
Dear Fantegero  
Thank you for writing this amazing story, "The Silence Between Cities"
.
May 17, 2026
FIRST IMPRESSION
The place where humanity's soul exists is so often imperceivable and a person can sush the internal struggles a soul is having permanently. Time, distance, and perseverance is meat to the soul. It expects such hardships if the prize is worthy. But the heroine in this story, Mel, begins a deeper search of her soul as the years have now past with only quick meetings, messages and promises. Then at the very moment Mel sets her heart and mind to make her soul press past all resistance, her love needs something more than a monogamous relationship. After 10 years! Now the truth. This is Mel's story and outwardly one has heard this tale, maybe too many times. But this story goes so deep into what makes a beautiful, loving, precious woman. I have read a few here lately, and like those characterizations, this one knocks me out. I was once married to a "Mel." Being young and stupid at the time I had no idea her worth and her inner beauty. She endured so much from me before we split up that there have been times when I have wondered how and why she put up with me. This story brilliantly gives enlightenment into the humanity in woman that believes the best of others, hopes for the best of all futures, and wishes the best of others. Very much like dear Melanie in "Gone With The Wind."
THEME
Adrian has a 10 year long distance relationship with Melanie. They have kept their hopes for marriage alive by internet, quick meetings at airports and phone calls. The relationship suddenly is challenged by Adrian's subtle insinuations that monogamy is not what he desires any longer. As it dawns on Melanie, over several conversations, that this is more than an idle wish, she begins to wonder about how she had come to believe that a "happily ever after" marriage could have ever been possible.
STRUCTURE
The story is extremely reflective and told in the third person from Mel's perspective. The prose is soft and casual as Mel's thoughts bring her soul to it's ultimate torment. "Maybe she never knew him."
 MY PONDER MOMENT
This was my pondering moment:
So she listened.
But every attempt left her emotionally fractured.
One evening, while walking home through Chinatown after work, Mei caught herself staring at couples passing by. Ordinary couples. Laughing over shared meals. Holding hands casually. She envied their simplicity. Not because their relationships were perfect, but because their boundaries seemed understood without negotiation.
With Adrian, everything suddenly felt unstable.
I think, well okay, this is my own experience, every relationship comes to a point like this one. Something in the relationship challenges the expectations. Did I promise that? Was that how I am perceived? If so why does she love me? The time for searching the soul to determine the price of love relationships comes as an awakening to a part of me that just assumes everything is sunshine and roses. My soul. It does not care to be disturbed thank you. But it is my soul that is going to have to pay the price. If my heart is hurt, my mind twisted, I can numb, I can get counseling, or veg, but the soul? It carries the scars. Mel's realization that what Adrian wants is so beyond her capacity to love and accept that she must end the relationship. And this is the power of the piece, neither person really wants to hurt the other. But neither can except something that makes the whole relationship feel "unstable."
SUGGESTIONS
I was unaware of any need for edits. A very strong narrative and characterizations.
 IN SUMMARY
The need for happy endings is alive and well in me. Just don't read much of those stories anymore. I had a happy ending once. But then, you know, life happens. For Mel and Adrian who have made a 10 year long distance love relationship work are on the verge of losing their happy ending. Mel sees the couples that are joyful, as they hold hands at dinner, or walking together. She also perceives the boundaries that have been set around those relationships. Boundaries that Adrian is requesting to no longer be in their relationship. Suddenly, there is no longer the feeling of stability for Mel. The nature of man, at least from my experience, is we are not too concerned about stability, as long as we can conquer our world each day. But Mel, and the beauty of Mel, is she epitomizes where the need for stability lies, and why it had better be there if man wants an enduring relationship with a woman. Perhaps, or at least I hope, I have a bit more understanding now. Thank You!
I hope my thoughts and impressions have been a support for your writing. Let me know if you have any questions about my review.
Kind Regards,
~Kenword~
|