*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/tadpole1/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: ON
442 Public Reviews Given
1,167 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Depends. Sometimes, in depth, and sometimes, "just the feel of the item."
I'm good at...
I'll let you be the judge.
Favorite Genres
Sci/fi and fantasy. Anything with a happy ending.
Least Favorite Genres
Anything depressing.
Favorite Item Types
Static.
I will not review...
I do not like reviewing anything that was not spell checked. Do your homework first.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... Next
26
26
Review of The Wishing Tree  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.0)
Good afternoon Fyn,

I enjoyed your story. The title pulled me in, and the heartfelt story kept me reading. It was very sweet and touching, a story of true love.

What could have made it better? I would have liked to know the couple's names earlier. It would have helped me to become attached quicker.

This may be a local expression, if not, is the word "some" extra? "We'll be fine. Bet you feel some better finally telling me about it."

"Another autumn" feels vague. Maybe "Years later"?


Thank you for sharing your story of lasting love.


Tadpole1
27
27
Review of Her First Time  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Zeke,

This was cute. *Smile*

You were able to misdirect what was about to happen to the young lady in the beginning. I smiled as I read along, wondering if she wasn't in a xxx xxxx (blanks to avoid a spoiler for anyone reading the review).

I liked it, but I'm going to go back to see if I can find any suggestions...It's quit good, so I'm "looking" for a suggestion. Here it is: Do you think that the two have the same voice? Do they sound the same to you? Is there a way to differentiate them? Perhaps one could speak with shorter sentences? I don't know, but it's a good idea to make each voice distinctive whenever possible. Sometimes, it's even possible to know who is speaking just by the dialogue.

Thanks for sharing!

Tadpole1
28
28
Review by Tadpole1
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Groups  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Ken, In my inbox, I saw congratulations written for you, so I popped by to check why. I’m not sure why you were being congratulated, but congratulations! Lol.

While I was here, I decided to read one of your structured poems. By the way, are you good enough with poetry rules to teach those unskilled?

Anyway, back to your piece.

abab bab abab Did I get that right?

I’m not sure what the glistening spheres are. Tears?

In my personal opinion, poetry is always good because it comes from someone’s heart, and the rules (such as I understand them) allow great freedom in the writing.

So, how does this piece make me feel? I find it a bit pessimistic and would like a final stanza of hope added. This being said, I think I wrote one about terrorism that probably didn’t give much hope either. (I’m rolling my eyes at myself here.)

Thanks for sharing and have a sunshiny day!

T


29
29
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi Imran,

Thank you for sharing your chapters. *Smile*

What I liked: I liked the feeling of intense emotion. It was almost as if there was a bit of biographical information here.

What I think could be improved: Show, Don't Tell. My guess is that you will hear a lot of that here. This story is being "told."

Write the story as if it were happening right now. Use strong active verbs, and avoid weak verbs like was and were. Add dialogue. Have the characters interact together. Give more setting. Write as if it were a film, one action triggering the next.

Good luck and thank you for sharing!

Keep writing,

Tadpole1
30
30
Review of The Test  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi Jacky,

Jellalabad?

I have no idea, so of course, I Googled it. Roll eyes. This being said, I am still not sure.

I read your little flash fiction because I jumped into the Pond to see what was happening and I saw that your story won.

With only three-hundred words, you are limited to what you can write, but if you were to expand your little story (just to be able to write a critique in this review) I would point out that there's no setting (grounding) in the story and Mom only pops in at the end. Also, silly me, I didn't get the punch line. I suppose that Mom doesn't think that video games are worth fighting for? (I'm blushing with embarrassment here.)


Congratulations for winning!

Tadpole1
31
31
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi PS,

You popped up again, so here's another review!

I enjoyed your satire, smiling all the while.

Typo: "I 'watch' in horror" I believe you meant "watched."

32
32
Review of The Survivors  
Review by Tadpole1
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Groups  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi PS,

Thank you for your poem. It takes us through darkness to find hope.

My favorite line: Actually, I like the two first lines. I find them very poetic.

Thanks for sharing!

Keep writing,

Tadpole1
33
33
Review of Ethnicity  
Review by Tadpole1
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Groups  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi AngieB,

With so few words you were able to convey a positive outlook on several deep subjects. Impressive.

It was a very pleasant read, and we could all learn from the message.

My favorite line: "We share different texture hair, we share different accents." With this simple line, we already have an idea where the poem is going.

Thanks for sharing. Keep writing,

Tadpole1
34
34
Review by Tadpole1
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Groups  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi ya Sailor,

This was a mighty cute story. The kind I would have liked to have been able to tell my kids. It was a feel-good story.

How could it be improved? Well, I think the story itself was just fine. Perhaps, a grammar check?

Here are two things I picked out, but I believe there are more.

1) They added a variety of food outlets, and repositioned... Don't break up the two parts of the verb with a comma.

They added and repositioned.

2) ...then the current fashion. (than)

Thanks for sharing!

Tadpole1
35
35
Review of MEMORIES  
Review by Tadpole1
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Groups  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi JJ,

This little piece grabbed me and ripped my heart apart. At first, I thought it was a roommate. Finally, I realized it was your pet, probably a cat. That threw me back to the loss of our golden retriever and when we had to put him to sleep. So painful.

It was very moving.

Thanks for sharing!

Tadpole1
36
36
Review of history quiz  
Review by Tadpole1
In affiliation with Cross Timbers Groups  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Jack,

I saw a review from you in my inbox, so I thought I'd pop over and review something for you.

I had to smile when I started the test. I figured that I'd get about 50%. Then I thought, there are three parts to each question--I'll make a 33.33%. As luck has it, I happily made a super XX%. Roll eyes. My son would have aced the test.

Thanks for putting me in my place. Roll eyes again. Anyway, I enjoyed taking the test. It was quite interesting.

Thanks for sharing!

Tadpole1
37
37
Review of He Yells a Lot  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Paul,

"I know you did it! You won the flash fiction contest. Congratulations!"

Tadpole1


38
38
Review of Brotherly Love  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Miles,

I entered the contest too, so I decided to peek at your story.

It was really cute! I liked it a lot.

By the way, do you think that it would be interesting to have a twist at the end? Maybe the mom blames Kevin for it when, indeed, it was Jimmy, but Jimmy was clever enough to make his mom think that it was his brother framing him instead of Jimmy framing his brother in a wicked way?

I liked your story. Good job. *Smile*

Keep writing!

Tadpole1
39
39
Review of Caught  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Jacky,

I entered the flash fiction contest too, so I decided to take a peek at your entry.

This was so cute! I had to smile. Great job. Loved the twist at the end.

There's a difference between "everyday" and "every day."

everyday -- Something ordinary. She wore her everyday dress instead of her Sunday best.
every day -- Daily. She wore that dress every single day!

Keep writing!

Tadpole1
40
40
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
CanImagine – Be Careful What You Tell Your Kids


*RainbowL* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *RainbowR*

Hi everyone. Any of my comments or suggestions are just that: comments or suggestions. They are always given with respect and the hopes that they will be helpful. If you don’t agree with them, just ignore them; after all, you know what is best for your story. Also, three and a half stars means that it’s pretty good. Five stars means that I couldn’t make any suggestions for improvement. *Smile*

Themes — is this reader blown away by mind-blowing philosophy or originality? Do we ever learn, or perhaps, like father like son, or perhaps…

Grammar: Please see line by line review. These are useful sites. I particularly like the Purdue Owl one. You might want to take a look at it.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...
http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/questionstags...
http://www.grammar-monster.com/lessons/which_that_...
http://wps.ablongman.com/long_faigley_penguinhb_1/...
http://grammartips.homestead.com/compoundsentences...

Just My Personal Opinion: *Smile*

Hi CanImagine,*Smile*

I had a few belly laughs. Thank you very much!

I totally enjoyed this short story.

Tadpole1

Tadpole1

Sometimes, we adults can think or behave like children. When telling an interesting or exciting story, we relish every Ooh! and Ah! heaped upon us. Young people often react so strongly to a good tale that the

joy is much greater for the storyteller. awkward

Having learned from sad experience; comma

it is not wise to tell a child about actions you performed that were inherently unwise. Even when accompanied by warnings of the stupidity of your decisions and how close you may have come to death.

Born in the middle 50's, my formative years were not clouded with fear of terrorists nor were we surrounded by violence. The watchdogs now set to "protect" us from these threats did not exist. Even gangs were small and had little effect on daily life. We feared organized crime and the Soviet Union. My, how times have changed.

When I was around sixteen, fireworks were, and still are illegal in the County of Los Angeles. Not wanting to miss the Fourth of July fun, and being a typical boy, I decided to make homemade fireworks for the family's entertainment.

My adult neighbor taught the mournful neighborhood that using fireworks at home could have irreparable results. His widow and children have never forgotten.


Not a difficult feat since my hobby was chemistry. Yes, I was a nerd. In those days being called a nerd or geek was an insult and not a lifestyle choice with possible respect for any accompanying talents.

We had an enjoyable firework display by the pool where emergency water was available, and that should have been the end of it. As I got older and surprisingly less wise, my friends and I decided that with a few electronic components and a purchased Estes model rocket, we could make a shoulder mounted launcher out of a cardboard carpet tube. It turned out successful, and the resulting explosion of the rocket against the old washing machine in the back hills of Valencia was impressive. So impressive, we ran like

scared children fearing getting caught and harshly penalized. You still were young enough to be considered a child by some, no?

Discussing it afterward, we realized, all three of us may have

could have


died or received serious injuries if the rocket had exploded while inside the tube launcher. We decided the whole idea was terribly stupid and never did anything that dangerous again.

Please don't misunderstand me. I was a kid, easily bored and did many more crazy and dangerous things—just not quite that idiotic.

*****


Many years later, I now had five children who all enjoyed hearing stories told as often as possible. Not just my little ones who would sit me down and speak as young children do saying, "Daddy, tell me story of 'you' life." ?? ‘your’ ??

My older kids would ask, "Dad, what other crazy things have you done?"

After telling stories of how Captain Hook's problems all came from not listening to his parents, the question of my adventures from my son Drew, standing at the door, brought more temptation than I could endure. I recounted the very stupid and crazy experience I had when still young consisting of making a homemade rocket launcher. This is very interesting, but I think the above sentences could be smoother.


Not forgetting to reiterate how incredibly dangerous it was. Also, eliciting a promise that he would never consider anything so hazardous. Two fragments

Fragments are fine every once in a while, but I think sentences would be better here.


*****


Now it is time for you to stop and listen to your inner voice and discern what happened next. I'm relieved to say that the ensuing events, though spectacular, did not result in death or injury. Me too!

Drew and his friend Spencer—the names have not been changed, and neither are they innocent— Thanks for the belly laught!

decided because of my tale, a carpet tube would be a great launcher for rockets. Fortunately, the house had accumulated a supply of fireworks over the years purchased from places outside the state and the county. I say fortunately because the two boys elected to skip the whole—build a high explosive rocket—idea, and elected to use some of the existing supply of bottle rockets. These produce a much lower yield in explosive power; I promise you.

As a side thought, I have never claimed to be mature or to have accumulated wisdom to go with my years. These illegal fireworks would not have been in the house if I had indeed grown into a wise man. Lol!

On one balmy evening in July, my son's friend was visiting. I happened to glance out the window and see the two boys crossing the yard headed to the gate that would take them to the Homeowners Association land, "Behind the Houses," as my kids called it. A carpet tube and bottle rockets seemed a suspicious set of play toys to take into an area of two to three feet high dangerously dry grass in the greatest heat of summer. Like father, like son. Oh my!

Catching up with them, I explained, as wise fathers should, their obvious intent was dangerous, a potential fire hazard and I sent them back to the house. Poor clueless trusting father, thinking that the story would end there. All I had to do was look back at my life, and I should have realized the adventure was yet to come. This is really funny! Well, let’s temper that. You might have seen it coming…

Less than an hour later, Lindsy, my daughter noticed a large plume of smoke rising from noticeable orange flames of the burning grass at the top of the little one-hundred-foot-high hill beyond our fence. too long

Less than an hour later, Lindsy, my daughter, burst into the room. She had noticed a large plume of smoke with huge orange flames. The grass at the top of the hill beyond our fence, was burning!


Within a few minutes, two fire department helicopters flew over and performed water drops followed up by firemen from multiple engine companies comma trying to squash the fire before it grew into a major brush fire. They succeeded, no comma and extinguished the fire in less than thirty minutes comma restricting the destruction to under five acres of brush. The initial burn site was only two or three hundred yards from the rear of the police station. That is most likely why it was discovered so quickly.

If you have a phrase in the form: “xxxxing yyy zzzz” following an independent clause (stand alone sentence) then add a comma to separate them.

Two fire department…, trying xxx.
They succeeded and extinguished…, restricting xxx.


As any father would, during the excitement I checked and verified that all my children were home and safe. Drew was there, though his friend Spencer seemed to have gone home unexpectedly. As the excitement died down, one of my children informed me they had seen Drew and Spencer fleeing from the fire zone. Later, neighbor children informed us that they had observed Drew at the burn site just before the fire and their parents had reported this to the fire department.

Interrogation of my son brought a full confession. Not that a denial would have been very effective with the plethora of witnesses. Years later, my son wrote an essay in school recounting this event. From that paper, I learned that the first few rockets exploded harmlessly in the air above an area clear of brush. It was the accidental dropping of the tube that allowed the already lit rocket to enter the dry grass adjacent to the launch site comma igniting the brush fire. Also, Spencer, Drew's friend had reported the event to his parents.

The family waited with feelings of trepidation for the inevitable contact with the Police or Fire Department. We were not disappointed. The next evening, when responding to a knock on the door, we discovered uniformed members of the Bomb Squad standing in the entryway. Lol! Behind them, in front of our house, sat a police vehicle with a bomb disposal unit attached. Concern and anxiety passed through me as the officer asked me to step outside for a word. Many scenarios of disaster passed through my mind as I agreed and quietly closed the door behind me. Yikes! At least, no one was hurt.

To my surprise, the officer had researched our family and found that we had no record of trouble except the requisite speeding ticket here or there. The extremely kind officer informed me that he had sons of his own and asked me how I wanted him to handle the situation. The look of shock and confusion on my face brought a smile to the officer's face comma and he decided to help me out with a few suggestions. Lol! Maybe he plans to scare goodness into the wayward second generation.

He proposed that if I wanted to, "scare him straight," I could allow him to be "arrested" and spend the night in juvenile detention without creating a record of Drew's incarceration. The officer also suggested the option of his partner and himself giving a lecture designed to, no comma "scare the hell" out of Drew but leave him in the custody of his parents after eliciting a promise of perfect behavior. As a final suggestion, he said I looked like a good dad, and if I so desired, he would allow me to provide a solution and discipline of my choosing. All of the options required the family to turn over any contraband to be placed into the bomb disposal unit for later destruction. Ah, Daddy must confess to his illegal stash!

Not feeling comfortable with allowing my young, mostly innocent, and usually well-behaved son to spend a night in juvenile detention, I selected the second option of "scare the hell" out of him. The officers and I entered the house to find Drew on the couch waiting. The two uniformed men told my son that it was possible that he would be held responsible for the thirty-thousand-dollar cost to the County of Los Angeles to extinguish the fire. Since he was a minor, the cost and responsibility would fall on his parents. Watching the mortified reaction of my son to this revelation, the officer promised to do all he could to prevent those consequences. Even if successful, any future incidents would fall twice as hard on the family with possible jail time for his parents. Lol!

Drew was sufficiently cowed and promised never to do such a thing again. He turned over the contraband fireworks which the Bomb Squad dutifully placed in the disposal unit. After a handshaking ceremony and a wink at me, the officers left taking the family's supply of fireworks with them. I cannot overstate my gratitude to those fine officers who understood the difficulties of fatherhood.

Always a unique child with an active imagination, this was not the first exciting event he brought the family. Unclear as to whom “he” refers.

There is the time Secret Service Agents surprised us at home in response to several counterfeit one hundred dollar bills that Drew had printed and given to friends at school as a joke. For some reason, the US Treasury Department did not see the humor in the incident. However, as they say, "That is another story." Excellent ending!

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to read your work. Please take any suggestions you like and disregard the rest because only you know what is right for your writing.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...
http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/questionstags...
http://www.grammar-monster.com/lessons/which_that_...

*RainbowL* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *RainbowR*





41
41
Review of Behold  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.0)
Dear SaintLee,

Although I did not completely understand the text, I enjoyed it. It gave me a sense of melancholy. I liked the rhythm of the thump thump, thump thump. I could hear it in my head. I also liked the visual disposition of the poem. It was aesthetically pleasing.

Thank you for sharing! *Smile*

42
42
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Cat,

Lol! "no fairy tale is complete without a dragon"

I loved your short story! It was wonderful. I could see everything clearly, and I loved your voice.

Absolutely a pleasure. *Smile*

Thank you for sharing!

Tadpole1
43
43
Review of Acting Like A Man  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi ya, Harry,

That was truly a story in poetic form. Great job!

I didn't see anything that I didn't like.

At the end, you could feel the tension rising when we wondered who would open the door.

Thanks for sharing,

Tadpole1
44
44
Review of Natural Life  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Natural Life

*RainbowL* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *RainbowR*

Hi everyone. Any of my comments or suggestions are just that: comments or suggestions. They are always given with respect and the hopes that they will be helpful. If you don’t agree with them, just ignore them; after all, you know what is best for your story. *Smile*

What I liked best: Oh, I loved the magic! But wait, I loved the emotion. Oh, dear, I loved the characters.

Plot: Elizabeth brings healing and happy growth wherever she goes. When she comes home, she hears her little brother cry out. She heals her beaten mother—again. Unfortunately, there is another who needs healing, but she lacks the power for him.

Pacing: The pacing was good, but I think adding more scenery wouldn't hurt it.
Hooking: I was hooked right away and throughout the story.
Tension: Great rise in tension at the end.


Style & Voice -- Concerning style: My comments will assume that you would like to write either in first person or third person limited. However, I would like to point out that many, if not most, of the books that I have bought recently use the omniscient point of view. Ultimately, style is the author's choice.

Style: It is important to choose whether the story will be told in the present tense or the past tense and keep that tense.

Style: In general, try to keep to only one adjective in a sentence.

Style: It pretty well stayed in Elizabeth's point of view. Good job.


Scene/Setting: Lovely. I think there could have been more.

Characters: Well done.

Elizabeth: with her super healing powers.
Momma: who needs her daughter.
Little brother: who knows he can count on his big sister to heal Momma.
Dad: He is ill and needs healing, but . . . I won't give the end away.

Grammar: Please see line by line review. I only mentioned one missing comma.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...
http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/questionstags...
http://www.grammar-monster.com/lessons/which_that_...
http://wps.ablongman.com/long_faigley_penguinhb_1/...
http://grammartips.homestead.com/compoundsentences...

Just My Personal Opinion: *Smile*

*Smile*

Hi,

Fantastic!

I loved the story. I was drawn in right away and the ending blew me away.

Thanks for sharing!

Tadpole1

Tadpole1


I slowly walk towards a huge dead oak.

Style: This is a perfectly sound sentence, but how could it be better?
Try to keep to one adverb or adjective.
Suggestion: I ambled towards a huge dead oak.


It is so sad to see what was once magnificent tree, dead. Its bark is grey in color, where there is some, and branches are broken and frayed. I place my hand on the tree, and press my ear to it's trunk, my long hair getting caught in its broken bark. At first, I hear nothing, no sign of life flowing through this tree. Then a sudden burst of heat runs through my body, going towards my hand which is still arranged on the tree. There is a sudden circling gush of wind around the tree and I, which then stops the flowing from my hand. I take a couple steps back and watch this lifeless tree transform. I watch as the bark comes together and all the crevasses fill in. It is no longer gray in color, but a warm luscious brown. Broken branches extend to their original length. Tiny leaf buds appear, and begin to unfold into beautiful leaves.

Yes! It's spring. Well, it really is spring, and I love when trees and flowers awaken. There may be more coming, so let me read on . . .


I admire my work for a few more minutes and think to myself, "Why me? Why did He choose me? I'm a nobody." I look at the sky and ask out loud "Why me?", and like many times before I receive no answer. I let out a loud sigh and start heading home to my cabin.

I'm caught up in the story and can't wait to see what happens next.

On my way home, I imagine exotic flowers popping up along my path and as if I was magic they appear. I softly touch every little sapling I see and I watch them grown. As I get close to the cabin, I can hear my brother Beau crying. I break into a sprint to

try and Style: Whenever considering words like "try," ask yourself if you really need them.

find him and I spot him on the front porch. I quickly get to him and begin wiping away his tears.

When his tears have slowed,

Style: Watch the verb tenses. "imagine, appear, …get and begin" are present tense; whereas, "have slowed and was" are past tenses.


I asked what was wrong, and he began to cry again.

New paragraph
Through sobs and sniffles all he could manage to say was, "I tried to stop him but he just kept hitting and kicking momma till she was all bloody and couldn't get up."

New paragraph
I immediately knew that the "he" he was referring to was our father, who is an alcoholic, and I assume already back at the bar.

I ran inside to find my mother. At the end of the kitchen table I see her all bloody and bruised, possibly even broken. She wouldn't look at me, she just kept staring down at her lap. Neither of us spoke as I made my way to the stove. I grabbed the kettle and started to boil some water. There was nothing but silence as the water came to a boil. I dug into the back of the cupboard, where I hid my special healing tea, and then made my mother a cup. After a couple of sips comma I watched the gash across her chin close up and the various bruises and scuffs fade and then disappear. I hear, what I believe is her nose snapping back into place. The healing continues throughout her body slowly relaxing her. Momma sits there silent, for a few more moments, and then looks at me with tears in her eyes.

Cool! Healing tea!


"Thank you for healing me again, Elizabeth," She says. I give her a big hug then head to my room to think.

Momma is lucky to have such an extraordinary daughter.


I'm so frustrated. I can heal a dead tree, bring it back to life even. I've healed my mother, over and over again. Why can't I heal my dad? I have tried and it never works. What's the use in having these powers, if I can't heal all wounds? The loss of my little sister, forever changed my father, and I guess his wounds are too deep. But still, I don't understand, and no matter how many times I ask Him him why, there is no answer.

Wow! The tension in the last paragraph shot up like a rocket. Fantastic.


Thank you for giving me the opportunity to read your work. Please take any suggestions you like and disregard the rest because only you know what is right for your writing.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...
http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/questionstags...
http://www.grammar-monster.com/lessons/which_that_...

*RainbowL* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *RainbowR*




45
45
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)

*RainbowL* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *RainbowR*

Hi everyone. Any of my comments or suggestions are just that: comments or suggestions. They are always given with respect and the hopes that they will be helpful. If you don’t agree with them, just ignore them; after all, you know what is best for your story. *Smile*

What I liked best: I liked both the plot and the writing.

Plot: At last, Persephone has a chance to escape the underworld, but she decides because she wants to be loved by Hades.

Pace: good
Hook: good
Tension: good
Confusions: no


Style & Voice -- Concerning style: My comments will assume that you would like to write either in first person or third person limited. However, I would like to point out that many, if not most, of the books that I have bought recently use the omniscient point of view. Ultimately, style is the author's choice.

The voice was good. No problems. The style was good. No problems.


Referencing: I chose to read the story because of the title.

Scene/Setting: Well done.

Characters:

Persephone
Hades

Grammar: Please see line by line review. I would have added more commas, but it is a difference in style.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...
http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/questionstags...
http://www.grammar-monster.com/lessons/which_that_...
http://wps.ablongman.com/long_faigley_penguinhb_1/...
http://grammartips.homestead.com/compoundsentences...

Just My Personal Opinion:

Hi Sidheashe,*Smile*

I saw your story in the newsletter, so I thought that I would pop over and take a peek. Here I go…


I truly enjoyed the story from the beginning to the end. Well done. *Smile*

Tadpole1


Word count: 903

What if Persephone chose to stay with Hades?

She looked at the dead dirt path ahead of her. Her ruby red shoes that were so unlike her were a stark contrast to the grayish colored earth. Good hook.

The soft yellow lantern light barely illuminated the cavern she was in, but at this point Persephone was used to that. It had been months since she was dragged to the underworld, months since she had seen anything but gray and black and red. Persephone kept walking. She had to. If she stayed still she was sure the screams of the dying would catch up to her. Their wails were overwhelming.

Persephone walked for what felt like hours, walked until those ruby red shoes pinched at her feet so hard she was sure they were bleeding the inside crimson. Persephone paused at a crossroad, leaned against the earthen wall of the cave, and removed her shoes. The dirt was cold beneath her bare feet, but everything was cold in the underworld. Persephone straightened up and looked around. There were three passages ahead of her and there at the end of the left most passage was something bright.

Curious, Persephone walked toward the silver brightness, leaving the ruby shoes behind her. As she neared the brightness, the light from her lantern no longer seemed to matter and Persephone hurried forward. One last moment of darkness seemed to cling to her like a second skin and then she emerged into silver light. Persephone breathed in wonder, the cold air bit into her skin through the thin layers of her black dress, but she couldn’t bring herself to care. For the first time in months, Persephone was standing in sunlight.

Transfixed by the almost solid wall of silver light, Persephone crossed to the center of the earthen bridge in the middle of the cavern chamber, leaving her lantern somewhere behind her. In my mind, she had already dropped the lantern.

Persephone gazed up at the silver light in awe. Tears welled in her eyes, from frustration or sadness she didn’t know, but Persephone angrily wiped them away. There would be no crying. She was stronger than that. She was stronger than her mother believed, stronger than HE believed.

There was a time when she wasn’t. There was a time, when she would have burst into tears from being surrounded by all of this cold darkness. Persephone was by nature a creature of the light. Her dominion was over nature and things that lived and grew.

For that Persephone, the idea of being surrounded by nothing but cold dead earth would have caused the girl to weep until there was nothing left to weep, and, in fact, that is what happened. Verb tense changed from past to present.

Persephone had grown from her imprisonment. She had become stronger than any would have thought she could. A small part of her cried out for her to be grateful to HIM. It proclaimed that she would have lived her life in ignorance and naivety if not for HIS love. Was she not better now? Was she not improved?

Thought: creature of light (without "the")


“No!” Persephone cried to that part of herself. “I am not grateful to him. I miss the sunlight. I miss flowers and life. I miss my mother.” But that little voice would not leave her be.

“Were you not lonely before? Did you not long for a companion that your mother would never give you?”

“I had Artemis and Athena! I was not alone.” She proclaimed, but doubt gnawed at her.
The tension is good.


“You lie to yourself.” The voice seemed sad. “It is true you were not physically alone, but the goddesses are not the type of companion you were hungry for. You longed for a man. You longed for the intimacy of a soul mate.”

“There were other ways.” Persephone quietly said.

“There was no other way.” The voice answered. “Your mother turned away every suitor that asked for your hand. She denied every opportunity for you to be with a man. She wanted you for herself. She wanted to keep you prisoner in that field of flowers, a child forever ignorant of the ways of a woman.” nice argument

“What would I have become without HIM?” Persephone questioned. “Would I have ever changed or would I still be picking flowers?”

Persephone mournfully looked up at the silver sunlight. There was little to love in the underworld. The screams of the dead permeated the air and the world was always gray and black and red, but in some ways, the underworld was almost peaceful. Its coolness was almost calming. HIS presence was almost comforting.

Persephone had lived in the land of the light for hundreds of years. Helios’ radiance was glorious and filled with energy, but how long can one live in a world of nothing but light? Persephone realized she was tired. All of her struggles to escape and all of her fighting against HIS darkness had led her here to this bridge, standing beneath the light of the sun. If she screamed from here, Helios would hear her. Her mother would sweep her from this place and back she would go to the field of flowers, never to escape. She would never see HIM again. Well done.

Persephone looked from the glaring light into the cool darkness of the inner cave. Her lantern had fallen just before the bridge. Its soft yellow light was warm and without a second thought Persephone scooped it up. As she left the cavern chamber and headed back into the cave, back to HIM, Persephone never once looked back at the silver light. Oooo!

I really enjoyed your short story!

Everything is good, but I will share something that I search for in my writing. The word "look." There are so many possibilities to find a more interesting way to say it. In this case, maybe:

Persephone glanced from the …


Thank you for giving me the opportunity to read your work. Please take any suggestions you like and disregard the rest because only you know what is right for your writing.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...
http://www.englishgrammarsecrets.com/questionstags...
http://www.grammar-monster.com/lessons/which_that_...

*RainbowL* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *PoseyP* *TulipB* *MushroomG* *ButterflyG* *FishP* *StarfishY* *Frog* *StarfishR* *FishB* *ButterflyV* *MushroomV* *TulipR* *PoseyY* *Grass* *RainbowR*




46
46
Review of Lucy  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Espero,

This story is definitely written by a cat-owner. You can tell. Grin.

Congratulations on winning! *TrophyB*

I found just one little hiccup.

You wrote:

into the car of her of volition.

Suggestion:

into the car of her own volition.

Happy Holidays,

Tadpole1
47
47
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Dear Angus,

'A WRITER'S CURSE' is one of the best short stories I've read in a while.

Of course, I had to look Karen Houston up. Grin. Are you Karen?

I don't think that it really needed the different colors. The first time I read it, I was actually "listening" to it. Then, I took the time to sit down and read it with my eyes.

I can see why your story won the contest. Congratulations!

Well done,

Tadpole1

48
48
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Dave,

I love it, starting with the image.

Great job, no suggestions.

Tadpole1
49
49
Review of The Doyenne  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi Rodoji,

I enjoyed your flash fiction The Doyenne very much. It was emotional, and I was surprised. Well done. *Smile*

It seems a few words might have been missing. You might want to read it out loud.

Good job and thank you for sharing.

Tadpole1 *Frog*
50
50
Review of The Fixer  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Jacky,

I just loved The Fixer! Wonderful! Scary! And...a warning...*Bigsmile*

Good job,

Tadpole1 *Frog*

Oh, yes, I almost forgot. You should reread the story, maybe even out loud. There are a few missing words or something. I felt them as I read the story.
188 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 8 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/tadpole1/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2