\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED ITEMS
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/rick12221/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9
Review Requests: ON
1,048 Public Reviews Given
1,068 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 5 6 7 8 -9- 10 11 12 13 14 ... Next
201
201
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your fanfiction is a delightful blend of the enchanting worlds of "Frozen" and "Winnie the Pooh." Combining these beloved universes for Disney's 100th anniversary is a charming idea that will appeal to fans of all ages. The story flows smoothly, capturing the essence of both worlds and their characters.

Strengths:

Character Voices: You did an excellent job capturing the unique voices of each character. Elsa's calm wisdom, Anna's spirited curiosity, and Pooh's gentle simplicity all shine through. Olaf's childlike wonder and the distinctive personalities of the Hundred Acre Wood residents are also well-portrayed.

Imagery and Descriptions: The descriptions of the setting, especially the transition from Arendelle to the Hundred Acre Wood, are vivid and magical. The imagery of the shimmering silver cloud and the serene forest clearing is particularly effective in creating a whimsical atmosphere.

Humor and Heart: The story is infused with humor and warmth, staying true to the spirit of both "Frozen" and "Winnie the Pooh." Moments like Olaf learning about meteorology and the playful interactions between the characters add a lighthearted touch.

Suggestions for Improvement:

Pacing: While the story flows well, the transition between scenes could be smoother. The shift from the breakfast scene to the appearance of the silver cloud feels a bit abrupt. Adding a bit more buildup or foreshadowing could enhance the magical transition.

Dialogue Tags: Some dialogue exchanges could benefit from varied tags to avoid repetition and clarify who's speaking. For example, instead of repeatedly using "said," try incorporating tags like "replied," "murmured," or even descriptive actions to convey tone and emotion.

Character Interaction: The interactions between Elsa, Anna, and the Hundred Acre Wood residents are charming, but you could delve deeper into their emotions and thoughts. For instance, how do Elsa and Anna feel about meeting these characters from a childhood story? Exploring their internal reactions can add depth to the narrative.

Conflict and Resolution: Introducing a small conflict or challenge during their visit could add an engaging element to the story. It doesn't have to be a major problem—perhaps a minor mishap that requires the characters to work together, highlighting their strengths and building bonds.

Overall, your fanfiction is a heartwarming and creative tribute to Disney's timeless characters. With a few tweaks to pacing, dialogue, and character interactions, it has the potential to be even more enchanting. Great job, and keep writing!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
202
202
Review of My Moods  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your poem, "Meltdown," is an engaging piece that captures a range of emotions and experiences. Here's a review of your work:

Title:

The title "Meltdown" is intriguing and suggests a significant emotional experience. It sets the tone for the rest of the poem, making readers curious about the content.
Structure:

The poem follows a clear and consistent structure with four quatrains (four-line stanzas). The rhyme scheme is ABAB in each stanza, which provides a rhythmic and melodic quality to the piece.
Themes:

The poem explores themes of family dynamics, personal contemplation, and the complexities of life and emotions. It effectively balances moments of joy and sadness, adding depth to the narrative.
Imagery and Language:

The imagery is vivid and relatable, especially in lines like "Meltdown shreds a pom-pom" and "And heaven's so starstruck." These lines create strong visual and emotional impressions.
The language is accessible and straightforward, which aligns well with the casual tone you're aiming for. However, some phrases might benefit from slight adjustments to enhance clarity and impact.
Emotional Impact:

The poem conveys a sense of introspection and emotional turmoil. It effectively captures the speaker's struggles and moments of reflection. The emotional shifts between joy, sadness, and contemplation keep the reader engaged.
Flow and Rhythm:

The poem flows smoothly, with a consistent rhythm that makes it easy to read. The rhyme scheme adds to this smoothness, creating a pleasing auditory experience.
Suggestions for Improvement:

Consider refining some lines for clarity and stronger impact. For instance, "Weaker not so near" could be rephrased to better convey the intended meaning.
Expanding on certain ideas or emotions could add more depth to the poem. For example, the stanza about pondering luck and muses wandering could be developed further to explore these concepts in more detail.
Overall, "Meltdown" is a thoughtful and well-crafted poem that effectively conveys a range of emotions and experiences. With some minor refinements, it can become even more impactful. Keep writing and experimenting with different themes and styles—you're on a great path!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
203
203
Review of moms  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem, titled "MOTHERS," beautifully captures the essence and significance of motherhood. It paints a vivid picture of the love, sacrifices, and joy that mothers bring into the world. Here is a revised version to enhance its flow and emotional impact:

MOTHERS

The one who gives life its meaning,
The one who makes it better,

Mothers, who sacrifice half of their lives,
Caring for their kids with nothing in exchange,

The one who gives you the love you need and more,
Mothers can be called angels, guides, carers,

The ones after God,
Nothing brings more joy than giving birth,

The immense joy of seeing your child grow,
The overwhelming pride in watching them achieve their dreams,

To all mothers reading this poem,
WE KIDS THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR EFFORTS AND SACRIFICES.
Your name holds a STUNNING meaning, which is,
On behalf of all kids, children, and teens, you are,

This version keeps the heartfelt sentiments and adds a bit more structure to the lines for clarity and rhythm. The emotional depth remains intact, celebrating the unparalleled role of mothers in our lives.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
204
204
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
"The Adventure of a Lifetime" is an engaging short story that takes the reader on an unexpected journey. William, the protagonist, is a dedicated canoeist whose excitement for a new adventure leads him to the mysterious Bermuda Triangle. The story's structure is straightforward, making it easy to follow while keeping the reader hooked with its unfolding events.

The initial setup is intriguing. William’s curiosity is piqued by an advertisement from the Outdoor Water League, and the mention of the Bermuda Triangle immediately creates a sense of suspense. The transition from his excitement to the actual adventure is well-handled, with the narrative smoothly moving from his home to the pier in the Bahamas.

The description of William's preparation and the dock hand's casual dismissal of his worries help to build tension. The portrayal of the storm and William’s struggle against the elements is vivid and intense. Phrases like "the canoe was flung about" and "he felt the canoe teeter backwards" effectively convey the perilous situation.

Waking up on the beach, William's confusion and the surreal transformation of the environment add a mysterious and almost supernatural twist. The changing colors of the trees and grasses create a strong visual image that emphasizes the strangeness of the place he has ended up.

The ending is both surprising and amusing. The casual response to William's distress call, "you're just being marooned!" injects a touch of humor, which contrasts nicely with the tension built up earlier in the story. This unexpected twist leaves the reader with a smile, fitting well with the light-hearted tone hinted at throughout the narrative.

Overall, "The Adventure of a Lifetime" is a well-crafted story that balances suspense, adventure, and humor. It keeps the reader engaged from start to finish, and the elements of surprise and humor add a memorable touch. Great job!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
205
205
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)

This story has a good mix of tension, emotion, and intrigue, which keeps the reader engaged throughout. Here are some thoughts and suggestions:

Strengths:

Emotional Depth: The story does a great job of showcasing Brenda's desperation and determination. Her pleas and the physical description of her pain and exhaustion make her struggle relatable.
Descriptive Setting: The vivid descriptions of the Tower of London, the forest, and Hadeon's hut create a strong sense of place. This helps immerse the reader in the story.
Character Dynamics: The interaction between Brenda and Hadeon is compelling. Hadeon’s skepticism and Brenda’s desperation create a tense dynamic that drives the plot forward.
Mystery and Suspense: The quest for the Core is intriguing, and the element of mystery surrounding its location and nature adds to the story's suspense.
Areas for Improvement:

Dialogue Consistency: Some of the dialogue, especially from Hadeon, feels inconsistent with her character. For instance, phrases like "Silly human" seem almost humorous and out of place for an immortal being. Hadeon's character might benefit from a more consistently cold and calculating tone.
Pacing: The story could benefit from tightening up in some areas. For example, Brenda's journey to Hadeon’s hut and her subsequent request for help could be more concise to maintain the story's momentum.
Clarity of Action: Some actions and their descriptions could be clearer. For example, the transition to the Forest of Ebony and the discovery of the waterfall could be more straightforward to avoid confusion.
Internal Monologue: Brenda's internal monologue is effective in showing her thoughts and emotions but can be repetitive at times. Streamlining these sections could help maintain the reader's interest.
Specific Suggestions:

Dialogue Improvement:
Instead of "Silly human," Hadeon could say, "You are hopelessly naive, aren't you?"
When Hadeon agrees to help Brenda, a line like, "Very well, but know this: failure will not be tolerated," could add to the tension.
Pacing Adjustment:
The section where Brenda wakes up and decides to seek Hadeon’s help can be shortened. Focus on her determination and skip over unnecessary details.
Clarifying Action:
The teleportation scene could be simplified. For example, "Hadeon grabbed Brenda’s arm, and with a snap of her fingers, they were engulfed in darkness, traveling through the void to the Forest of Ebony."
Example Revision:
Here’s a revised excerpt incorporating some of the suggestions:

“No, please!” Brenda dropped to the cold, moss-covered ground. “Just... please. Think about how much this means to me!” Her voice trembled.

Outside the Tower of London, the street lamps were turned off, allowing the stars to twinkle in the night sky, shining their light onto the courtyard below.

Brenda raised her head to meet Hadeon’s eyes, hoping for sympathy, only to find them unchanged—dark as a black hole, as if you could fall inside and never resurface.

Brenda was at Hadeon’s mercy. She was the animal, and Hadeon was the dagger. She bowed her head again, ready to do anything.

“Please," Brenda’s voice cracked with desperation, “I’ll do anything.”

Hadeon’s voice carried skepticism. “Anything? Hm…” Tapping her chin, she weighed the prospect of gaining the Core with Brenda. Was Brenda the right human to share power with? As she stared into Brenda’s eyes, conviction mixed with doubt. This scenario had played out before. Now she needed to test Brenda’s sincerity.

“You failed me once. I gave you another chance. You failed me twice. Should I listen to your pleas again? Just for you to fail me a third time?” Hadeon’s eyes glinted red at the memory. She never thought that history would repeat itself.

Under the silvery glow of moonlight, Brenda spoke with urgency. “But think about all the sacrifices made to reach this moment.”

Hadeon’s answer was cold. “The troubles of mortals do not concern me.”

The night seemed to close in around Brenda and set in her chest. This was her life’s work. She needed another chance. “It’s the reason my parents died. They sacrificed themselves for this one thing.”

Hadeon sighed.

It was as if Brenda didn’t hear her.

“Brenda—”

Brenda lifted her head to meet Hadeon’s pale gaze, watching as white mist flowed from her fingertips. Her heart sank. “What?” she asked, her voice quiet.

Hadeon frowned. Her eyes flashed but stopped. “Do you even know where the Core is located?”

“Yes. Each name has a meaning and purpose.”

Hadeon’s frown deepened. “You told me this before. Are you sure that the Core is encrusted in a sword?”

Brenda bit her lip until she tasted blood. “Yes,” she replied. She tried to say more, but couldn’t. The “yes” wasn’t a fact, it was a guess, and Hadeon seemed to notice it.

Hadeon saw the swelling lip. As skeptical as she was, what harm could a third chance do? “Listen, I’ll give you one last chance. And when... I mean... if you fail, well, goodbye-“

Brenda shot to her feet. “Thank you! You don’t know how much this means to me… I won’t fail.”

Hadeon snapped her fingers, and Brenda’s mouth closed.

“Don’t jinx it.”

Brenda stood up, curtsied, and rushed out of the room before Hadeon could change her mind. Even though she was excited, Brenda’s stomach churned. This was her last chance, and Hadeon made sure of it. There will be no fourth chance.

Overall, the story is engaging and has the potential to be even more captivating with a bit of refinement. Great job!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
206
206
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)

review - "We will buy a house and plant a cherry tree,
that way you will always have your favorite fruit."
I liked the way that you were when we were dreaming
and making plans.
You joked we should sneak to the house at night
and plant a tree before it was technically ours:
a secret adventure to share.
I laughed and logged the memory away
of your face when you said it,
but I was always the rule follower,
and you were always the pirate.

We moved into the house,
and you forgot the cherry tree.
And I didn't mind,
because I didn't need a cherry tree
as long as I had you.

Looking back, I think I had it backwards -
I needed the cherry tree.
I needed my own dreams,
more than I needed you.

Years after you moved out,
you came and planted a cherry tree in my yard -
still the same pirate.
But it isn't mine.
It's not the same.
And cherries are still my favorite fruit,
but every time you ask how
"your cherry tree" is doing,
I think about chopping it down.
ChatGPT
This piece captures a poignant reflection on a past relationship, blending nostalgia and regret with a clear sense of personal growth. Here are some thoughts on it:

Emotion and Imagery: The imagery of the cherry tree serves as a powerful metaphor throughout the piece. It symbolizes both the shared dreams and the individual needs of the narrator. The cherry tree is a tangible representation of the relationship and the personal aspirations that were neglected.

Character Dynamics: The contrast between the narrator and their partner is well-drawn. The narrator is a "rule follower," while the partner is a "pirate," adding a sense of adventure and unpredictability. This dynamic highlights the different approaches to life and dreams within the relationship.

Narrative Arc: The narrative arc from planning and dreaming together to the eventual realization that the narrator needed their own dreams more than the relationship is effectively conveyed. The shift from shared dreams to personal reflection adds depth to the story.

Symbolic Gesture: The act of the partner planting a cherry tree years after moving out is symbolic. It shows a lingering connection and a sense of unresolved feelings. However, the narrator's reaction to this gesture – thinking about chopping the tree down – underscores the emotional complexity and the desire to move on.

Tone and Style: The casual and reflective tone suits the piece. The conversational style makes the emotions feel genuine and relatable. The use of direct language helps convey the narrator's inner thoughts and feelings effectively.

Conclusion: The ending leaves a strong impression. The narrator's conflict about the cherry tree and their lingering feelings towards the partner are palpable. It emphasizes the ongoing struggle between holding onto the past and embracing personal growth.

Overall, this piece is a touching and introspective exploration of love, dreams, and personal identity. The cherry tree metaphor is particularly effective in tying the narrative together and conveying the emotional journey of the narrator.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
207
207
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
This story introduces an intriguing premise with Liliane Montgomery, a teenager who can see Grym, the Spirit of Death. The relationship between Liliane and Grym is well-developed, showing a mix of annoyance and dependence. The dialogue between them reveals Liliane's discomfort with her ability and Grym's casual approach to his grim duties.

The descriptions of Grym are vivid and unique, deviating from typical depictions of death spirits. His casual attire and use of modern technology, like an iPod, make him relatable and almost human, which adds an interesting twist. The contrast between his appearance and his role creates a compelling character dynamic.

Liliane's struggle with her ability is portrayed effectively. Her frustration at being seen as strange by her parents and her fear of looking people in the eye to avoid knowing their fate adds depth to her character. The conflict between wanting to help her father and the fear of being disbelieved is a strong emotional thread that readers can connect with.

The story flows well, with a good balance of dialogue and narrative. The scenes are easy to visualize, and the pacing keeps the reader engaged. The tension between Liliane and Grym, and within Liliane herself, is well-maintained throughout the piece.

One area that could be improved is the backstory. While the current narrative hints at why Liliane has this ability and how she met Grym, more details about these aspects would enrich the story. Additionally, the emotional impact of her grandmother's death, which seems to have triggered her ability, could be explored further to add more depth to Liliane's character.

Overall, this is a well-crafted story with interesting characters and a compelling premise. With some expansion on the backstory and more exploration of Liliane's internal conflict, it has the potential to be even more engaging.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
208
208
Review of The Caring Soul  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your story captures a touching moment of selflessness during a difficult time. Here are some thoughts and suggestions for improvement:

Opening and Setting the Scene:

The opening does a good job of setting the context. However, it can be tightened for clarity. Consider starting with a stronger hook to draw readers in.
Example: "Two years ago, during the peak of the COVID-19 crisis in the Philippines, hospitals overflowed with patients, leaving no rooms or beds available."
Detailing the Scene:

You describe the chaotic hospital environment well, but adding more sensory details can make it more vivid.
Example: "Tents sprang up outside hospital buildings, and the frantic buzz of people panic-buying oxygen filled the air."
Character Introduction:

Introduce the grandmother in a way that immediately builds empathy. Her background story is important but can be integrated more smoothly.
Example: "Among the patients was a resilient grandmother, a widow whose husband had passed away eight years prior from a cardiac arrest. Despite her children, a doctor and a nurse, working at the same hospital, she had always managed her fevers with fruit juice and warm porridge."
Dialogue and Interaction:

The dialogue between characters can be more natural and expressive. Show emotions through actions and reactions.
Example: When the grandmother hears the crying woman, instead of just telling what happens, show her internal struggle and decision-making process.
Clarity and Grammar:

Ensure that the grammar and punctuation are correct for clarity. For example, "She is a widow, her husband died 8 years ago due to cardiac arrest" should be "She was a widow; her husband had died eight years ago due to a cardiac arrest."
Watch for run-on sentences and split them for better readability.
Flow and Pacing:

The pacing of the story is good, but some parts can be condensed for better flow. For instance, the grandmother’s decision to leave the hospital can be more concise while retaining emotional impact.
Conclusion and Emotional Impact:

The ending is heartwarming, but reinforcing the grandmother's strength and the emotional bond created can leave a lasting impact.
Example: "A month later, as she read heartfelt letters from the children of the man she had saved, tears of joy filled her eyes. The words 'Thank you, Lola,' written in shaky, innocent penmanship, were a testament to her kindness."
Final Touches:

Add a final reflection or thought from the grandmother to bring closure.
Example: "As she hugged the grateful wife, she realized that even in the darkest times, a single act of kindness could light the way for many."
Overall, your story has a strong foundation with a compelling theme. By refining the details and enhancing the emotional depth, it can become even more powerful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
209
209
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This piece on Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin, better known as Mary Shelley, sets a vivid backdrop for the creation of "Frankenstein." The opening quote, "There is something at work in my soul which I do not understand," immediately establishes a sense of introspection and mystery, which resonates with the themes of Shelley's famous novel.

The passage effectively introduces Mary Shelley's parents, William Godwin and Mary Wollstonecraft, highlighting their progressive beliefs and influence on Mary's upbringing. The mention of Wollstonecraft's death shortly after Mary’s birth adds a tragic note, underscoring the hardships Mary faced from a young age. The complex relationship with her stepmother, Mary Jane Clairmont, and her father’s support, paint a picture of a challenging yet intellectually stimulating environment.

However, the writing could benefit from some polishing for clarity and flow. Here are a few suggestions:

Punctuation and Structure: Some sentences are long and could be broken up to enhance readability. For example:

"When she was conceived, her parents were not married to each other. Both of them believed in free love and making choices on their own without any influence of any custom or authority."
"After about 10 days of giving birth to her, the author of the famous 'Vindication of the Rights of Women' died."
Consistency and Detail: Some details are introduced abruptly. Providing a bit more context could help. For instance:

"Mary despised her stepmother, Mary Jane Clairmont, who made more efforts to educate her half-sisters than Mary."
"Godwin, now known as the Father of Anarchism, did not believe in marriage but married Wollstonecraft to legitimize Mary."
Character Development: While the text mentions Mary's fears and her stepmother's favoritism, elaborating a bit more on these points could add depth. For example:

"Mary was often overshadowed by her stepmother's attention to her half-sisters, which deepened her fear of losing her father’s affection."
Transition: The transition from Godwin's encouragement to his warnings about human nature could be smoother. For example:

"Godwin encouraged Mary to read extensively and pursue her potential, much like her mother. Yet, he also warned her about the darker aspects of human nature, cautioning her against letting inner sadness and fears consume her."
Overall, the piece provides a compelling introduction to Mary Shelley's early life, setting the stage for understanding the influences behind her writing. With a few tweaks, it could be even more engaging and insightful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
210
210
for entry "Hopeless" Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your poem is evocative and captures a deep sense of internal struggle. Here's a more detailed review:

Emotion and Theme: The theme of being trapped within one's mind is powerfully conveyed. The emotions of confusion, mistrust, and yearning are palpable, making the reader empathize with the speaker's plight.

Imagery and Language: Your use of imagery, such as "love burned down to dust" and "a maze of ashen mistrust," paints a vivid picture of the speaker's mental state. The choice of words like "cold," "confused," and "foolishness" effectively highlights the despair and frustration.

Flow and Structure: The poem has a good flow, with a consistent rhythm that enhances the reading experience. The rhyme scheme is maintained well, adding to the overall cohesion of the poem.

Inner Conflict: The lines "Good, bad, right, wrong, love burned down to dust / Losing my soul in a maze of ashen mistrust" effectively depict the internal conflict and the struggle to make sense of emotions and thoughts.

Ending: The poem ends on a powerful note, emphasizing the speaker's isolation and misery. "I stand alone, cold, confused, only misery composed" leaves a lasting impact, reinforcing the sense of hopelessness.

Suggestions for Improvement:
Expansion: You might consider expanding on specific moments or memories that led to these feelings. This could provide more depth and context to the speaker's emotional state.
Contrasts: Introducing moments of fleeting hope or contrast could make the despair even more striking. For instance, mentioning a time when the speaker felt alive could enhance the sense of loss.
Overall, your poem effectively communicates a deep and personal struggle, making it relatable and impactful. Keep writing and exploring these themes, as your ability to convey emotion is quite strong.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
211
211
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your story is delightful and engaging, full of vivid characters and a strong sense of place. Here are some thoughts on it:

Strengths:
Characterization: The dynamics between June and Elsie are well-developed and humorous. Their contrasting personalities create a lively and enjoyable interaction.

Dialogue: The dialogue feels natural and adds to the characterization. Elsie's enthusiastic and optimistic nature contrasts well with June's more practical and somewhat reluctant attitude.

Setting: The descriptions of the drive through the Tennessee countryside and the small-town settings are evocative and help immerse the reader in the story.

Plot: The combination of a treasure hunt and uncovering a theft ring makes for an intriguing and entertaining plot. The twists and turns keep the reader engaged.

Areas for Improvement:

Pacing: The story sometimes feels a bit rushed, especially during the climax when June and Elsie discover the stolen goods and confront the culprits. Adding a bit more detail and slowing down the action in these scenes could enhance the suspense and make the resolution more satisfying.

Clarity of Clues: The riddle about the "cracker barrel building" and the "blue cow's short story" is creative, but it might benefit from a bit more context or explanation to help the reader follow along with the characters' thought process.

Conflict Resolution: The resolution with the police arriving and the culprits being caught feels a bit too convenient. Adding a bit more tension or difficulty in this part could make the ending more impactful.

Specific Suggestions:

Enhance the Suspense: When June and Elsie discover the Apple products, consider adding more descriptive language to build suspense. For example, describe the moment they realize what they've found in more detail, including their physical reactions and thoughts.

Elaborate on the Treasure Hunt: Include more of the treasure hunt clues and tasks to give a fuller picture of the competition. This could also provide more opportunities for character development and humorous moments.

Develop the Climax: Flesh out the confrontation with the clerk and the arrival of the police. Maybe June and Elsie try to leave quietly but get caught, leading to a tense standoff until the police arrive.

Overall Impression:

Your story is a charming and entertaining read with a good mix of humor, mystery, and action. Focusing on the pacing and adding more detail to key scenes can elevate it even further. Keep up the great work!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
212
212
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Song Review: "Oh Yeah – Oh my Gaga"

The song "Oh Yeah – Oh my Gaga" is an electrifying ode to Lady Gaga, blending fervent adoration with evocative imagery. It's structured as a passionate declaration of love and admiration, using repetitive choruses and sultry spoken interludes to create a mesmerizing trance-like effect on the listener.

Lyrics Analysis:

Chorus Repetition:

The repeated lines "Oh yeah – Oh my Gaga, Oh yeah – Oh my Gaga, I’m mesmerized; caught in a trance" serve to emphasize the overwhelming and almost hypnotic admiration the singer feels for Gaga. This repetition is effective in creating a hook that is memorable and engaging.
Theme of Devotion:

Lines like "I’ve given freely, without any strings" and "Wishing for your presence by my side" express a deep, unconditional love. The singer portrays themselves as willing to forsake material wealth for the chance to be with Gaga, highlighting the purity of their affection.
Artistic Admiration:

The lyrics "I want your passion, fashion, and design" and "You’re ICONIC talent and flare" underscore Gaga’s influence as an artist and fashion icon. The singer’s longing for Gaga’s presence is intertwined with an appreciation for her artistic contributions.
Sultry Spoken Interludes:

The use of spoken word, such as "OOH-LA-LA" and "I know that you want me," adds a layer of intimacy and raw emotion. This stylistic choice effectively breaks the flow of the song, drawing attention to the intensity of the singer’s feelings.
Video Concept:

Setting:

The choice of an empty theatre lit by candles in late 1895 New York creates a nostalgic, almost haunting atmosphere. This contrasts sharply with Gaga's modern and avant-garde image, making the visuals intriguing.
Symbolism:

The custodian and the film projector symbolize looking back at Gaga’s illustrious career, while the red roses suggest love and admiration. The custodian’s mask hints at hidden identities and perhaps the universal appeal of Gaga’s persona.
Narrative:

The custodian’s actions, from sweeping the stage to watching the film, represent a journey through Gaga’s career. The final act of picking up a rose and looking at the screen with love ties the narrative together, symbolizing undying admiration.
Imagery:

Ending the video with Gaga in her iconic lightning bolt dress with a teacup captures her quirky and distinctive style. This still, followed by the custodian’s affectionate gesture, leaves a lasting impression of reverence and endearment.
Overall Impression:

"Oh Yeah – Oh my Gaga" is a vivid tribute to Lady Gaga, capturing the essence of fandom through its fervent lyrics and evocative visuals. The song’s repetitive structure and passionate delivery effectively convey the depth of the singer’s admiration. The video concept complements the song by juxtaposing historical and modern elements, creating a memorable and emotionally resonant experience.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
213
213
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This story grabs attention right away with its mix of everyday life and hints of something extraordinary. The narrator starts by wishing their gift, or curse, had a dramatic origin, but quickly admits it might have been there all along, lurking until it surfaced during puberty. This sets up an intriguing premise and keeps the reader curious.

The first encounter with the delivery driver is well-written, capturing the narrator's impatience and the delivery driver's no-nonsense attitude. It grounds the story in reality, making the later supernatural elements more impactful. The narrator's crush on Fiona, an older college student, adds a relatable layer of youthful infatuation and vulnerability.

As the story unfolds, the narrator's gift becomes apparent through a vision they have while attempting to draw Fiona. The vision is disturbing, depicting Fiona in danger from a man with a knife. This part is tense and filled with emotion, effectively conveying the narrator's panic and helplessness. The description of the drawing process is vivid, making the reader feel the urgency and fear the narrator experiences.

The interaction between the narrator and Fiona when she returns is heartbreaking. The narrator struggles to communicate the impending danger, and Fiona's confusion and eventual annoyance add to the emotional weight. The delivery driver and Fiona's reactions provide a believable and human response to the narrator's strange behavior.

The climax of the story, where the narrator's vision comes true, is both satisfying and tragic. Fiona's narrow escape and the acknowledgment from Greg add a bittersweet resolution. The narrator's decision to never return to the café underscores the impact of their experience, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.

Overall, this story is compelling and emotionally engaging. It combines relatable teenage emotions with supernatural elements in a way that feels grounded and real. The writing is clear and descriptive, making it easy to follow and connect with the characters. This story successfully blends the ordinary with the extraordinary, creating a memorable and thought-provoking narrative.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
214
214
Review of Food Feast  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Review of "Food Feast"

Plot and World-Building:
"Food Feast" presents an intriguing and complex universe where various alien communities coexist on an orbital structure. The concept of "Mentally Digesting" information about different communities adds a unique layer to the narrative, indicating a sophisticated technology or ability that helps characters navigate diverse cultures and potential dangers. The story centers on Kaszime, a human protector, and her interactions with Braak, an alien with blue skin and scales, as they investigate mysterious near-deaths and a possible poisoning event within these communities.

Characters:
Kaszime and Braak are well-defined protagonists with a clear sense of duty and professionalism. Kaszime's willingness to "Mentally Digest" information about all communities shows her dedication and thoroughness. Braak, as her helper, provides a grounded and experienced perspective, helping her navigate the complexities of Community Thirty-Seven. Their dynamic is supportive, with a mix of mentorship and collaboration that feels authentic.

Dialogue:
The dialogue is functional and serves to move the plot forward, though it can feel a bit stiff at times. The characters' exchanges about their duties and observations help to build the world and provide necessary exposition. However, some interactions could benefit from more natural conversational flow and emotional depth to make the characters more relatable.

Pacing:
The pacing is steady, with a balance between action scenes, such as the fight between the Hocsons, and investigative moments, like the examination of the food establishment. The story progresses logically from one event to the next, maintaining a sense of urgency as Kaszime and Braak uncover more about the threats in the community.

Conflict and Tension:
The primary conflict revolves around the mysterious illnesses and deaths occurring within the community. The tension is well-maintained as Kaszime and Braak face various challenges, from breaking up fights to dealing with potential biohazards in food establishments. The story effectively keeps the reader engaged by continually presenting new problems and partial solutions that build towards a larger mystery.

Setting and Atmosphere:
The setting of the orbital communities is vividly described, with distinct areas such as the Food Preparation and Food Growth sectors. The atmosphere in each scene is appropriately tense or relaxed, reflecting the immediate concerns of the characters. The blend of futuristic technology and diverse alien cultures creates a rich backdrop for the narrative.

Themes:
"Food Feast" touches on themes of duty, interspecies cooperation, and the complexities of managing a multicultural society. Kaszime's role as a protector highlights the responsibilities of maintaining order and safety, while Braak's support underscores the importance of collaboration across different species.

Suggestions for Improvement:

Character Development: Deepen the emotional aspects of Kaszime and Braak's characters. Show more of their internal thoughts and feelings to make them more relatable and three-dimensional.
Dialogue: Work on making the dialogue more natural. Characters could use contractions more often and speak in a way that reflects their unique personalities and backgrounds.
Conflict Complexity: Introduce more layers to the central conflict. Perhaps there are political tensions or personal stakes for Kaszime and Braak that make their investigation even more pressing.
Descriptive Language: Enhance the descriptive passages to create a more immersive experience. Show more of the sensory details that define life in the orbital communities.
Overall, "Food Feast" is an engaging story with a well-constructed world and a solid plot. With further refinement of character interactions and deeper emotional engagement, it has the potential to be even more compelling.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
215
215
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your letter, "Dear Oedipus," written from the perspective of the Oracle of Delphi, Loki, is quite compelling. It captures the mythical tone and provides a rich narrative that fits well within the context of ancient Greek mythology. Here are some thoughts and suggestions:

Strengths:
Authentic Voice: The tone and style effectively mimic the grandeur and mystique of ancient oracles. It feels like something an oracle might say, filled with confidence and a sense of inevitability about fate.

Engaging Content: The letter is filled with intriguing promises about revealing the past and future, which maintains interest and aligns well with the myth of Oedipus.

Repetition for Emphasis: The repeated assurance that "Your past and your future will come to pass exactly as I inform you that it will" reinforces the oracle's authority and the inevitability of fate.

Areas for Improvement:
Consistency in Tone: While the tone is generally fitting, some modern phrases or expressions occasionally slip in, such as "I am doing all that I can to persuade you to come." Keeping the language consistently archaic and formal would enhance the authenticity.

Character Introduction: Introducing Loki as the Oracle of Delphi can be a bit confusing since Loki is a figure from Norse mythology, not Greek. Clarifying why Loki is in this role or choosing a Greek figure might help maintain coherence.

Conciseness and Clarity: The letter could be more concise in certain sections. Repetition is useful, but some phrases and sentences could be tightened to improve readability without losing the essence of the message.

Emotional Connection: While the letter is informative, adding more emotional depth could make it more compelling. Exploring the personal stakes for Oedipus in greater detail might create a stronger emotional impact.

Suggested Edits:
Tone Consistency:

Original: "I am doing all that I can to persuade you to come."
Suggested: "I implore you, Oedipus, to heed my summons and seek the truth that awaits you."
Character Introduction:

Original: "I am the Oracle of Delphi, Loki, and I heard about your desire to come visit me."
Suggested: "I am the Oracle of Delphi, anointed by the gods to reveal the mysteries of your fate."
Conciseness and Clarity:

Original: "Do not think that by ignoring what you already know in your heart will create a different end than the one I will tell you."
Suggested: "Ignoring your heart's truth will not alter the fate I reveal."
Emotional Connection:

Original: "Your fate is mixed with adventure, unimaginable events, unexpected people, and intriguing mysteries."
Suggested: "Your fate intertwines with adventure, heartache, and profound revelations. Embrace it, for it is the path the gods have chosen for you."
Overall, your letter does a great job of capturing the mythical essence and drawing Oedipus into the narrative. With a few adjustments for tone consistency, character alignment, conciseness, and emotional depth, it can become even more engaging and powerful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
216
216
Review of Untrue  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your piece dives into the complex emotions surrounding a difficult breakup, capturing the tension between love and the necessity of parting ways for the greater good. Here are some thoughts and suggestions to enhance it further:

Strengths:

Emotional Depth: The raw, unfiltered emotion is palpable, making it relatable and engaging. The pain and conflict you describe feel very real.
Narrative Voice: Your voice comes through strongly, which is crucial for a piece like this. It feels personal and genuine.
Intent and Sacrifice: The narrative clearly conveys the sacrifice made for the perceived betterment of both individuals involved, which adds depth to the story.
Areas for Improvement:

Clarity and Structure: The piece could benefit from a bit more structure. Breaking it into paragraphs will make it easier to follow and give readers a moment to digest the intense emotions.
Repetition: Some phrases and ideas are repeated, which can dilute the impact. For instance, "I left to save us" and variations of this thought appear multiple times. Try to consolidate these repetitions to strengthen the message.
Flow and Pacing: The flow of thoughts can feel a bit scattered at times. Consider organizing your ideas more linearly. For example, start with the emotions felt, then move to the reasons behind the decision, and conclude with reflections on the future.
Grammar and Punctuation: There are some grammatical errors and run-on sentences that could be cleaned up. This will make the piece more polished and easier to read.
Revised Version:

You think I've moved on, but that's simply not true. You think I don't feel the pain, sorrow, and anger, but I do. I feel everything, and I feel it all too intensely. I can't help but act like nothing happened because I need to; it saves me. Not facing these feelings head-on is deteriorating my mind and spirit. I know this already, but I can't help it. I need to avoid all the feelings, memories, and consequences of the decision I made for both of us.

I made the hard choice for the first time, but I made it with the wrong person. He thinks I left because I couldn't handle what he was giving me, which isn't true. I left to save us both. I didn't want us to grow to hate each other. I love him deeply and will care for him forever, but I had to leave so he could get better. In time, he'll see that his life will be extraordinarily better without me, though it will be a hard year for him to realize that.

I know he thinks I've moved on and that I left him in his time of need, making him feel betrayed and lied to. But I did what was needed for both of us. If he truly loves me as he claims, he'll see that eventually. Maybe one day, our paths will cross again, whether next year at school or six years from now when our lives are more stable.

Some days, I regret the choice I made, but most days, I'm proud of him and believe he'll be happier in the long run. I will never regret knowing this was the right thing to do, no matter how wrong it feels. I'm putting my faith in God for once. I won't beg God to change things because this is how it must be for now, but hopefully not forever.

This version retains the core emotions and thoughts of your original piece while providing clearer structure and flow. Keep writing and exploring these deep, personal themes. Your voice and story are compelling, and with a bit more polish, they will shine even brighter.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
217
217
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
"The crickets sang their haunting melody" is a poignant and beautifully crafted poem that captures the bittersweet emotions of unrequited love against a backdrop of nature's serene beauty. The poem employs the villanelle form, characterized by its repetition and rhyming scheme, which enhances the thematic elements of longing and persistence.

Strengths
Repetition and Structure:
The use of the villanelle structure, with its repeating lines, serves to emphasize the speaker’s persistent longing and unfulfilled desire. The repeated lines, "The crickets sang their haunting melody" and "I wish you’d sing that song along with me," effectively convey a sense of yearning and a cyclical pattern of hope and disappointment.

Imagery and Setting:
The poem vividly sets the scene with rich imagery of a forest trail, campfire, and the sound of crickets. These elements create a romantic yet melancholic atmosphere, perfect for the unfolding narrative. The natural setting acts as a silent witness to the speaker's emotional journey.

Emotional Depth:
The poem captures the essence of unrequited love and the speaker’s earnest efforts to connect with their beloved. Lines like "Try and try as I might to make you see / my love for you is true, you still withdrew" encapsulate the frustration and sorrow of loving someone who doesn't reciprocate those feelings.

Symbolism:
The crickets' song symbolizes the ongoing, haunting nature of the speaker's love and longing. The repeated reference to their "haunting melody" ties together the natural world with the speaker’s inner emotional state, creating a seamless blend of external and internal experiences.

Areas for Improvement
Variety in Imagery:
While the repetition serves the villanelle form well, a bit more variety in the imagery within the non-repeating lines could add more depth and interest to the poem. Exploring additional sensory details or different aspects of the setting might enrich the narrative.

Character Interaction:
The poem focuses heavily on the speaker’s perspective. Including more interaction or dialogue between the speaker and their beloved could provide greater insight into the dynamics of their relationship and the reasons behind the beloved’s resistance.

Conclusion:
The poem ends on a note of continued longing with the repeated refrain. While this is effective, a stronger concluding stanza that perhaps hints at resolution or acceptance could offer a more impactful closure to the emotional journey.

Overall Impression
"The crickets sang their haunting melody" is a touching and well-executed poem that successfully uses the villanelle form to explore themes of love, longing, and nature. Its strengths lie in its emotive repetition and evocative imagery. With minor adjustments to vary the imagery and deepen the character interaction, the poem could reach even greater emotional and narrative heights. Overall, it is a memorable piece that resonates with anyone who has experienced the ache of unreciprocated affection.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
218
218
Review of Freeway  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem captures the frenetic energy and relentless movement of freeway life, painting a vivid picture of the day-to-day rush and the overwhelming nature of urban existence. Let's break down some of the key elements that stand out:

Imagery and Language: The use of vivid imagery, like "Ribbons of molten light" and "Shimmering metallic ants," brings the freeway scenes to life. The comparison to "molten light" suggests both beauty and danger, while "metallic ants" highlights the mechanical, almost lifeless nature of the cars. The language is rich and evocative, pulling the reader into the sensory experience of the freeway.

Rhythm and Flow: The poem has a rhythmic quality that mimics the constant motion of traffic. Lines like "Snake swiftly / Out of sight" and "Rush through the freeway morning crush" flow smoothly, much like the cars they describe. This rhythm helps convey the sense of relentless movement and the unending cycle of the freeway.

Theme and Emotion: There's a strong sense of critique towards the urban lifestyle. The repeated references to the endless nature of the freeway ("endless appetites," "endless freeway course") suggest a never-ending cycle that's exhausting and perhaps futile. The final lines, "Until at last I wake in fright. / Just a nightmare, / She’ll be right," introduce a personal reaction to this chaos. The nightmare might symbolize the anxiety and stress of modern life, while "She’ll be right" seems to offer a bit of reassurance, perhaps a nod to the resilience of the human spirit.

Structure: The poem's structure, with its short, clipped lines and stanzas, mirrors the stop-and-go nature of traffic. This structure reinforces the themes of interruption and constant movement. The break towards the end, leading to the personal reflection, provides a shift in tone that brings the poem to a thoughtful close.

Overall, the poem is a compelling portrayal of the freeway's ceaseless activity and its impact on the human psyche. It combines strong imagery with a rhythmic flow and explores deeper themes of modern life and its anxieties. The final reassurance provides a hopeful contrast to the otherwise intense depiction of urban chaos.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
219
219
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
I Saw the Whole Thing
WC 299


The notebook creaked as It opened. Graphite hit paper as I gave my account to Detective Iverson.

“Mrs. Ingram, is it?”

“It’s Miss.”

“To the best of your recollection, Miss Ingram, tell me what you saw.”

“I saw the whole thing!”

“She saw the whole thing,” he called out.

Thundering gumshoes hit asphalt as they closed in.

What they didn’t know was that I hadn’t seen anything. My friend, Ben, was being accused of a crime. Assuming he was guilty, they slapped the cuffs on him and drove away, sirens blaring. I had to defend him.

“Well, I was supposed to meet my friend, Ben—”

“The accused?”

“Yes. But I got here first. There was a man yelling something—”

“The deceased?”

“Yes,” I said. “And behind him was another man in a red jacket. He was holding the murder weapon.”

“Ben Adler shot this man in cold blood. There was no other man, Miss Ingram,” he said, a decibel too loud.

“You asked me. That’s what I saw. The guy shot him and ran. That’s when Ben arrived,” I continued. “And then we heard sirens and you guys showed up.”

“Ben Adler had the weapon in his hand!”

“The murderer dropped it, and Ben picked it up, in case we needed to defend ourselves,” I said. “That’s everything, start to finish.”

A cacophony of voices filled the air as Detective Iverson shared my information. I prayed my account would give Ben a fighting chance.

Truth?

I never saw anything, but the cops don’t know that. I hope they don’t make me come down to the station. They’ll realize I’m blind and throw the book at me.

Maybe Ben and I will share a cell. I’d like that…unless he did it.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
220
220
Review of Fear  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
"Fear" by Keaton Foster is an intense and powerful poem that explores deep emotions and the impact of fear on an individual's life. The poem's fragmented structure and use of repetition amplify the feelings of anxiety and despair, creating a haunting atmosphere that resonates with readers.

The use of short, sharp lines like "Fear / Is near" and "Hope / Is not" immediately sets a tone of foreboding. The juxtaposition of fear and hope establishes a contrast that runs throughout the poem, highlighting the absence of positive emotions and the overwhelming presence of negative ones. This choice of words emphasizes the intensity of the emotions being described, making the reader feel the weight of each line.

The poem delves into themes of inner turmoil and external conflict. Lines like "Bones / Are broken" and "Heart / Is missing" suggest physical and emotional pain, while "War / Rages on" indicates a continuous struggle. The poet's use of "Within / Without" conveys a sense of being trapped by fear both internally and externally. This duality of struggle is a powerful reflection of the human experience when dealing with fear and anxiety.

The repetition of "Fear" throughout the poem reinforces its pervasive nature, making it clear that fear is not just an emotion but a state of being that affects every aspect of the poet's life. The line "Fear / A hell of way / Indeed / To live…" serves as a poignant conclusion, summarizing the exhausting and all-encompassing nature of living in fear.

The poem also touches on themes of betrayal, isolation, and the search for understanding. Lines like "Betraying you / Fooling myself" and "Alone / Am I" convey a deep sense of loneliness and self-deception. The mention of "God" and "Family" being broken adds a layer of existential and relational crisis, suggesting a loss of faith and support systems.

Foster's choice of imagery, such as "Words / Weapons" and "Poems / Turned statements," indicates a struggle with communication and expression. This imagery suggests that words, which are typically tools for connection and understanding, have become instruments of harm and misunderstanding.

Overall, "Fear" is a raw and evocative piece that captures the essence of living with constant dread and the psychological toll it takes. Foster's use of fragmented lines, repetition, and stark imagery effectively conveys the pervasive and destructive nature of fear, making this poem a compelling read.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
221
221
Review of Unfolding Self  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your poem beautifully uses the metaphor of a book to describe your journey of self-discovery. Here’s a more detailed review:

Metaphor and Imagery:

The metaphor of seeing oneself as a book is compelling. It allows readers to easily understand the complexity of a person's life, with its different chapters and pages representing various experiences and memories.
The imagery of "favorite chapters" and "pages...I no longer want to re-read" is vivid. It conveys the idea that some memories are cherished while others are painful or best forgotten.
Themes and Emotions:

Acceptance and Self-Awareness: The poem reflects a deep understanding of oneself, acknowledging both the positive and negative parts of life.
Resilience: There's an underlying theme of resilience, as you mention continuing to discover yourself despite the parts you'd rather forget.
Individuality: You emphasize the uniqueness of your story and the importance of living your own narrative, which adds a personal and relatable touch.
Structure and Flow:

The free verse structure works well for this type of reflective poetry. It allows for a natural flow of thoughts and emotions.
The repetition of certain phrases, like "I have" and "I am," reinforces the introspective tone and gives the poem a rhythm, even without a strict rhyme scheme.
Language and Tone:

The language is straightforward yet evocative, making it accessible while still being profound.
The tone is contemplative and introspective, which suits the theme of self-discovery and personal growth.
Suggestions for Improvement:

Consistency in Tense and Pronouns: The shift from "I" to "a like anybody else" could be smoother. Consider changing "a like anybody else" to "like anyone else" for grammatical consistency.
Polishing Phrasing: The line "I badly desire to just tear down and be forgotten" could be refined for clarity. Perhaps, "that I desperately wish I could tear out and forget" would maintain the intensity while being clearer.
Conclusion: The final lines affirming the value of your own story are powerful. Ensure they stand out by perhaps adding a pause or break before them, making them a distinct, impactful ending.
Overall, your poem is a heartfelt and insightful piece that effectively uses metaphor and imagery to convey the complexity of personal growth and self-acceptance. With a few minor adjustments, it can become even more polished and impactful. Keep writing and exploring your unique narrative!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
222
222
for entry "Maryann's Monkey" Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Your story, "Mighty Maryann, mistress of Marvel Mango Milkshake Makers," is fun and whimsical. Here are a few points to consider to make it even better:

Strengths:
Alliteration: Your use of alliteration is impressive and adds a playful rhythm to the story. It gives a unique flavor that fits the light-hearted tone.
Humor: The humor in the narrative, especially the playful conflict between Monkey and Jolly Jim, keeps the story entertaining.
Character Names: The names are memorable and add to the story’s charm. Maryann, the Monkey, and Jolly Jim are all vivid characters that contribute to the whimsical setting.
Areas for Improvement:
Clarity and Flow: While the alliteration is engaging, it occasionally makes the story hard to follow. Simplifying some sentences without losing the playful tone could help. For example, "Mighty Maryann, mistress of Marvel Mango Milkshake Makers, managed menu mischief all Monday morning" is great, but "Maryann's meandering Monkey made mistakes" could be clearer as "Maryann's Monkey made mistakes by missing messages and messing up ingredients."
Character Development: Adding a bit more detail about Maryann and the Monkey could help readers connect with them. Why is the Monkey making mistakes? Is he new to the job or just having a bad day?
Resolution: The ending feels a bit rushed. The transition from conflict to resolution could be smoother. Maybe show a bit more interaction between Maryann, the Monkey, and Jolly Jim before the apology.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
223
223
Review of Strange Love  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your writing captures the complexity of love in a thoughtful way, highlighting the uniqueness of loving someone despite their flaws and unconventional traits. Here are a few suggestions to enhance clarity and flow:

Original: It's strange that you still love someone eventhough she has flaws.

Revised: It's strange that you still love someone even though she has flaws.

Original: Unusually, you love someone who is considered unconventional.

Revised: It's unusual to love someone who is considered unconventional.

Original: Remarkably, you love someone who has an empty heart or perhaps a barren land where flowers no longer bloom.

Revised: Remarkably, you love someone with an empty heart, like a barren land where flowers no longer bloom.

Original: It's extraordinary that you love someone opposite to you.

Revised: It's extraordinary to love someone who is opposite to you.

Original: It's peculiar that you love someone who, is judged by others' standards.

Revised: It's peculiar to love someone judged by others' standards.

Original: Intriguingly, you love someone who embodies both introversion and extroversion.

Revised: Intriguingly, you love someone who embodies both introversion and extroversion.

Your descriptions effectively convey the paradoxes and challenges of love, emphasizing its depth and resilience. By refining some of the sentences, the message becomes even clearer and more impactful. Keep focusing on these unique contrasts and your writing will continue to engage and resonate with readers.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
224
224
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your poem beautifully captures the profound sacrifice and the significance of Jesus Christ's crucifixion and birth. It weaves together the stark reality of His suffering and the spiritual hope that His sacrifice brings to believers. Here are some thoughts on your work:

Emotional Depth: The imagery of Christ on the cross is powerful and evokes a strong emotional response. Words like "bludgeoned," "berated," "vicious," and "agonizing" effectively convey the intensity of His suffering. This draws the reader into the gravity of the moment and the ultimate sacrifice made for humanity.

Spiritual Reflection: The poem transitions from the crucifixion to the broader spiritual context of Christ's role in salvation. By mentioning "Our Holy Father’s decision" and "enter His forever-resplendent kingdom," you emphasize the theological significance of these events. This reflection on divine purpose helps ground the narrative in its religious context.

Contrast of Events: Juxtaposing the agonizing defeat on the cross with the joyful celebration of Christmas creates a powerful contrast. This highlights the full spectrum of Christ's life and mission—from His humble birth to His sacrificial death. It underscores the importance of both events in Christian faith.

Celebration of Christmas: The latter part of the poem shifts to the joyous celebration of Christ’s birth. Describing Christmas as a time of "wondrous passion" and "enlightened respect" brings a sense of warmth and reverence. This balances the earlier somber tone and reminds readers of the hope and love that Christ's birth symbolizes.

Language and Style: The language used is both poetic and accessible, making the themes relatable while maintaining a respectful tone. The choice of words and the flow of the poem maintain a reverent and contemplative mood, suitable for the subject matter.

Overall, your poem effectively captures the dual nature of Christ's story—the suffering and the joy, the sacrifice and the salvation. It's a reflective piece that invites readers to contemplate the depth of Christ's love and the significance of His life and death.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
225
225
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
"Red Bird in Snow" is a captivating tale that blends the serene beauty of a winter landscape with a poignant message about the consequences of our deepest desires. The narrative's simplicity makes it accessible, yet it carries a powerful twist that leaves a lasting impression.

The story begins with an elderly man walking through the snowy woods near his home, a setting that evokes a sense of calm and reflection. This tranquil scene is abruptly interrupted when he encounters a red bird stuck in a snowdrift. The old man's act of kindness in freeing the bird sets the stage for the unfolding magical events.

The red bird reveals itself to be magical, offering the man a single wish as a token of gratitude. The warning to be careful with wishes is a classic trope, preparing the reader for the twist to come. The man's wish to be with his wife forever is heartfelt and speaks to the universal desire for eternal love and companionship.

As the story progresses, the man returns home to share the extraordinary encounter with his wife. Their shared smile and the anticipation of the wish coming true create a warm, hopeful moment. However, the story takes a dark turn at midnight when the Grim Reaper arrives, accompanied by the red bird. This twist is both shocking and thought-provoking, as the man's wish is granted in an unexpected and literal manner.

The ending is powerful, illustrating the theme that wishes can have unintended consequences. The arrival of death for both the man and his wife underscores the finality and permanence of their togetherness, a bittersweet fulfillment of the man's wish.

Overall, "Red Bird in Snow" is a well-crafted story with a strong emotional impact. Its concise narrative and effective use of a plot twist make it memorable. The story encourages readers to reflect on the nature of their desires and the potential costs of getting what they wish for.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
745 Reviews • *Magnify*
Page of 30 • 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/rick12221/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9