*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/vzabel/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/15
Review Requests: OFF
1,385 Public Reviews Given
1,714 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 11 12 13 14 -15- 16 17 18 19 20 ... Next
351
351
Review of The Locket  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
A very capivating tale, Shaara. I enjoyed it and the fact that you give the reader the definitions of unfamiliar words after the story.

I would have just liked the story fleshed out a bit more. You tell us some things that would have been more interesting to 'see' happen.

This story is more of an adult perspective than I think would be interesting to readers of TWAU, but it is a rather well-written one.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
352
352
Review of Bird Watching  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.0)
This story I really like, Shaara. It would be great for Young Love in TWAU. You have caught the innocence of young teens discovering each other perfectly. The point of view is that of the teens, too.

*Idea* You might delete all exclimation points except in dialogue.

*Idea* Using second person in Her owl with its batman ear tufts looked so real you could almost reach out and touch its softness actually weakens the story. You might subsitute 'he' for 'you.'

*Idea* You forgot the opening quotation marks in the following: It's really good, you know," he managed to say without his voice cracking too badly.

When you have revised, please let me know. I would like to see this in TWAU.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
353
353
Review of Autumn's Song  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.5)
I like the flow and the rhyme. The only problem I see is the lack of punctution to help divide the thoughts and ideas.

*Idea* I would suggest a comma at the ends of lines 1, 2, 3, and 5 and periods at the ends of lines 4 and 6.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
354
354
Review of Surface Lure  
Review by Vivian
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
I'm not much of a horror buff, in fact I don't care for it at all. This story, though, sounds good so far.
The suspense certainly builds.

The first paragraph has a couple of problems that almost lost my interest. You use the word conscious twice and close together, which should be avoided if possible. Secondly, I think you mean consciousness. The wording "He came up to conscious" is ackward, even if you change conscious to consciousness. Maybe he gained consciousness or he gained awareness.
355
355
Review of Druid Forests  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
What words can describe near perfection? You write so well that your work should be published.

I like the way you worked history into this poem, making the reader aware of more than lines of poetry, but also the pull of history.

The repetition of "Beneath" at the beginning of each stanza ties the verses together well.

I enjoyed this poem very much, and I couldn't find any problems at all.

Viv
** Image ID #767943 Unavailable **
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
356
356
Review of Diwali  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.5)
An interesting poem, but since I'm not familiar with either the occasion or the form of the poem, I just have to comment on my reaction to the piece itself.

You have lovely imagery. Even not knowing about the celebration, I can imagin what is happening. That's the mark of a good writer.

The semicolon after 'ignorance' should be a comma, and commas are not needed after 'mirth' or 'love.' The comma after 'blessed' should be a smicolon or a period to avoid the run-on sentence.

Viv
** Image ID #754674 Unavailable **
357
357
Review of Samhain  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Another good story from the pen, uh, computer of W.D. Wilcox.

I like the information contained in this story. You weave your research into the tale very well, in an interesting way.

*Idea* Some dialogue, even if the narrator's thoughts, would have added to the overall effect.

*Idea* Your writing would be so much more powerful if you could avoid that vague 'it.'

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
358
358
Review of Ben And Rosie  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
This is a very good story with a good lesson included. I did some problems that can be smoothed out, improving the structure.

If you avoid using second person (you, your, etc.) except in dialogue, your writing is stronger. For example,To look at him, you wouldn’t even be able to tell he was slow. Maybe change it to something like To look at him, I couldn't even tell he was slow.

The following, Ben kept tapping her arm every time he asked a question, would be more straight forward as Ben tapped her arm every time he asked a question.

Alright should be all right.

He was dressed all in black with wearing a cowboy hat on, and a toy gun and holster hanging over the middle of his crotch. Perhaps have "...holster handing between his legs," or something like that.

There are other places with unneeded words, like 'looking right at her' doesn't need 'right.'

The lying at the end might send the wrong message to children. Could you come up with a different way? Maybe they ran through a yard with sprinklers on as they ran home?

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon


359
359
Review of Soul's Remedy  
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I hope that W.Com has provided you with an outlet for your pain and agony so that the need for self injury is lessened.

Your poem is full of emotion and imagery that makes my heart cringe. I can understand the need to release pain, but I've always been able to accomplish that through my writing.

One point, I don't understand why you capitalize 'soul' in the last line. Since you use 'my' in front of it, 'soul' should not be capitalized.

Viv
noticing newbies committee sig
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
360
360
Review of Cindy Jo  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
All I can say is, "Bravo, Harry, bravo!"

Yes, I found a couple of problems, quotation marks in the wrong place, a needed comma, but they cannot distract from the over-all effect and power of this piece.

I tip my hat to you for what you can accomplish with your stereoms. Keep reading and writing and spreading your thoughtful messages.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon


361
361
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Whether your article is written perfectly or not, the thought and effort, plus truth, that you have inserted into this article is amazing.

I agree with your point that those who refuse to give 5 stars should not accept them. Talk about a double standard!

You not only put much consideration into how you rate, but also into explaining how you do. Good job.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
362
362
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.5)
Oh, WD, this poem is so lonely, lovely, and heartbreaking. I can see the little girl so plainly, and I can relate to her isolation.

I'm also sure that children could relate to her experience, some only too well. I would like to use this poem in TWAU if you would be willing to punctuate it. Please let me know one way or the other.

Everyone should read this piece because it shares the pain a parent feels at his child's suffering and a glimpse of a child alone. Beautifully worded.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
363
363
Review of For Linda  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
I'm a push-over for love poems that tell the beauty of married love, long-lasting love. That concept takes maturity and time to develop and to understand.

If I were your wife, I would want this poem printed, framed, and hung on the wall.

I enjoyed this one very, very much, Harry.

Viv
** Image ID #754674 Unavailable **
364
364
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Another very good, thought-provoking work, Harry.

You cover a depth of meaning that many over look, that we accept more those that look like us. Yes, it is a shame to feel that way.

I have just one question. Why do you have that all agree in the third stanza, but then show that some disagree? Did I miss something?

You really do make us think.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon



365
365
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.5)
Ah, Harry, another good read. You have such a way with words, that all your poetry, whatever the form, keeps my attention and tickles my imagination.

The wording of the first line seems a bit off. In my mind I see midnight standing somewhere while people walk by it. Perhaps rewording might help. Past midnight, 'the boys' and I are taking a walk.

Again, I enjoy your poetry.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
366
366
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hi, I hope you're becoming comfortable here.

I really like the imagery of your poem. The words create clear mental pictures. "The tiring clockwork sea" is nearly an oxymoron.

Your spelling needs some checking: ageing, Ryhmless both are incorrect.

You have a distinct talent for using words poetically.

Viv
noticing newbies committee sig
Image #754404 over display limit. -?-
367
367
Review of Night Ride  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.0)
Very good work. Your message and theme are so true and so well expressed.

I would just suggest that you do use needed punctuation so that your thoughts and ideas are clear and don't run together. I know many people don't think punctuation is needed in poetry. However, unless one is writing only for himself or herself, punctuation helps the reader better understand what is written. If not for the lack of punctuation, this would have 5 stars from me.

You are a very good writer. I'm going to enjoy reading your work, very much enjoy.

Viv
noticing newbies committee sig
Image #754404 over display limit. -?-
368
368
Review of No Boundaries  
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Welcome to Writing.Com.

Your story has a great concept. I really like the story that you have.

*Idea* I would just suggest, that if you have someone who can and would, you have it thoroughly edited for gammar problems. If you don't have anyone, and would like an edit, please let me know.

You have a great talent of telling a story.

Viv
noticing newbies committee sig
Image #754404 over display limit. -?-
369
369
Review of depression  
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Your poem is a cry of pain. I wish I could reach out and take it away.

You use your words well to describe depression all too clearly.

If you would check your spelling problems and add some needed punctuation to help make understanding your thoughts easier, your poem would be excellent. Wont should be won't; cant should be can't; an should be and.

Please, if this is biographical, I hope you continue to ignore the call of the bottle.

Viv
noticing newbies committee sig
Image #754404 over display limit. -?-
370
370
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Harry, I'm amazed at how you can take articles from the news and create such a work of art. Yes, dark art to be sure, but still art.

This storeom brings forth a truth that many refuse to face.

Viv'
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
371
371
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
Very good job, Holly. You have given us an interesting, informative, and helpful newsletter. Thank you for making haiku understandable.

Viv
Review sig designed by Orions Moon
372
372
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.5)
Dot, you have addressed something that most authors will find interesting with a piece that they should find helpful. Good job.

*Idea* One thing that concerns me is that you address writing a novel. Shouldn't you maybe have this as characteristics of a novelist?

*Idea* Limiting the use of exclamation points to dialogue will actually strenghten your writing.

Interesting piece.

Viv
** Image ID #745227 Unavailable **
373
373
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
I do like your poetry, Harry. You have a unique way of using words to create the images you want us to sense and see.

The one thing that caught my eye that you might want to fix is the extra short line at the end of the second stanza. Omiting it completely wouldn't hurt your poem and would help the flow.

Good job, Harry.

Viv
** Image ID #745227 Unavailable **
374
374
Review of The Gen X Shuffle  
Review by Vivian
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
This trip down memory lane via music held my attention and kept it, despite the R rating.

*Pthb* I never noticed the rating before I clicked the link (because I found in posted on the reviewing forum), so I was a bit shocked to read those, uh, dropping of waste materials in your wording. The thing is, your article would actually be stronger without the added ingredients.

As usual, you manage to use words to build the mental picture you want.

Viv
{image:745227

375
375
Review of A Worthy Quest  
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I've missed your storeoms, Harry, and this one is excellent.

*Smile* I admire your alliteration sprinkled throughout.

*Delight* The message comes through loud and clear. Good job of expressing the need for all to stand up to evil in order to vanquish it.

I enjoyed this piece very much.

Viv
** Image ID #745227 Unavailable **



504 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 21 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/vzabel/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/15