*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/harryg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/19
Review Requests: OFF
1,432 Public Reviews Given
1,595 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 15 16 17 18 -19- 20 ... Next
451
451
Review of The Beast  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, W.D. ~

You have written a very imaginative story. I enjoyed the read! *Smile* Using only one-syllable word throughout this must have been quite hard.

A few suggestions:

had one spoke to him >>> had spoken would be correct, maybe had talked to him

him doubt(,) and in

the hot(,) wet wall

six(-)inch claws

called[,] the Gor?”


Cheers!

Harry

Please check out my new book:
http://www.lulu.com/harry
452
452
Review of The Well  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi, W.D. ~

You write a very good story! This held my interest throughout. *Smile*

A few suggestions:

that it ran forever >>>> runs

a nine(-)year(-)old boy

holding it(,) Tom!

It’s working(,) Jeff!

No sweat(;)[,] just keep

but further down >>> farther

stick matches(,) and he fumbled around

old(,) boney fingers

Tom[,] and his bucket

Come on(,) Jeff!

the round(-)shaped ball of light

rope with both hands(,) he tried

was wet(,) and the match

Jeff stood beside him(,) shifting his weight from one leg to the other[,] and looking very nervous

“Well(,) you plum scared me(;)[,] that’s for sure. I told ya ‘bout playing (')round this well

“Well(,) you're darn


Cheers!

Harry

Please check out my new book:
http://www.lulu.com/harry






453
453
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi, Viv ~

Overall, your story was good. However, I did have some problem areas:

his head(,) revealing short(-)cut(,) blond hair and sleepy(,) light-blue

the top two team(s) would

each team would meet each team for the preliminaries for two innings, then the top two team would play for the championship. Round three, Team Six and Team Five battled inning after inning with the score tied.
>>>> Confusing? Round three ? What happened to rounds 1 & 2 ?? Is this the third preliminary game of round one? Is this game in extra innings (was supposed to be only two innings?)?

Two runs scored. = ?? If it was the last inning and the team scoring was the 'home' team, the game would have ended with the first run scoring! Since game ended with that inning bottom, only one run would have counted. Should be "The winning run scored."

a one(-)armed hug

“Since they’re only going to play one inning, = ???
>>>>No way! The championship game is only one inning when the prelims were two innings??? In one inning, only one-third of players might even get to bat in the championship game. Very, very unlikely.....without a whole lot of ticked-off players and parents!!! It is unbelievable that a championship game would not be at least three innings to allow all players in the starting lineup to bat at least once!

“Uh, oh, the first batter struck out. Shane’s up next. He hit one to left behind the short stop. He’s on first.” >>>> Too fast for live play by play! Need to slow it down somehow.

“Shane stole [to] second

Wow! (H)e hit one deep

Man! (H)e hit a

the head coach[,] from the university team hosting the camp[,] said as

fight sometimes[,] and do tend

Cheers!

Harry






















454
454
Review of The Voice  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello, W.D. ~

I like this one! *Smile* You write a good spooky tale!

Only a couple of suggestions:

walls[,] but showed

“Stay put(.)[,] I’m
coming!”

Sal sounded desperate(,) and his fear began


Cheers!

Harry
455
455
Review of The Salesman  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi, W.D. ~

Well, this story is certainly dark...but well-told.

Here are a few minor suggestions:

John Steele[,] tramped down

Just twenty-four years old, he was a black(-)haired, blue(-)eyed,

him(,) and his two kids thought

a white(,) sleeveless undershirt

firmly(,) and John made

here, isn’t it(?)”

damn thing(')s brand new.

selling the thing[’]s. I’ve
never used it(;)[,] I just keep

why’s that(,) Mr. Casper

carpet area[,] and then clean


Cheers!

Harry
456
456
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Amy ~

Quite touching and sweet! Momkey boy is lucky to have such a wonderful mother. *Smile*

five-year(-)old girls

Cheers!

Harry
457
457
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi, Amy ~

This reflective piece seems fine to me. It is quite thought-provoking, in fact. *Smile*

With my one-year(-)old son

Cheers!

Harry
458
458
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi, W.D. ~

Cute! *Smile*

A few punctuation suggestions:

for a second[;](,) skin hanging down

will play[,] Romeo.

is full(-)bodied, big(-)boned, pleasingly

has long(,)blond hair

sprouting cowlick[,] are
accented

stream[,] without ever

to the area[,] and has decided

performance[,] and twitters around

a large tree(,) and Romeo stands

the tower(,) and fair Juliet sits

has ended(,) and the curtain begins

Cheers!

Harry




459
459
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, W.D. ~

A well-told Christmas story! An enjoyable read. *Smile*

I have a few punctuation suggestions:

I tell you(,) my friend, I miss

years(,) and Kris has

their backs[;](,) pushing them against

those were the
days(,) my friend.”

snow blowing all around him[,] was a

“Oh my goodness, no(,) boys!”

of the family(,) and I’ve already

you little(,) pointy(-)eared
rogues,

Cheers!

Harry
460
460
Review of In Honor  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

Wonderful content here! Very nicely done tribute.

Only a couple of comments:

1) The building wall stood at right angles
To the sidewalk where I walked,
On each brick a name embossed,
>>>>> If the wall was at right angles, it would be like an inverted T. You'd be walking.........then come to a wall at right angle l
l
................l........
Am I confused , or how could you read the bricks in the wall?? Seems the sidewalk should run parallel to the wall for you to read the bricks?? I'm confused!!

2)How can we e’re repay the debt >>> e're ??
This plays tricks to my eye : we e're ...
It looks like a typo! Is e're supposed to be ever? Then shouldn't it be e'er? Anyway, you might reconsider this wording.

Again, an excellent piece. *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry
461
461
Review of Mood in Poetry  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

"enjambement" still looks funny....LOL

Content is okay!

Cheers!

Harry
462
462
Review by Harry
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi thrice ~

My suggestions:

The sun was expanding[;] ( -- ) going
nova, pulsar, quasar, blackhole, dwarf star, it didn’t matter. The world was coming to an end(!)

than it did yesterday(,)(w)hich
meant it

Give me a break, will you(?)

. We each have [are] (our) own style

it was true(;) he did not want

He (lay)[laid] down(,) and the coffin lid closed

Ah, to (H)ell with ya!”

He was ravenous[,] but
could not go

Suddenly(,) he tumbled down the steps, landing in a mass of dripping flesh. Trudeau[,] rushed to his side and (,)picking him up in his arms, carried his smoking body

lie still and rest(;) you might be able

his long(-)time friend

There is safty below >>> safety

of the mausoleum(,) desperately

Like I said in an earlier review, you write horror stories quite well! *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry
463
463
Review of Mr. Bones  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hi again, W.D. ~

You are a good writer. You build suspense well. *Smile*

A few suggstions:

the gray-haired
(p)rincipal of Diablo Elementary School.

and thought
‘(G)od, here she

“Well(,) haven’t you

“Well(,) I think their

are in order(,) and I’m sure

Why don’t you return to your
class and get ready for the second half of school(?)”

My god(,) man, how many

(")Well, of course I know,” said Principal Hardy

I see nothing wrong with that(.)[,]
(D)o you?”

thin face(,) and his dark(,) sunken eyes gave him

... they’re faces are
blank.”>>>>> their faces

gone to the (C)hildren’s (H)ospital >>>> above, you capitalized these. Be consistent!

You do horror stories well! *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry
464
464
Review of The Jump  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello, W.D. ~

Well-written story. Very suspenseful and well told.
I do offer the following suggestions for your consideration: ( ) = insert, [ ] = delete

had done all the essential homework [,]
and made the >>>>> delete comma

blond-headed (newswoman) was more interested in the
danger of the jump itself [rather] than the stupid idiot >>> newswoman....delete rather

climbed in the window(;)[,] all of the
glass had long

cameras and the crowd(,)
as he tightly buckled

designated half(-)mile point

shot forward(,) and time stood

all he could here >>> hear

dip downward(;)[,] he felt the

at this point[,] but to sit back and brace

end dipped lower(,) and Josh saw

He realized then[,] he was

opposite side[;] (,) mouths hanging open

Believability of story: I found it hard to conceive of the scenario given. Any experienced stunt driver who had figured a daredevil jump such as this would not be so far off as in the story in his estimate of how far the car would travel! He might have missed-figured by enough to not quite reach the other side and crash headfirst into the cliff beneath the rim, but it is not believable to me that he was so far off that the car turned nosedown and fell into the river below. A car traveling at 120 mph leaving a ramp would probably sail the necessary 90 feet in the story, no? [The distance was 50 yards (150 feet) minus the ramp's 20 yards (60 feet) extended over the rim equals only 30 yards (90 feet) to sail.] Anyway, I failed to believe it would/could happen as written. *Frown*

Cheers!

Harry
465
465
Review of In Me, a Mother  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Amy ~

Perfection!

Cheers!

Harry
466
466
Review of Regarding the Gun  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi, Amy ~

Very nice alliteration and assonance going on here.
Too many lines starting with 'I' for my taste, I'm afraid...

Cheers!

harry
467
467
Review of Skirts of Rain  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Amy ~

Very, very nicely penned! *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry
468
468
Review of Sensory Words  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

These listings seem fairly comprehensive!

as possible(.) (You) may use (a) thesaurus.

squar

tal

Cheers!

Harry
469
469
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

Very informative! *Smile*

A couple of minor misspellings:

enjambement: enjambment, no 'e'

simile: the comparison of two unlike thins >>> things

enjambement: >>>> delete e
Looking through the eyes
NOTE: enjambement

Cheers!

Harry
470
470
Review of What is Poetry?  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi, VIV ~

An ambitious goal...to define/explain poetry!! *Smile*


The emotions a scene, an experience, an attachment evoke >>>> or is understood, eh? so evokes


A vital element of great poetry is concreteness, insisting on the specific, the concrete. Lines of poetry should present a concrete image. >>>There's a lot of 'concrete' here.... overuse of the word.

to Milton, the language of poetry was >>> is ?

have [been] evolved into

Might check your spacing between text, Some spaces seem too large.

Cheers!

Harry
471
471
Review of White Lace  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

Excellently written story!! You are truly one of the best short-story writers I've ever read. This story is simply excellently told. *Smile*

I could find only three minor, minor glitches:

some old(-)fashioned types

The clerk le[a]d them to the rear of the shop(,) where she pointed

Cheers!

Harry
472
472
Review of The Night Crawler  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

Excellent writing! The story is gripping throughout.

A couple of things:

gave off whiffs of musky[,] mold

The sea breeze stoked her bare arms, >>> stroked ?

The time sequence of the last paragraph threw me. Is it immediately following the yelling and shots? Or is it the next morning or later? If immediately following, it is unlikely she would leave the safety of her locked house, plus it is midnight and she would not be "Her eyes searched the face of the distant cliff..." because it would be too dark to see two miles away. If later, then it does not transition very well from the end of the previous paragraph...too abrupt.

Other than these minor points, this is quite nicely written. You are an excellent writer of short stories!

Cheers!

Harry
473
473
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Viv ~

A very well told story. I like this a lot.

I did have a few suggestions:

“Omi, mother, please, you must come away from here before this rabble turns on us,” (o)ne of the younger women >>>>> one of ....Also, is 'mother' here how she refers to her mother so should be capitalized??

Can you not understand that my son is in there somewhere(?)”

take you to my mother-in-law(')s,

why have (Y)ou[r] forsaken me!”

He half(-)carried

He’s alive!” John('s) exclamation brough(t) her


Nice writing, Viv!

Cheers!

Harry
474
474
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.5)

Hi, Viv ~

The Day of Two Suns (ID #663721)
The search for survivial during war >>> survival

The soldiers prodded across >>>> plodded ?

think some their forces are

except come into the army >> Is it Army when you are speaking of a branch of service??

(indent} “Sure, go ahead.

Who’s little, bother?” >>> brother

came in paniced pants.>>>panicked

he wetted his handkerchief >>> wet?


The story was well developed and engrossing throughout. Nice job, Viv ! *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry
475
475
Review of False Flowering  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi, Amy ~

Another superb write from you! Very well penned.

My one suggestion:

or faerie tale; a filtered lullaby. >>> comma in place of semicolon here

Cheers!

Harry
485 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 20 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/harryg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/19