*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/1starsong
Review Requests: OFF
7,130 Public Reviews Given
7,195 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... -1- 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Next
1
1
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Jim! I am happy to review your item in "I Write: Enter the Second Decade.*Delight*


It is so cool that you are recording your experiences with your work and places you visit. It is interesting to hear about places to visit and to eat! *Smile* This entry was fun to read and I had to smile at the wrong assumptions! *Laugh*

The writing was clear with a mix of fact and humour. I enjoyed the Buffalo Wings section where your making the exception
turned out so well! *Laugh*

The article is organized well with subtitles and a hint of where you go next. The voice is personal, inviting readers into your world. I liked the greetings at the end too. *Thumbsup*

Thanks for sharing your experiences. Write on!

eyestar
A  birthday gift
2
2
Review of Coffee Spuddle  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI Words Whirling 'Round! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*

*Coffeeb* Wow! The title to this poem was intriguing! What a great word. Thanks for the note on it's meaning. *Smile*

*Coffeer* I had so much fun reading this poem and had a good laugh! The details are so clear and show well the meaning of "spuddle". Black toast and not turning the coffee on shows how out of sorts the poet was. I had to laugh at the end.... even though I don't like coffee. I got the frustration of the situation. *Laugh*

*Coffeev* It was a pleasure to read the poem aloud with its clear rhyme and easy rhythm. You might put quote marks around the words the child speaks. *Wink* Awesome piece for a coffee addict!

*Star*Thanks for sharing this entertaining poem. *Thumbsup*

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
SuperPower Raid


3
3
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Delight* Hiya BlueMoon! I am happy to review your word search for "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group Coffee Raid! *Wink*


*Coffeer* Whew! This word search was a challenge. I am glad you left some space between certain word phrases as it helped me find them. It took me awhile to find "melya"! *Smile*

*Coffeeg* I find the words are interesting especially the addition of places to have coffee. The title is appealing too though I was unsure that places would be classed paraphenalia. LOL Yet it covers everything.

*Coffeeo* You might expand your introduction adding your rationale for the topic and maybe some colour or emoticons just for fun and aesthetics. I had fun solving this puzzle. Thanks for sharing this entertaining item.

eyestar
SuperPower Raid
4
4
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Delight* Hiya Spacecat! I am happy to review your word search for our "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group Coffee Raid.


*Coffeeb* Your word search was fun to do and the last word I found was the word "coffee"! I wonder if it is because I don't like coffee. *Laugh* I found it to be complex enough to be challenging.

*Coffeegr* Adding the story master and story mistress as words were interesting choices for the topic. I might have added Lilly to the list too as she is the coffee addict! LOL The word "cream" might be a topical word to add as some folks like cream in coffee.

*Coffeev* I had fun with this bit of entertainment. In your introduction you could add some colour and emoticons maybe for fun and maybe link the activity. *Wink*

Thanks for sharing your vision.

eyestar
SuperPower Raid
5
5
Review of Contest Entries  
for entry "Something is Wrong
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Delight* Hi Angelica. I am happy to review your item from "I Write: Enter the Second Decade! *Thumbsup*

*Smile* Oh my gosh! What a pain to find unusable merchandise. Who sells stuff like that! In such a short piece you really captured the feeling of the buyer and how frustrated she was. It felt at the end like she was an impulse buyer and convinced her self not to buy. *Laugh*

*Flowery* It is interesting that you begin with the question before you notice the holes. Was the question about telling the seller about the flaws?

*Thumbsup* It is so cool to be able to write a whole episode with meaning in so few words. Good job!

eyestar
A  birthday gift

6
6
Review of Woods Words  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Delight* Hiya Fyn! I am thrilled to fulfill the Seer of Destiny package from "SuperPower MB Shop for Anonymous Orders
Thanks for your generous donation to "Invalid Item *Heartp*



*Fairy*Personal Impression
I love trees and talk to them so this poem really appealed to me. I could so imagine their words and know they do communicate with each other. I watched a cool show about such a topic. The poem is delightful and imaginative with fabulously clear images and I couldn't stop reading...more than twice! I had a great time.


*Fairy* Tone, Form & Flow
This was an excellent free verse poem filled with effective use of assonance and consonance, vibrant imagery. The soundscape was delicious as repeated sounds like c, "knurled knee" "canopy of seclusion". The first line enjambment was effective. I could feel the mood as you describe in such detail with clarity of a specific image or idea in each verse. I enjoyed the flow very much. Too many cool images to choose from. Consistent punctuation served the work. I liked the emphatic "But!" *Wink*

*Fairy* Emotional Impact
I was touched by the connection you made to trees and nature as a place to be inspired. I love the idea of trees keeping one's secrets. It is a magical place I quickly entered into and wished I was there too! *Heart* That owl is sweet!

Thanks for sharing your mystical vision! *Starstruck* I am there. Excellent poem. Write on!

eyestar
Remember, this is only an Eyestar View! *Wink*
for "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group
Sig for blog/reveiws
7
7
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Delight* Hiya Fyn! I am thrilled to fulfill the Seer of Destiny package from "SuperPower MB Shop for Anonymous Orders
Thanks for your generous donation to "Invalid Item *Heartp*


*Fairy*Personal Impression
I chose this poem as the title made me curious and as I read it reminded me of those socks that get lost in the dryer somehow! I had so much fun and laughed a lot. Pets are a handful. *Laugh*

*Fairy* Tone & Mood & Impact
I enjoyed the changing tone and mood. I felt the confusion, mystery to the surprise and then the acceptance of the reason things disappeared. The happiness of finding the things and then just giving in allows you to know where you might find the next things that go missing. *Thumbsup*
The tone was vibrant and drew me into the emotion of the moment. It was easy to enter the experience and images like "hungry couch" and "sneaky elf" were funny. I felt bad about the loss of the ring and laughed at the tv remote having disappeared. One does here this does happen. LOL Sixteen dollars gone!!! Too cute and a smart creature!

*Fairy* Rhyme, Form & Flow
I really enjoyed the vitality of the voice as it changes and it had a pleasant flow with an easy rhyme scheme. While the syllable count of lines was inconsistent I thought it suited the emotional content. I had fun reading and nothing jarred me out of the poem. The images were specific and clear adding to the entertainment value and the use of assonance and consonance added to the soundscape in an effective manner. Punctuation served the read. I wondered if "tis" should have an apostrophe before it. *Wink*

Thanks for sharing your vision! I was truly entertained and could really imagine such a situation. The trinkets the dog would take were original and comical too. The name certainly would suit the pup! *Starstruck* This must have been fun to write.

eyestar
Remember, this is only an Eyestar View! *Wink*
for "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group
Sig for blog/reveiws

8
8
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Delight* Hi Sumojo! I am happy to review your blog entry in "I Write: Enter the Second Decade!

*Thumbsup* I was intrigued by the title as it is a relevant question we all consider
I appreciate your sincere voice here. I felt for the woman who was not sure about motherhood and recall my own doubts about my gifts. Yet you did it! And so it was meant to be. If others see your gift of being a matriarch, you too must know it. Motherhood is so important. Not everyone can do it. Doubt is just meant to bring you down.

*Smile* You make good points about parents with certain talents trying to pass on to their children though not always so as we do rebel. I think we get caught in programming of society and until we break free we tend to follow status quo! Yet we create some cool stuff even if we don't know why we are here.

I think we are born to BE whoever we are... a journey of discovery with no right or wrong path...an experience. *Wink*

I liked the image of the "blank canvas" and how vulnerable children are as they absorb what they see just like we did. I wonder if that is where some confusion comes from as we try to honour parents and the opinions of others, at least until we mature. We can always choose if we know we can.

This was a vulnerable response to the prompt. Thanks for sharing who you be! *Heart*

Write on!

eyestar

A  birthday gift
9
9
Review of Camikazi  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
*Delight* Hi whiskerface! I am happy to review your story from "I Write: Enter the Second Decade!


*Dragon* I enjoy dragon stories and I have seen the first movie about Toothless, though it was some time ago. The story captures Toothless and the twin's personalities in this fanfiction piece.

*Dragon2* The first paragraph sets the scene and I could imagine Toothless lazing. I wondered if the comment about Barf and Belch were Toothless's or the narrator.

*Dragon* The description of the dragon's attitude toward the twins is subtle but clear. The mix of narration and dialogue is effective. The conversations forward the story and reveal feelings and character consistently. The action scene demonstrating Camikazi's potential technique of abusing Hiccup added to the drama and revealed the twins strengths. I liked the light hearted end of High five! LOL

I wondered for a while if the twins were playing a trick on Toothless.

*Quill* You missed a quotation mark at the start of What do you think, Sis?” *Wink*
I am still confused a bit on who the narrator was. I am not a pro on this though. *Smile*

*Dragon* It was fun to read this episode and I am curious about the next phase especially from the last line about it being epic! *Star*

Great job on the fanfiction!

eyestar
A  birthday gift
10
10
Review of Wrong Address  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Delight* Hey AmyJo! I am happy to review your story in the "I Write: Enter the Second Decade! *Smile*


*Magnify* The title gave me a clue to the theme and I was imagining all the things that could go with having the wrong address. It appealed to my curiosity.

*Magnify*I enjoy Sherlock Holmes tales so this has an appealing theme and your use of the number 22 from the prompt is perfect. The two addresses do have similarities so it makes sense the man would get mixed up maybe. *Thumbsup* Even the rhyming names add to the humour of the tale.

*Magnify* The first line set the place and drew me in as we do not know who would be at the door.
The description of the man was clear both physical and in his action. I thought Mr. Jones was helpful inspite of him thinking the man rude. He did see he might need help. I thought of Peter Pan when you said lost something Precious and Jones thought the man lost. *Wink* I think you could put Mr. Jone's thoughts to himself in italics as it is not spoken aloud. *Smile*

*Magnify* Interesting word "askance". I am not sure I have seen it too often! Cool.

*Magnify* You did a good job with making a complete episode in so few words! Wow. I think you could do another little chapter so we can see what will happen next. *Smile*

*Star*Thanks for sharing your style and joining in the party! *Balloonp*
11
11
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Balloonp**Cupcakev*Happy days
Celebrating 22 years of WDC history with a review for you! *Delight*


*Candleb*Wow! Your personal heartfelt expression really engaged me and I had to keep reading. I enjoyed learning a bit more about your amazing self too.

*Confettig*I totally related to your experience about the technical aspects. Bitem? Ahhh! I too found mentors who were so patient with my questions. Truly you described the essence of WDC as inspirational with a world family vibe, supportive and inclusive. No wonder we get addicted. So much to do, learn and share. A loving home.


*Balloongo*The piece was coherently written and easy to follow as you share the benefits you have received from the site. I agree with your ideas. I never thought of the benefit to the brain and yep being actively engaged and learning does that. Excellent point!

*Cake2*It is wonderful to pay tribute here to some of yor mentors. We all need to know we are appreciated.

*Candleb* I notice you mention the story Master and mistress y another name: word Master. Was this on purpose? Interesting.

*Star*Thank you for sharing your awesome response to the prompt. The voice sounded like it was speaking to WDC and its creators and participants. Your gratitude shone through the work. You rock.


Keep on shining as the star you are and party On!

eyestar
reviewing with "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group!

Colourful sig by AEWilcox!
12
12
Review of My Sister Kathy  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Balloonp**Cupcakev*Happy days Amyjo! Welcome to WDC!
Celebrating 22 years of WDC history with a review for you! *Delight*


*Candleb*Wow! This poem was a moving tribute to your sister. Condolences that she left so early. It is hard to deal with such illness and bittersweet when one is happy the sick one is not suffering anymore. Yet, the absence is sad! Kudos for you now able to express the relationship you had with her and your hope for her. The idea of wings is beautiful.

*Confettig*The voice of the poet speaking to the deceased is effective as we do often talk to those who have gone on, as if we sense they are somehow aware of us.

*Cake2* I would add "Experience" Or "Emotional" as a genre as opposed to "Writing" as it is more specific.

*Balloongo*I wanted to add the word "was" in the second line to improve flow and add length of line. eg. was so short. *Wink*

*Cake2*The poem has a 4 line structure with a good rhyme scheme. I did not notice an even syllable count for an even flow yet reading aloud I was only thrown out a bit in the first verse which could a bit of tweaking. Of course the short lines could be for effect. "Cancer took you in your prime, your life it did distort" came to mind. But that is just me playing. I wondered about the word "interesting" . I liked the image of the crazy schemes and you leave it to our imagination. I have 3 sisters so I can imagine. The thing is we could change teams! *Laugh*

*Balloongo* Some use of alliteration like "thick as thieves" and assonance assisted the flow and soundscape. Minimum punctuation works well here.

*Star*Thanks for sharing such a vulnerable theme in a poetic manner and for sharing your gift. I could enter into the memory written from an observant voice. Good job! Thanks for letting me play in your expression.*Heart*

Have a great time at our WDC Party!

eyestar
reviewing with "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group!

Colourful sig by AEWilcox!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
13
13
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*

*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI DRSmith! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*


*Laugh* Oh wow! This is hilarious and I had a great time reading the trials of trying to gift the commandments. Brilliant ideas and with each culture the refusal and its reason makes sense. Too funny.

*Smile*It was a pleasure to read the poem aloud with its clear rhythm and rhyme pattern and its vibrant dialogue throughout. It was quite dramatic and easy to make out the different voices and cultural clues. Use of assonance and consonance also added to the flowing soundscape. Well done.

*Delight* I was drawn right into the tale with its vivid images and characters. I couldn't wait to see what would come next! I had to laugh at him going to Mexico and then you did well picking the commandment for the French. *Laugh* You have Moses and the assumed "quirk" or habit of the Jewish archetype down pat as with the other cultures. What a creative and original piece of fun.

*Star* Your muse had a brilliant day coming up with this well conceived and constructed epic tale. I was so entertained. The picture was a colourful addition as well.


Light on the path as you write on!!*Star* Thanks for all of your contributions through your years here at WDC! *Heart*

eyestar
A  birthday gift
14
14
Review of From the Shore  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*

*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI Walkinbird. I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*


*Fairy3* Wow! I can really hear the voice of Arwen here as she regales the details of her being and her love for Aragorn as he sees him off on his journey. You capture her sadness that she may not go and may not see him again. The last line is sorrowful as I imagine her having no more sight as she was bid to leave the land as well. The voice is potent in its emotion.

*Fairy2* It has a Tolkien flair and the use of elvish language is effective and fun! Thanks for the little translation too! *Wink*

*Fairy* The free style suits the theme and emotional content and you have created a fine soundscape with your use of assonance and consonance. It was a pleasure to read aloud and get caught up in the flow and her vision. The language reflects her time and culture as well. *Thumbsup*

*Star*Thanks for sharing this powerful lament that shows your understanding and enjoyment of these characters. A wonderful tribute to their love and to Tolkien!


Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
WDC Power Personal Star sig



15
15
Review of Erin the Fair  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Hotair3* Hi Buddhangela! I am happy to do a review to celebrate you! *Delight*


*Shamrock* I so enjoy limericks and find them a challenge, especially the comical tone of them! So I was happy to see this one. I also love fairies so the topic was appealing. *Fairy2*

*Shamrock* You capture the belief about the fae in the last line where the family is in despair. According to legends the fae can steal away young ones and they are never seen again. Cool. The contrast between a marriage to a Baron and the fae is comical as well as I am sure the family was happy about the status that would have come! I can imagine the woe is me!

*Shamrock*The limerick form is well constructed but for the first line, which only has 8 syllables instead of nine. *Wink* I like the Irish tone suggested in the last line with the dropped letters. *Thumbsup* The poem flowed in a jaunty way and was fun to read and imagine the scene.

*Burstg* A little thought: you could say "our Erin" and then in the last line use "our family" as if one of the family was telling the tale. It would give that extra syllable in line one. I sometimes find that first line tough too.

*Star* Thanks for sharing your craft and entering the contest! You rock.
Light on the path as you write on.

eyestar
A  birthday gift
16
16
for entry "I Do - 8/15/2013
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI DragonWrites! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*

*Delight* I so enjoy these types of poems as they feel like stream of consciousness. The reflection of what love is is a relevant theme and well captured in this free style poem. I liked the flow and the mix of opinion and questioning ending with a hopeful romantic wish. Wonderful to read aloud.

*Heart* Your images are clear and appealing as the poet considers the deep question and seems to dream of the perfect definition and feeling of love. Adding a wish for a partner adds a romantic tone.

*Heartp* I like the originality of the stanzas which take us on a mind journey and the struggle to know love and yet unready to strike out yet to experience, all the while asking questions for knowledge and truth and hope. I was engaged from the start with the question/answer, doubt/hope and romantic longings. It was appealing to read aloud.

*Heartv* Ending with "I do" seems to settle the query! Good job! Thanks for sharing your gift.

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
A  birthday gift

17
17
Review of A Dog's Christmas  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI jdennis! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*

*Delight* Oh how delightful. I love parodies of songs and they can be a challenge! Using a dog for Christmas song is so lovely. I used one in my last parody...using the song "Chestnuts Roasting!"*Laugh*

*Dog1*I could hear the rhythm and cadence of the Christmas Story you parodied. Good job!

*Dog2* This was hilarious and full of clear images that had me giggling. Im liked the description of the two dogs and their antics. I laughed when the mouse came down the chimney landing on his butt! LOL I could just imagine the dogs climbing the tree and its outcome. Perfect!

*Mouse*The poem flowed fairly well as I read aloud with a few glitchy places. It was so fun and enjoyable they slip by.

*Quill*This line could drop the "and" for greater flow as it continues into the next line with "and".
"Underneath him and climbing"

*Treepine* Thanks for sharing this comical epic type Christmas tale! I was highly entertained. *Starstruck* I loved the idea of the mouse stirring the house! Brilliant!

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
A  birthday gift
18
18
Review of Fay  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI Chrisdaltro! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*

*Fairy2* Oh I love fairies! So yep I recall adding this awesome poem in my newsletter and never got around to reviewing it. Here I am with fond memories. *Smile*

*Fairy* I enjoyed the story line of this poem and was sad at the end. It reminded me of Peter Pan where Tink almost dies. At least they clapped and believed again. The use of the "I' voice narrating as a fairy was effective to draw us into her tale. The details of her life are clearly described. I could imagine her.

*Fairy3* While the rhyme is steady with well chosen thematic words, I notice the rhythm does not see to have a definite pattern. It makes for a wild read yet you needed the details. Could be tightened if you were to revise. For example, Words like "somehow" are not vivid or poetic. *Wink*

*Fairyl*It is really sad to think fairies can annoy folks. *Shock2* You had me hoping more would remember the magical beings. I agree with their mission to sparkle and shine! *Laugh* I have seen them light up the night. *Wink*

*Fairyr* I liked your tribute to the fay and it is a challenge to tell a story in a poem form so good for you for sharing this bit of magic.

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
A  birthday gift

19
19
Review of Fair Trade  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI Genipher! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*

*Delight* Wow! I love it. A sonnet with a leprechaun! How original. *Thumbsup* The title makes sense for the theme too!

*Shamrock* This was so fun to read aloud and the theme for the sonnet had a comical air which is unique. I loved it. I could see the imagery you created as well as the tone of the speaker. It is told like a tale with effective dialogue and a surprise as to the traded item. Wonderful.

*Gold* I am not sure what the taboo words were for the prompt as it changes in the contest each time. The form has the feel and flow of a sonnet and the language suits the time and fantasy theme.
The rhythm and rhyme are effective and the tone is clear. The conversation has a lilt of the Irish!
When he speaks you do not need to begin verse 4 with quotation marks as the dialogue continues from the speaker in the previous verse. *Wink*

*Star* I like the narrator who begins the tale though usually I think sonnets are spoken by one person. Maybe. This is so creative and fun with mischief and a happy summative couplet I really enjoyed the originality. Not sure I have read many happy or comical sonnets. They are usually plaintive or emotional. Your version is original and as I tend to like happier things, I loved it!

Thanks for sharing your gift! *Thumbsup*

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
A  birthday gift


20
20
Review of Cat's Eyes  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | N/A (Review only item.)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI Max! I am here with a review to celebrate you! *Star*

I like cinquains and was happy to find your unique creations that you add to your novels. It is cool to attribute them too. I love cats so this was an easy choice for me. You have captured the comparison of human to cat brilliantly! They can be deceiving as they are so cute but yep, superior!
*Laugh*

The form is intact according to the definition and the use of story type lines feels unique and invites personal response. *Thumbsup* Your use of repeating sounds in words adds to the flow and soundscape. A pleasure to read aloud. The pause in the second line is effective and the use of "I" twice in the line creates the idea of being supreme. *Wink* I was wondering about centering it as we usually see them centered. This works as is though.

In a definition I learned for this, there is a connection between the first and last line...like a contrast or simile. Eg. I might have said something like "Supreme, I think I am..." in the first two lines... and it would contrast with the "I'm not". LOL That is just my switch if I used the alternative style. Your expression is effective as I could also see then idea of "I'm not thinking... which would make you not supreme too! A cat would think you were not thinking so well to think you rule. *Laugh*

Thanks for sharing your poetic stylings. I had so much fun! *Star*

And congrats on your anniversary and gratitude for all of your many contributions over the years. You rock! *Starstruck*

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
A  birthday gift

21
21
Review of Cats or Dogs  
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


*BalloonR**ConfettiP*HI leeboi! I am here with a review to celebrate you on your 14th anniversary! *Star*

*Dog1*I like the premise of this poll as I know people who have really definite alliances to dogs or cats! *Delight* I like both, though I prefer to have a cat as they tend to be more independent and can use cat litter so I can be free to be out longer! LOL

*cat1* Your question is direct in your intro! You could perhaps add colour or emoticons for fun and maybe give your choice and why you were inspired to ask the question! *Wink*

*Quill* I was reading about doing effective polls that could interest and include more people and broaden the scope of discovery. In your options, it might be an idea to add more choices:
Neither (as there could be bird people or horse people.{e:smile),
Both equally (as there can be folks who love both or can't choose).

The poll is relevant and applicable to most people so I am glad I found it! {e:delight} I loved the cover picture. *Thumbsup*

Light on the path as you write on!!*Star*

eyestar
A  birthday gift

22
22
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Balloonp* Hiya HollyMerry! I am here with a review to celebrate you as "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group celebrates 15 years here at WDC! *Delight*


*Balloonb* I found your wonderful stash of poetry and had to jump in to read! You have a unique voice. I could really feel the whole aura of atmosphere as Jane Eyre wanders to moor. You have captured her vividly. I felt the depth of her feeling of loss.

*Confettip*I enjoyed reading the language aloud for its flow and soundscape created by rhyme, assonance, consonance and effective enjambments.*Thumbsup* The punctuation and varying line lengths with a line of verse. Elegant!

*Cupcakey* Word choice is thematic and the tone and language reflects the time and place of the poem theme. So many awesome lines like : "Beneath the wind’s banshee keen." kept me reading. You have a gift!

*Star*Impressive creation and well conceived. I loved it! *Heart* Thanks for sharing your Word wizardry.

*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*CakeP*


eyestar
** Image ID #2276360 Unavailable **
23
23
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | N/A (Review only item.)
*Balloonp* Hiya MeganRose! I am here with a review to celebrate you as "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group celebrates 15 years here at WDC! *Delight*



*Balloonb*Whew! This was a tough prompt and you did it! The song has rhyme and beat and I loved the wisdom in the refrain.

*Confettip*The composition has an interesting flow with short phrasings with in a line. Cool!
Your ideas and images are well chosen to show the fragility both the negative version and ones like love! Nice job!

*Cupcakey* Adding some ways to overcome the low vibes of fragile times added a positive and inspiring message as well. *Heart*

*Candleo* Thanks for entering the rabbit hole and stretching your skills to new heights! *Star*


eyestar
** Image ID #2276360 Unavailable **
24
24
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Balloonp* Congratulations on your promotion KingsideCastle. *Cool*. I am here with a review to celebrate you as "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group celebrates 15 years here at WDC! *Delight*



*Balloonb*Down the rabbit hole memories! I am judging a new round so I thought I would go back in history...your story. LOL I remember this cool exercise and enjoyed how you always tried to get chess references into the prompt! *Thumbsup*

*Confettip* The title is brilliant as the mirror reading part of the prompt and the word "match" gave me a clue that this might refer to a game. Indeed, you have the chess reference. What a great idea to play the opposite colour with the opposite hand showing the reversal of the place. *Cool* You did repeat the idea of daytime/nighttime but it added to the nonsense.

*Cupcakey* I enjoyed reading the poem aloud as it flowed readily with its effective rhyme and beat. I did notice a pattern in the verses. Though a few lines are off syllable count it did not detract from the read and meaning.

*Candleo* The backwards mirror image is cool and something I learned there was a gimmick for! LOL What do I know about tech!

*Star*Thanks for sharing this entertaining poem! Well done.

eyestar
** Image ID #2276360 Unavailable **
25
25
Review by eyestar~*
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
*Delight* Hi Christopher! I am happy to review to celebrate you. *Smile*


*Heart* Oh my gosh! This is a moving story and I was drawn in right from the start where you share bad news. I wanted to know more. I was a bit slowed down by the adverb in the first sentence. I wonder how you could show "apologetically". *Think*

*Peng* You revealed your main character Sid so vividly with his actions and dialogue that showed his emotions. The situation felt realistic. The comment about the Queen really nailed his thinking even while he will eventually realize the truth.

*Thumbsup* His reminiscing about the army and the contrast with this situation was potent as this situation is one closer to his heart. The description of the ward and the picture of this vivacious woman, even while ill, was vivid and I like how you lead us into Sid's memories about how they met. It makes sense here. It was a unique relationship that he did not give up on! Cool.

*Smile* Good job with bringing us back to the present with his wife's quip! *Laugh* I think it made sense too that he would forget a gift and then want to get the best he could for the last anniversary. The Disney Princess idea was cute and made me smile. His wife is shown to be young at heart!

*Bursty* His desperation to get the perfect ring was so well shown in all the ways he tried to raise money and met blocks at every turn. I can imagine his frustration. He knew she would not mind not getting such an expensive item and I wish he had stuck with that. The twist here was unexpected and dark. Wow!

*Shock2* The last line revealed his darker side that I did not expect, which says he might have gone a bit round the bend, not even considering what his wife would say. She would know he could not afford it. The message that grief took him over the edge was clear. Even his voice and smirk at the end sounds not like him. Well done.

*Penr* The story and plot flowed in a coherent manner with lots of descriptive detail and active verbs to keep the drama moving. The mix of dialogue and narrative was effective and the historical ring was an original idea, perfect for a gift.

*Quill* I am not a pro on story writing especially point of view as I tend to be all over the map with that when I write and I could be wrong so I will just query as it occurred to me:
I think you are writing in third person yet this line to me sounds like Sid is talking:
"How could he face the love of his life when.." Maybe something like "He wondered how..."

*Quill* Also I noticed a typo: "A crazy thought flited through his mind, but .." "Flited" should be "flitted". I wondered about the phrase with "but" as the the word "crazy" already indicated he was beyond sanity. The but usually indicates an opposite. Not sure how to fix it and maybe it is just me! If you leave it out altogether as redundant, the reader will soon come to their own conclusion.
"A crazy thought flitted through his head and he sprang..." This would keep a faster pace and keep a bit of surprise. The girl later mentions insane and we can see for ourselves. *Wink* Just a thought.

*Star*Whew! This was entertaining and evoked so many emotions and reactions. Thanks for sharing this love tale with a twist. Now I want to know what happens. LOL

Good luck with the contest.

Write on!

2,558 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 103 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/1starsong