Overall Impression
Hi mininessie ! Cute username! This is an original storyline and has much potential. You also have some good descriptions. Isadora's first few years make me curious as to her future and what other trouble her tail is going to give her. I have given you 2.5 stars because of some typos and other grammatical snafus which I have below. I hope you keep working with it.
Please remember that these comments are given in the spirit of helpfulness and are not meant to discourage you from writing. Reviews are meant to show you what you can improve upon and catch any errors that you may have missed.
Other Comments
'Your daughter she has A... A...' If the doctor is saying this, there should be quotations around it and I don't think the 'A's need to be capitalized since they're in the middle of the sentence. I also think this sentence could use a comma after 'daughter'
I'm a little confused about when Isadora's tail emerged. Was she born with it?
The fourth sentence of the first paragraph seems a little long. I think for dramatic emphasis, it would be better as two. Something like: Something was wrong with her little girl, something the doctor didn't want to tell her. The longer he waited, the more scared she became.
You need a comma after sighed at 'The doctor sighed "Isadora...'
'It a very...' It should be It's or It is
'...there child.' In this usage, there should be their In the first two sentences of the second paragraph.
'...made her situation worst.' worst should be worse
There is a missing beginning quotation for Katie's dialogue in the third paragraph.
'Isadora was not yet two years old was showing...' This is a little awkward. You can either take out the first 'was' or add an 'and' before the second 'was' Isadora, not yet two years old was showing... or Isadora was not yet two years old, and was showing
In the fourth paragraph, the sentence starting, 'Katie called again...' seems a little long and I think could be broken up into two sentences or there needs to be a semi-colon after answer
Fifth paragraph:
The explanation of what is on the floor needs to have a comma, I think, before it. Isadora's room was a small room that was quite messy, toys of all kinds on the floor.
The second sentence needs commas. Whenever you have lists, you need to separate the items with commas. The items that are names of shows should be capitalized and either underlined or have quotations around them.
'Isadora had just turned years old...' How old?
'Look at her daughter..." Look should be She looked
mommy in this usage (I'm ok mommy) should be capitalized since you can replace it with a proper name.
'After she had collected her she...' I'm having difficulty following who is doing what in this section. You might consider stating who is doing the collecting. The sentence after this one is a little confusing as well. '...years she has had...' Since the story is in past tense, has isn't grammatically correct. You might try rewording that sentence.
'This was the first time in a long time...' mentioning 'time' twice so close together seems a little repetitive. Try using a synonym for 'time' in the second spot; like while or something like that. I'm not quite sure why Katie wouldn't see her own daughter's tail. She should be bathing and clothing her daughter every day, so she should know its growth rate.
'The kitchen was a small room. That resembled...' This should be one sentence.
'black marble granite' I don't think it's possible to have a counter top of both marble and granite. In a kitchen situation, granite is more likely
I'm a little confused about her age. Kindergarten age is usually five or six. If Isadora is only seven years old or so, I wouldn't think that she would be tall enough to reach the cupboards with her tail. 'As she used her tail...' That sentence, I think, needs to be joined with the previous sentence, or As should be something else.
'...schools actually...' should be school's actual
'Isadora stepped out of the car and stepped...' you don't need the second stepped
'...some of which Isadora liked she passed...' This part of the sentence either needs a comma or be separated into two. I think for the sake of length, the sentence should end at ...some of which Isadora liked.
'...kindergarten room. Where...' There is no need to end the sentence here, this way, the second sentence doesn't make sense.
'Hello Katie," said to Isadora's teacher. I think the quotation is in the wrong spot.
'...out form behind...' I think you mean from
'...her mom as when her teacher...' you don't need both as and when
Showing that she doesn't bite. This really isn't a complete sentence and should be joined with the one after it.
'...made at her mom...' I think you mean mad
The you in "you be good Isadora," needs to be capitalized.
'The classroom the room was a buzz.' I'm not quite sure what you mean.
I think Aome is a typo
'...at isadora A long silence..." isadora needs to be capitalized and you're missing a period at the end of the sentence.
'Confused Isadora Questioned.' You need a comma after 'confused' and 'Questioned' doesn't need to be capitalized.
'Her teachers smile...' teachers is possessive and needs an apostrophe teacher's
You need a comma after 'Ms. Zorski asked,' and her dialogue needs commas or should be more than one sentence; like: "Isadora, surely you have a daddy. A daddy is like a mommy, only he is a man."
it's in "it's a tail." needs to be capitalized
"Yeah there is is missing an end quotation, and you're missing the beginning one of what the class starts chanting.
'Isadora closed her eyes she thought she block the hatred around her by not seeing it.' The middle of this sentence is a little unclear.
You need a period at the end of, "Where are you taking me?" She asked
The Its in "Its okay Isadora..." needs an apostrophe It's
sort in "sort of." needs to be capitalized.
'...Isadora felt his sensation.' is his a typo? I'm not sure what you mean here. I think Isadora is a little young to be experiencing sexual sensations. It might help to expand on what happens to Isadora here.
'...her teacher thought her...' I think thought should be though
'Isadora feared to answer get teacher...' Do you need a comma here? I'm not sure how 'get teacher' fits in.
In the last full paragraph, you have whe which I think must be a typo for when
'Isadora's tail was wrapped around Ms.Zorski's leg trying to suffocate her.' Are you sure you don't mean neck? You can't suffocate someone through their leg.
At the very end, you have stat I think you mean state
Remember to watch your tenses. The majority of this story is in past tense, but there are several spots where you switch, and it makes the sentences a little difficult to understand. One example is in the middle, you have She slowly pops out from behind her mom, and is about to enter the classroom... now pops and is are present tense verbs and are inconsistent with your form and should be popped and was. So just be careful of that.
Again, please don't be discouraged by the star rating and all of these suggestions. I want to help you improve this and I hope that my comments can do that for you. If you have any questions, please let me know. Write on!!!
I'm Striking Out in the Summer BOWL-A-RAMA with THE TALENT POND!
I’M HEATIN’ THINGS UP BY REVIEWING FOR THE TALENT POND!
Click the item below to find out how you can too.
|
|