\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ripglaedr3/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9
Review Requests: OFF
3,064 Public Reviews Given
3,745 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Feedback reveals much about a reviewer. What you offer in reaction can expose you. No crusader, “just another victim reporting.”
Feels like a million words in review. Wordometer needle stuck. I improve my critical analysis in feedback, meet other writers, if only their words. *Quill*}
Read my reviews, see output from others. Responses to my reviews have affirmed enough.
I try not be/play authority of someone else’s words, left to the master of the work. I will get carried away in response. Reflect/react/review, with fuller perspective.
In 2024: “Your reviews are great…supportive, encouraging, and ‘in depth’, with excellent suggestions…exactly the kind of reviews I…strive to write. Alas, such reviews are the exception on here. Most are drive-by reviews…just heap praise on the item. A small number are just critical and not supportive...Yours are among the one (in) twenty…that are gems. People should be grateful for getting them.”
I'm good at...
Poetry, shorter stuff. I'm mostly blind. I react and encourage with feedback, suggest direction to something better. I break the conventional fourth wall. Not sure what it means.
Favorite Genres
nature, love, psychological, spiritual, inspirational, humor, emotional, drama, human interest, dystopian.
Favorite Item Types
poetry, short story, essay/opinion/blog
Public Reviews
Previous ... 5 6 7 8 -9- 10 11 12 13 14 ... Next
201
201
Review of Autumn  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*ConfettiV*
We Celebrate your writing this month.


Happy Account Anniversary An apple a day.... Author Icon
or should I say Biddle, Connie ? *Think*

It’s your Writing.Com Account Anniversary this month. I’m a group reviewer who has been prying to find this little poem "AutumnOpen in new Window.to lend comment.

"Autumn" is a beautifully crafted ‘Whitney’ poem that encapsulates the essence of the season, with concise elegance. The structure, employed by you, adheres to the prescribed syllable count, and within these constraints, you still manage to create a vivid snapshot of autumn's transformative beauty. The brevity of each line adds to the impact, allowing each word to resonate, and contribute, to the overall sensory experience.

Your style is marked here by its simplicity and precision, emphasizing the inherent beauty of autumn through carefully chosen words. The poem begins with the stark image of "drops red leaves," capturing the visual spectacle of falling foliage. This starkness is followed by the subtle cooling of the sun, a sensory shift that aligns with the changing weather. The concise phrases, such as "clears the air" and "shortens the day," create a vivid progression, seamlessly moving through the elements of autumn.

The theme revolves around the transformative nature of autumn, emphasizing the visual and atmospheric changes that define the season. The shift from summer to fall is depicted through a series of concise yet evocative images, each line contributing to the overall portrayal of this seasonal metamorphosis. The mention of blooming mums and ripening pumpkins adds a touch of warmth and abundance, creating a well-rounded representation of autumn's bounty.

The Whitney form's syllabic constraints add a layer of discipline to the poem, requiring precision in expression. The seven-line structure allows for a concise exploration of autumn's key features, while maintaining a sense of rhythmic flow. You could consider experimentation with subtle variations in line length or introducing strategic line breaks that could enhance the vision of the poem's dynamic quality, without deviating from the prescribed syllabic structure of this poetry form.

Poetic devices are subtly woven into the fabric of your offering, enhancing its sensory richness. The repetition of "drops" in the opening line adds a gentle rhythm, mimicking the falling leaves. The use of strong verbs, such as "cools," "clears," and "shortens," contributes to the poem's vivid and active language. To further enrich the poetic elements even further, for this or any other poem, consider exploring metaphorical language or introducing symbolic connections that deepen the thematic resonance for your reading audience.

My favorite season to wield words about, “Autumn" is a delightful exploration of the season's transformative beauty within the constraints of the Whitney form. Continue to experiment with poetic devices to deepen the emotional and thematic resonance complimentary to your visionary words.. Your ability to capture the essence of autumn within the structured confines of the Whitney form showcases a keen understanding of poetic craft.

A belated happy anniversary to you.



Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Account Anniversary Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
202
202
Review of On Being Alone  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello C.E. Thieroff Author Icon,

"On Being Alone" presents a touching introspective exploration of the narrator's experience with solitude, love, and the complexities of relationships. This item described as prose (could be assigned different category?) offers a candid glimpse into some internal reflections, addressing the loneliness that coexists with the desire for companionship. The theme of solitude and its emotional impact is a universal one, making the narrative relatable to a broad audience, of which I know a few right now.

The approach to the subject matter is deeply personal and authentic, creating an immediate connection between narrator and reader. The introspective nature of this piece allows readers to empathize with that longing for companionship, acknowledgment of personal shortcomings, and reflection about past relationships. The informal tone and conversational style contribute to the authenticity, inviting a reader to connect with the internal dialogue.

The theme of loneliness is effectively conveyed through the described yearning for physical touch, companionship, and the tenderness observed in others' relationships. The contrast between the convenience of solitude and the emotional void it leaves is discernible. The narrator's self-awareness regarding personal shortcomings adds depth to the portrayal of loneliness, as the internal struggle, is not solely attributed to external circumstances, but also to introspective acknowledgment.

The telling here exhibits a strong command of grammar and language, maintaining clarity and coherence throughout. The straightforward expression aligns with the conversational style, facilitating ease of understanding for readers like myself. The use of sentence structure effectively conveys the emotional nuances, emphasizing the narrator's feelings of ache, self-awareness, and the complexities of past loves.

Literary devices, such as metaphors and similes, are sparingly used but contribute to the vivid imagery within the prose. The comparison of the narrator's heart being crumpled "like a fender into a telephone pole at forty miles an hour" is a poignant metaphor that encapsulates the emotional impact of past heartbreaks. Consider incorporating more metaphorical language or symbolic connections to further enrich your narrative here and evoke a deeper emotional response.

Suggestions for improvement could involve experimenting with varied sentence structures or introducing brief moments of reflection on specific memories. This could add a nuanced layer to the narrative and engage readers on a more sensory and emotional level. For example, expanding on a specific memory or incorporating dialogue could enhance the reader's connection to the narrator's experiences.

Upon completion of my perusal of this offering, a compelling and sincere exploration of solitude, love, and self-awareness was discovered. The authenticity of the narrative, coupled with a strong command of language, creates a piece that resonates with readers on an emotional level. Consider further developing the use of literary devices and experimenting with narrative structure to enhance the richness of the prose. It is relatable and a worthy write to have considered for this response.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
203
203
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy WDC Account Anniversary Chrys O'Shea - Writing again Author Icon,
belated actually,

I perused your poetry, in recognition of your 11 years as a member in our writing community. And so, I decided to review "Which One Will Win?Open in new Window., adorned with the sky blue ribbon.

Your poem provoked thought that drew upon the metaphor of two wolves, to explore the internal struggles within the human soul. The opening lines immediately set a contemplative tone, presenting the turmoil within, as a conflict between two opposing forces. The use of vivid imagery, such as "gnarling and snarling in a fight," creates a visceral portrayal of the inner conflict, inviting readers to visualize the emotional struggles described.

Your style is marked by clarity, and a directness of expression that enhances the impact of the poem's message. The metaphor of the two wolves provides a tangible and relatable image for readers, making the internal struggle accessible. The concise and straightforward language mirrors the simplicity of the allegorical message, allowing the central theme to resonate with clarity. The poem unfolds as a moral reflection, prompting readers to introspect, and consider the choices that shape their internal landscape.

The theme revolves around the internal conflict between opposing forces, within the human soul, as symbolized by the two wolves. The dichotomy of good and evil, kindness and hatred, love and anger, is presented with stark clarity. The moral question of which wolf will prevail becomes a universal inquiry, inviting readers to reflect on their own choices, and actions. The poem's message aligns with the timeless wisdom found in the old Cherokee legend, emphasizing the power of individual choice, in shaping one's character.

Formally, the poem adheres to a straightforward structure, utilizing concise stanzas to convey its message. The use of short lines contributes to the poem's rhythmic quality, creating a steady pace that mirrors the internal struggle described. You might consider experimenting with variations in line length, or introducing subtle pauses, to enhance the piece's dynamic quality, and emphasize key moments, within the narrative.

Poetic devices, particularly metaphor and repetition, play a crucial role in conveying the poem's allegorical message. The repeated phrase "Which one will win" becomes a refrain, emphasizing the central question, and prompting introspection. The metaphor of the two wolves serves as a powerful symbol, encapsulating the internal dualities that shape human behavior. To further enrich the poetic elements, exploring variations in language, or introducing symbolic connections that deepen the layers of meaning within the allegory, might be beneficial, in relation to connection for readers.

Looking again, "Which One Will Win?" is a reflective exploration of internal struggles, and the choices that define the human soul. Refining the form to enhance its dynamic quality, if you choose, and continue to experiment with poetic devices, could deepen the emotional, and thematic, resonance. Your ability to convey a timeless moral message, with clarity, and resonance, showcases a keen understanding of the human experience.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewers Group
WDC Anniversary Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
204
204
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
~~~ A Newbie Review ~~~


Hello Riply Duke,

In your prose piece, "Consider the Seed," you embark on a contemplative journey, drawing parallels between the growth of a seed and the emotional resilience required during times of heartbreak. The opening lines beckon readers to empathize with the seed's transformative process, "think of a seed and how it must feel," immediately establishing a metaphorical foundation that sets the tone for introspective exploration.

Your style is characterized by its brevity and impactful imagery. The concise sentences mirror the seed's gradual expansion and burst forth, enhancing this depicted sensory quality. The use of second-person narration, addressing the reader directly with phrases like "think of a seed" and "consider the seed," fosters a sense of shared reflection, inviting readers to internalize the metaphor and connect it to their own experiences. It also passes as wisdom, advice for those needing perspective.

The theme revolves around resilience, growth, and the missed potential when growth is hindered. The metaphorical association of the seed's growth with emotional healing provides a nuanced perspective on the process of overcoming heartbreak. The theme encourages readers to ponder the potential for personal growth that can arise from adversity, emphasizing the transformative power embedded within challenging experiences.

Formally, the prose format is like free verse (poetry), as it allows for a free-flowing exploration of ideas, unbound by traditional verse structures. The absence of line breaks contributes to a seamless narrative, allowing the metaphor to unfold organically. You might consider experimenting with varying sentence structures or incorporating brief pauses to add a rhythmic cadence, enhancing the poem's flow while maintaining the fluidity of the offered prose.

Poetic devices are subtly interwoven throughout the poem, contributing to its emotional resonance. The metaphor of the seed serves as a powerful symbol, encapsulating the potential for growth and transformation. The use of personification, attributing emotions to the seed, fosters a deeper connection between the reader and the metaphor. To amplify the poetic elements, consider exploring additional metaphors or incorporating subtle wordplay to enrich the narrative. Or just something to hold on to for that next write.

"Consider the Seed" impresses as a thought-provoking exploration of resilience and personal growth, skillfully employing metaphor to convey complex emotional experiences. I think I would like to see you enhance its rhythmic flow, and continue to explore poetic devices to deepen the emotional and thematic resonance. It’s masterful, as is. A pleasure to discover and offer comment.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Angel Army Reviewer
Non-Animated Angel Army Signature


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
205
205
Review of Haiku #65  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Vanishing Vapor Author Icon,

"Haiku #65" offers a vivid snapshot of nature, capturing the essence of anticipation and celebration among birds before the impending blizzard. I delve into the haiku's style, theme, and form to unravel its nuances, while exploring the underlying message.

The haiku adheres to the traditional 5-7-5 syllable structure, presenting a concise yet evocative scene. The brevity of the Japanese form often necessitates precision in language, and your poem achieves this succinctly. Each line contributes to the overall atmosphere, creating a visual and emotional impact.

The opening line, "birds sing in sunshine," sets a harmonious and uplifting tone. The juxtaposition of "birds" and "sunshine" creates an image of vitality and joy. The act of singing becomes a metaphor for the birds' expression of life and happiness. This line introduces a sense of immediacy, drawing readers into the moment of the birds' celebration.

The second line, "blithely before blizzard ice," introduces an impending contrast to the initial joy. The use of "blithely" conveys a carefree spirit, emphasizing the stark shift in weather that follows. The choice of "blizzard ice" conjures an image of harsh conditions, foreshadowing the challenges ahead. This line serves as a pivotal moment in the haiku, introducing a layer of tension and anticipation.

The concluding line, "quiets those taken," brings closure to the haiku with a poignant reflection on the transience of life. The word "quiets" carries a dual meaning, alluding to both the hush of the impending blizzard and the silence that follows the birds' celebration. The phrase "those taken" suggests a somber acknowledgment of the inevitable impact of nature's forces.

The thematic exploration of life's fleeting moments and the contrast between celebration and silence resonates deeply with me. The haiku prompts introspection about the cyclical nature of existence and the transient beauty found in simple, spontaneous joys. The use of alliteration and assonance punctuates reader response to the conveyance, especially in that second line.

You might consider refining the opening line for a more nuanced introduction. For example, "birds' songs echo" or "birds' melodies" could enhance the auditory aspect of their celebration, providing a more immersive experience for readers. It would tie nicely with the brief musicality employed by the mentioned poetic devices..

The obscurely titled "Haiku #65" effectively captures a delicate balance between joy and impending challenges. Its thematic depth and adherence to the haiku form contribute to a poignant reflection on the cycles of nature and life. A pleasure to have read and considered for this feedback.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Angel Army Reviewer
Non-Animated Angel Army Signature


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
206
206
Review of A beat of blood  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello Tones,

"A beat of blood" presents a unique take on the traditional haiku form, deviating from the conventional 5-7-5 syllable structure. I’ve explored the poem’s elements that make this piece distinctive and how the departure from the traditional form impacts the conveyance offered.

The opening line, "I woke last night to the sound," sets the stage with a sense of awakening and awareness. The use of the first-person perspective immediately draws the reader into a personal experience. The word "sound" is open-ended, inviting curiosity about what is to come. This line establishes a contemplative mood, prompting readers to delve into the auditory experience described.

The second line, "of the drum in me," introduces a metaphorical layer to the haiku. The drum, often associated with rhythm and heartbeat, becomes a symbolic representation of something internal. This metaphor suggests an intimate connection between the speaker and the rhythmic essence within them. The choice of "in me" implies an introspective exploration, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of the internal drum.

The title, "A beat of blood," aligns seamlessly with the thematic elements of the haiku. The imagery of blood introduces a visceral and evocative element, enhancing the emotional impact of the poem. This connection between the drum and blood deepens the metaphor, suggesting a profound and life-sustaining rhythm within the speaker.

The third line, "Bloody, broken, it beat," maintains its vivid and evocative conclusion. The use of "Bloody, broken" adds a layer of intensity and vulnerability to the haiku. The juxtaposition of these descriptors with "it beat" creates a poignant contrast, emphasizing the persistence of the internal drum despite its apparent fragility.

The departure from the traditional syllable structure remains a bold choice that adds a layer of experimentation to the haiku. Almost inverted, this structure creates a sense of irregularity and disruption, aligning with the theme of brokenness. I noted something that may have been designed to enhance the intentional departure from convention. You took an extra beat. An extra space before the end line word ‘beat’’ was a visual demonstration of throwing this off its axis, just a little more. If intended, very subtle and tactile move that drew the attention of this reader.

Your haiku offers a thought-provoking exploration of internal struggle and resilience. The title enhances the poem’s thematic resonance, and the departure from the traditional structure contributes to something with a unique identity, emphasizing its experimental nature. A worthwhile endeavor that broadens perspective for this poetry consumer.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Angel Army Reviewer
Non-Animated Angel Army Signature


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
207
207
Review of Timid  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello ladyabstract Author Icon,

"Timid" presents a delightful haiku that harvests the essence of nature's dance through the personification of trees. There are various aspects of this poem that contribute to it’s charm.

The first line, "Wind, the breath of life," establishes a vivid connection between the wind and life itself. By attributing breath to the wind, the haiku introduces a subtle anthropomorphic quality, implying that the wind possesses life-like characteristics. This personification sets the stage for the ensuing interaction between the wind and the trees.

The second line, "coaxes trees to sway and dance," beautifully portrays the influence of the wind on the trees. The word "coaxes" suggests a gentle encouragement, creating an image of a nurturing force guiding the trees. The choice of "sway and dance" adds a dynamic and rhythmic quality to the scene. This line effectively conveys the fluid and graceful movement of the trees as they respond to the wind's coaxing.

The third line, "till they're shy no more," introduces a touch of whimsy and personification. Describing the trees as becoming "shy" implies a certain timidity or hesitation in their initial response to the wind. However, as the dance progresses, the trees shed their timidity and fully embrace the movement. This transformation adds a layer of emotion and character to the natural elements, inviting readers to empathize with the trees' journey from timidity to confidence.

The theme revolves around the interaction between nature's elements, emphasizing the transformative power of the wind on the trees. It captures a delicate and almost playful moment in the dance of the natural world.

In terms of form, your haiku has adhered to the traditional structural form with its three lines involving the 5-7-5 syllable count. The concise and focused nature of the Japanese form allows for a succinct portrayal of the scene, conveying a complete image for me that suggests it’s emotional nuance.

As a suggestion, consider experimenting with the use of a specific season word (kigo) to ground the haiku in a particular time of year. This could enhance the traditional aspects of the poem, connecting it to the ever-changing seasons in the haiku tradition.

I found, "Timid" to be a delightful haiku that captures the grace and transformation within nature's dance. Your skillful use of personification and vivid imagery contributes to the poem's charm and evocative quality. It aligns with what I attempt to discover with a poem, and a joy to consider for this feedback.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Angel Army Reviewer
Non-Animated Angel Army Signature


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
208
208
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Lenna Rivoli Author Icon,

"The Praying-Mantis" is a captivating haiku that offers a vivid glimpse into the world of the insect while evoking a sense of reverence and divinity.

The first line, "Long limbed and graceful," immediately draws attention to the physical attributes of the praying mantis. The choice of "long limbed" conjures an image of elongated limbs, creating a visual impression of elegance and delicacy. This line establishes a strong foundation for the subsequent descriptions, setting the stage for the portrayal of the insect's poised demeanor.

The second line, "In a solemn stance of poise," introduces a sense of mindfulness and intentionality. The use of "solemn" suggests a solemn seriousness, emphasizing the gravity of the mantis's posture. The word "poise" further reinforces the idea of balance and grace, portraying the insect in a state of poised readiness. This line not only describes the physical posture of the mantis but also alludes to a deeper, almost meditative quality.

The third line, "Saintly and divine," elevates the haiku to a spiritual dimension. The choice of "saintly" implies a sense of purity and holiness, while "divine" amplifies the religious undertones. This line adds a layer of metaphorical significance, inviting readers to perceive the praying mantis not merely as an insect but as a symbol of reverence. The use of religious imagery enriches the thematic depth, transforming the haiku into a contemplative piece.

The overall theme revolves around the praying mantis as a symbol of grace, poise, and perhaps even spiritual significance. The haiku beautifully captures the essence of the insect's physical and metaphorical qualities, merging the tangible with the transcendent. In terms of form, the haiku adheres to the traditional structure of three lines with a 5-7-5 syllable count. This form enhances the concise and focused nature of the poem, allowing it to convey a vivid image and evoke a specific emotional response.

As a suggestion, consider exploring the use of a specific season word (kigo) to enhance the haiku's connection to a particular time of year. This could further anchor the poem within a seasonal context and contribute to the traditional aspects of haiku.

In conclusion, this is a beautifully crafted haiku that seamlessly combines visual imagery with metaphorical depth, and perhaps a bit of personification. Your choice of language and thematic exploration results in a haiku that resonates with a sense of reverence and contemplation.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Angel Army Reviewer
Non-Animated Angel Army Signature


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
209
209
Review of Fall's Spire  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Maverick Author Icon,

Upon reading your haiku titled "Fall’s Spire," I'm immediately drawn into the beauty and simplicity encapsulated within the form’s three lines. The elegance of the language and the vivid imagery crafted in such a compact structure demonstrate a mastery of the haiku style. I here offer my reaction to the various elements incorporated that are contributing to beauty your poem.

The first line, "Crystalline descent," sets the tone for the entire haiku. The choice of "crystalline" conjures a sense of purity and clarity, and paired with "descent," it paints a vivid picture of something delicate falling. This could be interpreted as either rain or dew, and the ambiguity adds depth for a curious reader like me, as it invites readers to engage with the imagery on a personal level. The word "crystalline" also introduces a sense of refinement, hinting at the aesthetic quality of the natural phenomenon.

The second line, "Drops distend the lake's basin," beautifully expands on the initial image. The use of "distend" is particularly intriguing as it suggests not just a filling but a stretching, emphasizing the impact of the falling drops on the lake. This line introduces a tactile quality, making the reader feel the subtle, transformative touch of each raindrop on the lake's surface. The choice of "basin" adds a sense of containment and emphasizes the interconnectedness of nature.

The final line, "Chilled kisses, Fall's spire," gracefully concludes the haiku with a metaphorical flourish. Describing raindrops as "chilled kisses" is a poetic personification that adds an emotional layer to the natural scene. The term "Fall's spire" is a delightful play on words, seamlessly blending the seasonal reference with the image of drops descending like a spire. This line invites contemplation on the symbiotic relationship between the elements and the changing season.

The overall theme of the haiku appears to be the transformative beauty of autumn rain. It captures a moment of serene transition, where raindrops interact with the lake, echoing the cyclical patterns of nature. The seasonal reference to fall is subtly woven into the fabric of the poem, adding depth and a temporal dimension to the scene.

In terms of form, the haiku adheres to the traditional structure of three lines with a 5-7-5 syllable count. The form contributes to the poem's effectiveness, allowing it to convey a profound image and emotion within a concise framework.

As a suggestion, consider exploring the possibility of incorporating a kigo (seasonal word) more explicitly to enhance the seasonal association within the haiku. This could provide readers with an even more distinct sense of fall.

“Fall’s Spire" caught my attention by title alone, sometimes part of the poem itself. A good hook is certainly a good title. Your haiku skillfully captures the essence of autumn rain. Your use of language, imagery, and form collectively create a harmonious and evocative piece that resonates with this reader.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
210
210
Review of Wings  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello foxtale Author Icon,

"Wings" is a captivating haiku that encapsulates a profound sentiment within the brevity of three lines. The poem explores the theme of forgiveness through the imagery of white cranes and the symbolic act of folding paper. The style, theme, form, and poetic devices contribute to the haiku's elegance and emotional resonance.

The style of the haiku is characterized by its simplicity and clarity, adhering to the traditional form of this poetic genre. The brevity of haiku often demands concise language, and "Wings" achieves this, distilling a poignant message within the 17-syllable structure. The choice of words is evocative, with "wings," "forgiveness," "white cranes," and "paper creased - folded" forming a delicate tapestry of imagery and emotion.

The theme of forgiveness is central to the haiku, conveyed through the metaphor of white cranes. Cranes, in many cultures, symbolize longevity, peace, and grace. In this context, the haiku suggests that forgiveness can be a transformative and graceful process, akin to the growth of one thousand strong cranes. The act of folding paper further reinforces the theme, alluding to the meditative and deliberate nature of forgiveness. The theme invites readers to contemplate the beauty and power inherent in the act of forgiving.

This form, adhering to structural rule, deeply rooted in Japanese poetry, accentuates brevity and precision. The choice of form is fitting for the contemplative nature, allowing the reader to absorb the essence of forgiveness in a few carefully crafted lines. The brevity also adds a sense of immediacy, emphasizing the impact of forgiveness in a concise space.

Poetic devices, particularly metaphor and symbolism, enhance the haiku's depth. The metaphor of "Wings beat forgiveness" suggests a dynamic and transformative process, as if forgiveness has its own rhythm and life force. The image of "white cranes grow one thousand strong" symbolizes the abundance and strength that forgiveness can generate. Additionally, the act of folding paper serves as a symbolic gesture, echoing the intricate and intentional nature of forgiveness.

On Line Three:

The reference to folding paper could be interpreted as a nod to origami, the traditional Japanese art of paper folding, where intricate and beautiful sculptures are created by folding a single sheet of paper. Considering this interpretation adds an additional layer of meaning to the poem. In this context, the act of folding paper becomes a deliberate, intentional, and artistic process. Each fold is purposeful, requiring patience, precision, and a careful understanding of the paper's potential. Applying this to the theme of forgiveness in the haiku, the choice of origami as a metaphor suggests that forgiveness, like the delicate art of folding paper, is a thoughtful, conscious, and transformative act.

Origami involves taking something flat and two-dimensional and turning it into a three-dimensional work of art. As with forgiveness, in the haiku it could be seen as the process of transforming a complex emotional landscape into something more harmonious and beautiful. Each fold represents a step in this transformation, creating a new, intricate form from the raw material of a challenging situation.

Additionally, origami often symbolizes harmony, balance, and simplicity. By linking forgiveness to the art of origami, the haiku conveys a sense that forgiveness, like a well-crafted origami sculpture, brings balance and harmony to the emotional complexities involved. It emphasizes the idea that forgiveness is not only a resolution but also a form of emotional artistry.

The metaphor of origami also introduces a cultural layer to the poem, aligning it with Japanese traditions. This cultural context adds richness and depth to the haiku, inviting readers to consider forgiveness within the framework of a specific cultural practice. Interpreting the folding of paper as origami enriches the poem's view by infusing the intentional, transformative, and artistic qualities associated with this traditional Japanese craft. It aligns the act of forgiveness with the meticulous art of origami, creating a nuanced and culturally resonant exploration of the theme.

Suggestions for improvement:
1. Consider experimenting with line breaks to emphasize specific words or images. For example, "Wings beat / forgiveness" could be broken into two lines to highlight the rhythmic quality of forgiveness. Experimenting with line breaks can enhance the visual and auditory impact of the haiku.

2. Explore variations in punctuation or spacing to create pauses that allow readers to savor each element of the haiku. For instance, consider using an em dash or ellipsis to create subtle breaks: "Wings beat forgiveness— / White cranes grow one thousand strong..."

A beautifully crafted haiku that skillfully explores forgiveness through vivid imagery and symbolism. Your haiku's simplicity, thematic depth, and adherence to traditional form make it a compelling and contemplative piece.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
211
211
Review of Spectrum  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy Account Anniversary B4HEART Author Icon,

I’ve come to review your writing in honor of your 23 years here! An original member and still active. I poked around and managed to find something I thought would be a challenge to consider for feedback.

In "Spectrum", I find a piece that contemplates the profound mysteries of life, death, and what lies beyond this mortal coil. The poem engages with existential questions, employing a rhythmic and rhyming structure that gives the verses a melodic quality. The opening lines, "We're here today, gone tomorrow, time shall surpass," immediately set the stage for a reflective exploration of the transient nature of life and the enigma that shrouds our existence.

Stylistically, the poem adopts a conversational and contemplative tone, inviting readers to join the poet in pondering life's uncertainties. The rhyming scheme enhances the musicality of the verses, creating a cadence that guides the reader through the exploration of complex themes. The repetition of the word "Life" in the lines "Ironically, Life, Life is a Mystery" serves as a rhetorical device, emphasizing the overarching theme and the inherent mystery associated with existence.

I find a theme that revolves around the elusive nature of life, death, and the uncertainty that surrounds what comes afterward. The poem grapples with age-old questions about the origins of life, the purpose of existence, and the unknown realm of death. The reference to Adam and Eve and the mention of evolution touch upon contrasting views of our origin, adding layers to the thematic exploration. The uncertainty surrounding the afterlife is expressed through vivid imagery, such as the prism through which we flow and the possibility of encountering light.

The form of this piece, with its concise stanzas and rhyming couplets, contributes to the accessibility of the profound subject matter. The use of rhetorical questions, such as "Are we reborn or finished when life runs out?" and "Has death no being, just the end, Limbo?" prompts readers to actively engage with the poet's contemplation. The rhythmic flow of the verses creates a sense of continuity, mirroring the ongoing quest for understanding.

Poetic devices, including irony and vivid imagery, enrich the verses with layers of meaning. The use of irony in describing life as a mystery, paralleling it with historical uncertainties, highlights the paradoxical nature of our quest for answers. The imagery of death as a prism through which we flow adds a visual and conceptual dimension to the exploration, emphasizing the diverse possibilities that might await beyond life.

While your poem effectively navigates existential questions, the inclusion of specific examples or personal reflections could add a bit more of an intimate touch. If still possible to edit further, you might consider expanding on the poet's perspective or incorporating metaphorical elements to further illustrate the complexities of life and death.

Much to consider with your offering. This was an interesting experience, finding a new/old source to consider. A belated WDC Account Anniversary to you.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Account Anniversary Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
212
212
Review of Farewell My Child  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy Account Anniversary BScholl Author Icon,

I came to review your writing in acknowledgment of your 14th anniversary here. I couldn’t find anything new or updated in over a year, skimmed your IRA article before finding this short story.

"Farewell My Child" is a poignant exploration of the bittersweet emotions surrounding the departure of a child for college. The narrative unfolds with a reflective tone, allowing readers to connect with the universal experience of letting go. The story deftly captures the nuances of family dynamics, the impact of change, and the reassurance that love remains a steadfast companion.

The hook is emotionally resonant, immediately drawing one into the heart of the story. The opening paragraph, with the departure of Brittany for college, sets the stage for a narrative rich in introspection and the complexities of family relationships. The line, "After eighteen and a half years of being her daddy, all I felt was -- my heart breaking," encapsulates the emotional core of the piece, creating an empathetic connection with parents like myself who've faced a similar milestone.

The theme here revolves around the inevitability of change, the challenges of adjusting to an "empty nest," and the enduring nature of familial love. The story adeptly navigates the emotional landscape of the characters, delving into the mother's grief and the father's attempts at comfort. The theme is relatable, offering readers a mirror to their own experiences or those they anticipate.

The use of dialogue is a notable strength for this story, capturing the authenticity of familial interactions. The exchange between the husband and wife at Bill's Steakhouse provides a window into their emotional struggles, fears, and attempts to find solace. For example, the wife's line, "It’s just that she won’t be part of our daily lives. She won’t be our little girl. She won’t be Brittany. She’ll change," reflects the poignant realization of a parent grappling with the transformative nature of their child's departure.

The ending brings a heartwarming twist with Brittany's text message, introducing a sense of hope and continuity. This unexpected moment serves as a positive resolution, offering solace for the parents and reinforcing the idea that change can also bring new forms of connection. The line, "Farewell my child, you've grown up today," beautifully encapsulates the sentiment of letting go while cherishing the memories of childhood.

Suggestions for improvement:
1. Consider further exploration of the father's internal thoughts and emotions. Providing insight into his perspective during key moments could deepen the emotional impact and enhance the reader's connection with his character. I can tell you as a father, all kinds of scenarios play out…good and bad.

2. Utilize sensory details to evoke a more vivid setting. Enhancing descriptions of the restaurant, characters, and surroundings could contribute to a more immersive reading experience. For example, elaborating on the ambiance of Bill's Steakhouse or incorporating more visual details during key moments could enrich the storytelling. Sometimes, the setting triggers our subconscious thought, intermingles with those moments in ways we can’t separate from in memory.

3. Explore the theme of resilience and adaptation. While the story touches on the challenges of change, further emphasis on the characters' resilience and their journey toward adapting to the new phase of life could add layers to the narrative. Sometimes, it’s about what you can’t foresee, ultimately over-prepare for. A comparative I’ve had is either a vacation or camping trip, having supplies for every situation, yet we overpack and still omit the necessary.

In conclusion, as a father of a college dropout, "Farewell My Child" successfully captures the emotional complexities of a significant life transition for me. The story effectively balances introspection, dialogue, and a heartwarming resolution, providing readers with a relatable and moving narrative. In my case, this could have been a horror story ramp up, including the financial advisor (real) who got me into an annuity to hide my money to preserve his potential for federal funding/grant opportunities. My annuity is still worth the initial seed money. No longer enjoying that 10% annual bump. And a year of wasted college money. Worse, impact on my son who couldn’t tell me he was failing, out of fear. He was not ready. I image most think about the cost and value of college over what the investment will bring.

This story gave me plenty to recall and consider. Lots of planned money for college not being used now. If any of the 80k remaining wil ever be used by either kid…and what to do with this non-taxed money…dunno. At least I have a big annuity *Laugh**Cry* and a bunch of Roth’s for her and me, other investments, properties, her life insurance, her 401k that rivals all our savings, and cash on hand. My kid is working full-time, stays at home, earns 4% on the 30k he’s already saved…in 3 years time. He says he’s paying me back. *Laugh* So many things with this story reminding me, and I’m only thinking of money as parent. *Sad*

Your story was a trip down memory lane, and was happy to discover. Have a great WDC Account Birthday/Anniversary!

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Anniversary Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
213
213
Review of Dancing Nowhere  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy WDC Anniversary Annie,

I find some items viewable in your portfolio and was drawn to this old poem. "Dancing Nowhere" delicately explores the poignant theme of memory loss and the profound impact it has on individuals and their loved ones. The opening lines, "Locked inside a changing mind / While others search for the key," immediately draw the reader into the emotional landscape of the poem. The metaphor of a changing mind as a locked space sets the tone for a reflective exploration of the challenges and losses associated with memory deterioration.

Stylistically, the poem adopts a contemplative and measured tone, mirroring the gradual and often disorienting process of memory loss. The simplicity of language contributes to the accessibility of the verses, allowing the emotional weight of the subject matter to resonate with readers. The short and concise lines create a sense of rhythmic flow, mirroring the passage of time and the incremental nature of memory decline.

The theme revolves around the impact of memory loss, specifically the gradual fading of sweet memories and the unsettling reality of becoming unrecognizable to one's own children. The imagery of memories disappearing "till there is nothing left but breath" paints a vivid picture of the diminishing essence of self. The repetition of the word "breath" reinforces the idea that even when memories fade, the essence of life persists until the very end.

The poem adopts a structured form, with each stanza contributing to the narrative arc. The gradual progression from the search for the key to the ultimate release, as God "turns the key and sets them free," follows a logical and emotional trajectory. This structure adds coherence to your poem and guides the reader through the poignant journey of memory loss.

Poetic devices, such as metaphor and personification, enrich the verses with layers of meaning. The mind being described as a changing space and the search for the key serve as powerful metaphors for the complexity and difficulty of addressing memory decline. The personification of God turning the key not only adds a spiritual dimension to the narrative but also conveys a sense of release and liberation from the struggles of a life "dancing nowhere."

While the poem effectively communicates the emotional weight of memory loss, incorporating specific examples or vivid anecdotes could have deepened the reader's connection to this valuable insight of the subject matter. For instance, getting further into particular memories that slip away or describing the impact on familial relationships might enhance the emotional resonance of the poem. It’s ripe with possibilities for more, or a new approach now that time has passed.

I have a connection to memory loss, preparing for the possibility. This poem drew me in and helped gain perspective. Hope to see you around again writing and submitting your poems.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Anniversary Reviewer

Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
214
214
Review of Pajama Feet  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy WDC Anniversary DJ,

I discovered your writing here as a Writing.Com Account Anniversary reviewer. A fan of the written verses, I considered this poem because of its title for the following feedback:

"Pajama Feet" evokes a tender yet heart-wrenching narrative; it skillfully captures the innocence of a child's anticipation juxtaposed with the stark reality of loss. I found the style of your poem is straightforward, using concise language to convey a poignant story. The choice of short, simple phrases adds to the emotional impact, allowing this reader to connect with the rawness of the depicted moment.

The theme revolves around the fragile beauty of childhood joy and the abrupt confrontation with life's harshness. The initial scenes of a happy little boy, excited about Christmas and a promised toy, create a warm annd relatable atmosphere. The abrupt shift in tone, however, appears masterfully executed, as the revelation of the mother's passing shatters the festive illusion. This thematic duality creates a poignant contrast that can linger in the reader's emotions.

Formally, your offering adheres to a consistent rhyme scheme, contributing to its rhythmic flow. The repetition of the phrase "Pajama Feet" acts as a poignant refrain, emphasizing the innocence associated with the child. The use of vivid imagery, such as "glistening snow" and "twinkling bright lights," enhances the sensory experience, immersing those who might peruse with the festive setting before the heartbreaking revelation and turn of events, sometimes negating one of the happiest times of the year..

Poetic devices are employed herein with subtlety, allowing the narrative to brilliantly shine. The personification of the house, described as "stands silent," adds a haunting yet powerful quality to the scene, amplifying the emptiness felt by the child. The metaphorical use of the mother's passing, described as her heart ceasing to "play," adds depth to the emotional impact. It leaves one longing for that lost interaction and joy with her.

I tend to offer suggestions when I review, where I can. Something I thought: Consider exploring additional metaphorical elements or symbolic imagery to further enrich the layers of the poem. For instance, introducing symbols associated with hope or resilience could amplify the emotional journey of the young protagonist. An older poem, I’m sure you’re happy with it.

The conclusion of “Pajama Feet” leaves a lingering sense of sorrow and empathy for the young boy, which is emphasizing this fragility of life and the unexpected turns it can take…the unfairness of it for a child to experience. The juxtaposition of the child's innocent excitement with the harsh reality of loss is a powerful testament to the unpredictable nature of existence. Well worth considering.

A belated Account Anniversary. It was a pleasure considering your words and lending comment.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Anniversary Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
215
215
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy WDC Anniversary Cynaemon Author Icon,

I was poking around your Writing.Com portfolio and wanted to send a review for your 20th anniversary here. This title caught my eye: “An Ode on Extinction", which unfolds as a poignant lamentation for the loss of nature's treasures, blending vivid imagery with a call to action. The poem's opening lines immediately immerse the reader in a vivid landscape, as the fire in the ancient forest becomes a powerful symbol of destruction. The use of the fire as a metaphor carries emotional weight, as it not only describes a physical event but also encapsulates the broader theme of environmental degradation.

Stylistically, the poem adopts a solemn and reflective tone, echoing the elegiac tradition of odes. The choice of an ode as a form aligns with the gravity of the subject matter, providing a structured framework for the expression of grief and urgency. The simplicity of language, particularly in phrases like "Waves crash on long-forgotten shores," contributes to the elegiac quality, allowing the reader to feel the weight of each line.

The theme centers around the irreversible loss of elements of nature, from the ancient forest to the long-forgotten shores. The poem explores the impact of human activities on the environment, emphasizing the consequences that extend beyond the physical realm to the metaphysical, as seen in the choking gods and silenced creatures of the deep. The use of repetition, such as "never be heard again" and "never be seen again," underscores the permanence of this loss, creating a sense of inevitability.

Poetic devices, such as personification, infuse the verses with a sense of empathy and interconnectedness. The wind, river, and voice of the voiceless become anthropomorphic conduits for conveying the sorrow of the natural world. The personification of the wind, for instance, as it sighs "through leafy treetops where my children sing," adds a layer of intimacy to the narrative, inviting the reader to empathize with the voiceless entities.

The plea "I am the voice of the voiceless ~ Hear my cry!" serves as a powerful climax, emphasizing the urgency of addressing environmental issues. The use of the exclamation mark underscores the impassioned call, urging readers to pay heed to the cries of nature. This direct appeal elevates the poem beyond a mere elegy, transforming it into a call to action.

While the poem effectively communicates its lament for the loss of nature, further exploration of specific examples or vivid descriptions could enhance the reader's emotional connection. For instance, expanding on the unique characteristics of the ancient forest or the long-forgotten shores could evoke a more immersive experience. Perhaps, for a future poem, as this has been on lock down here many years.

Well, a belated anniversary acknowledgment it is. I was happy to have this opportunity to acknowledge your work here with the help of anniversary group.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Anniversary Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
216
216
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.


Happy Account Anniversary BlueJay Author Icon,

I thought I’d stop by as a reviewer from the WDC Account Anniversary group. Upon discovering your writing, I came across this song parody and gave it a read-aloud listen.

"I'm Beginning To Get A Migraine Headache" presents a humorous and relatable twist on the classic Christmas song, offering a playful take on the challenges of daily life. The song parody you offer seems to skillfully maintain the structure and rhythm of the original while injecting a dose of everyday reality. The opening lines immediately set the tone, with title line, blending humor with a candid depiction of the speaker's hectic routine, creating a delightful juxtaposition.

Stylistically, your poem embraces a conversational and informal tone, aligning with the parody genre. The choice to use the structure of a well-known Christmas song adds an element of familiarity, allowing your readers to easily engage with the humorous adaptation. The rhyme scheme and rhythm mirror the original song, contributing to the playful cadence that underscores the comical aspects of the speaker's experiences.

The theme revolves around the chaotic nature of a typical day, highlighting the mundane challenges that often go unnoticed. Through the lens of that humor, the poem captures the universal struggles of balancing work, family, and daily responsibilities. The recurring motif of a migraine headache serves as a comical thread, weaving through each stanza and unifying the various scenarios into a cohesive and yet repetitive narrative.

The poem cleverly employs hyperbole, exaggerating the challenges faced by the speaker, such as the kid eating sticks or the cat choosing the den as the perfect spot for regurgitation. These exaggerated elements contribute to the humor and serve as a vehicle for the reader to empathize with the speaker's chaotic day in a lighthearted manner. Actually, my cats puke on the carpet a lot, too.

While yourvsong parody effectively communicates its humorous intent, a suggestion for further enhancement could involve expanding on specific details to create more vivid images. For example, you could look into expanding upon the unique aspects of the speaker's work or family life which could add layers to the humor. Additionally, incorporating more creative language or wordplay could elevate the comedic impact.

It was a unique pleasure to have found this among your writing. Eighteen years ago a newbie. Got me beat by one. Belated anniversary wishes,

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Anniversary Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-



*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
217
217
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Dear 👼intuey Author Icon,

This narrative appears to blend elements of supernatural occurrences with a focus on nature-based healing and a cautionary message about the consequences of straying from the natural order. The use of voices carried on the wind seems to involve a spiritual connection to nature rather than traditional religious practices. The story suggests a caution against misusing this connection, as seen with the negative outcome when the protagonist's mother deviates into darker practices, potentially resembling witchcraft. The narrative seems to explore themes of balance, the consequences of meddling with forces beyond one's understanding, and the importance of recognizing when to let go.

The narrative is generally cohesive, but there are a few areas where clarification could enhance reader understanding. For instance:

1. Transition between healing and the supernatural:
The transition from learning about natural healing methods to the supernatural element is somewhat abrupt. Adding a smoother transition or a gradual introduction to the protagonist's growing abilities might help readers connect the two aspects more seamlessly.

2. Explanation of the voices on the wind:
Providing more insight into the origin or nature of the voices on the wind could help readers better understand the supernatural elements in the story. This could involve exploring the protagonist's spiritual journey or her understanding of these voices.

3. Character motivations:
Clarifying the mother's motivations for deviating into darker practices and what led her to make questionable decisions would add depth to her character and help readers empathize or comprehend her actions.

4. Daddy's transformation:
The narrative could benefit from a more nuanced exploration of the father's transformation. Describing the signs of his change and the emotional impact on the family could create a more vivid and immersive experience for the reader.

5. Resolution and aftermath:
The conclusion of the story is abrupt, and more details about the aftermath of the father's transformation and how the family copes with it would provide a more satisfying resolution.

Addressing these points could help bridge potential gaps and enhance the overall flow and coherence of the narrative, enabling readers to connect more deeply with the story's themes and characters. Understanding that a nuanced limited POV of the old woman can allow us to consider what to fill in. Though, it’s cautionary.

The narrative voice appears to be reliable, with the storytelling framed as a recollection by a 105-year-old named Lilly-Mae. The choice to narrate events with a childlike perspective might be a deliberate stylistic device aimed at conveying innocence or preserving the essence of the protagonist's earlier experiences. This technique can create a unique narrative flavor and allow the story to unfold through the eyes of a more naive, younger self.

The decision to tell the story could serve various purposes. It might be a form of reflection, a recounting of significant life events, or even be a cautionary tale. The notion of a death bed confession is a plausible interpretation, where Lilly-Mae, in her old age, reflects on a pivotal and possibly haunting episode from her past. This approach adds a layer of introspection and lends weight to the narrative, inviting readers to consider the consequences of the characters' actions and the broader themes explored in the story.

The narrative strongly implies that Daddy underwent a sinister transformation, potentially influenced by the mother's misguided attempts to prolong his life. The supernatural element, the change in Daddy's behavior, and the subsequent need to cleanse the room suggest a malevolent force took over him.

As for the absence of direct dialogue or attribution, it contributes to the narrative style but does leave room for interpretation. It's not actually stated whether the adult speaker was a party to any negligence or harm to their parent. The story focuses more on the consequences of the mother's actions and the family's response. The lack of detailed dialogue may intentionally leave certain aspects open to the reader's interpretation, allowing them to fill in some gaps with their imagination. This approach adds an air of mystery and invites readers to engage actively with the narrative.

I think this is how people are generally deceived. Letting readers assume information not provided by filling in the gaps where the reader is lead to help influence the drama, deceit into possible falsehood, for the purpose of employing flawed logic to dictate outcomes.

This is not religion or supernatural, because one cancels the other. This is a story that deflects from one’s own blame as a party to mistreating another. This is where reality and fiction intersect to fool the gullible. Even the speaker, if not deliberately misleading, is retelling lies of the mother to explain away how daddy met his demise. I chose to believe another hidden story at play that lead to his demise. It’s easy to get why some who step up to buy into the supernatural aspects of story, even if doubt and logic employed, because ‘what if’?

I look at the true purpose of telling this story. It’s entered as evidence. Not fact checked, not able to be investigated, it stands on its merit. The more the story goes around in circles, the more it is held as true. Daddy is dead, does not speak from the grave. Ultimately, a sensational story that seeks approval, or to delude from real truth. The story is a lie like those tales told in dark nights around campfire. What I could interpret.

This was intriguing and an interesting story with hidden subtext that could take any reader anywhere. It was a pleasure to consider for this feedback.


Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!




*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
218
218
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY!!! from "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*
Celebrating your writing this month with a review.



Hello Moarzjasac Author Icon,

I’m a reviewer for the WDC Account Anniversary committee, dropping by to pry into your written offerings. I was caught by the dreamy poem title here and wanted to lend response.

"The hush of falling snow" captures the serene beauty of a winter landscape with a delicate touch. The initial stanzas, adorned with imagery of "down soft new fallen snow," evoke a sensory experience, allowing readers to feel the softness and purity of the snowfall. The choice of language here not only describes the physical quality of the snow but also sets a tranquil tone for the reader.

The theme revolves around the transformative power of snow, both visually and acoustically. The poem explores how this "thick blanket" of snow becomes a silent force, muffling all sounds and creating a serene ambiance. The focus on "little children's footprints" beneath the even surface introduces a poignant element, suggesting the innocence and joy associated with snowfall, perhaps hinting at the transient nature of childhood.

The form of the poem reflects on the calm and ordered nature of a snow-covered landscape. The concise lines and straightforward structure mimic the simplicity of falling snow, creating a sense of kinship and unity. This form enhances the poem’s overall effect, allowing this reader to experience your offered words in a way that mirrors the unhurried descent of snowflakes.

Poetic devices, such as alliteration in "smooth cover" and "little children's footprints," contribute to the musicality of the verses. The repetition of the 's' sound mimics the softness of snow, creating a subtle, melodic quality. Additionally, the use of personification in "the hush of falling snow" endows the snowfall with a sense of human quality, or more, as if it actively has the ability to bring about silence, or ‘hush’..

While the simplicity of the poem is its strength, considering the exploration of additional sensory details could enhance the reader's engagement with this piece. Expanding on the visual aspects of the snowfall or diving deeper into the emotional impact upon the observer could deepen the poem's resonance, create a connection with those who relate to this experience, want the words to transform and transcend this experience. For example, incorporating the play of moonlight on the snow or exploring the speaker's emotional response to the quietness might provide more layers to the narrative. Just as blanket is employed, snowfall might seem like a wall that shuts out sound.

This was a great poem to consider with its dreamy, nature-romantic play. Thanks and hope to visit again.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
219
219
Review of THIS BROKEN HEART  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*


Happy WDC Anniversary Mari,

As an Anniversary Reviewer, I had the pleasure of perusing your portfolio to find your poetry…in particular, this item that I now lend thought to you.

In "THIS BROKEN HEART," you have crafted a vivid portrayal of heartbreak, intertwining themes of self-discovery and betrayal. The style employed is characterized by a blend of elegance and raw emotion, as reflected within the juxtaposition of a "Tailor-made suit" against the speaker's acknowledgment of being an "ugly duckling." This stylistic choice emphasizes the contrast between outward appearances and inner vulnerabilities, setting the stage for the exploration of love's complexities.

The theme of your poem revolves around the fragility of trust and the painful realization of deception. The initial admiration for the other person's kindness and acceptance creates a hopeful atmosphere, only to be shattered by the harsh revelation of the ultimate betrayal. The use of contrasting imagery, from the "dashing" appearance to the broken heart, creates a poignant narrative arc that resonates with the universal experience of heartache.

Formally, the poem employs a structured rhyme scheme, contributing to its rhythmic flow. The controlled cadence enhances the emotional impact, guiding the reader through the speaker's journey of vulnerability and eventual empowerment. The progression from admiration to disillusionment is marked by a subtle shift in tone, providing a dynamic rhythm that mirrors the emotional turbulence within the speaker.

Poetic devices play a crucial role in amplifying the emotional depth of this poem. The metaphor of the "ugly duckling" adds a layer of self-reflection, portraying the speaker's perception of inadequacy before the encounter. It enforced a feeling of one’s own self-negation as reaction. The use of personification here, describing tricks as "useless" and seeing through the "guise," imbues the speaker with newfound wisdom and strength in the face of deceit, albeit unfortunate education in love.

I considered if there was anything that could be improved. It is an old poem now, likely not to be reconsidered.
Suggestion: To enhance the impact of the emotional climax, consider experimenting with more varied and evocative language. Introduce metaphorical elements or symbols that vividly encapsulate the emotional transformation, adding layers to the speaker's resilience. For example, weaving in symbols of rebirth or renewal could elevate the thematic exploration you have created.

The conclusion leaves the reader with a sense of empowerment as the speaker sees through the deception and asserts newfound wisdom. The poem encapsulates the bittersweet journey of self-discovery, highlighting the scars left by betrayal but also celebrating the strength that emerges from the broken pieces.

Thank you for sharing with the community that I might read and offer my comment.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power
and Anniversary Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
220
220
Review of Finding  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Anniversary Reviews email siggie


*CakeB* HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary ReviewsOpen in new Window.*CakeP*


Happy WDC Account Anniversary Maria,

It was a pleasure to review your writing and consider this piece for feedback, with acknowledgement of your upcoming 17th anniversary on Writing.Com. "Finding" for me unfolded as a poignant journey of self-discovery and empowerment, which is encapsulated within the brevity of its verses. The poem's introspective tone is immediately striking, inviting this reader to explore the nuanced layers of the speaker's personal evolution. The simplicity of the language contrasts with the depth of these emotions conveyed, on display, creating a resonant narrative.

Stylistically, your poem employs concise lines and a straightforward structure, mirroring the clarity that comes with this one’s self-realization. The use of enjambment in "To have found the woman / among the remains of the girl" propels the reader seamlessly from one thought to the next, emphasizing the interconnectedness of these profound discoveries. This stylistic choice contributes to the overall flow, allowing your readership to navigate the speaker's transformative moments with ease.

The theme revolves around the process of self-discovery and the empowerment that stems from embracing one's true identity. The metaphorical progression from "the blob of me" to "the woman / among the remains of the girl" conveys a powerful and visual narrative of personal growth. The poem suggests that this journey is not linear but shaped by time, relationships, and internal strength. The invocation of various elements such as "compassionate friends," "a patient and forgiving man," and "fate" or "God" adds a spiritual dimension to the exploration of evolving selfhood.

The poem here effectively employs repetition within its lines to emphasize the gradual nature of this transformation. The refrain "It took..." serves as a rhythmic anchor, underlining the multifaceted aspects and contributors to the speaker's evolution. The repetition creates a sense of accumulation, an inventory, reinforcing the idea that strength, friendship, love, and fate are all integral components of the journey.

The use of metaphorical imagery, particularly being "enchanted by the Morning Sun," serves as a powerful and visual conclusion to the poem. The morning sun often symbolizes renewal and hope, suggesting that the speaker's self-discovery has brought about a new dawn in their life. It’s a realization, too. This choice of imagery adds a positive and uplifting note to the culmination of the speaker’s journey. Readers should find it affirming.

While the poem effectively communicates its themes, incorporating specific examples or vivid anecdotes could enhance the reader's connection to the speaker's experiences. Delving deeper into the impact of compassionate friends or illustrating the patient and forgiving moments with the man could provide more emotional resonance.

Overall, it was a pleasure to have considered this write for review.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Image #power over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
221
221
Review of Among the Books  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Detective Author Icon

"Among The Books" is a delightful ode to the enchanting world found within the pages of literature, expressing the solace and joy derived from the companionship of books. The poem's style is marked by a playful rhythm and rhyme scheme that echoes the whimsical nature of the subject matter.

Stylistically, you've adopted a casual and conversational tone, inviting readers into the speaker's personal journey among bookshelves and literary realms. The repetition of the phrase "Oh lonesome me" at the beginning creates a musical cadence, drawing attention to the speaker's initial sense of solitude. The rhyme scheme, particularly evident in lines like "Battles fought against ancient foes / And thrills to keep you on your toes," adds a lighthearted and engaging quality to the poem.

Thematically, this offering celebrates the transformative power of books, presenting them as portals to diverse adventures and realms. The speaker's quest for "long lost treasure" becomes a metaphor for the search for meaning and courage found within the pages of literature. The choice to mention specific locations like "the streets of Baltimore" and "a house on a rainy English moor" adds a layer of vividness, invoking iconic literary settings that readers can easily visualize.

Formally, your poem adheres to a regular rhyme scheme and consistent meter, contributing to its rhythmic flow. The use of enjambment allows ideas to seamlessly transition from one line to the next, mirroring the fluidity of thought and exploration. The single stanza structure creates a sense of unity, emphasizing the interconnectedness of the various literary adventures mentioned.

Poetic devices, such as metaphor and alliteration, enhance the poem's imagery and musicality. The comparison of each book to a "treasure trove" emphasizes the richness and value of the stories contained within. Alliteration, as seen in "sparkle of diamonds and pearls," adds a touch of elegance to the language, heightening the sense of wonder associated with the literary discoveries.

By way of a suggestion, consider expanding on specific examples of the types of books or genres that provide solace to the speaker. This could offer readers a more detailed insight into the speaker's literary preferences and deepen the emotional connection.

A charming celebration of the endless wonders found within the world of literature. With its rhythmic cadence and joyful exploration of various literary landscapes, I found it an engaging homage to the transformative power of books.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
222
222
Review of Poems old and new  Open in new Window.
for entry "ColorsOpen in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Jaya,

"Colors" unfolds like a vibrant tapestry, weaving together elements of nature, emotions, and spirituality. The poem explores the transformative power of colors and the profound impact they have on the speaker's perception of life. Let's delve into the various aspects that contribute to the richness of this piece.

Stylistically, your poem embraces a lyrical quality, employing vivid and sensory language to evoke a vivid mental image. The use of metaphorical language, such as "My world has burst into a thousand colors," immediately immerses the reader in a world painted with emotion. The repetition of "colors" reinforces the central theme, emphasizing the multisensory experience the speaker undergoes.

Thematically, this offering revolves around the theme of rejuvenation and the cyclical nature of life. The contrast between the perceived depressive nature of fall and the speaker's optimistic outlook creates a dynamic tension. This interplay between darkness and light reflects the broader theme of life's fluctuations and the enduring hope for positive change.

Formally, the poem adheres to a free verse structure, allowing the ideas to flow organically. The enjambment contributes to the seamless progression of thoughts, mirroring the fluidity of nature. The choice to present the poem as a single stanza enhances the sense of continuity, reinforcing the idea of life's ongoing journey.

Poetic devices, such as metaphor and personification, are skillfully employed to enhance the impact here. The comparison of fall's grey to a depressive state challenges conventional perceptions, inviting the reader to reconsider the beauty inherent in every season. The personification of nature as "standing sentinel" and "creative regeneration" infuses the poem with a sense of divine agency, highlighting the connection between the natural world and the speaker's spiritual perspective.

As a suggestion, consider exploring specific instances or examples that illustrate the transformative power of colors in the speaker's life. Providing concrete imagery or experiences could further anchor the poem in relatable emotions, allowing readers to connect more deeply with the speaker's journey.

Your poem is a celebration of life's kaleidoscope, artfully painted with language that resonates with optimism and spiritual awareness. The poem's fusion of style, theme, form, and poetic devices creates a harmonious composition that invites readers to reflect on the ever-changing hues of existence.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
223
223
Review of Summer Thunder  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Mouser,

Your poem, "Summer Thunder", invited this reader into a nostalgic realm, where the speaker reminisces about shared moments with their father during stormy times. The poem's beauty lies not only in its simplicity but in the depth of emotion it evokes through vivid imagery and a poignant narrative.

The style employed in this poem is akin to a reflective memoir, capturing the essence of a past shared experience. The choice of the first-person perspective creates an intimate connection between the speaker and the reader. The straightforward language mirrors the simplicity of the moments described, contributing to the overall sincerity of the piece.

Thematically, your offering explores the bond between the speaker and their father, using the backdrop of a summer thunderstorm as a metaphor for the passage of time and shared memories. The choice of focusing on the storm as a shared experience adds a layer of symbolism, suggesting the resilience and strength of the familial connection amidst life's turbulence.

The form of this poem aligns with its contemplative nature, utilizing short, concise lines that echo the pauses in the storm described. The enjambment creates a natural flow, mirroring the steady progression of rain. The structure itself becomes a reflection of the ebb and flow of memories, enhancing the thematic resonance.

Poetic devices, such as personification, play a subtle yet impactful role. The rain is described as "Sheet down on the thirsty yard," imbuing it with human-like qualities of thirst. This personification not only adds a layer of depth to the description but also subtly reinforces the theme of shared human experiences.

The poem's strength lies in its ability to transport me to a specific moment in time. In a way, it gives me my own vision of place. I feel I'm overlooking a vast farm field. I'm sensing dusk into night, when the day is drawing to a close. I did trouble with one section of the poem:

"There were long pauses
As we watched the lightning and thunder
Progress the rain would
Sheet down on the thirsty yard."

You had already described rain in 'sheets'. Either is used well. However, here the breaks or enjambment take away power from the natural break between 'progress' and 'the rain would sheet down on a thirsty yard.' That strong image is culled from reading through several hesitations to finally get what is meant. It helps if a reader does not have to stop and reread to consider this passage.

To avoid repetition, 'The rain drove down in sheets/Punctuated by lightning and thunder' could be edited to read: "Punctuated by lightning and thunder/the rain drove down'. You might find more impactful, unless you want to add personification to the rain or lend a more sensory experience.

A further suggestion would be to consider searching deeper into specific details or emotions associated with the father-child relationship during these storms. Expanding on certain nuances of these interactions could elevate the emotional impact and provide readers with a more immersive experience. What connects me is my own conversations with my kids and what I might share with them about storms, or about life, or how we passed time. Describing a few details can give us age (beyond 'kid'), the father's vocation/interests, the era, and more.

To sum up, "Summer Thunder" captivates with its sincerity and evocative imagery. Your poem beautifully encapsulates the warmth and significance of shared moments, making it a poignant ode to familial bonds. A pleasure to have perused to offer my comment.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
224
224
Review of Lurch  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello Piripica,

I read so many writers here, that I sometimes lose the impression a poet like yourself had made on me in the past. I wanted to look back at old reviews, but will have to read this stand alone. I’m sure I will get more familiar with your writing as I go.

Engaging with your poem "Lurch" was like navigating the undulating currents of introspection, as the poet masterfully captures the ebb and flow of emotional terrain. The choice of the title itself, "Lurch," sets a tone of uncertainty, and this feeling reverberates throughout the poem.

The style is noteworthy, employing a first-person narrative that immersed me as reader in the speaker's internal journey. The repetition of "again" adds emphasis, underlining the cyclical nature of the emotional turbulence. This choice cleverly mirrors the lurching feeling the poem describes, creating a rhythmic resonance.

Thematically, the poem delves into the speaker's struggle with an unfamiliar emotional landscape. The metaphor of the riverbed and the lack of a stable point to push off from evoke a sense of vulnerability and disorientation. The irony in "Out of my depth again" adds a layer of complexity, suggesting a recurring pattern that the speaker grapples with.

In terms of form, the poem adopts a free verse structure that mirrors the fluidity and unpredictability of emotions. The enjambment effectively mimics the uninterrupted flow of the internal monologue, contributing to the overall immersive experience. The stanzas themselves act as emotional markers, mirroring the shifting dynamics within the speaker.

Poetic devices, such as metaphor and personification, enrich the poem's texture. The comparison of the people to "White birds gliding slowly through a green world" conjures vivid imagery, emphasizing a sense of detachment and grace in the observed interactions. The personification of the green mirror as an unsteady path cleverly contrasts the security of the speaker's hands climbing along their metaphorical path.

I don’t know if anybody notices this kind of stuff, based on reaction to my own poetry endeavor. But, I think I’ve caught it… And my favorite line in the poem, “while overhanging leaves kiss their mirror twins on the edges.” As I was enjoying its visual beauty, I happened to notice this passage centers the poem, just as if you have mirrored one half of this offering with the other. Structurally, these are the kinds of things I try to apply and look for in good poetry. I was impressed by this.

As for suggestion, you could consider further exploring the emotional impact of the lurching feeling. Delve into specific emotions or experiences that contribute to this recurring sense of being "out of depth." Expanding on these aspects could enhance the reader's connection to the speaker's internal struggle.

I feel this poem captivates with its introspective journey, employing a skillful blend of style, theme, form, and poetic devices. The vivid imagery and rhythmic cadence create a poignant exploration of emotional turbulence.

A pleasure to revisit your poetry that I might lend some comment.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Super Power Reviewer
Join the fun! We inspire reviewers through kindness and learning!  Winner of eight Quills!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
225
225
Review of Christmas is Here  Open in new Window.
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello Amethyst Angel 💐 Author Icon,

Your parody lyrics, "Christmas Is Here," crafted in the style of an Imagine Dragons song, cleverly blend humor and introspection to create a refreshing take on the holiday season. The lyrics navigate the familiar landscape of Christmas traditions, injecting a humorous twist and a deeper reflection on the essence of the celebration. Let's delve into the various elements that make this parody engaging and effective.

Stylistically, your lyrics successfully capture the energetic and dynamic style associated with Imagine Dragons. The use of colloquial language, playful rhymes, and the incorporation of specific Christmas references contribute to the parody's authenticity. Lines like "Tripping over tinsel, it's dangerous" and "Shop at Ross, gift for the boss" showcase a witty play on words and demonstrate a keen understanding of the original song's tone.

Meter and lyricism play a crucial role in maintaining the rhythm and flow of the parody, aligning with the melody of "Whatever It Takes." The verses maintain a consistent meter, enhancing the musicality of the lyrics. For example, the line "Everybody's waiting for Santa Claus" maintains the cadence expected in an Imagine Dragons song. This adherence to rhythm is essential for capturing the essence of the original track while infusing it with a festive and humorous spirit.

The theme of the parody cleverly subverts conventional Christmas expectations. The lyrics humorously critique the chaos of holiday preparations, the stress associated with gift-giving, and the societal pressures surrounding the season. The lines "What is it 'bout Christmas / Makes people think it's time to kiss?" and "And that means more than just traffic (A ton)" poke fun at the clichés of the holiday while inviting reflection on the deeper meanings often overshadowed by the hustle and bustle.

The chorus serves as a poignant anchor, redirecting the focus from the superficial aspects of Christmas to its profound significance. Lines like "Christmas is here / And that means peace out to everyone" and "Hold the fruitcake, we're not ready / 'Cause Christmas is here" pivot the lyrics toward a more reflective and spiritual dimension. This thematic shift adds depth to the parody, transcending the initial comedic critique.

For suggestions, consider exploring opportunities to enhance the internal rhyme scheme or introduce variations in rhyme patterns to further mimic the intricacies of Imagine Dragons' lyricism. Additionally, experiment with vocal dynamics and pacing to capture the intensity and emotion characteristic of the original song. This can add another layer of authenticity to the parody.

This was fun and a unique experience, reviewing your Christmas parody lyrics.

Sincerely,

Brian
WDC Angel Army Reviewer
Non-Animated Angel Army Signature


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
1,519 Reviews *Magnify*
Page of 61 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ripglaedr3/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9