*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/borgford/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/sort_by_last/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/8
Review Requests: OFF
622 Public Reviews Given
968 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 -8- 9 ... Next
176
176
Review of Ominous Lake  
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (4.5)
Great descriptions. Your really set the stage. It makes you want to know what happens next, so you obviously need to continue the story.

I'm no expert on ediing but I will try one item - ignore it if it doesn't help.

<None saw the girl running...save for one> This sentence seems to be a different style or tone from the rest of the piece. The wording seems out of sync. Maybe it's the word "save" also the word "None" as opposed to "No one"

Keep at it.
Brian
177
177
Review by Brian
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hey - a great little story. Good luck in the contest. I thought God was a baseball fan. "In the Big Inning". You made this funny from front to back.

Here are a couple of observations, it they are of any help.

Writing in the third person pronoun "he", it is sometimes confusing at the start if "he" refers to the subject of the story or God.
<another of the mini bottles from the mini bar in the mini fridge in his mini room, > very effective use of repetition "mini"
<hotel stationary> spelling this it the "stationery" with an "e" as opposed to motionless.

Well done - keep writing.
Brian



178
178
Review of not sure yet  
Review by Brian
Rated: 18+
Good start - needs some editing as you referred to. Here are a couple of observations. Hope it helps.

<The hold he had on me was embeckable> I have no idea what "embeckable" means
<birthday party i think> Capitlaize "I" (check all instances)
<just disapperad > spelling


Keep at it.
Brian
179
179
Review of Reborn at Dusk  
Review by Brian
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
Good effort.

I think you could use a bit of editing. Here are some observations - hope it is helpful

< "hey !> Capitalize "Hey"
< Camilla froze in place like a deer caught in the head lights waiting for death to strike her quick> I think you need some commas here.
<To afraid to turn > should read "Too afraid"
<Paper bags ruffled and a small faint ring form the cash register rang> "ring" and "rang" are redundant.

Keep writing
Brian
180
180
Review by Brian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Interesting account of a simple every day event. I like your descriptions. Here are a couple of things I spotted in terms of style - which I am trying to develop.

<pulling life’s possessions> you didn't say "her life's possessions" as an experienced writer, I assume that is intentional, not an accident. But it does stand out for me.
<Most nights are spent at the rescue> As a new writer, I avoid the passive voice, but for some it seems to work. I need to find out where it works and where it doesn't
<then contentedly she falls asleep> You have not only used an adverb, but placed it oddly. Still it seems to work.

These aren't criticisms, just observations from a new writer, looking for the appropriate style. You obviously know how to write.

Keep at it.
Brian
181
181
Review by Brian
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Isn't this a creative cute tale - I like it.

It's very captivating and kept my attention through to the end. I'm not an expert, but it looks well written to me.

A couple of observations from a rookie: (ignore them if you don't agree)

< He indicated a silver-haired gentleman wearing a cape> I'm not a pro at grammar, but something seems wrong here. Perhaps "he looked towards a..." or something similar.
<want to come but I hate > comma after come?
<she added hastily> I try to avoid adverbs

Great job - keep it up.

Brian

182
182
Review of Baptist In Space  
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.5)
This is a cute story.

I notice tthat you seem to have several typos and spelling errors. They look accidental, but some may be intentional:

<planned thier pilgrimage> typo - should be "their"
<Centenual of Isreal's nation> - do you mean Centenial?
<descended upon his congegation... > "congregation"
<A door openned> "opened"
<stood infront > "in front" space
<Thankyou and have a nice day> space between "Thank" and "you"

I enjoyed the story - keep at it.
Brian

183
183
Review of Samuels' Story  
Review by Brian
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Sounds like you have a good start.

Here are a couple quick editorial notes:

You started the first two paragraphs with the person's name - maybe to repetitious
"Vin Samuels live in southeast" should be "lives"
"that was very intricate" "very" is a weak word
"Inter-net " should be 'internet"

Keep at it.
Brian
184
184
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.0)
Cute story, I liked it. Here are a couple of editorial comments. I'm not an expert, so I hope they are correct and that they are helpful.


"that began and ended disturbingly abruptly" The only thing worse than an adverb, is two adverbs. Try to find a stronger verb.
"quietly hoping " more adverbs
"and was apt to spit tobacco" try for parallelism. The first two verbs were past tense and this one is at odds with them.
" While he sat too stunned to " not clear who "he" refers to. Needs to be more connection between pronoun and that to which it refers.
"later, after certain things happened that were never disclosed" passive voice, but doesn't seem to hurt the flow.
"and was especially" verb refers to people and should read "were"

Keep it up
Brian
185
185
Review of First Kiss  
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (4.0)
Nicely written - very warm story.

A couple of comments from a rooke:

"morning dew made her curl her toes in a futile" maybe just "made her toes curl"
"She felt rather than heard" add a comma after "felt"?
"hugging her tightly." any chance of dropping the adverb in favor of a stronger verb?

Keep it up - you do a great job.
Brian
186
186
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.5)
Excellent tale. Well told.

I noticed a couple areas that confused me a bit, so you might want to recheck the flow.

Eg:

"people also come to do some fishing" A bit confusing "also" means in addition to something already mentioned. What is it?
"story about the lake when he fell asleep" needs some punctuation. Sounds like a story about a time when he fell asleep - but I don't think that's what is intended.
"As he rushes to save her, she is engulfed by " careful with the he/she - again a bit confusing. Maybe change she to Emily.
"sinks rapidly" I avoid adverbs - look for a stronger verb.

Keep it up
Brian
187
187
Review of Heading Away  
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (2.5)
This appears to be a sketch or outline of the beginning of the story, so it is hard to get the full feel for where it is going. You will need to work on editing and grammar. Here are a few examples.


"This is why I emigrated to the United of States of America" You emigrate from somewhere and immigrate to somewhere - use immgrate here unless you specify where from. You use immigrant in the next paragraph.
"Chinatown where the living expenses is lower" are lower
Work on proper presentation of numbers - eg spell out in full at the start of a sentence.

Keep at it and it should develop.

Brian

188
188
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.5)
This is a great intro. Looks like it should be an interesting and comic story.

Seems to be well writting - but I'm not an expert. Here are a couple of editorial comments:

" just as he had a mouthful of scolding hot coffee in his mouth" I though "scolding" was a typo, but based an a later usage, you may have put it in on purpose. It may be a confusing term for the reader. comma after "mouth"
"managed to procure a can of coffee and to chug most of it " I would use "get" rather than "procure" to make the tone more consistent with "chug"

Carry on - I look forward to reading the rest.
Brian
189
189
Review of The Vacation  
Review by Brian
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
Good story - I hope it is fiction. Keeps your attention right to the end. I can really feel for your main character.

A couple of edtiorial comments (from a rookie myself, but I have really been researching writing style)

"We quickly walked across the courtyard toward the second building. Guillermo knocked firmly on the door." I would drop the adverbs in favor of stronger verbs - eg banged on the door, scooted across the courtyard.
" I was told." avoid the passive voice.

Looks like you have lots to offer - keep writing. Writing is my retirement plan - if I can retire with the current economy.

Brian
190
190
Review of JOHNNY  
Review by Brian
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
This looks like it could be part of a larger work, but it stands on its own quite well.

At times, I find the folksy style a bit hard to follow. eg "He could be family or the boy next door", maybe a comma in the middle would help.

The dashes you use could probably be spaced out a bit more. Visually they sometimes look like hyphenated words which alter the meaning.

'blow out that candle and give me a piece." Captialize B

All I can come up with is a couple of nitpicky edits. Must mean its a pretty good piece.

I liked it.
Brian
191
191
Review by Brian
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
This piece certainly gives you a feel for this guy's life - hope it isn't yours.

I have a couple of grammatical comments, but you don't want to clean it up so much that you destroy the rustic style.

"was fort dollars" should be "forty"
" litle out of a little less" spelling on the first "little"
"gambler, atleast not with" space between "at" and "least"
"budlight" I think this should be Bud Light
" Still I dont quit" apsotrophe required
"exactly 300$," dollar sign on the wrong side.

I think there are a few more, but you get the idea. But this may be part of your intent to create the personality.

Thanks for listening.
Brian



192
192
Review of Face  
Review by Brian
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
I'm Canadian, so we spell most things the same way - execpt for "tyre/tire" and "jail/gaol". So I understand you.

Powerful account , feels real - I hope it's fiction. It sets the stage for whatever you plan next.

Here is just a couple observaions:
"whole period is pretty hazy"
"both are quite ridiculous"
"That was quite weird"
"really hard"
"been quite a shock"

Pretty, really and quite are weak words. I think you can elimnate them without weakening the story.

I am not an expert, but i dug as deep as I could, and that's all I could come up with.

Go to it.
Brian
193
193
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.5)
Good story - you make it sound real, so it is either a true story, or well written fiction. I'm not a great editor, but I made some notes in bold. Hope it is helpful.
Thanks for your writing.
Brian



A string of shots rang out when the Sergeant(no capital required) shouted:
“Hold your fire!” “No pun intended,” he mumbled under his breath. “Surrender boys, come on out now with your hands up.”
Three juvies slowly obeyed (avoid the adverb and look for a stronger verb) Sergeant Pierce, quivering with fear and faces drained of color, slow and guarded, they came outside.

It was the summer of 1985; school was out, and three young men had too much time on their hands, crazy imaginations and a marked lack of self-control. They were bored and their parents were busy at work, thinking the boys were mature enough to spend the afternoons on their own. It was summertime, school was out and what one didn't think of another did.
(this sentence is a bit awkward and difficult to follow) They were playing with fire and about to get burnt.

Fires were being set sporadically (passive voice)all over Mayfield, a small town in Southwestern Ohio, for a little over a week. While a few received minor injuries, no lives were lost(passive voice) as yet. Property damage had run up to about half-a-million --- a few barns, fields, a tree farm and a few old farm houses.
“Something has got to give! This destructive terrorism must be stopped,” was all Sergeant Pierce could say or think of as he shook his head in disgust.
The County Sheriff had sent out the canine unit after the first church burnt to the ground.
Downright meanness was driving these rascals who were obviously getting kicks from creating a wake of turmoil and misery. So far they were lucky enough to keep the dogs at bay. They were hiking up the creek or escaping in a vehicle. The authorities felt like they were blindly investigating, and only coming up with a handful of leads.
Finally, while watching the 11 O'clock news, we were assured(passive voice) it wouldn’t be long before fate caught up with these careless pranksters. With the County involved, the local P.D. and the arson squad, all hands were on deck. The local news kept us apprised of the latest happenings and witnesses started coming forward in droves.

It was Thursday evening around 7:15 p.m., when we got our final call. A house was burning in the middle of Mayfield. It was the home of a single mother with three young children. Alarms sounded from nearby fire stations and sirens began to wail as thick black smoke cascaded over the town.
At the scene a young mother was holding a two-year old, towheaded boy with rosy cheeks. He was wearing Superman pajamas.
“Please! Please! Save my babies. My other two boys are still inside,” their mama cried through stifled sobs.
Four of our bravest firemen stepped inside of hell{maybe change to "the hell") to find two little boys, aged four and six.
Water was storming (remove was, change to stormed)down heavy and hard in every direction from the multiple fire hoses. Smoke thickened and breathing was labored and painful.
Finally, the firemen emerged holding two raggedy dolls. The paramedics began CPR, rolling the boys into separate ambulances and heading for the nearest burn center at Mercy South.
Both boys had barely escaped death after being hooked up to ventilators all night and treated for third degree burns. Both were in the same hospital room while their mother sat in a corner rocker holding their baby brother. She was distraught but thankful all her boys were alive. Each time a nurse came in to change their bandages, the two boys would scream in agony. It was hard.(what was hard?)

Luke, their three-month old puppy, was gone. The fire burned hot, and there was nothing identifiable left at the residence.

Sergeant Pierce walked into the hospital room, assuring the boys' mother they were on the trail of these offenders and determined to find them by day’s end.
Around 6 O’clock that same afternoon, the canine unit trailed their scent to an old abandoned shack on the outskirts of town. The kids were shaken to say the least as we had them surrounded and weren’t sure whether they were going to put up a fight. After a few shots came barreling out the shack, the authorities ran for cover and unloaded return rounds. That’s when Sergeant Pierce shouted, “Hold your fire!” These adolescents came from good families. Heck, we all knew them. While their intentions were ominous, they had too much time on their hands and not enough supervision. Nevertheless, they did what they did, and they would have to pay for it. The kids were remorseful and tearful, holding their heads down as they stumbled out one-by-one. Surely they’d go through the court system, make restitution, do some community service and spend a few years in reform school, until finally released back into society.
The oldest boy begged, "Please tell me we didn't hurt anybody!"
Sergeant Pierce set them straight, "Because of the three of you, two little boys are being treated for third degree burns at Mercy South, and last night was touch-and-go. They're going to be in there for quite a while because of your thoughtless deeds."

The next morning an old man a block down the street from the still smoking residence called Channel 10. Luke, the young pup was found wandering around the area pitiful, forlorn and lost --- looking for his family no doubt. Except for a few scrapes and singed hair matted with soot, Luke was shaken but no worse for wear.

In the mid-nineties, Channel 10 did a fresh story on the now grown-up teens who’d been the cause of a lot of grief, pain and havoc the summer of 1985. They were profoundly impacted by their crime spree, and two of them had stayed in Mayfield and were now visiting local schools and teaching about the dangers of playing with fire. Fortunately, Mayfield is a kind forgiving community. We all knew deep down that those boys could have been anyone's sons.

The two little boys who were nearly killed that night have deep scars, a nagging reminder of that dangerous night. Darned if their mother didn’t marry the Preacher(capital not necessary) who ministered to them at Mercy South.

Sergeant Pierce died of heart failure a few years back. We all mourned his death and the whole town turned out for his funeral. He is remembered (passive voice)well as Pierce Park sits in the heart of town, a thriving reminder of Sergeant Pierce, his kindness and valor.
194
194
Review of Things Change  
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.5)
Touching story - well told.

I would try to avoid the use of adverbs and opt instead for a stronger verb.

Also count the number of times you used the word "had". I think it's more than 20. Maybe try to eliminate some of them.

Keep it up. Looking forward to seeing more of your stuff.

Brian
195
195
Review of The "Blue" Dragon  
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.5)
Cute story - sounds like an incident where my white German Shepard was chased by a Chihuahua. Being a new writer, I am not an expert, but I have noted a few grammatical and word changes I would make.

Brian

---

The tale that I tell is of the elusive “Blue” Dragon. While the color of it’s skin may come in many shades, as you will see, this is a most appropriate title.

The “Blue” Dragon differs from that of dragons of fantasy for many reasons. Firstly, there are no wings to speak of. Secondly, It’s (it's) slender body is smooth and supple, with no scales. Thirdly, and most importantly, is in it’s mannerisms. Let me explain.(is this statement necessary?)

The “Blue” Dragon has a very predictable pattern of habits. They feast(It feasts - conflicting noun/verb) on the fallen lima beans of this island(which island?), that have softened on the ground from torrential rain that plagues this (plaguing the) area year round. They (the paragraph starts singular, but you change to plural)are solitary creatures, though not of their own choosing.

One particular interaction comes to mind when I speak of these creatures.

I was documenting a certain “Blue” Dragon on the south side of the island. The weather was particularly dreary that day. The subject(animal?) was walking about, grabbing a lima bean here and there, and generally minding it’s own business, when a beast jumped out from behind a tree.

The beast was easily ten times the size of the dragon. In startled amazement the dragon let out a raucous belch, which can be expected when your diet consists solely of lima beans.

Snarls and growls came from the beast(passive voice). Followed by incessant yelping.

The beast fled in the opposite direction, surely deterred by the noxious odor of the dragon’s flatulence. The dragon appeared saddened even more, knowing that this was another creature that would never be his companion.

As I turned away from this scene with a tear in my for the dragon’s solitude, I vowed never again to let my wife bring our pet Chihuahua on another expedition.
196
196
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is one of the better poll questions I have seen on here. Being a self selecting questionaire, I'm not sure how valid the results are. But it is interesting to notes the high percentage of Introverts. Intuitively, I would have thought of writers as Extroverts, but upon reflection that may have been bad intuition. Reading many of the Bios here, I see that there are a lot of people who have issues that they keep to themselves and use writing as an outlet.

The majority also are Feeling rather than sensing, which makes sense and fits with lots of the writing.

My profile is ESTJ, which also may explain why my writing style is far different than much that I see here.

Curious as to what you will do with the results. I am a big fan of MBTI. I used it in my early career to help guide me. It was very helpful. I have often used it in classroom settings when I teach behavioral subjects.

Brian
197
197
Review by Brian
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Intersting twist to the story. Well done. I think I would leave out some of the background information in the first few paragraphs. The power of the story is in the visualization. The background information seems to preempt the possiblity of this beeing a staged event. The viewer/reader would not be privy to such information.

The setting and the dialogue really kept me going.

Brian
198
198
Review by Brian
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
Just a couple of quick comments on style and editing.

I would eliminate passive voice (a loud boom was heard).

The first sentence is ambiguous (Dimitri rode in the back of a truck carrying about fifteen troops each.) Each what?

"There was quite a few of these..." The use of "quite" is weak.

Good story line - work on the style.

Brian
199
199
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.0)
This is an interesting personal story. As written it will provide you with good historical documentation. I think it needs a bit of work if you plan to have other read it. It is sequential narrative - written in the order things happened. Try to reduce the use of adverbs and look instead for a stronger verb. Avoid using the word "very" - it is weak.

Good effort - keep it up.

Brian
200
200
Review by Brian
Rated: E | (3.0)
I'm not sure if this is a real life experience or not - it sounds like it is. I have written a couple hundred little stories of my life. Most are humorous or entertaining, but a few tug at your heart strings like this one of yours. I am working hard at trying to develop a style that makes a reader want to read on. I don't have any concrete suggestions for your article, but it feels more like my original writing which in terms of style, was not compelling.

Sometimes I start with the ending. In this case you might start with the discovery of the ring. Or in the middle - losing the ring.

This is a touching story that I think needs some work on style and delivery. But I am too much of a rookie to give you any more specifics.

Thanks for listening.

Brian
207 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 9 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/borgford/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/sort_by_last/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/8