*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/vamp_cat/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11
Review Requests: OFF
2,441 Public Reviews Given
4,528 Total Reviews Given
I'm good at...
You'll get a mixture of proofreading and editing advice. I generally do a line by line.
Favorite Genres
Horror, fantasy, Sci-fi.
Least Favorite Genres
Do not care for works that straight dramas.
Favorite Item Types
Micro fiction, flash fiction, short stories, and chapters.
Least Favorite Item Types
I know little of poetry and I do not care for straight dramas.
I will not review...
I review most things.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 7 8 9 10 -11- 12 13 14 15 16 ... Next
251
251
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hello,

Welcome to Writing.com.

I like the title.

You may want to look at the tag. Where I understand it was written for a contest, it does little make me want to look inside.

I like stories more when the person you are reading about has a name. Any name helps get a sense of a person. Then you would have nearly as many pronouns littering the story. This I feel would only increase the flow of the overall story.

Excellent formatting, grammar and spelling.

I found your description to be very effective.

Also, you should look at listing this story as something other than "other".

The main reason I am giving your story a 3.5 is because although I liked the writing; I did not find anything to be unique nor did it have that special quality allowing the story to stay with me, long after I read it.


I wish you well on your writing journey.

Alice


252
252
Review of The Hole  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello,

I saw you entered this into another contest. Good for you.

Well, one thing is for sure! You have found your style and voice.

I am going to send you a version of your story reformatted. Like last time. You can just copy it as is. Now, I am going to give some suggestions.

Firstly, I have noticed that you tend to focus on objets rather than people. I think it would involve the reader more effectively if you were to shift more of your focus on the main character. Look at Poe or Lovecraft, (after reading two of your story's, I find it hard to believe that you have not read their work.) They focus on feelings; both the physical and the emotional, allowing for the reader to be present in the tale.

I would also include some sensory details. This too would make the story more tangible. A great deal of folks have not tasted brandy.

There is too much of a jump between the opening paragraph and the second. It needs only a line or two, to make the transition smooth. Is he at Cara's house? Is it another place altogether?

The next issue I see, is one that many writers do. They state a place or time and do not go beyond this to show it. To me, one of the many pleasures of reading and writing is the opportunity to travel. I get no real sense of Louisiana in the story. You do this so little.

I do find that the sense of time comes across nicely though. This I do admire.

After hours of searching the labyrinthine bowels of New Orleans Cara spotted a small shop.

Orleans, Cara

There was a hand written sign in the window that simply said “Toys and Games” in an elegant script.

said,


“Do you have anything more intricate?” The hawker’s brow furrowed as he thought.

“More…intricate? Let me see.” Replacing the farm puzzle beneath the counter the salesman began to rummage a bit more furiously until he returned with a heavy black cylinder about a foot tall and a few inches across.


Please consider...

“Do you have anything more intricate?”

The hawker’s brow furrowed as he thought. “More…intricate? Let me see.” Replacing the farm puzzle beneath the counter the salesman began to rummage a bit more furiously until he returned with a heavy black cylinder about a foot tall and a few inches across.

“What makes it so challenging?” The clerk chuckled and replied, “See for yourself.” Cara twisted the end of the container and pulled it off. She gingerly poured some of the pieces onto the countertop. After a cursory examination she pronounced, “This can’t be right.” The proprietor simply smiled.


“What makes it so challenging?”

The clerk chuckled and replied, “See for yourself.”

Cara twisted the end of the container and pulled it off. She gingerly poured some of the pieces onto the countertop. After a cursory examination she pronounced, “This can’t be right.”

The proprietor simply smiled.

He horse was barely unhitched when Cara had vaulted from the carriage and locked herself in the study.

The horse


I think it would help increase the flow of the story if you were to rework some of the sentences that start with the characters.

Night after night Cara would be picking through the tiny black bits of wood, sometimes going a whole evening without adding a single piece.

Night after night,


I have NO IDEA why he knows Cara. How does he come to know the story?


“It will not be long now.” She thought to herself.

now," she

The pall of the winter season took its toll on her vigor and her pace in the evenings had slowed considerably. Even in the deep south of America, the countryside was not spared from a thorough lashing of the wind. Cara watched as the gale outside her window galloped through the branches of the trees. She ceased her work on the puzzle to better observe the tumult. Her breath caught in her throat as she could swear she heard a deep, sepulchral voice in the wind uttering a single word.

“Work.” The chamber became ice cold, even though a fire roared in the hearth. Cara huddled a down quilt around her but nothing could stave off the frigid cold that had foisted itself upon her. And once again the howling wind seemed to spur her on to resume her efforts.



The pall of the winter season took its toll on her vigor and her pace in the evenings had slowed considerably. Even in the deep south of America, the countryside was not spared from a thorough lashing of the wind. Cara watched as the gale outside her window galloped through the branches of the trees. She ceased her work on the puzzle to better observe the tumult. Her breath caught in her throat as she could swear she heard a deep, sepulchral voice in the wind uttering a single word. “Work."

The chamber became ice cold, even though a fire roared in the hearth. Cara huddled a down quilt around her but nothing could stave off the frigid cold that had foisted itself upon her. And once again the howling wind seemed to spur her on to resume her efforts.








I think once in the shop, the story really comes to life.






To my dear reader,

I have recently had opportunity to engage in an evening of fun and games that was held in celebration of a dear friend’s birthday. There was chess, card games, and even billiards, which offered me yet another chance to display a complete and utter lack of any tangible skill in these particular fields of competition. After brandy was served, I observed several people gathered around an antique ebony table in the corner of the game room. As I approached, I saw that these intrepid individuals were attempting to construct a jigsaw puzzle of decent size and intricate design. I was offered a seat but politely declined. More than likely the others at the table thought me to be a bit antisocial or misanthropic, but the truth of the matter was much more disturbing. The sight of the puzzle brought memories of my friend Cara back to the surface of my mind, and at the time I had no desire to relive them.

Cara lived in Louisiana in a white columned mansion christened Mount Willow due to the multitude of large
trees of the same name surrounding the house. Mount Willow had been in her family since before American independence, and provided Cara’s ancestors a quiet seclusion not to be found in any European city. The house passed to Cara when both her parents died of Scarlet Fever. She was in her late-teens, with only a skeletal staff of two servants: a cook, Hannah, and a groom, Charles. Eventually the home began a slow descent into disrepair. The stairs creaked more than they used to. Doors hung slightly more crooked on their hinges. Many rooms had acquired new design accents courtesy of the local spider population. Also, due to the swampy areas around the house, the air inside Mount Willow always seemed to have a stale, musty odor to it.

The only respite from Cara’s essentially solitary existence at Mount Willow was the visits from her tutors. In their will, Cara’s parents saw to it that she would not lack for a continuous education. She could speak English, French, and was learning Italian. She was very adept at music, and could play several instruments, but it was also her father’s wish that she be trained in science and mathematics as well. Cara had always taken to her studies with more than due diligence, but the thing she loved more than anything else was solving and constructing puzzles. As any visitor to Mount Willow could attest, this beauty’s domicile was decorated with the finished products of her endeavors. Framed portraits of every kind populated her rooms and only upon closer inspection would the fragmented nature of the picture be revealed.

As time went on and Cara’s skill increased, she found the puzzles that were available to her in general shops to be less and less challenging. In order to find an object worthy of her abilities she would be forced to travel to the nearest city, New Orleans. They said that anything you could want would be found there. Surely there would be a shop that carried what she was looking for. That morning she found Charles and bade him to prepare the carriage for the trip. It was only a drive of a little more than a couple of hours, so no overnight bag would be required. A few minutes more and she was on the road. The carriage was not ornate by any standard, but was completely enclosed with curtained glass windows to protect passengers not only from the elements, but from prying eyes should the need arise. The majority of the ride was bouncy and uneven until the dirt roads gave way to the cobblestone streets of New Orleans proper.

It was cloudy and overcast, a thoroughly gray day. The horses slowly clopped their way through the winding narrow streets. Cara eagerly peered at the shop windows searching for anything that looked promising. And while she was clearly in the merchant district of the city, there seemed to be no shops that would suit her needs. After hours of searching the labyrinthine bowels of New Orleans Cara spotted a small shop. There was a hand written sign in the window that simply said “Toys and Games” in an elegant script. Cara bade Charles to stop the coach so she might investigate the establishment further. The groom tied the horses to an iron hitching post near the curb and Cara made her way in.

Once inside the shop, Cara instantly noticed the aroma of soft incense that wafted gently through the air. It had a delicate hint of vanilla that made it most appealing. Oil lanterns whose illumination radiated from behind glass panes of a pure crimson hue, giving the entire establishment an ominous blood colored tinge, lighted the store. The wooden floor was highly polished and creaked under her footsteps. The walls of the shop were completely covered with shelves populated with all manner of weird and esoteric artifacts. The wares of the store seemed to be arranged in no particular order, and seemed to have little if anything to do with toys and games as the sign said. Cara observed a skull of undetermined species placed next to what looked like an unborn child in a jar full of liquid, which itself resided next to a small sculpture of somewhat dubious design that made color rush to the girl’s cheeks.

“Hello there, Mademoiselle.” The gravelly voice with a Gallic accent from the back of the store frightened Cara, as she did not see the person who addressed her. Slowly she approached the back of the store, taking care not to bump into the dusty shelves that flanked her, lest she break some rare item she could not pay for. Standing behind the counter was a portly gentleman dressed in a very dapper manner. His store may be unobtrusive but clearly this man was doing very well. When he stood to greet her, he towered over Cara. She could see that his black coat was made of very fine silk. Coupled with the red cravat, diamond pinky ring and matching tie tack, the man was the picture of sinister elegance. He had black hair that was thinning and slicked straight back off his forehead in the European style, and a goatee that had just begun to gray. His eyes, she thought must have been a light amber color, because in the ruddy lantern light they took on a somewhat disquieting maroon hue that reminded Cara of the color of dried blood.

“How may I help you this evening?” His voice snapped her back to business.

“I see that your sign said toys and games. I was wondering if you had any puzzles for sale.” The proprietor’s eyes widened a bit with his reply.

“Puzzles? Ah yes of course Mademoiselle. I have something just right for you.” From beneath the cherry wood counter the salesman produced a small box.

“This puzzle has 500 different pieces and when completed creates a delightful picture of barnyard animals at play.” Cara’s interest was immediately stifled when she heard the clerk mention 500 pieces. Such a thing was child’s play to her.

“Do you have anything more intricate?” The hawker’s brow furrowed as he thought.

“More…intricate? Let me see.” Replacing the farm puzzle beneath the counter the salesman began to rummage a bit more furiously until he returned with a heavy black cylinder about a foot tall and a few inches across.

“I have this for you. This puzzle has over 2000 pieces and is said to be the most difficult one ever conceived. He handed the cylinder to Cara who accepted it with a most skeptical expression on her face. Clearly this man was just out to make a sale.

“What makes it so challenging?” The clerk chuckled and replied, “See for yourself.”

Cara twisted the end of the container and pulled it off. She gingerly poured some of the pieces onto the countertop. After a cursory examination she pronounced, “This can’t be right.” The proprietor simply smiled.

“It certainly is Mademoiselle.” Cara poured half the contents of the container on the counter to make absolutely sure. All of the pieces of the puzzle were solid black. Anticipating the question, the salesman answered, “Yes, the whole puzzle is one mass of color. Truly only a most dedicated person would attempt to solve such a monstrosity. It is called ‘The Hole’. It is said that a clock maker named Elsevier created it sometime in the 15th century. An Italian noble named Baron Brumante commissioned the puzzle. When time came for payment there was haggling over the price. Being one to not suffer anyone with an abundance of patience, the Baron had the clock maker clapped in irons and tossed into an oubliette, but not before Elsevier cursed the Baron. As it turns out, over time, the Baron became obsessed with solving the puzzle he had stolen from the clock maker. All other matters seemed to lose their importance. His household fell into disrepair, and his finances went neglected. He ate and slept less and less, and it is said that in the end the puzzle consumed him.” He let his last words hang in the air a bit with the silence only broken by the sound of the two gold coins that Cara dropped on the counter. She scooped the exposed puzzle fragments back into their container and sealed it. The salesman placed the cylinder into a small bag and dropped the gold into his pocket with a smile.

“Enjoy the puzzle and do come again.” The clerk’s words barely registered as Cara was well on her way out the door. The ride home passed in a blur. She simply could not wait to delve into the puzzle, which less ardent individuals would consider a nightmare. He horse was barely unhitched when Cara had vaulted from the carriage and locked herself in the study. She carried the onyx hued container over to the hand carved mahogany table near the bay window. She enjoyed looking at the trees outside while constructing puzzles. The high backed leather chair seemed to envelope her delightful form as she sank into its soft comfortable cushions.

She carefully unscrewed the top of the cylinder and poured the entire contents onto the smooth, polished tabletop. In the sunlight, the black pieces seemed to have a strange opalescence about them, much how a dark bird’s plumage will shimmer purple or green in bright daylight. Cara spread the tiny multi-faceted pieces out on the table until there was a single, fragmented layer of iridescent black covering the mahogany. Conventional strategy was to seek out the flat edges first in order to construct the framework in which you would be working. Cara knew this to be a sound plan but was becoming increasingly frustrated at the complete absence of any flat edged pieces. She did however observe how a certain number of the pieces had curved edges and her first error dawned on her. Of course! She naturally assumed the puzzle to be the standard rectangular shape that all her other works had in common. This puzzle, “The Hole” was obviously destined to be round. With deliberate and meticulous effort, Cara began to separate the fragments that had slightly curved edges from the rest of their fellows.

As the hours passed the outer ring of the puzzle began to take shape. It was plain to see that once completed “The Hole” would cover the majority of the tabletop. Piece after piece was pressed into place until the chime sounded to signal that dinner was served. Cara unseated herself leaving the outer ring incomplete by only two pieces, but decided to finish at least this part and arranged the remaining pair into the ebony circle as the dinner chime sounded a second time. After dessert Cara once more found herself seated before the onyx hued enigma. Only now there seemed to be something slightly amiss. She could have sworn that the pieces were all solid black in color, but now there seemed to be a tiny thread-width silver line traversing the entire circumference of the puzzle. Given the fact that it was barely noticeable Cara rationalized that it was only natural that she had not observed it until now. She also knew that it would be very slow going the rest of the way. There would be no flattened edges to aid her in the placing of the pieces. Still, she was determined that she would eventually complete the daunting task that lay before her.

Night after night Cara would be picking through the tiny black bits of wood, sometimes going a whole evening without adding a single piece. As time wore on however some parts of the puzzle began to take shape and a few black tendrils began to snake their way towards the center. While she was hunched over the table, the brunette beauty’s attention was focused entirely on the fitting of one piece into another. Her eyes grew suddenly very heavy. Before long she was fully snoozing at the table. While Cara slumbered, a pair of eyes slowly opened in the completed portions of the puzzle. A pair of hateful, covetous eyes, searching eyes that lingered over many parts of the room but especially on Cara herself. All through the night while she slept, the eyes surveyed her as if trying to take in every possible detail of her being. Then, a wispy, vaporous material began to waft out of “The Hole”. The pale, smoky mist gradually began to coalesce into the shape of a rotted, skeletal hand. The spectral appendage began to softly caress Cara’s shoulders; slowly trailing is fingers down towards her bosom. For hours the gaunt limb ran itself all over Cara’s body. It was not until the first rays of dawn sliced their way through the window that the incorporeal hand quickly dissipated and the surface of the puzzle returned to normal.

Summer turned to autumn, autumn turned to winter, and along with the irrevocable change in the seasons, Cara’s work on the puzzle progressed. The solid black areas increased in width and even began to connect in some spots. Cara’s face lit up with a self-satisfied smile as she surveyed the progress she had made.

“It will not be long now.” She thought to herself. The pall of the winter season took its toll on her vigor and her pace in the evenings had slowed considerably. Even in the deep south of America, the countryside was not spared from a thorough lashing of the wind. Cara watched as the gale outside her window galloped through the branches of the trees. She ceased her work on the puzzle to better observe the tumult. Her breath caught in her throat as she could swear she heard a deep, sepulchral voice in the wind uttering a single word.

“Work.” The chamber became ice cold, even though a fire roared in the hearth. Cara huddled a down quilt around her but nothing could stave off the frigid cold that had foisted itself upon her. And once again the howling wind seemed to spur her on to resume her efforts.

“Work.” The word seemed to fairly float on the wind, lingering just on the edges of the noise outside. After another moment the word caressed her ears as if it was whispered right next to her. Then she could not pinpoint its location at all as it seemed to emanate from all around her. Cara’s heart fluttered as her gaze returned to the table. With a trembling hand she reached out to the remaining loose pieces and began to sort through them. Almost immediately the room began to warm. Before long, the girl began to feel like herself again. The feel of the puzzle pieces was comforting to her. As she continued to press the pieces into place, her pace of work began to increase. Cara’s vision slowly blurred as her hands seemed to move of their own accord. Physically her eyes were locked on the growing field of ebony on the table, but her mind was most definitely elsewhere. So much so that she did not notice the pair of cold, dead eyes that once again greedily stared at her from the tabletop.
Piece after piece fell into place, some even seemed to join together without any assistance from Cara. After an hour of this furious pace, Cara slumped in her chair. The mysterious force moving her hands faded, and the puzzle sat on the table completely inert. The great black spot, now finished, stared at her like a giant shark’s eye. The air in the study hung perfectly still. The flames on Cara’s candelabra flickered in the silent room. The exhausted girl stood up to examine her handy work and a wave of proud accomplishment along with profound relief washed over her.

Slowly, the way someone would caress a sleeping lover, Cara moved her fingers over the smooth unbroken surface of the puzzle.

“How could it be smooth?” An icy spectral hand reached out of the boundless space within the puzzle and stroked Cara’s fingers. She screamed. A desiccated hand clamped itself on her shoulder from behind. She was spun around and confronted by the horrific visage of a rotted corpse, wearing a malicious, cadaverous smile. A second more and she was lifted off her feet and shoved into the black, circular abyss on the tabletop. There was a sickening crunching sound followed by a viscous red fluid that began to slowly seep out from the circumference of the puzzle. The murderous phantom looked into “The Hole” and breathed a lingering sigh of relief.

For the first time in centuries, Baron Brumante felt the warmth of the fire wash over him. In time, his form grew more opaque. The gray of his rotted flesh began to fill out and look ever more human. A muffled scream emanated from within the surface of the puzzle. The Baron smiled as he watched the slowly decaying form of Cara futilely reaching toward him. As the newly restored noble observed with some pleasure the panicked girl’s struggles, he carefully dislodged a piece from the edge of the puzzle. Cara’s screams sounded as if she were trapped underwater. The darkness of her surroundings began to press in upon her. Bit by bit she helplessly watched as the small spot of light that led back to the world grew more distant. It became smaller and smaller until the blackness completely enveloped her.

253
253
Review of The Gift  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
It's good to have you back!

I reposted the link in the forum so it would work.

I think title is a little blah. It does not stand out in any way, nor does it pull me in.

The opening paragraph is good.

I think you need a small transitional sentence between the opening paragraph and the second.

“LIES!” she screamed. “YOU’RE FULL OF s*** AND LIES! YOU CAN’T DO THIS TOO ME!”

TO ME!"



I told you had not heard the last of me”


me."


Okay... Overall I thought that was written here was well written. But I thought did not quite enough tension for me. Don't worry about unless you hear more of the same or if it rings true to you. Horror, like sex is personal. What works for one may not do anything for the next.


Alice



254
254
Review of Foggy Reality  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hello Nevada Star,

Welcome to WDC. I hope you get as much as i have from the site.

Opening paragraph are so important. Often people decided wether they are going to read the whole story or not. Let's take a look at yours.

It was a chilly October night as I drove down the long, foggy road, not knowing where it would lead. Not knowing how I ended up on the road. The only thing that I can think of was that I must have taken a wrong turn off of the main highway. My headlights, trying to shine through the thick fog, I spotted this old cemetery on the right side of the road.

There are a handful of opening in horror that are well-used; I am afraid you have just struck upon one. That combined with placing the tale in October makes the story feel like there is no need to any more.

Perhaps change time of year to fall or suggest the time of year by using descriptions.

I would cut the opening paragraph all together. But if you do, you will also have to rework the second paragraph as well.

Where are the parents?” proceeding to slow down; with the concern that this child might be lost. When my car came to a complete stop, I opened the door and got out.

I think this should be broken up into two different sentences.

“Are you ok?” she asked.

It should be:

OK

or

okay


I came from around the corner, and the old woman looked at me, and asked “Are you hungry dear?”

asked,

I replied to her with a soft, squeaky voice. “No.”

voice,

“Ok suit yourself” she replied.

"OK

yourself,"


"Where am I?" "How did I get here?" I am so confused, the last thing I remember I looking for a police station or even a phone.

"Where am I? How did I get here?" I am so confused, the last thing I remember I looking for a police station or even a phone.

"Well dear, you passed out in your car, and my husband brought you back here." "He called the local tow truck driver to help with your car."


"Well dear, you passed out in your car, and my husband brought you back here. He called the local tow truck driver to help with your car."


“Not just the man” she replied, “the whole family.”

man,"


“No.” I said. “I came across some headstones that belonged to some young adults. It looked like they were in a tragic accident together.”

"No,"


She responded, “Yes they were.” Being intrigued I wanted to know more about the story. She told me it was none of my business because I was not a local. “I am sorry for being interested.” I told the old woman, “thank you for letting me sleep here, and taking care of me. I think that I will be on my way.” As I was walking out the door, the woman said to me, “Please get off this road before night fall.”

She responded, “Yes they were.” Being intrigued I wanted to know more about the story. She told me it was none of my business because I was not a local. “I am sorry for being interested.” I told the old woman, “thank you for letting me sleep here, and taking care of me. I think that I will be on my way.”

As I was walking out the door, the woman said to me, “Please get off this road before night fall.”

I ran to my car, and started it up; put it in drive and got out of this hillbilly hell.

Great line!

“Could this really be?” I thought. “Is she really deceased? Could that have been a ghost I was talking to last night?”

'Could this really be?' I thought. “Is she really deceased? Could that have been a ghost I was talking to last night?”

I thought to myself, “how crazy.”

'How crazy.'

“How can I help you darling?

darling?"

“Well darling there is no road around here with a cemetery. Now I was puzzled.


“Well darling there is no road around here with a cemetery."

Now I was puzzled.


Overall I think you have fine story but it still needs some work. Writing is hard. Writing horror is really hard. Doing both is harder still. Keep at it. You'll get there.


Alice






255
255
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hello,

Thank you for entering The Struck by Lightening flash fiction contest. Sorry about it taking so looooong but when you are without a laptop and you have to save to buy a new one, it takes awhile.

Great title!

You followed all the rules.

The formatting looks good.

The sour smell of sweat fills my nostrils.Frigid air freezes the moisture on my skin.

You should have a line of space between these two sentences.

Pulling my blanket around me I try to shut out the remnants of my nightmare.

I think this should be the start of a new paragraph.

I know it is there, deep down in the inky blackness, but its exact form eludes me.

I think it should be...

there; deep

Mouth slowly parting to reveal a large serpent-like tongue as it's fetid breath seeps between puss stained lips.

its

breathe


Behind me lie darkness and desolation, in front of me mountainous sand dunes.

lay


Some of these notes may be do to the fact that I am in the USA and you are not.

I always have a problem with when it is first person and the person dies at the end. I cannot help but wonder, if the person died a horrible death, then where did the tale come from.

As always,

ALice




256
256
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hello,

I thought this would be more separate stories but still connected. That is not what we have here. It's really one story that takes place over several days.

III. Wednesday: 8:10 a.m.

A.M.


I think overall this works. I thought it was easy to follow and found no glaring faults.

I would have liked more of a setting and more description but I am not sure if that is a question of style or not. I do feel that if you were to incorporate these things, your story would be stronger for it.

Alice




257
257
Review of The Photograph  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello,

I would like to see you separate the paragraphs.

The opening paragraph is good. I would like you to consider one thing...

There weren't any fish in the lake either.

To me, this line seems tacked on.

I kind of scared him when I yelled, "Don't you dare replace that frame."

Since he is yelling, it should end with an explanation point.

Year after year we would spend a week with the whole family listening to the creaks and moans of the wharf while we caught up of current events.

Year after year,

A very nice conclusions.

For me it is not a huge wow, but nonetheless, it is still very nice.

Mari

258
258
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
I know this has gotten a ton of great reviews, so I had high hopes. I love scary tales and New Orleans.

Certainly the grammar, spelling and formatting are great.

The story was easy to follow.

The dailog was very good.

I in no way thought it took place in New Orleans and there ticked me off. It is real shame. I think this could been a truely great tale if the hotel had been almost a third charactor. Grant it, one them went on a ghost/vamp tour, which is very New Orleans, but even that if you took out one word (vamp) it could happen in a number of other places.

Plus a lot of folks might guess what a gallerie was but, there was no ferns, rod iron ivy...

I felt the ending was very rushed.

All-and-all not bad, but it could been even bettter.


Alice

259
259
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
The opening paragraph is good. It gives a sense of plot, character and setting.

Joseph could still recall why he had gone into that tiny, dank office and reluctantly had to admit that ego had played a large part.

I think you could tighten this up a little. Please consider...

Joseph could still recall why he had gone into that tiny, dank office and reluctantly had to admit ego played a large part.



Even during the founding of the Guard's 510th on his home planet years before, the best that he could have hoped for was an early release from boot camp.

Here too, please consider...

Even during the founding of the Guard's 510th on his home planet years before, the best he could hope for was an early release from boot camp.


I know it may seem like small things, but it will make the story even story, by increasing the overall flow of the story. Words to look out for are: that, have, had, was.

I know it is long and rather boring, but it truly can make a difference.

Of course you will and should not be able to remove all of them, that would silly. But please consider it.


I wish you well on your writing journey.

Alice


260
260
Review of Basket Delight  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
If you want to enter the contest and you run out of room, we can work something out.

Remember everyone retools their story. Keep in mind King starting writing when he was your age and did not sell a thing for years. He also did not have a kick ass writing site to help him along.

Okay... Here is what I really think...

Flashes are hard. The most important part of any story is the ending. Like a lot of writer's you work your way to the end and you ran out of room.

You can start your story anywhere. You can add what you like.

Some of the grammar is screwy, but if you tell a good story, that is an easy fix. Heck some will even over look it.

Look at the last two paragraphs... These are where you should spent your words.

Take my advice and write another version with a strong focus on the ending and see if you do not get better reviews. I bet you do.

Alice


261
261
Review of The Fish Wife  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello,

Although the title is simple, it nonetheless does it job of adding to the story.

The opening paragraph gives the setting and a sense of the of the main character.

The story has a good flow to it and a nice bit of description, never overbearing.

Overall, I found this tale to well-written, but high on horror.

Alice

262
262
Review of 11 - 19  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)


Congratulations!P/b}

Your story was selected as the best in the Struck by Lightening contest in the round of 3/1/08, prompt: Lizzy Borden.

Here is your gift of *Gift1*5,000 gift points*Gift1*.


Thank you for your wonderful tale.


Alice
263
263
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hello,

And thank you for taking part in this round of the Struck by Lightening.

You followed all of the rules.

FYI: I will read everything again AFTER the close of the contest. That is the read that counts the most.

+++

Title is good.

Formatting looks good.

The opening paragraph does a nice job of hinting at the tale yet to come.

Small Note:

Her feet and hands had been severed from their limbs which, along with the head, had been separated from her torso.

limbs, which along


Overall, you did a fine job.


I hope to see you in other rounds.


Alice
264
264
Review of Lizzie  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello,

Thank you for taking part in the round of the Struck by Lightening.

You followed all of the rules.

+++

The title is fine.

Formatting looks good.

Little Elizabeth sat at her changing desk, tears streaming down her cheeks.

What is a "changing desk"?

Actually they did not die at night, nor in their bed. Abigail went first on the bedroom floor and then Lizzy's father while he napped on the couch.


“I’m sorry, daddy,” she whispered as she brought the axe down with deadly precision.

"daddy," should be "Daddy,"



Great idea about the reflection and her hearing the poem, and one that was well-written.


Alice



265
265
Review of 11 - 19  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hello,

Thank you for taking part in this round of the Struck by Lightening.

You followed all of the rules.

+++

I am not sure what to make of the title.

Like my blessed Mother said, “If you ain’t got family, you ain’t got nothin’.”

mother


Actually, the stepmother went first, but this is fiction, not a history lesson.


Good read!

Alice





266
266
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
I tried 4 different ways to look for your mySpace page. I did not find it.

+++

I like the title.

For here, you should consider placing a line of space between each paragraph, this will make it easier to read.


I heard that same grotesque sound his skull made as it fractured, into God-only-knew how many pieces.

Here, when you say, "that same grotesque sound..." it seems off, because that sound has not occurred, but I understand that this may be in the middle of the novel.


Instinctively, I held my hand up in front of my face in disbelief, only it was Martin’s hand I held up.

disbelief;


Sorry, this is not my cup of tea. I tend to dislike first person POV. You have love them so quickly, or route for them and to this rather a generic action. Plus it was all a dream: Yawn.

Now I am ONE person, and other may love this, so take heart.

You may be better severed to also list this as action as well as horror. To me, it was very light on horror and much more action.

Overall your writing is easy to follow both in your prose and grammar.

Alice
267
267
Review of Wrong Turn  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello,

Title: Wrong turn should be... Wrong Turn



Somewhere between the explosion and his arrival to wherever it is he appeared, definitely ended in a wrong turn.

Incorrect tense... "is" should be "was".

Scott Clayton had been on patrol, same as the day before but this day was the conclusion to his life.

patrol;



Out of nowhere a young Iraqi quickly rounded the corner and before anyone could get him in their crosshairs he yelled “Allah Akbar” and detonated his vest.

corner,

crosshairs,

yelled,

Akbar,"


You apparently are not Yusef Hasem are you sir? Scott, with a look of drawn out frustration asked “where am I?” “You are in Jannah, did you not know this?” Scott’s look drew even more confusion. “Where in the hell is Jannah?” This of course was a sort of oxy-moron as they cannot be the same. The man behind the counter came to the conclusion something went wrong down in divinity distribution. “Sir, before I answer your questions I need to know your name.” “Scott, Scott Clayton.” “Thank you sir, give me one moment and I will be back to answer your questions.” The man made a 360 and spoke one more thing. “Jannah is heaven, at least for Muslims.” Quickly he disappeared to the back.



You apparently are not Yusef Hasem are you sir?

Scott, with a look of drawn out frustration asked, “Where am I?”

“You are in Jannah, did you not know this?”

Scott’s look drew even more confusion. “Where in the hell is Jannah?” This of course was a sort of oxy-moron as they cannot be the same.

The man behind the counter came to the conclusion something went wrong down in divinity distribution. “Sir, before I answer your questions I need to know your name.”

“Scott, Scott Clayton.”

“Thank you sir, give me one moment and I will be back to answer your questions.” The man made a 360 and spoke one moretime, “Jannah is heaven, at least for Muslims.” Quickly, he disappeared to the back.


What is divinity distribution and if his family was going to be alright.

all right.

Slowly they take their seats at a table which of course was topped with a bowl of fruit from the surrounding garden.

table,


I can and will give you more notes, but I have no idea if you want them for sure or not. If you would like further notes, please tell.

What you have is bad but there are many little things that need attention for me to rate this any higher at this time.


Alice





268
268
Review of Pikemen's Bridge  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hey LOVECRAFT!

I've been meaning to read this. I start half a dozen times. I like to read things in go. No stopping or starting.

Formatting looks great.

If there is a twist of werewolves you change the opening line.

Good description in the opening paragraph.

Dialog is good.


Mikes stomach wriggled around like an jittery worm.

like a jittery


Pieces of flesh burnt from the smoldering bullet crisped around the jagged edges of the strangers neck.

stranger's




Sherriff Bentson arrived a half hour later with Deputy Tails.


half-hour



I recognize the name Bentson too.


The smell of gun powder had cleared out of the room through the front door.

gunpowder



I wonder, is Pikemens a play off of Pickman?



If you are in the USA Sheriff and not Sherriff.

The icy current bit through Mikes bones, like an icicle being dragged along his skeleton.

Mike's


The Sherriff held out a hand and touched it to Mikes chest.


Mike's

The earth trembled beneath the pillar, sending shivers through Mikes body.

Mike's


The beasts head was shaped like a ball of chewing gum, round in some places, indented in others.

beast's

It’s tip met his skin.

Its


With his mouth open and inviting the thing inside, the tube shot forward, springing down Mikes throat and into his stomach.

Mike's


Mikes body twitched on the ground.

Mike's



This was fun.


Alice














269
269
Review of Evermore  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
I see you did it, you expand the story.


It looks really good. I found no errors in the way of spelling, formatting or grammar.


You did a good at expanding this. I still would liked a bit more of what things looked, felt, smelled like once he was inside, but I love that stuff.


As always,

Alice

270
270
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello again,

On to chapter two and three.


Formatting is clean.

The transition from the first chapter to the second works fine.

My confidence grew as their positivity outpoured.

"positivity" with really does not work.


As I passed the last building I noticed they were no longer keeping pace.

building,


Some had them strapped to their back, others had them between their legs and a few just held them like a walking staff.

backs;


He looked at me a moment and then said non-chalantly, “Blue.”

Chalantly is not a word on its own so it should not be hyphenated.


I laughed again out loud, glad to at least find something new even if it did look like it was built by Dr. Seuss.

I laughed again out loud, glad to at least find something new even if it did look like Dr. Seuss built it.

“Three? No, No, No.


“Three? No, no, no.



The one thing I was disappointed in was the description. To me, there are not all that vivid.


ALICE


271
271
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello,

The title is interesting.

I really liked the tag on this. It is why I am reading this.

Formatting looks good.

The opening pargraph is fine but not a huge "Wow" for me. Many tales start in a hurricane.

They were all crowding around the far end of the house whispering frightenly and covering their mouths and eyes with their hands.

I do not think "frightenly" works.

“What do we have here?” her voice strung out like an untuned bow.

YOU CANNOT TUNE A BOW.

“My sister has been killed. He killed her. This territory is now mine. He is now mine!” the Black Witch hissed.

Consider...


“My sister has been killed. He killed her. This territory is now mine. He is mine!” the Black Witch hissed.


“I was ready to,” I said, suddenly aware of the insanity of my thinking.

too,"



In someways, this feels like an update of "The Wizard of Oz".

I just read a little more, and I know now that it is. COOL!



Alice
272
272
Review of Take Out  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
*Balloon3* Congratulations! *Balloon3*


Your tale was selected as the best in this round of the Struck by Lightening in the round of February 23 2007.

Here is your prize of 5000 gift points.

As always,

Alice
273
273
Review of Wishing Well  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I read through winners of the Twilight Zone contest. I am not impressed with any of them. The best is well written and has a good TZ feel to it but the idea and the way in which it is written is not a knock out.

I don't understand him not loving this. Go Figure.

Alice
274
274
Review of The Matchmaker  
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello,

I saw this in a couple of contests this had placed in so I thought I would give this a read.


I found no errors in regards to spelling or formatting.

I do have on small note:

“Bewitched, bothered and bewildered? She replied, teasingly.

bewildered?" she

I thought that over all this was well written and easy to follow.

Alice
275
275
Review by AliceNgoreland
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hello,

The spacing off a tiny amount.

This reads fairly well. There are placing where is you were to combine sentences, it would have a better flow.

Here is my problem with it. If you are not a Doctor Who fan, you would not have a clue as to what anything was or what anything looked like.

A great work of fan fiction has many things. First and foremost, keep the flavor if not the voice of what has already been established, which I feel you have.

Now what makes it worth reading beyond this and a good plot is... it is a chance to explore thoughts or things that are left out of the show.

Now it may be that you and I see the Doctor in two different ways. It feels as if you see the show as a jolly good romp, which it is. But I feel what makes it last is not this, it is because of the things it touches upon and allows us to think and feel. Damn good writing, which is much more than good dialog and action packed plot.

In the end you are merely telling us a story and not showing us a story.

All of that being said, I must say that the current incarnation of the Doctor has such heart, is so clever, and intelligence: it does what SF does best... It inspires me to have hope in humanity and our future.



Alice
807 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 33 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/vamp_cat/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11