Hello, I am here to provide you with some feedback on your item for the Simply Positive Reviewer's Group. Please note that ALL comments contained in this review are only one reader's opinion and are meant only as observations from one writer to another. Use what you find helpful, and ignore the rest. Most importanly, Keep Writing!
TITTLE, DESCRIPTION; : Great tittle, description is good.
FIRST IMPRESSIONS: : Great premise to this story, I liked the attention to description, but after a bit, you rather lose the reader in detail. Can you add more action? Tighten your description for a faster pace, show us the monster!
PLOT; FLOW; : Great plot and storyline. Flow is good in event sequence, but needs some revision and tightening to create a stronger dramatic arc.
Characters, Dialogue: : Mr. Sutherland is compelling, I felt very sympathetic towards him, but not emotionally invested because I didn't feel I really knew him. Monster is well thought out, but can you let readers ' see' more of it attacking in the end? Dialogue is realistic, but again, needs tightening - less detail, use threat, action to chill readers.
IMAGERY; EMOTION: : Fantastic imagery, but I'd revise to tighten it to the key / relevant areas, too much narrative detail is an info dump that loses readers interest. Try some shorter, sharper sentences as well.
Emotion is strong, but drowned by detail overload, let us see through Mr. Sutherland's eyes, hear through his ears.
Favorite Lines/Parts: :
Opening paragraph, first appearance of monster.
Ending.
SUGGESTIONS; :
bodies in the gallows on the [ too much detail, overpowers itself]
cheeks seamed seemed to always stay rosy. [ I'd revise this line; His seamed cheeks were always rosy.
to finally slam. [ tighter]
timid wiring warning
He stood there for awhile.... [ Revise tighten sentence and paragraph; Thought;
He stared at the blinking light until the phone piereced his thoughts, startling him. Sutherland jumped, stomped over to answer it.
[ Why is he so afraid of the phone? Add more detail through his thoughts, reactions to clarify this]
like breathing. Breathing hissed through the speaker.
scared slightly. was terrified.
said in merely a whisper. whispered.
CLOSING THOUGHTS; : A great chiller of a story, with some editing, revising, polishing, it will be an incredible read!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** |
|