I am glad you appreciated my previous review. I'm happy to help other writers over the stumbling blocks that I can. We all help each other here.
Okay, this is a pretty detailed review~~ everything is just a suggestion, as YOU write your own stuff``AND IT'S REAL GOOD.
Ankush, your artistry with words shines, more than your punctuation does in this poem. I'm very moved by the subject and your literary presentation of being caged in. Your subject has many daily life implications. Your choice of words are perfect and flow easily, and your rhyme falls right in time. You've got a beat, and you keep it going. It's a good thing.
However, I question your punctuation. Though not a soap box fan of the semicolon, I think we're not on the same page about its use.
Let me quote from my old grammar book:
Semicolons are used--
*Between main clauses without an expressed connective
* Between main clauseslinked with a conjunctive adverb
* With coordinating conjunctions, and
* To separate elements containing other marks
In the first stanza, you use the semicolon properly. I losely interpret the semicolon rule to say "use it to stick two sentences (with subject and verbs) together. It's like glue instead of a period. I have a strange way of phrasing things sometimes. Are you still with me?
Your use of semicolons in this section, I don't understand.
But then, I was taken aback;
when he irately said:
'Dolt! If you don't understand my feeling;
then please stop muttering!'
I would suggest:
But he is protected inside
from the marauders outside.
But then, I was taken aback
when he irately said:
"Dolt! If you don't understand my feeling,
then please stop muttering!"
I would suggest for you to use another word besides "asked" in your conversation with the bird in the cage. You have lots of options that are more specific, for example--questioned, a query, a reply, a loud squeel of conviction--you get the idea. . . .
(then you could use the word reply, as in "I replied to his question. . . ")
"But he is protected inside; from the marauders outside." I question use of semicolon.
Question use of "But" again. Can you think of another word? . . . and, however, never-the-less. . . But means "in contrast to what has come before, a 'not alike" of the thing that came before. You use "But" three times in your poem. That's okay, but two would be better.
I hope all this critiquing is what you were expecting. Since I used to be an English teacher, I have a lot of rules burned into my head.
I liked very much that you put a glossery at the bottom of your poem. Most of the general meanings are the same here in Texas, but you include nuances. Bravo
This is a very good work, and I like it alot. You are a very talented writer. Stick with it, my Friend. What season is in India now?
peace, sunflower
{{b}My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed" {/b}
I help you now, you help me later.
|
|