*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/riot/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11
Review Requests: OFF
1,559 Public Reviews Given
2,107 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
My reviews typically cover: initial responses, technicalities and mechanics, favorite parts, areas of improvement, and overall impression.
I'm good at...
Honesty, and finding what works versus what doesn't work. I will never give you a rating I don't think your work deserves. I am also particularly good at spotting grammatical errors and typos.
Favorite Genres
Philosophy, Steampunk, Horror, Dark, Emotional, Science Fiction, Technology, and Political Science. I'm sure there are more that I'm missing.
Least Favorite Genres
Romance, Western, Religious, and anything froufrou.
I will not review...
Chapters and Novels, unless arrangements are made prior.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 7 8 9 10 -11- 12 13 14 15 16 ... Next
251
251
Review of Onward  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Heart* I am reviewing you on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*


Hello there!

I found this to be an interesting perception into the 'what if' of space exploration. It was a decent science fiction write that I felt touched a topic of great concern and controversy, and done tastefully.

I'm not sure how I feel about the ending, to be honest. I'm left with a mix of emotions, neither great or horrible. I liked the use of key words, like Titus and Cassius, as it's something mankind favors when naming their crafts and the like.

If I were to make a suggestion, I think I'd like the ending to have more focus on the robotics in the beginning. Although I have no problem with the change of characters and focus, I felt like there may be a missing piece somewhere in there since so much effort was described in the robot's descriptions and movement.

Overall, I liked this short science fiction piece, and I feel it'd be a good candidate for a longer story. *Thumbsup*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
252
252
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*


Hello Shannon!

I found this simple style of 'dairy' entries to be saddening and touching at the same time. Although the source is not directly known, I think that's alright, as it allows the reader to wonder and use their imagination. Since it incorporates feelings that most people can relate to, it advances a personal emotion from the reader.

Well done! *Smile*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
253
253
Review of Dark Spaces  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)


         Hello, Pat! *Bigsmile*

         
I'm reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum . Congratulations on being part of this week's review picks! *Star*


          *Captainwheel* Name, Teaser, Genres
         
I love the title of this poem. In its simplicity I really feel as though it captures the overall mood, while giving the reader a glimpse of what's to come. *Thumbsup*


          *Hourglass* Rhythm and Rhyme
         
Although I wasn't able to detect a direct structure, I felt this poem did have a clear rhythm to it.


          *Thought* Word Choice
         
I applaud the word choices in this poem because I think they directly influence the dark mood of the poem and the narrator's voice. The story within speaks of harsh words and reckless abandon, but the underlying silences beneath the surface. I found these combinations to be particularly contrasting: silences sobs, whispered apologies, disquieting memories, hazy spaces, and rage churns. *Thumbsup*


          *Nuclear* Favorite Part
         
It's always hard to state one's favorite part in a poem like this. In any event, I feel as though I can appreciate the authors work through either the work written or boldness to post something so personal. I would have to say that my favorite part in this poem is not any specific line in particular, but rather the overall composition of it. *Thumbsup*


          *Fleurdelis* Imagery and Feel
         
Even though the poem does not directly speak of reiteration and the cycle of emotion, it gives glimpse of the 'morrow and how the pattern repeats. While it's true that the reader can clearly see the angst of the author, there are other 'unseen' emotions that the reader can relate to, such as the repeating cycle, tension, sympathy, and helplessness.


          *Star* *Star* *Star* *Star* *Halfstar* Overall Impression
         
The notes at the bottom relieve me in that this isn't directly personal, but I think you did a remarkable job at setting a mood that a reader can relate to. Thank you for sharing this with us, and keep up the great work! *Smile*



Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
254
254
Review of My Journey  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
*Vine2**Heart**Vine1* This review brought to you by "Invalid Item *Vine2**Heart**Vine1*


Hi there Nadine,

I found your first item on the site by randomly browsing your portfolio. I think your item is labeled just fine, and I see you've utilized the three genre categories to their fullest. *Thumbsup*

I couldn't help but notice that this item has a 3.5 average rating, and I thought I'd point out that maybe it's because this seems more like a journal entry than anything. I think a lot of what you have written here could even be used in your bioblock, which is a brief description that you can fill out about yourself on your profile  .

Reading your entry over a couple of times, I felt as though I got to know you a little bit. From the sounds of it, you're determined to succeed, and I admire jumping out there and putting it all in the open. I hope you decide to stick around and post some more writing! *Smile*


Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

"Invalid Item :
255
255
Review of " BEAUTIFUL''  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  
Rated: E | (2.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
*Vine2**Heart**Vine1* This review brought to you through "Invalid Item *Vine2**Heart**Vine1*


         Hello Vineetaa,

          *Captainwheel* Name, Teaser, Genres
         
The title is simplistic, and although it does fit the poem, I wonder if the emotions within the poem call for something a little more descriptive.


          *Thought* Word Choice
         
I thought there were some pleasant word combinations in your poem. I particularly liked jumps in the sky, catches the stars, tarnished flowers, and eyes having rain water *Thumbsup*


          *Fleurdelis* Imagery and Feel
         
I think the teaser says it best when it describes this poem as being a conduit for the author's own inner peace. As with the word choices I liked in the section above, I do feel there's some imagery in the poem, even though some of them are highly abstract.


          *Key* Meter and Flow
         
I feel like the meter and flow was lost in this poem. I recognize that it's a free-verse, but there wasn't any hint as to how the reader could grasp reading this internally or even just out-loud. How do you feel reading it out loud? Does it feel perhaps more like abstract prose, maybe?


          *Magnify* Mechanics
         
I think part of the reason this poem was difficult to read is because it was written entirely in capital letters. Although you did place punctuation at the end of the lines, I felt as though you only put commas there to make it uniform and not because they were actually needed. I think if you were to write this with proper capitalization, or even just capitalize the first letter in each stanza, it would be much easier to read.

I've also found with poetry (capital letters aside) that end-line punctuation is not always a must. With the way you fragment the lines, words, and phrases, I think your poem might actually do more justice without any end-line punctuation.


          *Nuclear* Favorite Part
         
My favorite part was the second stanza. I like the imagery, and the abstract nature of it. *Thumbsup*


          *Star* *Star* *Halfstar* Overall Impression
         
I rated this a 2.5 because I think you need to revisit this item and check the technicalities of the writing. I believe you have strong abstract imagery and feel within this poem, but the presentation of it needs a lot of work. This is not a personal attack by any means, it's just difficult to read in the form that it is right now. If you ever decide to rework this poem or change it in any way, I'd be happy to come back and take another look at it. I definitely see where this poem is going, and I really hope that you continue on with it. *Smile*



Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
256
256
Review by Riot
In affiliation with Rising Stars of WdC  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* This review brought to you by "Random Thoughts and Cares through "Retired Founder, Rising Stars Program *Star*


Hello, Just an Ordinary Boo! *Smile*

While looking through your port, I came across this free-style poem. What sparked my interest, aside from its free-verse promise, was its title. Although the teaser gives hint at what's in store, I felt as though this poem was more philosophical in nature, in that it could be interpreted in many ways. Separation occurs, and how often can we see this in every day living? *Thumbsup*

I enjoyed this immediately on the first read through, and I was impressed at certain word combinations that pleased my senses. Some, but not all of them, were: cheeked pebbles, silver strands, recede reluctantly, and jeering sun.

If I had to pick a favorite part, it would be stanza four. I've revisited this stanza a few times now, and I think I still have things to mull over. In my opinion, this is always a really good quality in a poem. *Smile*

I also like that the ending stanza is comprised only of questions, and that this is the only place they're posed. It inspires the reader to ponder, to think, to re-read.

Overall, this poem got me thinking. Thank you for sharing it with me, it's a well written read!



Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

257
257
Review of The Dream Door  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Not all who wander are lost.

Congratulations on your nomination into "Ink Blot Hall of Fame PatrickB and "Invalid Item
Along with your nomination, you are also receiving the J.R.R. Tolkien Fan Package!
This package includes many things, one of which is this review from the "Invalid Item!


Hey again! *Smile*

I am always impressed by the work you place within your portfolio. It's obvious that everything you write is constructed with care and attention. Tonight, or this morning if you will, I had the pleasure of looking over the poem "The Dream Door"

My husband has a real knack for seeing meaning behind things within stories that are not the actual focus of the story. I believe in literature it's called MacGuffin. Perhaps it's only limited to television, but I think it pertains to this poem and the blanket. By definition it means a plot element that catches the viewers' attention or drives the plot and in the case of the poem here, I feel as though the act of sewing the blanket and providing a shield is more of a MacGuffin than anything. It allowed the child a focus, a purpose, and faith. I found it to be very heart warming.

Like the other poem I reviewed of yours, I found this to be a worthwhile and touching read. If you were to ever go back and modify this, my thoughts would be to read it out loud once over, and then read the stanzas individually. If you take them out of order, you may find where some of those minor bumps are in flow; it's nothing huge, mind you, but noticeable out loud.

Going back to what I said earlier about story-telling, I think you have a real knack for it. I'm honored to stumble into your port today. Thank you for sharing. *Smile*


Write on!
Riot

*Heart* Want to give back to your favorite author? Buy them a package to show your appreciation! *Heart*
"Invalid Item
258
258
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Not all who wander are lost.

Congratulations on your nomination into "Ink Blot Hall of Fame PatrickB and "Invalid Item
Along with your nomination, you are also receiving the J.R.R. Tolkien Fan Package!
This package includes many things, one of which is this review from the "Invalid Item!


Heya there! *Smile*


What I liked best about this poem was the narration and careful flow from line to line. I've been considering poetry a lot lately, and I've found that I have a deeper appreciation for near-rhymes that I just didn't before. Although there are exact rhymes in your poem, which you know, I felt that the added 'near-rhyme' was pleasant. For example, bestow/glow, mind/confined.

I think that you did a good job at making this a little on the longer side, in that you kept the imagery alive through descriptions. Key word combinations that I especially appreciated were: holy rift, symbol of that long lost time, worn surface bore, culmination of his schemes, and thin veneer.

This poem left me thinking, and re-reading, which I always find impressive. While I don't pretend to be the master of poetry and storytelling, I would rate this a four and a half only because there were some minor repetitions in rhyming (like with prize/eyes, eye/buy) that I felt could be embellished.

Thank you for sharing this poem with us, I am glad to have come across it! *Smile*


Write on!
Riot

*Heart* Want to give back to your favorite author? Buy them a package to show your appreciation! *Heart*
"Invalid Item
259
259
Review by Riot
In affiliation with Rising Stars of WdC  
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
*Star* This review brought to you by "Random Thoughts and Cares through "Retired Founder, Rising Stars Program *Star*


          *Captainwheel* Name, Teaser, Genres
         
The title of this short story may be from a phrase that's familiar, but it's fitting given the piece. It also sparked my curiosity as to what the story was about, since it could be used in many situations. The use of Gothic and Horror/Scary are also good choices. *Smile*


          *Anchor* Introduction and Hook
         
I thought that including Judges 11:32 in the beginning was fitting. I also think that there was some amazing imagery included in the beginning: singular volcanic peak arising from the sea defines the waves was my favorite, although homespun miasma and scar seared were also great uses.


          *Recycle* Sentence Variation
         
Your sentence variations seem to be pretty good. Most of them are in the ballpark for average length, and for those that are on the shorter side I think the emphases was done well.


          *Male**Female* Pacing and Pronouns
         
Some first names and pronouns I came across skimming it over again: they, she, Poppa, I, Momma, Mitzi, Aaron, Timmie, her, he, we, Jeff. I think you did a great job alternating the pronouns so that no single name was overly used. *Thumbsup*


          *Tools* Clichés and Redundancies
         
I didn't notice any clichés that really stuck out, and I think the meat of your words are varied well. I did spot on area where I think the sentence sounds strong without the repetition of 'was there'.
*Bullet* My older brother Jeff[,] was there too, reading the sports pages. ~ Since you already said that 'Pappa was there' and you're adding Jeff into the mix, I think it goes without saying that he was there. It cuts down on 'was there' being back to back, and helps the readability a bit since they're not parallel statements.


          *Thought* Characters and Dialog
         
I felt as though through dialog your characters really came to life. I was able to get a feel for who they were simply by the way they reacted to each other and their speech mannerism. Momma insisted on respect, Aaron was perhaps a bit of a rebel through the taunting jeer of being a Momma's boy, etc. I also adored the description of Mitzi with her corkscrew curls, and was haunted by the descriptions in the end.


          *Earth* Story Development
         
Like all of the good stories out there, this one contained a multitude of different things. It had background, a memory, and horror that sticks with the reader.


          *Magnify* Technicalities
         
*Bullet* Today was the day! Today was Mayfair! *Thumbsup*
*Bullet* Giggling and squirming were uncalled for. ~ I wonder if simply 'inappropriate' would fit better with Poppa's theme. It seems to command more authority.
*Bullet* He straightened his disciplined and weathered body[,] and then he reached out. ~ You don't need a comma after disciplined because that and weathered body are his description, but you might want to consider a comma after body because it becomes it separates clauses.
*Bullet* I felt Mitzi squeeze my hand[,] and I passed it on to Momma. ~ Placing a comma here separates the clauses and improves clarity.
*Bullet* Mike pushed at me[,] and I fell in the dust. ~ Both parts of this sentence can stand on their own, and the comma separates the clauses.
*Bullet* In my next memory of that day[,] I am at Mayfair, hidden... ~ The first part of this sentence is an introductory expression.



          *Star* *Star* *Star* *Star* *Halfstar* Overall Impression
         I gave you this rating because I enjoyed the story. It's clear you put a lot of time and effort into this piece of work, and it really shows through. Thank you for sharing this with us! *Smile*



Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

260
260
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Heart* I am reviewing you on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*


Hi Nicki! *Smile*

I couldn't begin to give you a line by line on all the work you've put into this, but I'm sure if I did it would be difficult to find errors or ways to improve. Considering your status in this challenge, I think your work definitely speaks for itself here. In case you missed the compliment, that means I think it's wonderful! *Bigsmile*

I love that you are able to be so creative in everything you do on the site and that through your artistic skills and imagination pieces of you shine through the cracks.

Keep up the excellent work and good luck!



Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
261
261
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
*Heart* I am reviewing you on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*


Hi Harry! *Heart*

It's always such a pleasure to browse your writing. This morning I had a chance to read "Who Were the Savages?. Although the subject and nature of the poem is truly tragic, I think you depicted a strong sense of longing, loss, and history in this poem.

Although I own nearly all of your books, your poetry books are my favorite for reasons such as poems like this. What I liked the best of this is the way the lines transitionally flow smoothly from one line to the next. Despite picking pieces from 'mid sentence' they still make sense in context and are visually appealing to the eye.

I have no offers for improvement on this poem, as usually is the case with your writing. Thank you for continuing to write such wonderful poetry!


Write On!
Riot
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
262
262
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
But people themselves alter so much, that there is something new to be observed in them forever.

Congratulations on your nomination into "Ink Blot Hall of Fame
Along with your nomination, you are also receiving the Jane Austen Fan Package!
This package includes many things, one of which is this review from the "Invalid Item!



Heya again! *Bigsmile*

I have enjoyed coming to this item several times, and now I have the honor of being among the excellent writers of your choice! *Blush*

I felt that this was worthy of a full review because it's an excellent work in progress. You created this in January of 2002! That's a whopping nine years of keeping track of this and being faithful. I think that's truly remarkable.

I think that the rules you set for yourself are good ones and very reasonable, although I can't imagine why anyone would be rude to you after giving them a compliment such as being on this list.

Thank you for sharing this with the site. I will enjoy continuing through this list as time goes on!



Write on!
Riot

*Heart* Want to spoil your favorite author? Buy them a package to show your appreciation! *Heart*
"Invalid Item
263
263
Review of Before 8 November  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello, ♥Hooves♥ *Smile*

          *Captainwheel* Name, Teaser, Genres
         
The title as just a date had me curious, especially when I noticed it was poetry. I actually asked myself, before reading the poem, "What's November 8th?" The teaser doesn't give me clue, but it still provides adequate information. Romance and Love are good use of the genres, but I wonder how come you didn't use the other two spots? *Wink*


          *Hourglass* Rhythm and Rhyme
         
I love the rhythm and couplets that make up this four stanza poem. There's a certain rhythm that seems to be expected from couplets, which I think you managed well. I like that the rhymes you provided were simplistic and uncomplicated, unlike the subject matter.


          *Thought* Word Choice
         
Like the rhyme, I would have to say I enjoyed the simplistic nature of your word choice. Not just in the rhymes either, but for the imagery as well. Except for the last stanza, there are actual months listed which helped this reader visualize (and feel) with more senses, as the passage as time came and went.


          *Key* Meter and Flow
         
There were two spots that I got tripped up a little on. The last line in the first stanza and the last line in the third. This could be an intentional pace change, but I can't be sure. I think with the first, it could be merely in that I'm not sure if I should pronounce '8' as 'eighth' or 'eight' - if that makes sense. For the second, I suspect it's due to March being one syllable compared to November/December with two syllables. My brain was expecting a different pace.


          *Nuclear* Favorite Part
         
My favorite part isn't anything that's really fancy: Your hand was not yet laced in mine? - For some reason, this pointed and unassuming question really put me in the time, place and feel of the poem. It created an image most of us can relate to, a yearning even. It really stuck out to me.


          *Magnify* Mechanics
         
Other than taking a look at those two lines I mentioned earlier, I think the mechanics are just fine. I don't see any room for improvement on grammar or punctuation.


          *Star* *Star* *Star* *Star* *Halfstar* Overall Impression
         
To reiterate my entire review, I found this to be a lovely read. It made me contemplate a lot and self reflect down memory lane. Thank you for sharing this! Excellently done!




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
264
264
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of the "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, Revelry new writings soon *Smile*


My husband would really get a kick out of this poem, as he's absolutely fanatical about Batman. Although there are several perfectly great villains, it can't be denied that there's something deliciously dark about The Joker.

With the exception of a semi-repeated stanza, I couldn't find a specific pattern, but I think that's just fine. If anything, I'd say that the lack of it only further strengthens the tone of the character being portrayed. Very fitting. *Thumbsup*

On an end note, I was also pleased to see the green on purple addition to THE Joker. Awesome! *Bigsmile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
265
265
Review of Release  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with JUST BECAUSE I WANT TO FORUM T...  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
*Heart* I am reviewing you on behalf of "JUST BECAUSE I WANT TO FORUM TEMP CLOSED *Heart*

*Delight* This is your second review for your package from ~A.J. Lyle~ , who wants to say, "Congratulations on your promotion!" *Delight*

Hello again, warriormom *Smile*

I love this poem! The picture that you've provided at the top really helps set the mood. I think it's great how the edge peels back like it does and how a bit of a 'wave' was added to it.

I think the imagery in this poem is really great. I especially like taunting grass and the feeling of one's release in the last stanza. The way tendrils describes her flowing hair, as well as the references to her skin, really help this reader feel the emotions intended by the poem.

Excellent work! Worthy of its awards, most definitely!



Write On!
Riot
266
266
Review of A sin!  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (3.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Be natural my children. For the writer that is natural has fulfilled all the rules of art.

Congratulations on your nomination into "Ink Blot Hall of Fame by jannie
Along with your nomination, you are also receiving the Charles Dickens Fan Package!
This package includes many things, one of which is this review from the "Invalid Item!



Hello, Marcus *Smile*

I think the variation in sentence structure is pretty well even. There are a couple of smaller sentences, but they seem to be well placed.

There were a couple of cliche phrases, namely: the last straw, the kiss of life, and bad day of bad days, but as long as you're aware of them and feel they fit the narration, I think they should be fine. Also, I couldn't find any redundancies worth noting except for noticed. (How's that for irony? *Wink*)

Paragraph four appears to be a past tense note with the phrase had taken, but I don't think it was meant to sound that way in that context. Perhaps took. I find that the same pattern arises in paragraph fifteen, but I think that can easily be remedied by removing it was realised.

*Woman* On the topic of first names and pronouns, there weren't many instances, so I felt that perhaps alternating between Steph and She more may feel evenly spaced. I thought the use of complex words was well done and also tastefully used.

*Thumbsup* Looking back, I'm surprised that I didn't spot any dialog. Given the detective style, I'm rather impressed!

*Questionbl* Should Office Manager be capitalized? Do you feel this is his name, or title, given it's prefixed with the?
*Questionbl* I think the c in Clients in the parenthesis needs to be lowercase. Better yet, maybe it could be integrated into a parenthetical phrase separated by commas rather than the actual parenthesis brackets.
*Questionbl* Unfortunately[,] this proved to be...
*Questionbl* Amazingly[,] a lemon flavoured lollipop flew...
*Up* With both phrases above: Since they are sentences that begin with introductory phrases, there should be a comma.
*Questionbl* Unfortunately[,] in the rush[,] no one... - Both introductory and parenthetical. You may want to look over this one carefully and decide how you want it to sound.
*Questionbl* ...bad day of bad days[,] and he exploded into...
*Questionbl* ...the clerks stopped kissing Steph[,] and it was suggested...
*Up* With both phrases above: Each comma suggestion separates the sentences because they're coordinated clauses.
*Questionbl* The moral of this sad[,] sad story is[:] [thou shall not steal.] - There's not much rewrite here. I don't think that the capitalized ending was necessary because it disobeyed the laws of narration and grammar that you appeared to put care into. With it being on one line, I don't feel as though it changes the meaning of the ending. *Smile*

*Reading* Overall, I thought this was a nice morning read. The reason I'm giving you a three star, which is considered average rating, is because of the above mentioned observations. Also, this is listed as drama and tragedy, but I felt as though the co-workers reactions to the choking Steph verged on satire in the way it was narrated, and I found their reactions to be unbelievable. If you decide to make further edits to this piece though, I'd be happy to come back and re-read and re-rate your piece.

Thank you for sharing! *Smile*



Write on!
Riot

*Heart* Want to spoil your favorite author? Buy them a package to show your appreciation! *Heart*
"Invalid Item

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
267
267
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, Sir Paendrag *Smile*

Firstly, welcome to the site. I know that this is merely a sentence, but it's obvious you either accidentally never finished it, or you had intended the sentence to be witty or profound. In the case you had intended to write more, I just thought I'd let you know that you can, optionally, mark your item private or save it as a draft. Either way, good luck with your future endeavors! *Smile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
268
268
Review by Riot
Rated: E | (5.0)
Because sometimes writing a review can't be done when there's only one item. Welcome to the site, we're not all jerks.
269
269
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, IsaacMarsh *Smile*

I really liked the flow of this poem! I thought the word choice was really good. I especially liked they create a façade; they feign the art. *Thumbsup*

I could find nothing to improve on this poem. Great job! *Thumbsup*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
270
270
Review of Immortality  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, Jose *Smile*

This is a 'longer' poem, but I well worth the read. I found the imagery in this to be extraordinarily good. Although there weren't any special word combinations or phrases that 'did it' for me, I'd have to say that it's the overall sentiments of the poem that I find so remarkable.

As my own writing has transformed over the years, I find it increasingly difficult to offer suggestions on poetry when it concerns punctuation. This is one of those rare types of poems where I feel the meaning outweighs minor punctuation or word choice. It was philosophically delightful and intriguing.

Thank you for sharing! *Smile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
271
271
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, kiwi-warz *Smile*

I think you did a good job with this free write poem. One of the things I couldn't help but notice is that you use punctuation at the end of all of the stanzas, yet not in between. While it's not required of course, it did make me question why not. There were a couple of parts where I thought it could really benefit from a comma or two. (For the in between.)

What I liked best about this poem was the imagery. I am especially fond of the word combinations bliss in virtue, unknown affliction leaves a dark footprint, and unintelligent plague.

Thank you for sharing! *Smile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
272
272
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: 18+ | (2.0)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, Wilshire *Smile*

I have to be quite honest. This was littered with a lot of grammatical errors, and it did impede on the ease of reading for me. However, I think it has potential. Before I get into the rest of what I want to say, I want to go over the technical stuff I found. It's a big gigantic, but I took a chunk of my morning to finish this in hopes it might do you some service. Most of it's organized from beginning to end, but I tried to clump some of the common errors together. Feel free to take what you agree with and junk the rest. *Wink*

Grammar Stuff:
*Bullet* ...out for the summer[.] I am going out with some... - I don't think the sentence following the comma is related enough to the first sentence to call for a semicolon. Instead, I think a period works just fine. *Smile*
*Bullet* ...mid-June night [is] this nice... - Oops! I think you forgot a word. *Wink*
*Bullet* While I wait for my friends*Xr* Jeanette and Lucille to come by[,] I think... - The whole phrase before the suggested comma is an introductory phrase. If you hadn't put their names following friends, your comma placement would be correct.
*Bullet* ...trying to have [somewhat] of a social life[.] It's really not... - Somewhat in this context is only one word. *Smile*
*Bullet* ...life as it comes at me[,] and it's worked out... - Two coordinated clauses require a comma separation.
*Bullet* ...was at [its] most gorgeous point... - With an apostrophe, it's would mean it is in this context. *Wink*
*Bullet* ...and eye [makeup] like most everyone else.
*Bullet* ...in the room[,] even if she isn't... - Introductory or dependent clauses also require commas for clarity. *Smile*
*Bullet* You know[,] the usual.
*Bullet* About four or five blocks down the street[,] I saw...
*Bullet* Leaving the house in the highest of spirits[,] we began walking, laughing...
          In the above two bullets the phrases before the suggested commas are introductory, thus, commas! (I know... I know... *Laugh*)
*Bullet* By the way[,] Lucille[,] those...
*Bullet* ...are so cute[.] Where did you get... - This is dialog, and although we have a tendency to talk as though we are speaking run on sentences, I think the period here helps the reader with flow. *Wink*
*Bullet* ...to be really good[.] We should watch...
*Bullet* No[,] never heard of it...
*Bullet* ...my oldest friends[,] and lately these nights...
*Bullet* Therefore[,] we were all in exceptionally... - Therefore is an introductory word. *Wink*
*Bullet* No[,] nothing ever happened with him...
*Bullet* ...over to Lucille[,] who was smiling right...
*Bullet* ...down the street[,] I saw a group of... - (Introductory phrase.)
*Bullet* ..."whoops" and yells [that] they were making..
*Bullet* ...in front of us[,] they momentarily came within earshot...
*Bullet* ...a dark grey band [t-shirt] that read...
*Bullet* ...and shorts[.] [He] had shaggy hair... - Ending this sentence here helps improve readability, without taking away from the description.
*Bullet* ...his friend [who] was saying it didn't look...
*Bullet* ...our other friends [who] happened to be going...
*Bullet* ...type of people [who] could be found here.
          With the above three bullets: Who or whom refer to people. That or which refer to non-humans. *Smile*
*Bullet* For this reason[,] I start most of my nights... - Introductory expression.
*Bullet* Well[,] it was pretty busy[,] but none of us...
*Bullet* ...anyone there[.] and, [M]oreover, the people there didn't... - *Wink*
*Bullet* ...was very crowded at the time[,] and the bartenders were...{/}
*Bullet* ...I'm having a lot of fun[,] and everyone...
*Bullet* ...happy hour there[,] and they have great prices...
*Bullet* ...about being too small[,] and I always...
*Bullet* ...were only 10 cents[,] and they had...
*Bullet* ...inches below her shoulders[,] and her skin...
          The above six bullets: Two coordinated clauses.
*Bullet* Luckily[,] we were able to find a table...
*Bullet* ...both liquor and beer[,] which was nice[,] since I very much... - Parenthetical phrases are usually surrounded on either side by commas.
*Bullet* Once he got his order[,] he turned carefully... - Introductory.
*Bullet* At this point[,] he said half to us[,] half to no one at all...
*Bullet* ...the bar opened up[,] and we were able...
*Bullet* ...or has [a] bad vocabulary. *Laugh*
*Bullet* ...I paid the barkeep[,] and went out...
*Bullet* ...spring quarter[,] and they were...
*Bullet* Apparently[,] John was another guy [whom] Lucille had...
*Bullet* John's house was a little out of the [way] from the bars...
*Bullet* Every so often[,] a group of party goers...
*Bullet* At this point[,] we were all pretty tipsy...
*Bullet* ...but at the last minute[,] she caught herself on a car parked...
*Bullet* Which was humorous[,] in and of itself[,] because she did not see...
*Bullet* The night was feeling wonderfully swell[,] and I felt amazingly...
*Bullet* I tried to choke out a warning to Lucille[,] who was still in the middle of the street[,] but I was hardly able...
*Bullet* ...and into a concentration[,] she tended to...
*Bullet* ...came racing past us[,] I heard a loud crash...
*Bullet* At this time[,] it call came together[,] and I noticed...
*Bullet* When I got there[,] he looked worse than I could imagine[,] and I...
*Bullet* ...I looked back at him[,] I thought about how much...
*Bullet* ...I had thought he was[,] and I couldn't...
*Bullet* With a slight smile[,] he said to me...

*Questionbl* article of clothing form each shop... - I think you meant from. *Wink*
*Questionbl* and atually had a half grin on his face. - Oops. I think you mean actually. *Wink*
*Questionbl* Just rather than flowing beautifully into a room and into a concentration[,] she tended to tip... - I see where you're going with this, and I think it's really beautiful imagery. Consider the first part of this sentence. Just rather than flowing... it doesn't really make sense? I think if you were to drop the casual tone you could really make this sentence dazzle.


I think you did a good job at giving your characters personality. I didn't have any trouble with deciphering who was saying what, and from what I gathered, their personalities fit well. The dialog was strong and fitting.

About the ending: I felt like you went to great lengths to flesh out a lot of character development and build up. The ending, and maybe done on purpose, felt disproportional comparatively.

If you decide to go back and re-work this, please don't hesitate to let me know. I'd be happy to read it over again and make another rating. *Smile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot
273
273
Review of To Love a Human  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*

Hello, Ella Marie Wathen *Smile*

I like the idea of reading this from three points of views, as you've done. I think that for easier reading, though, it might have more impact for the reader if they were fleshed out more.

I think that you have a distinct style for, forgive me if this was not your intention, teen writing. The descriptive nature of the characters you wrote about really reminds me of a story and style geared toward younger readers. I think part of this has to do with the fact that you're following them from first person point of view, and that the descriptions they give themselves are 'in character' - if that makes sense. (For instance, one character referred to their self as 'bodacious')


Some technical stuff I came across:
*Bullet* ...my parent[']s mistakes. - The apostrophe is missing before the possessive, indicating a plural noun.
*Bullet* ...floor too[.] The house...
*Bullet* ...I waited [there] approximately... - Oops! Wrong use of there/their/they're *Wink*
*Bullet* ...Ella's eyes grew wide as it sunk in what I was saying. - I think with a little bit of reword, this could say the same thing. Maybe something like: Ella's eyes grew wide as what I said sunk in.
*Bullet* ...at me[,] but I did...
*Bullet* ...not an easy task[,] [for] all of my outfits were designer.
*Bullet* ...teen movies[.] Everybody is close...
*Bullet* ...looked[,] she was 'All That'...
*Bullet* But[,] what was I supposed to do? - When a conjunction begins a sentence of this nature it needs to be followed by a comma.
*Bullet* I doubted this immensely[.] [However,] because I knew, I just knew, Marie... - This is the best suggestion I could think of for making this sentence work. Splitting an overly long sentence up into two or three can really help, without having to change the meaning.
*Bullet* ...and he was wearing a football jersey[,] and even... - Two coordinated clauses require a comma between them for clarity.
*Bullet* In my old school[,] this is... - The phrase before the comma is an introductory phrase, so it needs to be followed by a comma.
*Bullet* ...the hall for him[.] I paused, batted... - Sometimes, when there are obviously two apparent sentences combined into one, the simpler solution is to leave them as two sentences for easier readability. *Smile*
*Bullet* ...students came in[,] and I could tell... - Two coordinate clauses should be separated by a comma. *Wink*
*Bullet* ...taking role call. *Right* I think you meant roll call. (A list of names.)
*Bullet* ...being here yet[.] They always come late...
*Questionbl* make up coated *Right* makeup coated
*Questionbl* In the sentence she raced down the road..., I'm really not sure what you mean. Maybe you could re-word it or add another sentence for clarity.
*Questionbl* For right of passage did you mean rite of passage? *Smile*

*Stop* Capitalization for entire words has its use, but I think it was used excessively in your story. I understand that you're trying to use it as inflection in your dialog, however, I don't think it's needed. If you need to stress what the narrator is saying, I think you can do so with better supporting text.
*exlcaim* Watch out on word repetition. There were several instances where you repeated a words and phrases, that weren't in parallel sentences. With a word such as beautiful, a thesaurus might come in handy.
*Cut* I've found that excessively beginning with sentences with but or and can easily be avoided by removing the word entirely. I think it would be a good idea to go through what you've written and count how many times you do this, and see if you can't cut some of them.

To be honest, I had a difficult time reading this. I think that you put a lot of time and effort into developing your characters. Now I think it's time to go back and perhaps work on grammar and editing, so that this can become a really polished piece.

If you ever decide to go back and work on this some more, I'd be more than happy to go back and read and review it again. Keep writing! *Smile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot


My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
274
274
Review by Riot
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
If my doctor told me I had only six minutes to live, I wouldn't brood. I'd type a little faster.

Congratulations on your nomination into "Ink Blot Hall of Fame
Along with your nomination, you are also receiving the Isaac Asimov Fan Package!
This package includes many things, one of which is this review from the "Invalid Item!



Hello, Hyperiongate *Smile*

Once upon a time I reviewed this, but it's been a really long time since then. While rummaging your port, I came across this again and wanted to give you a better review.

I think you did a good job writing this article. The points you bring up are informative, well written, and easy to follow. I noticed in your item that you encourage improvement and honesty. I hope by comments below don't deter you from going back to this older article, as I found it insightful!

Some technical stuff:
*Bullet* ...great writer[.] This discussion... - I think with the way the last part of this sentence is set up a period might work better.
*Bullet* During that time[,] I have... - Introductory phrases or expressions are followed by a comma.
*Bullet* ...Challenges and have won my share... *Wink*
*Bullet* People [who] see grammar errors... - who refers to people, while that or which refers to non-humans. You're absolutely right about this sentence, by the way. *Laugh*
*Bullet* ...his gun to the police[,] so he decided...
*Bullet* Don't let the prompts... - Let the verbs agree. *Smile*
*Bullet* Susie wanted to be an astronaut [ever] since... *Right* This is a perfect example of a long sentence that does not require commas.
*Bullet* ...is in the story[,] but it does not drive... - Are these coordinated clauses? *Smile*
*Bullet* ...is [not to] worry about... - Stylistically, I think these sound better reversed. Consider them outside of the sentence...
*Bullet* It gets me into the story, the characters are there, [and] the situation is there[.] [All] I have left to do is wrap it up. - I think since you're listing everything that you can get away with this minor adjustment. It's alright to have the last part as a sentence on its own. It's not directly related and can stand on its own.
*Bullet* ...for everyone[,] but it... *Wink*
*Bullet* ...the reader continue on in search... - This is somewhat redundant and maybe picky, however, you did point out how fewer words can make the same point as a wordier piece... *Wink*
*Bullet* ...about mobsters[,] and I like...
*Bullet* You can't do this completely[,] but you can... (As with the bullet above, coordinated clauses need commas between them.)
*Questionbl* Who hasn't[?]
*Questionbl* ...8 oz. portion[?]

Thank you for keeping this up. I stand by my original comment in that everyone who writes flash fiction (or anything else even) should read this at least once. *Smile*



Write on!
Riot

*Heart* Want to spoil your favorite author? Buy them a package to show your appreciation! *Heart*
"Invalid Item
275
275
Review of Revolution!  
Review by Riot
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE NEWBIE REVIEWE...  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Heart* I am reviewing you today on behalf of "Simply Positive Review Forum *Heart*


Hello, RedGraves *Smile*

I thought this was a pretty good science-fiction read. Although it was short, I enjoyed this snippet.

Before I get into the rest, I want to point out some grammatical things:
*Bullet* ...Mars itself, and many lives were lost, but in the end... - I think listing this makes the sentence seem more grammatically sound, without changing the meaning or context of the sentence.
*Bullet* No more orders from Earth, no more losing their own precious resources to that ravenous behemoth planet, but just total and utter freedom. - Although this seems somewhat narrative, I think it can do without the but.
*Bullet* ...and their own hard work[,] however they wanted. - It seems like this sentence is somewhat incomplete, beginning with able the way it does, but I think this is what you're going for. In any case, I think the comma placed here helps clarify the sentence a little more. *Wink*
*Bullet* They owned themselves[;] they weren't... - This could end either with a period or semi-colon. Given the context though, and style, I thought it might be a good exercise of the dreaded semi-colon. *Bigsmile*
*Bullet* ...instead of [a or the] company appointed...
*Bullet* It was amazing[.] It really was. - This could also go either way with a period or comma, but I felt that the narration leading up to this point was similar to shorter sentences, so this change would fit in well. *Smile*
*Bullet* That was the turning point[.] It became...
*Bullet* ...and for a while it was all a stalemate.
*Bullet* ...to Earth for anyone [who] wanted it... - Use who or whom to refer to people, and that or which to refer to non-humans. *Wink*
*Bullet* ...could no longer observe[,] unless sent the.... - Introductory or dependent clauses need to be separated by a comma.
*Bullet* ...uploaded Virtual Humans [that/which] wish to embody... - The same as before, except reversed. Now we're talking about non-humans. *Smile*
*Questionbl* You have quite a bit of negative sentences, although I think that can be forgiven since this seems more like narrative. Negative sentences contain words like no, nobody, and never. There weren't very many passive verbs though, which I think helped considerably.

Truthfully, the ending didn't really surprise me. If anything, I felt as though this was a narrative rather than a letter. I did find the irony to be deliciously well thought out, though. It seems as though fate seems to always have that sort of cruel irony, doesn't it?

I'm not sure if you wrote this for a contest or not, or where it plays into things, as far as being in a larger story. As it is, I do feel it's a worthy short read, however, I think it might do better justice on the "twisted" end of things if it were embellished on more.

You only need a little bit of touch up grammatically. If you work on this a bit more, I'd be happy to re-read it again. Good job! *Smile*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
Riot


My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
617 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 25 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/riot/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11