Hello, I am here to provide you with some feedback on your item for the Simply Positive Reviewer's Group. If this review was a review request, thank you for asking me and feel free to ask for clarification on any comment!
Please note that ALL comments contained in this review are only one reader's opinion and are meant only as observations from one writer to another. Use what you find helpful, and ignore the rest. Most of all, Keep Writing!
TITLE, DESCRIPTION; : Excellent title, but I think Tye needs to feature a bit more in the story for it to be a true fit. Your description is interesting and a good fit.
FIRST IMPRESSIONS: : I liked the general flow of the story, but it does sound a bit rushed in places, for instance, how fast the child announced his desire for a dog and the parents agreed. Not much time for reflection, maybe Jacob could have been bringing this up from other conversations and parents could have talked about it previous night? What about Jacob buying food for puppy? Having feeding explained to him properly, walks, etc. He gets Tye, but seems to spend all his time at shelter. Can you add more balance to story there?
PLOT; FLOW; : Events flow logically for the most part, but as stated above and in suggestions, pieces are missing. Plot is great, just needs a little more clarity.
Characters, Dialogue: : Couldn't really connect to parents, they are a bit one-dimensional, but Jacob really sparkled.
IMAGERY; EMOTION: : Imagery could be a bit more detailed, what does pup look like? What does their home look like? yard, fenced? Jacob shows great emotional depths, I really liked this boy!
Favorite Lines/Parts: :
Jacob at the animal shelter, thinking about other dogs left behind.
SUGGESTIONS; :
Para 2; Jacob sulked his way to the kitchen. [ smoother]
I'd do an edit for strengthening dialogue, example, Mary would explain more about feeding, etc. to prospective new owners.
'Jacob's mother responded'- new line each time a different person speaks.
CLOSING THOUGHTS; :
You examine very important facts in this story,the reality of abandoned pets, importance of helping them, satisfaction of volunteering. Still, there is much bias that might lose you some readers, not all breeders over breed their animals or treat them as less than family members. Agreed, so called 'back yard'breeders do, but give the good ones some credit.
I would think the animal shelter would be clean, smell more of disinfectant, otherwise, how are they still in operation? Mary seemed a truly caring person who would insist on cleanliness.
A very good read, that would be truly outstanding with just a touch of editing in dialogue and overall plot.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
|
|