*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mcgupta44/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/28
Review Requests: ON
5,852 Public Reviews Given
5,942 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 24 25 26 27 -28- 29 30 31 32 33 ... Next
676
676
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
Who would not like this song? The sweetest songs are those that rise on their in the heart as a wail or pain or longing, moisten the eyes and get transformed, almost automatically, into words. Those are the words that endure long after the event that brought them forth.

M C Gupta
677
677
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
It is a beautiful song indeed. It has got to be beautiful because the lyrics were written not on a computer key board sitting coffee at midnight in the cozy comfort of home, probably for a contest, but came spontaneously to mind as an urge inspired by nature and the "forty shades of green".

Real poetry is not created. It springs forth and is written down from the welling sprout.

M C Gupta
678
678
Review of Rain  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a beautiful poem. A good poem recreates the scene, the memories, the past, the thoughts and feelings. Your poem does that in ample measure. And, leaves a longing in the heart.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
679
679
Review of Ingenuous  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is an interesting poem written in easy style, using short lines and simple words, presented in good rhyme. At a deeper level, there is a message about child psychology also.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
680
680
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
It is a nice piece of reflection about a dream.

In Hindu ancient scriptures, there is a famous story about King Janak regarding how he wondered about a dream he had and how a sage, aged 12 years, satisfied his curiosity.

http://www.kakaji.org/edition.asp?id=56

M C Gupta
681
681
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
The following from you are real pearls--

"Giving someone all your love is never an assurance that they'll love you back! Don't expect love in return; just wait for it to grow in their heart but if it doesn't, be content to know that it grew in yours."


"Perhaps God wants us to meet a few wrong people before meeting the right one so that when we finally meet the right person, we will know how to be grateful for that gift".

SUGGESTION--


closer to me then a friend; one I can share my inner most feelings intimately with, someone

>> closer to me than a friend; one I can share my innermost feelings intimately with, someone

M C Gupta
682
682
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.0)
This is rather an intriguing story. You have just written the initial part. I am sure you have a plot in your mind. I would have thought it worthwhile to write the whole story yourself as per the plot in your scheme of things. It may not be easy for others to add interactive pieces to a story which says something like--'When my father created your father'.........'both our fathers are no more'...........and, also talk of a third Father. If others add their pieces, it is unlikely to follow the plot that you have probably already thought of.

***

The following is hazy in meaning / grammar--

" I’m not going to make you be on my side, but I to your father in the world above that you’ll come to me when I feel I need you most.”

M C Gupta
683
683
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
It is a pretty good story.

*******


Teens found even the minimum wage jobs traditionally their niche, being swept up by desperate adult professionals

>> This is a good description of the hard times. BTW, should be--

Teens found even the minimum wage jobs, traditionally their niche, being swept up by desperate adult professionals

****

As accepting as the Brawer family had always been of her, it had only taken a chance encounter between her mother and his to fan the flames and remind Jude she didn't belong.

>> Pretty interesting. A good reminder that some things never change, whether across millennia or cultures or the type of socio- political regimes.

***

Garrett traced a finger intently over the Impala’s raised SS logo, seemingly no more sure of how to say goodbye then he was.

>> You need to check the grammar here.

684
684
Review of Find Me  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem, depicting feelings of depression, of being alone, of being lost, and praying for help.

The message is clear. There are no mistakes.


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
685
685
Review of Game of Life  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice inspiring poem. You need to take care of the following--

Even days that seem to hard,
you drag yourself along.

>> too hard

**

But some one wise once told me,

>> someone

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
686
686
Review of Thoughts  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 18+ | (2.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

I find major problems in this piece. An example is given below:

while yelling that intimacy isn't just phalus and orfice. insert.
most times its just that beer you kept buying

>>

while yelling that intimacy isn't just phallus and orifice. Insert.
Most times it's just that beer you kept buying

---To me these are not what is euphemistically called typos. For me they are 5 clear mistakes.

No offence meant. But, it would be dishonesty on my part to award you 4.5 stars as has been done by 4 more viewers.


M C Gupta

*********
POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner  (E)
A monthly contest for formal poetry in rhyme and meter.
#1017054 by Dr M C Gupta

"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT



687
687
Review of Behind The Door  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

You have used a new poetry form and have stuck to the rules well. The message, though a bit subtle, comes out clearly. There are no mistakes. A distinct rhythm is palpable (it has to be, this being a poem structured as per defined rhyme and meter).

It deserves 5 stars.

M C Gupta

*********
POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner  (E)
A monthly contest for formal poetry in rhyme and meter.
#1017054 by Dr M C Gupta

"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
688
688
Review of Insanity  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem. I think punctuation would increase its comprehensibility, in the process, also, automatically, improve certain expressions that are a bit hazy. It would, hopefully, improve the rhythm also.


In the heights of my imagination
deep within the heart of my core

>> It would look better as--

In the heights of my imagination
deep within the core of my heart


M C Gupta

*********
POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner  (E)
A monthly contest for formal poetry in rhyme and meter.
#1017054 by Dr M C Gupta

"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
689
689
Review of Concrete Roses  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.
It's a nice poem. The I felt the flow needs to be enhanced.

re are no mistakes, EXCEPT--

With ancient city rising deep
Into a wandering phrase

>> Probably you meant --phase

M C Gupta

*********
POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner  (E)
A monthly contest for formal poetry in rhyme and meter.
#1017054 by Dr M C Gupta

"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
690
690
Review of Tears of Sorrow  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

I have to tread with timidity when rating lower a poem rated 4.5 by eight viewers.

This is an unusual poem. Imagination is essential to poetry. Here the situation imagined is--

Sun loves the sky.
Clouds cover up the sun and steal it away from the sky.
Sky cries tears of pain, deprivation and anguish.
The tears fall down as rain. [Rain is perceived by the poet as tears].


Despite the right of the poet to imagine the unimaginable, lay thinking and common sense come in the way of perceiving the rain drops coming not from the clouds but from the sky. As a matter of fact, viewing the clouds as different from the sky and regarding the two as rivals, presents its own challenge to mental comprehension.

Then, there is the little matter of grammatical obscurity--

Rain patters and splatters on my table,
Pelt down their catharsis of agony,

>> What is the noun for which 'their' has been used? It just does not fit.

M C Gupta

*********
POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner  (E)
A monthly contest for formal poetry in rhyme and meter.
#1017054 by Dr M C Gupta

"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
691
691
Review of Blind Man's Heart  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
It is a pleasure to read this poem. It is not merely the story of a forlorn heart, with a happy ending. The cause behind that folorn-ness is touching. The man was blind and no one bothered to give him or his feelings a thought.

It is so uncommon to come across poems written for the underdog, the deprived, the poor, the weak, the unfortunate that your poem comes as a pleasant exception.

M C Gupta
 LINKS TO POEMS ABOUT THE DEPRIVED  (E)
Links to my poems about the destitute, the orphan, the beggar etc.
#1357603 by Dr M C Gupta
692
692
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
This is very well written. Congratulations for writing a poem in a genre that is so difficult to write, humour.

The content and the situation is eminently appropriate; there is rich imagery; rhyme and flow are excellent. There are no spelling or other mistakes.

It is remarkable that you can write excellent fiction as well as poetry.

SUGGESTIONS--

It would be nice if you explain the non-English words like gyani, antaryaami, etc.

M C Gupta

693
693
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
I can't admire it enough. This is almost a perfect story. Brings to my mind immediately the description of OUB (Out of Body) experience described by Dr. Raymond Mody, MD, PhD, in his once best seller--Life after life.

You have brought out beautifully the various aspects of love--filial love, man-woman love, spiritual love.

Very good write, a rare one.

M C Gupta
694
694
Review of Meditation  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
It is a nice poem. However, the idea of meditation does not come out well here. Meditation is much more than certain breathing exercises. Breath control through Pranayam is just a technique to enter meditational state. It is not a must. Intensely spiritual persons can achieve a state of meditation almost at will.

Also, I think the flow can be enhanced.

I once wrote a poem with the same title in 2003.

—--"MEDITATION


M C Gupta
695
695
Review of Summer's Delight  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
It is a good poem. My feeling was that it can be improved by--

-Attending to flow, maybe checking meter / syllabic counts [It has reasonably good flow already. However, it can be improved].

-Some words seem to be forced, such as the last word in the last line, obviously used for the sake of rhyme.

M C Gupta
696
696
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed.

Your syllabic counts are not constant. A ghazal must have proper "bahar", which is reflected by a combination of the counts and accents of syllables.

You have lines with 9, 10, 11 and even 12 syllables.

M C Gupta

*********
POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner  (E)
A monthly contest for formal poetry in rhyme and meter.
#1017054 by Dr M C Gupta

"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
697
697
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
It is a nice tribute to your mentor. You seem to be fond of 5-7-5 form and that's fine. The classical haiku has usually something to do with nature. In any case, one can always argue that you were telling us about the nature of your mentor:)

M C Gupta
698
698
Review of A butterfly  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
It's a beautiful haiku. Simple, easy, flowing naturally, about nature, correct structurally, no mistakes.

There no reason to hold back half a star.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

A return review will be appreciated--
"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
699
699
Review of MY BROTHER'S EYES  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.0)
These are beautiful thoughts that come from a sincere heart in a simple manner, without any mistakes of language, without much poetic affect, or without obvious effort at the semblance of bringing in some flow by any of the well known devices like rhyme or meter.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed


"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
700
700
Review of Somehow  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem. You have dealt with this topic in a novel manner. There are no mistakes.

Write on! And, please check my other contests.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
2,130 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 86 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mcgupta44/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/28