.

“At least I know that I did the right thing whatever happens in the end....officer.”

“The right thing Yates? You don’t really believe anyone will care about that do you? You should have run while you had the chance. Officer Longsbridge! Take this scum away to his cell and call the higher ups. Let him get acquainted with the hell he deserves. Oh you can get up now Yates, I have more important things to do; like washing my boot." Wow, again with the unbelievable dialog. Honestly, at this point I dislike that cop way more than the rapist. Kudos, if that is the reaction you are going for but bad news if it's not.

I did the right thing. Right? Yes, of course.

As you can see, I decided to line-by-line this piece because I felt it was important to let you know what I was thinking as I was reading through it. I have mentioned it several times through out but I sympathize more with the rapist in the story than anyone else. Now, if it was your intention to write a highly controversial piece by making the rapist a victim that is brilliant (in a sick, sick way). If it wasn't I think this story might offend alot of people. Actually either way it might offend people, props on a thought provoking piece though.

Grammar and punctuation are not my strong suits so I try not to focus on them. However, I did notice a few errors and some instances that read awkward to me. I would suggest a thorough proof reading and a slight rework. My biggest complaint is the unnatural dialog and that is wholly subjective so take it for what it is worth. Overall, I thought the story was very interesting and it did illicit strong emotions, so well done. Thank you for sharing your work and most definitely keep writing. *Smile*
~ Lilithmoon


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

392 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 16 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/lilithmoon/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/16