*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/tadpole1/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9
Review Requests: ON
442 Public Reviews Given
1,167 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Depends. Sometimes, in depth, and sometimes, "just the feel of the item."
I'm good at...
I'll let you be the judge.
Favorite Genres
Sci/fi and fantasy. Anything with a happy ending.
Least Favorite Genres
Anything depressing.
Favorite Item Types
Static.
I will not review...
I do not like reviewing anything that was not spell checked. Do your homework first.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 -9- ... Next
201
201
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hi Mrs.Night,

What I liked:

You have a good start for your story, and I wonder what will come next? *Smile*
You have set the stage and introduced the characters. I think that a story about twins in a new school could be very interesting. Your beginning makes me wonder why she doen't show emotion anymore and why he wants the eyeliner. This is good.

Some suggestions:

Is it possible that you wanted the brother's name to be spelled "Jacques" like in French?
Maybe you would like to say that one of the twins had hazel eyes? That would give you two different ways to describe their eyes. *Smile*

Hazel: adjective: of a light brown or yellowish brown color.

Happy thoughts and keep writing!

Tadpole1
202
202
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hi Krystxn,

Would you do something for me please? Since your chapters are not very short, could you post them separately? It would make it easier for me to review them, especially if I do not have a large block of time. As I have said before, your story is very interesting, so I want to read it. Smaller blocks would just make it easier for me.

Once, again, I think that you have a great story. We have established that, so let me jump to suggestions.

You wrote:

“She felt an instant connection with Jade, as if they were meant to be friends.”

I am not sure that this is true. What do you think about this instead:

“She felt a growing connection with Jade, as if they were meant to be friends.”

When I go back and review my writing, I often notice that I use the word “begin” a lot. So when I start editing my stories, I convert the word “begin” often. For example,

You wrote:

“She then began gliding, only metres above the ground, over the land.”

Suggestion:

“She then glided, only metres above the ground, over the land.”

Sometimes, when I just used the word “began,” and I need to use it soon after, I replace it with “started” to vary things a bit. Sometimes I try to paraphrase my original sentence.

You wrote:

“The sun began rising behind the hills,…”

Suggestion:

“The sun started rising behind the hills,” or “The rays from the rising sun shown from behind the hills,”
or “The sun’s rays reached from behind the hills,”

It seems to me that sometimes you use a comma when you should use a semi- colon. If you are not sure, try asking yourself if each part of the sentence could stand alone as a single sentence.

You wrote:

“So many thoughts were rushing through her head, she felt sorry for raising her voice on Jade, she should have presented herself better, they only just met.”

Suggestion:

“So many thoughts were rushing through her head; she felt sorry for raising her voice on Jade; she should have presented herself better; they only just met.”

Or

“So many thoughts were rushing through her head that she felt sorry for raising her voice on Jade. She should have presented herself better; after all, they only just met.”

Here are a few more of your sentences that you could look at:

“Thank you Jade, but I don’t think I can eat that, I’m sorry.”
“We must go, we do not have much time.”

There were others. Can you find them?

I absolutely loved this part:

“My father.” She whispered.”

I really did not expect this. Excellent.

Now, Krystxn, I honestly do not think that you used spell check because I found several spelling mistakes. It only takes a few seconds to use it before posting your chapter. What do you think?

A few examples:

“…but kept enough weight on her sp that she could not get up…”
I think that you meant “….on her so that…”


This one is not misspelled, but it is the wrong word:

You wrote:

“The girl and the dragon have set back out plans a few days, but we will not have to wait for long.”

But did you mean:

“The girl and the dragon have set back our plans a few days, but we will not have to wait for long.”


How about this one:

You wrote:

“Serena nodded, she could barely move. Jade jumped into the trees in one swift motion and dissappeared among the branches. Knowing she was along, Serena let herself fall back into the grass and closed her eyes.”

Is this better?

“Serena nodded, she could barely move. Jade jumped into the trees in one swift motion and disappeared among the branches. Knowing she was alone, Serena let herself fall back into the grass and closed her eyes.”

Note: “disappeared” and “alone”

You wrote:

“surprised at how lighting the dragon put her down”

Suggestion:

“surprised at how lightly the dragon put her down”

There were a couple of word combinations that I thought should be hyphenated:

“dagger like” suggestion “dagger-like”
“half open” suggestion “half-open”
“bow like” ….

It seems to me that you spoke about how much better it smelt in two different places. Is that right? Anyway, it felt like a repetition when I read it.

Somewhere you wrote “anyways.” Maybe “anyway” would be better.

I did not list everything that I saw in this review. There are more spelling mistakes and other mistakes. Your story is great, and you are a very good writer, but you need to proof this again yourself. Please remember that I am not an English professor, and I still make mistakes.

The 3.0 rating is because of all the errors. If you clean up your errors before posting, I will give a higher rating.

Keep writing, and please make smaller posts if you want remarks about spelling and punctuation like above,

Thanks,

Tadpole1
P. S. I hope that you found this helpful.
203
203
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi Krystxn,

Please let me say right away that I am “not” an English teacher, and I still make plenty of mistakes. Keeping this in mind, I have made some suggestions below. I realize that this is more editing than reviewing, so if you do not want this kind of feedback, just let me know.

General:

Once again, I truly enjoyed your chapter. I like both Serena and the dragon. The characters are developing nicely as is the plot. Also, I will be coming back for more of your story.

Below are some questions and comments for you.

**************

You started several paragraphs in a row with the word “she.” Perhaps you could reword some of your sentences to avoid this repetition?

Example: “She turned another corner and paused to catch her breath.”
Suggestion: After turning another corner, she paused to catch her breath.

Here is a question: If the dragon created a huge hole in the wall when it crashed to come inside, then why does it need to crash through the door to go outside?

Some suggestions:

You wrote:

“She got ready slowly, catching up with Madison down in the kitchen. As usual, she was flirting with one of the other servants.”

Suggestion:

She got ready slowly, catching up with Madison down in the kitchen. As usual, Madison was flirting with one of the other servants.

I might be mistaken (please, ask your English teacher) but I believe that the way you wrote the sentence, the word “she” actually refers to Serena, (something about modifiers maybe? I am not sure exactly). Please, double check this. In any case, I thought “Serena” when I read it, and making the change does make things clearer.

http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/597/01/...


You wrote:
“She had completely forgotten about the dragon now.

She was now beginning to work with planting the seeds for Spring.”

Suggestion: I think that the sentences sound better with out the word “now.”

You wrote: “Her hand touched a broom and fell over.”

Did her hand fall over?

Suggestion: Her hand touched a broom and made it fall.


You wrote:

“I want her found, alive.”

Suggestion:

I think that what you wrote is fine, but I think that it might be better with a dash.

I want her found – alive.



You wrote:

“It was the voice as the same soldier from before.”

Suggestion:

She recognized the voice. It was the same soldier’s voice as before.

You wrote:

“One of the soldiers ran off to go get more help to take the dragon down.”

Suggestion:

“….ran off to get more…” Could you sentence be just as clear without the word “go”? or perhaps
“ … ran for more help…” or
“… ran for reinforcements..”


You wrote:

““Yes, im fine” Did you mean “I’m”?

You wrote:

“It was followed by an intense heat.”

I think that this is fine, but would it be better without the word “an”?


Please, please remember that I am not an English teacher, and please take my suggestions for what they are worth.

Keep writing, and I will keep reading!

Tadpole1
204
204
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hello Krystxn ,

I thought that this was very good. I absolutely enjoyed it, and I will read more.

I wonder, could Serena be the King's hidden daughter? In any case, I am sure that she will meet the young dragon again!

Suggestions: Look at this sentence again. You may want to modify it. It was not clear to me.

"She got dressed in her servant clothes and after a quick breakfast prepared down in the kitchen she ran into the hallway."

You said "soldier's" several times when I thought that you meant "soldiers'." Maybe I just misunderstood.

One last thing, I guess that she climbed "onto" the mattress and not "into" it!

Keep Writing so that I can keep reading!

Tadpole1
205
205
Review of Like Long Ago  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi Dave,

Although I am not a baseball fan, I enjoyed your story, or the first part of your story. It was well-written, and conveyed your emotion.

Keep Writing,

Tadpole1
206
206
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Krystxn,

I liked your prologue. You apologized that it was short, but I like short. Among the people who read my book, When Dragons Lived, some would have preferred that the chapters be longer, and others liked the fast pace. I like a mixture of both.

Your prologue makes me want to read more which is your objective, right?

You say "door" and "doors." I would choose one or the other.

I imagined Darth Vador or Obi-wan Kenobi (spelling?) as the cloaked figure. Don't worry about that.

I had no idea that the extinct animals would be dragons - you got me there!

I would change "if he was" to "if he were."

Keep Writing!

Tadpole1
207
207
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi Mackenzie,

I enjoyed your poem. I like poems that rhyme. What do I think of you now? I think that you are a good writer who should keep writing. What would I change in your poem? I like for lines in poems to have the same number of syllables. I don't really know what that is called. Also, I like the pronoun "I" to be capitalized.

Spelling:

"recieve" suggestion "receive" rule: "I" before "E" except after "C."

Keep Writing!

Tadpole1
208
208
Review of The New Neighbors  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Coffeebean,

I love it! This is so clever, and it is absolutely fun. Not to mention that you have covered quite a few bases here concerning human character. Absolutely (repeating myself here) wonderful.

Happy thoughts and keep writing!

Tadpole1
209
209
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Chère Fyn,

Il me semble, ma chère amie, que vous avez appris à peindre avec les mots comme Monet a su utiliser sa brosse. Sur le canevas de votre feuille, vous avez mis de la lumière, tapissée avec de la couleur. A travers votre tableau de goût et de soleil, vous nous emmenez pour une petite promenade pour découvrir où les artistes trouvaient leur inspiration, ensemble, ou en association. Merci pour le voyage, merci pour « Le Journey. »

Le petit tetard
P. S. Please remember that spelling and grammar are my Achilles Heel.
210
210
Review of The Key Part V  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)


Hi Dorianne,

How are you? I've been busy, but I am back to review for you.

The description of the boy getting free at the police station was very good. I find that I was drawn into the paragraph:

"The boy looked at the policeman who was about one inch shorter and twenty pounds lighter. He looked past that policeman and started to smile. The policeman turned his head to see what was so interesting. With that movement, the kid’s hands suddenly became free and he grabbed the policeman’s gun. His other free hand grabbed the policeman by the neck and squeezed very hard."


"She had the look of tears running down" suggestion "...she had tears running down"...or something like "her cheeks were tear-stained"

I don't like "the look of tears," plus you use the word "look" very soon after. Actually, you used it three times in the same sentence (oops). In fact, you might like to do a search on the word "look" because I believe that you use it a bit too often throughout this chapter.

"ten minutes before any ambulance to come." suggestion "...an ambulance could come - or - could arrive or would arrive"

"down an hopped" suggestion "down and hopped"


"Oh look. He feels so cold now." suggestion - I would change "Oh look" to "Look." or "Look!" This is a very dramatic moment, and "Oh look." seems too casual.

"...his back on the wall." suggestion "...his back against the wall."

It looks like Morgan is in trouble. I guess that I will have to tune in to the next chapter to learn if Morgan is rescued and whether or not her father survives!

Keep Writing!

Tadpole1
211
211
Review of Small World  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hi Coffeebean,

I suppose that this was a piece that you wrote in response to the prompt? Perhaps with a word limit?

General: I enjoyed the story. You were able to give a different voice to the two main characters. I was able to see where the story was going before the end. The description of the setting was short but effective.

Grammar: I am not good with rules, but perhaps the following would be a preferred wording:

"Woods Street wondering which way the bus would come from." suggestion - ...from which way the bus would come

"... a concept James had trouble with." suggestion - ... a concept with which James had trouble.

Keep writing!

Tadpole1
212
212
Review of Fyndorian's Desk  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Fyndorian,

Your free style poem shows how much writing and the place you write mean to you. It reminds me of a book I read in French. It was called "de Mozart a Disney" or perhaps "de Disney a Mozart." In any case, it described how the two genies created their masterpieces. For Mozart (like Stephan King) it was all there just waiting to come out; whereas, Disney, apparently, had special rooms for each phase of the creation of his films. One was the brainstorming room; then there was the dreaded criticizing room, and the development room, before the finishing room. I might not have the rooms exactly right, but the idea is there.

All this to say that like the great Disney, you have your special writing room.

Mine is much different. I sit in the family room in front of the fire, or the living room depending on the sunlight and the season, with my portable computer on my lap and click away. When the sun is bright and the day warm, I print what I have written and go outside to proof with sunglasses!

Thank you for sharing your special corner,

Tadpole1
213
213
Review of The Guest  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi Coffeebean,

I guess that you are one of those people who can’t find the door without your morning brew?

I always have a hard time to read poems that people write when they are feeling sad because I try to think “up.”

Your poem is short and to the point. Your words rhyme very well. It is probably because I absolutely do not want to feel what your poem says that I do not feel the emotion which you are sending. Sincerely, I am certain that others, who understand better, feel your pain.

Since I believe that a review can only help if it shows us how we can do better, I would say that although the last two lines rhyme quite well, they could be improved. I am just thinking here:

Come close now – my last breath, (or dear last breath)
I welcome you – Sweetest death.

I am just a new kid on the block, Coffeebean, so please take my suggestion for what it is worth.

You wrote “I have had a lifelong love affair with the written word and a raging war against my nemesis...grammar.” I understand you fully.

If you find the time, I invite you to take a peek at some of my writing. In my profile, you will find poems and short stories as well as the first few chapters of When Dragons Lived and the first chapter of The Traveling Stick
 Rev - 11/17 The Traveling Stick-Ch 1  (E)
Kay's learns about the Traveling Stick.
#1545331 by Tadpole1
.

I am entering a short story contest and would enjoy your feedback. In "Abaculus Anthology contest - Hidden you will find two very different short stories: PK and Custom-made Shoes. In PK, Carly and Liz encounter a most unusual character in the Bahamas. In Custom-made Shoes, Suzanne gets more than she bargained for when she goes shopping for custom-made shoes. "Abaculus Anthlgy cntst-Custom-made Shoes"Abaculus Anthology contst - PK

In any case, it was nice to meet you, Coffeebean,

Tadpole1
214
214
Review of HOLE  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Big T,

Why did I give you a 5.0? I do not know. I guess it is because you took me somewhere new, somewhere unexpected. I did not know what was coming next. Actually, I still do not know what is coming next. I wonder if this is a stand alone piece or part of something bigger? I suppose that I gave you a 5.0 because you made me think.

Good job,

Keep writing,
Tadpole1
215
215
Review of Seven years  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (4.5)
Dear Cathryn,

Ooo, feel the anger! Shout the emancipation. Tell him exactly what you think. I really liked this poem. Your words came through will great success in transmitting your feelings and your message. Is that not what poetry is all about?

I am sure that if you had proofed your poem one more time you would have caught the tiny type-o:

"over to much," - May I suggest "too much"?

Tadpole1
216
216
Review of Deadly Dreams  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hi Dorianne,

I enjoyed reading your short story, thank you.

General comments: Your story has a beginning, middle and end. The doctor seems very informal (offering food, manner of forming phrases). I could see the end coming from the very beginning of the story. I would like to have seen more in depth writing outside of the conversation. My guess is that you had a word limit, and that is why you were not able to expand on the story.

Grammar / spelling - lost interest. “she stopped - the quote is out of place
- At least twice, you wrote "Ludy" instead of "Lucy."

I am looking forward to reading more of your work,

Tadpole1
217
217
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: E | (5.0)
Dear Horse,

general: You brought tears to my eyes. While reading your post, I thought of Obama. I hope that the new administration will indeed recognize the sacrifices that our veterans have given. I have teenage children and fear every day.

grammar: It was difficult to get past the message, so I did not notice any grammar or spelling mistakes.

Thank you for this important reminder,

Tadpole1
218
218
Review of Him  
Review by Tadpole1
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi,

I read your piece quickly, and my gut reaction was that I felt your pain. I liked your poem(?). Your last sentence was very good. You were able to share your pain with your reader. I have teenage boys, so I can understand the mental. First love is never forgotten. A few times, I was wondering about word choice:

Paragraph II, line two, word “though”
Paragraph III, lines four and five, “but to think that nature could cause it was impossible” Could this be smoother?
Last paragraph, last two lines “he would have truly never lived”

I hope that this is useful.

Good job, keep writing!
Tadpole1
218 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 9 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/tadpole1/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9