Wow! What a couple of difficult prompts to do acrostics with! The last one is such a long phrase and you did well keeping to the same subject.
Suggestions
Again, your punctuation makes the flow choppy. You have periods where you should have no punctuation. If you have a thought continuing to the next line, it doesn't need anything for separation.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
Serenity in Nata Uta form. You stuck to the form very well, and definitely reminded me what it feels like to be in a state of serenity.
Suggestions
Again, this poem is mostly technically sound. The major problems are with punctuation.
Line 2: Period
Line 6: No punctuation needed
Line 9: Period
Line 10: Period
Line 11: Semicolon
Line 12: Period
Line 14: Period
Line 16: No punctuation needed
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
Another dodoitsu. This time, about a girl whose parents shelter her from the world, and who wants to explore and experience life.
Suggestions
Mostly, this poem is sound. But there are a few spots where punctuation is used but not needed. A good example of this is the line 3 in stanza 3. No punctuation is needed here.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
Another libonelle that is well done! You do quite well with this form (and every other form I've read of yours as well). It has a soothing affect on the reader. If you need to de-stress, this poem will definitely help!
I have no suggestions to offer.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
This poem teaches children a great lesson. I like that you made it so that the subject of the poem turned out to really like Jim (and I won't give the rest away!).
Suggestions
I'd omit the because in line 2 in stanza 1. It'll help the flow.
Line 2 of stanza 3 also messes up the rhythm. I would consider revising this line to read:
I asked around and to find his name is Jim
Line 2 of stanza 4 is incredibly long! I would consider shortening this line:
I gave him my number, one day, and asked him to phone (this is still really long, too, but the best I could come up with).
Line 2 in stanza 8 is also very long. I would consider shortening this one as well.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
All of the things around us are, indeed, inspiration for our writing. I like how you incorporated it into this poem. I also like your use of vocabulary. The words you've chosen makes this poem flow so well!
I have no suggestions to offer. This poem is technically sound.
Thanks for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
This was a very good use of the Libonelle. I very much enjoyed reading this poem. The description of how a libonelle is written, at the top of your poem, was a little confusing. But I understood it by seeing your working example.
I have no suggestions to offer.
Thanks for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
What a wonderful poem about your dogs. I like the title, it's so fitting! Furbabies they are, and furbabies they'll always be. You definitely express how much you love them!
I have no suggestions to offer. This poem is technically sound.
Thank you for sharing!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
This poem is a wonderful remembrance of Jesus, and a wonderful tribute. I like the rhyme and rhythm of this, and the message. Your title and description are very fitting, and I like that the description takes some lines from your poem and mixes them together to rhyme.
Suggestions
I'd title He in your brief description.
The rhythm of your last line is a little off. Maybe changing it to read for being my shield and my sword.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
It is true that once we leave what is familiar and taken for granted, we find out how much it means to us. This poem describes exactly what it is to be homesick. I reflected very well with your words.
I have no suggestions to offer. This poem is technically sound.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
This poem tells the story about all of the decisions in your life very well, and shows how thankful you are to have what you have. You've done very well demonstrating this through your words.
I have no suggestions to offer. This poem is technically sound.
What a cute little poem for you to write for your children! It reads like something you would recite to them every evening at bedtime, so that they would know they're safe from monsters and bad dreams.
I have no suggestions to offer. This poem is technically sound.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
Acrostics are so fun to write! You can take just about any word and make it into something good or bad, whatever your heart desires.
This acrostic touches on rainfall, using raindrops as its inspiration. It reads in a soothing manner and contains a lot of descriptive imagery that put me in the middle of the rainshower.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
I wrote for this Writer's Cramp prompt, too. I admire that you wrote it in pantoum form. It is a very difficult form to write! You did a good job telling the story and keeping true to the history.
Suggestions
The rhythm on this is very inconsistant throughout the poem. Some lines are way too long for it to flow very well. An example:
The passengers were screaming as the train was falling, the momentum building up pace.
I'd revise this line to read:
Passengers were screaming, the train was falling; momentum building up pace.
There are a lot of lines where you can omit needless words (such as the) and it will help the flow immensely.
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
I love reading stories and poems in the fantasy genre. There is something about lands that exist only in our imagination and beings that we cannot see with our own two eyes that is exciting. This is a wonderful start to your novel.
Your dialogue and description are well done. I also like that you include a pronounciation guide for your names and geographic locations. I don't know how many times I've read a story and had to try to figure it out on my own.
Suggestions
Shouldn't Echos, as in your title, be Echoes?
Thank you for sharing this!
Melissa Reviewathon Reviewer
"Under a funeral seizure" is a very heavy in emotion. It has a strong ending and, again, your use of vocabulary to convey your meaning is very strong.
My favorite:
The entire third stanza.
My suggestion:
The beginning doesn't feel as strong as the end. Your metaphors in the third stanza are the strongest. If the first two stanzas were this strong, the poem would be five star material.
Overall, this is a well-written poem. The sadness was overwhelming.
I'm glad to see that you've returned to Writing.com and brought your poetry forms journal back with you. I hope that this weekend finds you in good spirits and good health!
There's a lot in this journal that wasn't in the previous one. I'm so happy that someone takes the time to detail the how-to's of the various poetic forms.
Suggestions -
You used to have an entry about the Pantuoum, but I don't see it in this journal. Is there a reason for that, or have you just not gotten to it yet?
Just a thought!
Thank you again for keeping track of the numerous poetic forms for Writing.com! This is an invaluable resource and something I refer to quite often!
"15 for 15 Contest --- Closed" is a great contest idea! I think almost everyone can come up with a spare 15 minutes a day. Count me in.
My only question is, if I have to go out of town for 3 of the days, do I just have to make up the prompts later? The rules aren't clear on the specifics of missed days, only if you're joining while the contest is already in progress.
"Sweet & Sour" is a Count-Up poem written for The Writer's Cramp. It's interesting to see what different pieces each writer can come up with from the same prompt. Yours is about a McDonald's nugget happy meal. Very cute!
I got a good giggle from this. Thank you for sharing and have a wonderful evening.
Write on!
-Mel
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mworden/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
All Writing.Com images are copyrighted and may not be copied / modified in any way. All other brand names & trademarks are owned by their respective companies.
Generated in 0.52 seconds at 7:11pm on Apr 26, 2024 via server web1.