*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/storytime/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/16
Review Requests: OFF
3,108 Public Reviews Given
7,053 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 12 13 14 15 -16- 17 18 19 20 21 ... Next
376
376
Review of Dependence  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello, Andrew Joseph Smith

You've done a good job with this one. It reads smoothly and the message is clear. I found no confusion or bumps. The words are well chosen for description so the imagery is strong. I didn't feel the emotion I would expect from such a scene, but that may be the way it was intended. A mixture of healing over destruction is a powerful image. I could see it clearly.

Well written!

Welcome to Writing.Com!
Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum



"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

377
377
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hello, Andrew Joseph Smith

Welcome to Writing.Com!

This has a serious tone, and the last two lines explain the point clearly. I had trouble discerning the message that led to those last lines, but it most likely is my fault. Poetry is not easy and so much is left to the reader to interpret, sometimes I'm left floundering.

All modelled fashioned by hands
That know the pain

I don't know what this bolded phrase means. Perhaps a more complete sentence would clear it up for readers such as I.
*Delight*

I found no typos or such. Well done!


esprit
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Member of the Noticing Newbies Committee
An Editor of the "Invalid Item

378
378
Review of What Death Does  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello, gringo

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I suggest looking at the choice of genres and try to use a variety to get on as many reading lists as you can. You'll get more readers.

Intro Rated:
Non-E


This can be changed to E in the Edit page. That will also get more readers. You have no non-E words in the title or brief description. The word 'death' is a genre, therefore it is E.


Is this an essay? What you have is credible, it makes sense. Most readers would have no argument with your words. It needs more to be a complete piece though. If it's random thoughts, it's fine. These are good practice and everyone should write them.

us all, the mortality

I don't believe the comma is needed.


Well done!



esprit
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


A Member of the Rewarding Reviewers Committee
Member of the Noticing Newbies Committee
An Editor of the "Invalid Item
379
379
Review of Sincerely You...  
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello, BeautifullyUnique

Welcome to Writing.Com!

You've done a good job with the gothic tone, it has a mysterious, emotional feel that's clear. The reader is pulled along well. It's a good job overall.

There are only a couple of things to look at.

But once, The comma gives it a bump.
We are one,
That angel
That once

For the love
That once,
Just once,
We share it
Will evolve


This is awkward to understand. The structure of the sentences aren't giving a clear image. I think it needs a definite defining punctuation of some kind to show the --it--goes with --Will evolve--. Or move the word to the next line. It will evolve.


A dark letter, to its love,

Is this a letter written by a letter, to its love, Tarah? An interesting aspect, as letters do hold secrets. You're a creative writer.


I enjoyed the read.

esprit
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Member of the Noticing Newbies Committee
An Editor of the "Invalid Item

380
380
Review of Fallen Angel  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (2.5)
Hello, xlullabydisaster

Welcome to Writing.Com

I enjoyed this piece, the emotion is good and clear.

In my opinion, as a reader of poetry, it would read smoother with longer lines. The short three and four words leave little room for a rhythm to develop. For instance;

I am dying
like a bed of roses
on a winter day


I am dying like a bed of roses
on a winter day.


The four word line fits in well after the longer line. The words are good and descriptive.


For a more complete, technical review, be sure and post your work on a few review forums. "Find a Review Forum

Welcome and enjoy your writing journey.


esprit

"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

381
381
Review of Silverfeathers  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello, silverfeathers

You've done an absolutely wonderful job on this. Well designed and symetrical so it's seen straight on - pleasant to the eyes.

I especially like the light, it reminds me of a camera flash. You probably intended a star and it looks like a star. My first thought though, was a flash. I like it very much. *Smile*



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
382
382
Review of The Lost Child  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hello, ski

I'm glad to accept your request for feedback. I hope it helps you see it from a different perspective. I was very hesitant to review this because of the perfect rates and ribbon its been awarded, but after thinking about it I realized you wouldn't have asked if you weren't serious. I do not choose to review personal pieces because they are too sensitive to critical suggestions. I made the exception only because you asked.

It is emotional of course, seen only from the narrator's viewpoint. The reader doesn't know anything about the child or the mother's emotions.

The genre of 'other' doesn't give the reader help in knowing where to place it. I have no suggestions there.

The opening line is a good hook. It causes the reader to prepare for a flashback of interest. I noticed some issues that got in the way of clarity and smooth reading. Remember, they are only my opinions.

"Come on Michelle, it's time to go," I yelled into the other room.

This phrase is 'telling' and I don't think it's all needed. --I called.--may be enough since the next line shows her being in another room. The word --yelled--sounds negative to me and that's not the tone you're trying to set.


"I want to keep playing," Was her response. I walked into the room, she looked up.

I suppose since this is a narrative,-was her response--is okay, but, it isn't too interesting. --she begged--she whined--she pleaded--she said--is a bit more descriptive and natural.

The second bolded phrase is awkward. Perhaps switching the words around would smooth it out a little. --she looked up as I walked into the room.--?


Her beautiful brown eyes sparkled as they locked with mine.

A good descriptive bit of imagery. Very clear.



the biggest in my short 17 years on this earth.

This would be clearer if the time difference was inserted somewhere. This appears to say he is 17 now, not some time ago.


The whole experience was a horror and the one thing that brought me through it was the smiling face and powerful hug from my little girl.

The 'experience' was the unplanned pregnancy and birth wasn't it? The smiling face and powerful hugs would come a few years later, wouldn't they? This says they all happened at the same time, which could use clarifying for a smoother visual.


When we got in the car, she would hug me.
--into--


As I look back, I can understand it now.

This is an extra word that causes a bump in the read. Read the line without it and hear the difference. You don't need both --looking back--and --now--.


We learned quickly, the things we did were fun, we

This word is used fourteen times and became very noticeable.


We created a love shell between us, problem was we didn't allow

This would read better with a period in place of the comma. Add the word --The--problem was, we... ---


to school functions, I suffered knowing that they

This sounds like it could be the end of the sentence. Try a period and decide. Otherwise, it becomes a long list.


I suffered

These five lines in a row all begin with these same words. They are powerful, emotional words, but the strength is lost with so many repeats. They only become redundant and you may lose the sympathy of the readers.


couldn't tell her because she was lost.
ruin this little girl's life?
little girl's life was turned upside down.
The Lost Child

These words set a tone to make the reader expect the child to be in dire straits, danger, abuse; but I didn't see any of that. You may or may not want to show an example or two to justify the strong images the words bring up.


She learned through emotional bashing, to distance herself from me

The comma should be removed to read smoother.


They did not want her to love me or show any emotion toward me.
I suffered knowing that she was so confused. I blame that on her mother.
Her mother allowed none of it
The normal bond was not allowed to grow

To hold the readers empathy, I suggest showing some examples to prove the blame. I see a mother who allows a child to visit her father every week, when she wouldn't have to, so these allegations aren't credible to me. True or not, they need to be clearer to be believable. The readers only know what is written and the words will direct their sympathy towards one or the other.


When I went to pick her up at

Grammar issue - awkward sounding. Can you find another word besides --went--?

It's a sad memory and certainly relevant in today's world. Many will relate and know exactly how you feel. The subject would fit a magazine for single parents.

I wonder if I'm the only reviewer who felt Father was blaming Mother too much? I'm left feeling bad only for the child, who is caught in the middle. I know this is personal, and this is why it's so difficult to review personals. I suggest you tone down the finger pointing and blame, and concentrate on showing the relationship with the child. I didn't see a lost child, I saw a lost dad. I wanted to feel sorry for him but his 'poor me' tone of voice wouldn't let me. It can be fixed easily if you wanted to, by making it less of a rant and more of honest self-anger, when applicable, and lost opportunity. Readers will be more drawn in and sympathtic.


I understand that I have to bring these emotions up to heal

This brought tears to my eyes as I think how I would feel in the same situation. It's true that writing helps to heal. Asking for reviews on these types of items though, can hurt. Journals are safer for healing writes. *Blush*

The main issue with this one is the attempt to show a fathers loss of custody of his child. His youth prevented him from taking responsibilty. From then on, he blamed the mother for everything. He seems to still be dodging responsibility and since I know that wasn't the intention of the write, it needs work to be credible and to bring the sympathy back to the main character.








** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
383
383
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello, Gracelin crys

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

The story has caught my interest well, the scenes are clear with enough action and emotion to hold the readers. The dialogue is believable and natural. I don't know the ages of the girls though they seem teen-agers. The prologue may have that info. - if it's read. Often, they're skipped.

I noticed a few things for you to consider.

This night, her best friend, June Allian had planned the better part of two weeks ago, when she had first heard from her cousin about the goings on in the ‘back of town.’ The rougher part of New Orleans, the part set away from the Mississippi River, hence the phrase ‘back of town.’

The first line isn't reading smoothly to me. I suggest try switching some words around and see what happens. For instance; -- her best friend, June Allian had planned--THIS NIGHT-- the better part of two weeks ago. The line is long and gives a lot of information all at once. I suggest tightening it by cutting extra info. and say what is needed clearly. Or make more sentences.

The second bolded phrase could be cut safely as it's only information for the readers. I don't believe it's needed and it is self-explanatory through the story.


sparkled in the light of the full moon that shone threw the window.
Spelling is --through--


creamy white, skin flawed only by the sprinkling of freckles across her nose and cheeks --Good description. She can be seen well.

She descended the grand staircase. Crossed the entrance hall and opened the front door.

Change this period to a comma. You'll need punctuation editing at some point, there are issues throughout the piece.


house when she heard the familiar sound of hoof prints,

Hear--hoofbeats--You can only see --hoofprints--


the ‘tunnel’ was nearly half a mile long. All she could see of the house was the eight giant pillars that ran along the front porch. No lights came from the windows, there was no movement at all.

The quotes around the word 'tunnel' aren't necessary for the readers to understand the reference.

Being able to see pillars from half a mile in the dark, made darker by the trees, isn't credible. She especially wouldn't be able to see movement from a person. From this distance, the trees would hide the house completely.


the wagon as it slowly careened down the road.

This word commonly refers to abruptness, and trying to image --slow abruptness--pulled me from the story. The words are contradictory. I suggest finding a more descriptive word. Since she's holding on tight, but the wagon is moving slowly, the word --lurched--came to my mind. Or,--swaying--


how to get to the ‘back of town.’

Each time these words appear, the quotes are around them. It became annoying. I can understand why they might be needed the first time, but by now they are well understood.


Crystal insisted on being prime and proper at all times,

Spelling is --prim--


Crystal insisted on being prime and proper at all times, and she teased her unceasingly, often saying that she would have tea with the dreadful pirate Jean

It's kind of difficult to know who -she- and -her- are referring to with this many. I think using June's name once would make it easier.


stood up on a stage constructed of barrels of hay.

I find it hard to believe rolls of hay could be rolled and bound tight enough to hold a man's weight, and they are moving and stomping I assume. Remember, these were rolled by hand, not machines.


Pulling one of her arms free, she jabbed her fingers into his eyes. Forcing him to step back, she then pushed her way farther

The line shouldn't end with --eyes--, it continues on naturally. It could end after --- --back.--


and let me introduce you to a few new friend of mine.”

--friends--


comfortable position, and set here mind on the fact that she would be there for awhile. --typo--


She looked about their surrounding trying to find something to say to
--surroundings--


It's an interesting beginning. I was a little suprised she wasn't more frightened or at least nervous among the crowd. She was confident and it showed, but realistically, a drunk would have at least yelled at her with a few choice words for poking him in the eyes. It was a good trick. *Delight* I also find it difficult to see her sitting for hours without being bothered a few times; after all, these guys are drunk and any girl showing up in the middle of the night will not be ignored and allowed to sleep. It's a good area for some humor, danger and action. Lots of emotion.

June has a good, strong personality. She seems more real to me than Crystal in this chapter.

Good writing!


The rate is for an above average storyline with work needed with clarity.




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
384
384
Review of The Wasteland  
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello, PiroManiac

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

You have a real talent for writing! This is good. The descriptions are clear and I can feel his thirst and exhaustion. The dialogue is excellent, realistic and easy to listen to. Their voices are becoming unique to each character.

I found a few things for you as are expected in a first draft. Technical stuff.


Even though it was night it was not dark out. The sky was a brownish color, spotted

This is an extra word that isn't needed for clarity. The line is clear without it and avoid wordiness when you can. This can be cut safely.


2: The wolves of the Wasteland

now explain yourself or get the hell out of The Wasteland. We don't need strangers," the wolf said.
"I'm partially albino. If I was clean my fur would be the same color as my eyes looked.

This one too, could be cut easily. It causes a small bump in the reading.


As they were walking they were nearing, closer and closer, to the huge undercut in the stone

This line reads awkwardly to me. It's a bit redundant as --nearing--is the same as --closer and closer--. I suggest trimming to tighten.


I've made it this far, I'm sure I can survive here, with out a pack or with one," Ash said,

I've noticed several of this type, but didn't highlight them all. This is one word. --without--


You'd die here with us and you'll die with out us. You'd be worthless to me."

them all 'till there's nothing left but a grave yard of corpse. But you,- why you I'll eat alive!!!"

The plural is --corpses--

One exclamation point is enough to show emotion, using more is frowned upon.
*Smile*

The sun was creeping slowly east ward, going down in the sky, but still it was hot.

Combine into one word. --eastward--

I suggest cuttting the bolded phrase as it will be obvious to the readers that the sun is setting.


Soon it would be night, and soon the sky would be a murked over brown. And soon Ash would be rejected from yet another wolf pack.
Soon.

Repetition is normally not a good idea, but here it works for me. It helps to show his mood as being almost hopeless. You might want to study it to see if you can say the same thing without so many repeats though. I do think think cutting the extra --And--beginning the sentence is a bad idea.


3:There's No Pretending This Is Nirvana

Intelligent thinking was down cast by my last pack. It was as though they hated me for

downcast

Some times thoughts are vile, like poison; bringing up subjects I don't want to think

4: Falling on Fire

"He died last night. No one has stepped up to take he place. No one is in charge," said

Lioness nodded. "As the Alpha female, I condone you to be our male leader. You will rise to the top and we will respect you."

This word caused a bump for me. Be sure it's the one you intended.


It was here that he could rise about the ashes of his previous life.

Did you intend to write --above--?


5: Questions to Be Answered

Ash nodded. He moved of, deeper into the cave. At the very back there was a place by

While Ash lay, unsleeping, Eagle asked permission to talk to him. Ash nodded and trotted over to where Eagle stood.

It's only right that I bring you to the border and show you why no one wants to be the leader."
It would just be so much easier if I showed you."
Ash nodded and stood up. He climbed down from the mound and bowed to Eagle. "Should we go now?"

Is this something left over from a previous revision? Ash rose twice.


Highmoon was when the moon was in the center of the sky, high above life, high above what is know.

--known--?


6: Highmoon

That there is a tremor going through are world causing tsunami's and ripples in the water?"

--our--


Like I am standing still and watching the world go by the speed of the suns own light; and I can do noting to change it."

A word is missing in the phrase. Perhaps, --at--the speed?


Then Eagle began running to the south, and Ash was following, liking the sound of his

There is a tendency toward using extra words that will cause wordiness. Don't make the readers go through too many to reach the point or they'll get bored. You're not there, but be aware of the tendency. --Then--could be cut easily. --the second bolded area could be shortened to --and Ash followed--- . --was--is a word to watch out for.


There was a dull pain from Ash's feet, a throbbing soreness, but other then that he felt

Good description! It draws sympathy from the reader.


There was a dull pain from Ash's feet, a throbbing soreness, but other then that he felt

--than--


and in some places deep trench in the ground, as if this place used to be under water.

--trenches were --in the ground--


The two complemented each other in color, in feel, in essence. As Ash trampled the ground with

This is the third use of this word and it caught my attention. Is there another word you could use?


The air was some how both tempid and humid at the same time- the sky some how both enlightening and alienating

--somehow--
Are you using --tempid--to mean --tepid? I know it's a new slang word meaning -cool- or -hot-. I'm not sure if it should be used in this particular piece though, it's too modern and the meaning isn't clear. Tepid means --warm--, so --tepid and humid--could both mean the same. Moist, warm air. That leaves the reader confused. What is causing the humidity since they are in the desert?


life was not welcome, the dirt baring up it vicious mounds of rocks and unfruitful weeds.

out of out very lungs... But yet we depend on them so much that if we leave we will die!

Chapter 7:untitled

The wolves gathered around Ash, waiting for his signal to begin there running scan of the wasteland.

--their--


No. I think life is no border for friendship. I think were freinds for eternity. I think we were freinds even before

or for revenge of Kanga? Your doing this for yourself?"

--we're friends--

--You're-- for --You are...


Chapter 8: Questions of insanity

I found no issues in chap. 8.

It's a good, interesting theme and you're doing an excellent job with it. You'll notice none of my suggestions are intended to change the basic story at all, it's perfect.





** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
385
385
Review by esprit
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
Hello, Whisper

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review
I wanted some real feedback

I enjoy reading and writing memories and I was glad to find this one on the review request page. The opening is good and catches the attention well. The open, friendly, back-fence style is easy to read and understand. The descriptions show the scene clearly.

mighty weapons that would clamp down on you finger.

A typo of --your--


He, however, had a full proof method of

This is --foolproof--


Then he turned and looked at me with a sinister grin. He flipped one of the quarters into the air, caught it and then placed it with the other

Try to avoid repetition when possible, especially so close together. The words tend to pop out and readers shouldn't notice words at all. You could probably cut both of these safely, without losing any clarity of meaning. You decide.


I rushed back to my spot, tore out the rusty can

I can hear and feel the child's excitment throughout, and this is but one example. Good job!


From my memories, there was no great accomplishment or pride in catching a carp, so I was a bit surprised at Greg's response. It must be a regional bias; I expected to hear laughter from the crowd. *Delight* I'm glad there was none. I like the inclusion of the veteran and his contribution.

It would help the reader's visulize these three if the age of at least one, perhaps the girl, was given. I urge you to write more of these three because practice will help you develop and show their personalities. I can see their actions well, but they are shadows with names. You've a good beginning though, I know they bicker and tease, I suspect they get along well. I look forward to learning more about them.

Well done!





** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
386
386
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello, Stuart Reb Donald

I just opened Holly Jahangiri newsletter for Authors and your title is the first thing I noticed, after reading the letter, of course. *Delight*

I intended to correct your use of this non-word because it's one that rubs against the grain for me. Thank you for standing up and publicly putting it in its place. I appreciate it.

I tested my irregardless theory by typing it in the title of this article.

It caught my attention so I had to read what you had to say. I liked the article very much.

applicable. It is not uh-plic-able beginning with a mind numbing uh and placing the emphasis on the plic.

Exactly. This made me think of another word that I don't like the sound of.

explicable

Down here where the real people live, 'explainable' is good and everyone knows what that means.

A good article, do it again!




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
387
387
Review of THE LEGACY  
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Hello, tosca

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review
Some readers think she's a villain, some think she's a hero. What do you think?

I think she's a lucky writer. Neither villain nor hero. *Smile*

I enjoyed this very much. It reads easily with no bumps or interruptions in the sequencing. It's good.

I have only one suggestion.

simple play of muscles that didn’t reflect in his eyes, “or maybe wrote it.”

I think cutting the bolded word would give this more of a clipped, arrogant confidence; it would be as close to a definite accusation as possible with no evidence. The -maybe- takes away his sureness of her guilt.


I like the idea of her hoping he'd like the book. That proved to me that she was innocent of the crime. *Delight*

Well done!


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
388
388
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello, Nekogal (D&C)

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review I really need R&Rs on the Prologue: Lucifer's Glory, as well as the 2nd Chapter. I really need feedback, since no ones really commented on it.

I've held onto this piece for a while, finally taking time today to work with it.
I like the idea of a Lucifer that doesn't have all the answers. *Smile* I admit I'm curious as to how the Love/Romance genre is going to fit with these two characters. I'll have to read on to find out.

I made some notes on this, I hope they help.

Steps echoed down a long, deserted hallway. Dust drifted soundlessly through the dry air as an old, mildewed book was swept clean by trembling, red stained hands.

These opening lines are not reading smoothly, to me. It took several readings before I found the reason. I suggest dropping the first line altogether because it gets in the way by being out of sequence. It appears footsteps are being heard at the same time the book is found. That isn't possible if these characters are the only ones there. I like the Dust line. The imagery is good in spite of the use of too many wordy adjectives. It works.
*Smile*

"This is it, Kizuato, this is it! The Book of Prophecies, how I've longed to hold

This sounds like a statement that could end with a period. The whole line shows his excitement very well, and is a good hook.


this very artifact in my hands..." a man, wearing a long black trench coat, covered in vast amounts of blood, said to his companion, a rather mysterious looking fellow.

Consider cutting this bolded phrase to tighten the scene. It slows and forces the reader to look away from the book, which is the main subject here. --mysterious looking fellow--is stated directly to the readers by the author, and doing that usually pulls the reader from the story.


we can determine whether or not we should continue our alliance with the others. I admit, I'm awfully suspicious
"Well, let us have a look at it,
" Kizuato said,


The dialogue is too stilted and formal for a couple of demons. They sound like college professors. I thought it may be only Kizuato's voice at first, but they both sound the same. I suggest loosening it up some, though I don't know how a demon should sound. Not as politely proper, maybe? They could be educated, but it doesn't match their blood covered robes. It doesn't sound believable in this scene.


gleaming yellow eyes and sharp fangs lighting the dark hall.

If these actually were bright enough to light the hall, I suggest saying so more definitely. For instance, use the book. Make it clear that there is no light coming in and the only source comes from their eyes and fangs.


"This wasn't here before...

This is 'telling' because the readers already know there was only one entry before. This could be cut.


There is just a hint of the problem, and a promise of an eagerly awaited for goddess. Enough hook to keep on reading. It's theme isn't clear yet, but this is a short prologue. It holds interest and seems to be a unique way of handling an old theme. Creative.

Well done, I enjoyed the read.




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
389
389
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello, Charlotte Rose

Welcome to Writing.Com!

This opening is very good. The tone is quiet and easy to listen to; like a storyteller. Beginning slow, the hints of change gives the reader a curious anticipation of looking forward. I want to know where she goes and what happens to her. You've done a good job of catching this readers attention. I like this character and see her as vulnerable, which allows me to worry about what she meant in the first line. I look forward to the second chapter.

I don't see any problems here. It's written tightly and reads smoothly. The emotion fits and pulls the reader in at once.

The indents work fine, but a space between paragraphs is easier on the readers eyes. At least at page length.

It's a good piece of writing. Well done!



Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum



"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
390
390
Review of Highways  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Kimchi

I decided to pay you a visit and I'm glad I did. I looked over your port and it's so organized, you've made me jealous. *Smile*

I read your testimonial piece and laughed, it's good.

This one though, caught my heart. The first line did it, it's such a good, sharp hook it's sure to keep the reader reading. This is good writing, and should be submitted to a parenting magazine, or several. You've introduced the topic with a heart wrenching line, then carried the reader through a realistic scenario, finally ending with common sense. I was there, watching. It's smooth and emotional. I found nothing missing and nothing added that didn't need to be.

I don't know what other genres you write, but you definitely have a talent for this one.
The title and brief description are good, too.

Well done!




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
391
391
Review of Love  
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (2.5)
Hello, nicholls

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

You have the makings of a very good horror. The building of tension is good, but too much other stuff is getting in the way, in my opinion. I think if you could tighten it up and stay on the main topic, it could become very scary and realistic. I will try to explain.

I copied from several areas to demonstrate where it loses its continuity and becomes muddy.

Lance had his knuckle’s firmly imprinted into the side of his cheek when the telephone beeped into life

I believe starting here would be a stronger opening than what you have. The opening is a bit confusing and difficult to see. The story is short and a backflash isn't needed. Since you have most of the same info entered again, all could be cut down to this para. It's the actual beginning of the story.


Jean cleared her throat and coughed loudly into the mouth piece.
Well dressed, well spoken


She is described as well-spoken, which shows me she has manners. Having her clear her throat and cough loudly into the receiver takes away that image.


We’ll be dispatching a patrol car in that area as soon as possible.”

Try changing the bolded --in--to --to--that area-. It would be more correct.


lock your doors and windows if you feel it necessary.

To keep it realistic, cut the bolded phrase. Police don't leave it up to citizens if they can help it.


with double priority. It was probably an over reaction, but Lance wasn’t interested in taking risks.
He was also sure that she was jumping to conclusions

I think you're trying to show him as being careful while staying sensible, but it leaves the reader wondering what to think. Maybe if you left only one phrase re. 'over-reaction', while he moves quickly, it would be clearer. He seems to trying to convince himself and I wonder why, since he doesn't know her. She's only a call. There's too much attention given to her.


of guilt about making blind judgments on the women,

This is repeated twice. It should be --woman--since there is only one. -Women - means more than one.


her voice reminds you of Jennifer.

This hints at a backstory, and it gives him emotion. Good.


Strips of molten sunlight protruded the closed curtains and he could see specs of dust

I have trouble seeing sunlight actually cause a curtain to -protrude-, to jog out. A different word showing it --shone--through, or something would be easier to image.


She was content yet appeared strangely occupied with other unforeseen matters.

This is wordy and slows the story down. She didn't appear --strangely occupied--to me. She was sitting quietly. This may be intended to insert a little mystery about her, but it isn't helping the story move forward. If you're planning a long novel, something like this would work better. Short stories can't handle many sub-plots. I suggest keeping Jennifer to one or two lines only to show how his mind works.


“The birds were singing,” Lance said between lips half closed.

Perhaps he could --whisper--and cut the rest of the bolded line. Whisper shows emotion and sadness, which is good. -lips half closed- made me stop reading to try to imagine what that looks like. You don't want to pull readers from the story for anything.


for the sake of the women caller as well as for him
The repeated typo as mentioned above.


Lonesome
never struck my fancy, not even when I was a little girl,
and
Just lately however (and this might sound darn crazy) I feel as if I have made
I can tell you now that is a fabrication, sorry to disappoint


With no transition to show the reader we were inside another character's head, this became confusing. I thought we were still listening to Lance until the --girl--part. I suggest removing this character as she contributes nothing to the story. This whole area could be cut to make a tighter read and use the space to increase the tension of the horror.


Bobby please don’t say that
Robby pinched his

I wondered if the names are intended to show dual personality? If so, you'll need to expand on that idea more. I can see this character well enough, physically, but I don't understand his problem. He changed too quickly for me to understand what set him off. He has a problem telling anyone he loves them, but I only figured that out after the fact. We don't need his whole backstory, but we do need more. If you can build him so his actions will be understood clearly, it will be a smoother read. Perhaps through his thoughts, or dialogue to Jennifer, he could make a statement about -love-.


but it was that alien feeling all over again. The out of body feeling, as the doctors would call it.

This is good and helps to show his condition, but it's covered too fast and leaves the reader floundering for answers.


He couldn’t help but smile and think about the mangled thoughts

This is out of character. Would he really smile? I can see him -grimace- or -frown-, but not smile. He could use more personality building too. Use some of that space spent on Jennifer to bring him to life.

What caused the noise outside the car? Generally, whenever something is brought into a story, it should be addressed and answered before the ending. I have to assume it was the cats, but why did she scream at that point? I don't understand if they were both fightened, why didn't they move to another parking space. Or at least speak of it a little more.

Slow down the climax to allow the readers to feel the full impact of her fear and his insaneness. Draw it out. The horror is real, and it's frightening - hold onto it until the readers can take no more. *Smile*

Lance had his knuckle’s firmly imprinted into the side of his cheek when the telephone beeped

This is good. It shows his boredom on a quiet night of duty.


The love scene is good - realistic.

The title doesn't do the story justice. Find a word relating to his problem to add to it. I don't have any suggestions, but you won't have a problem finding one. *Smile*

I enjoyed the theme and with revision, this will be very good. Get rid of all the extra words of information not relating to this plot, and it will be tight with tension.


Well done!




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
392
392
Review of Oh,Oh!  
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello, Rasputin

I found your item on the sidebar column, and the BD pulled me in.

This is written very well. It caught my attention with the first line.

I sat there in utter amazement at what my friend Harry was saying.

and little hooks throughout held it. The ending line was wonderful! It made me laugh out loud, it really did.

The tone of voice is natural and easy to listen to. I heard two friendly, decent young men agonizing over a matter of honor. The emotion caught me up in its confusion and anxiety. I could feel the hurt of disappointment from the main character. I was caught in its web until I reached this line, when my throat tightened with pride and relief. Good writing!

I told Mr.Post you convinced me it was wrong."

The story moves quickly through the scene without any bumps to slow it down. It was truly a pleasureable read and IMO, is publishable. It would fit nicely into a magazine.

Good characters too. *Smile*

Well done!

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
393
393
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello, Handy Prophet

Welcome to Writing.Com!

Wow! I think you've expressed the feelings of most of the members here, and you've done it very well.

Passion is like whiskey on paper, I find.

I think I understand what you're saying, but this bumps just a little. I believe you're saying, --Writing with passion is like...--is that correct? I think it would have better clarity with the word -writing- somewhere in the sentence. I like the analogy, by the way.


A well written story is just an endless series of visions. Words cease to have meaning while reading a good book.

I agree. You've some good points here.


Now, this formerly ambiguous form of expression is much more.

I don't agree with this though, but it's only my opinion.
*Smile*

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum

The only suggestion I have is to add some white space between the paras. Go into Edit and hit the enter key at the end of each para to leave a blank line to make the page look cleaner and be easier to read. On-line reading requires white space because reading on monitors isn't comfortable.

No typos that I noticed - good proofreading, too. *Smile*
Well done!


"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
394
394
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello, dreamer

Welcome to Writing.Com!

You've done a good job with this short story, I think kids would like it's simplicity and the good imagery. I can accompany Lilli easily in this scene.

The flowers she had seen in books never looked like this.

It would be good to show how these flowers are different so the readers can be amazed too.


valley everday and gather flowers.

A typo of --everyday--(I do this one a lot! My -y- sticks too.*Smile*

--gathered--flowers would be correct.


Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum

You've done a good job with this first post. I like the name --enchanted valley--to go with enchanted forest. Children who like fantasy will too. It's a wonderful word, full of all sorts of imaginings. *Delight*

I noticed you've posted it twice. Did you know you can delete the extra one? There is a menu underneath the title, choose --delete-- and then confirm -yes-. If you actually want both in your port, that's okay too.

Good writing!

"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
395
395
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hello, nahslyfe135

Welcome to Writing.Com!

This is a nice piece of prose. It isn't clear if it's a child's perspective or an adults, but it probably doesn't matter. It reminds me a bit of Utopia, something we'd all love. *Smile*

in the bossom of my mother,
Spelling is --bosom--


as she keeps the vines of life tied.

I like this line, it's an original.


Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum

Oh, I tried to visit your web site but the link won't open. I notice you'd typed --cm--instead of --com--, but it still wouldn't open when corrected.

Keep on writing!

"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
396
396
Review of Ch.2 The Oracle  
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hello, Nekogal (D&C)

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review
I really need feedback, since no ones really commented on it.


I will do my best. Since I haven't read the prologue or chap. 1, I won't comment on continuity or plot. It seems to be moving along well, so I don't think you've a problem there.

"Oh, thank Kiera! You're finally awake! You've been out for quite a while, three whole days almost. With all that blood you lost, it's a good thing Mamoru found you when he did," the girl said beaming, her high pitched voice squealing with excitement.

This is good. I can feel and hear her excitement through the exclamation points and descriptive words. --beaming--high pitched--squealing--Good choices to let readers hear her as well as see!


An enormous desk was positioned against the northern wall,
In the southern region of the small building,

At the first mention of 'direction', -northern- I didn't pay much attention, but when continuing with --southern and eastern--, it caught my attention. She just woke and was unaware of where she was. How was she able to tell direction in a darkened cabin? What did she use as a guide? Why is the direction important?


A mouse hole was spotted in the eastern portion of the room, accompanied by a door, leading to the outside,

Is this what you intended to say? --a mouse hole with a door to the outside--?? Is this what you meant? Since I missed the first chapter and don't know, it may be that these are 'mouse-size' people. That's the disadvantage of not beginning from the start of a story.
*Smile*

filled with tiny holes, and a crusty loaf of stale, half-eaten bread.

This isn't an entirely clear image. I see a half-loaf of bread. Not -half-eaten-. --half-eaten--gives images of regurgitated bread.
*Sick*

"Well, it seems you've come to. How are you feeling? Does the arm pain you much?" the young man, no, Mamoru, said as he entered the dusky cabin.

Using both -young man- and -Mamoru- may be a point brought forward from chapter one, and be needed - but, if not, I suggest using one or the other to avoid wordiness.


Lucifer was on his way to the throne room.
Reaching the throne room,
He entered the throne room,
The throne room was filled with

Be aware of repeating and try to avoid it. Use another word or write to avoid having to identify the room. --It--works. --The room-- will work. You may find you don't need most of these lines. Variety is good.


Lucifer was on his way to the throne room. He was supposed to be meeting with Ketsueki;

I don't think the first sentence is necessary for clarity. It tells the readers something they should be able to figure out with the next lines. It could be cut out. The second line is wordy. The red bolded words could be cut easily with no change in meaning. He is meeting Ketsueki, so --supposed-- is only an extra word.


Kizuato asked Ketsueki,

These two names are almost identical and I had trouble knowing who was who. I kept having to go back to their introductions and check the spelling of each. I suppose I would eventually know if I read the whole book, but I found it annoying and bothersome.


He also wore a crimson colored cape, which hung well below his knees.
Kizuato was wearing a bright tunic, the colors consisting of red, yellow, and orange. They were rather vibrant in comparison to Lucifer’s own clothes. Outlined on the colorful tunic was an elaborately embroidered flame. He also wore a crimson colored cape,
Ketsueki was probably the most down-dressed of them all. He’d come to the meeting in a dark brown cape,


There is a lot of space given over to their clothing. Is it going to be important later? Do the images have a special meaning? If so, I really wondered why Lucifer shows roses. *Delight* Should the readers remember what each is wearing? The color of the tunics and robe should be enough for the readers that want clothing described. Some readers won't care, because the personalities are more important. Clothing will change, personalities won't.


He also wore a crimson colored cape,

Cut the bolded word because -crimson- is a color. Avoid telling readers stuff they already know.


antique chairs at the flamboyant golden table
He took a seat at the back of the small table, motioning for the other two men to sit.

--antique and flamboyant--gives me an image of a large table, so when I read --small- it bumped and I had to look again to try to image it. You can avoid this bump by removing the word --small--. It would still say the same thing, but clearer.


Well then, where is she from? Or more, where is she right now?”

This doesn't sound authoritive enough for a King. Try something less casual. Perhaps;
--More importantly, where...--or --More to the point, where... just try different words until it sounds 'right' to you.


Kizuato was almost the opposite of Lucifer in appearance. His short, golden blonde hair draped over his face, giving him the appearance of a playful child.

Ketsueki leaned back in his chair, letting his hair fall across his face once again

Both characters having the same characteristic contributes to my confusion of their names. The word --again--stumped me because I wasn't aware of his hair doing this a first time. I knew I'd read of 'hair in the face' earlier and looked back to see who it was. This is a good image and works okay, I only suggest removing the word --again-- so the readers don't have to backtrack to find when it happened before.


I was at Kiera’s shrine because I was trying to find the pendent,

spelling is --pendant--
pendent doesn't refer to jewelry, but it is a word, so spellcheck won't find it.


Come, follow me.” He stood and motioned for them to follow him out the throne room.

This bolded line could be removed easily, without changing the meaning. Readers will know they followed by the next lines, which are good and clear.


Yet, this One knows not whether she is the Savior, that information is hidden from One’s eyes
Are you really a vampire? This One knows you are Chosen… yet you feel different than the others.

It isn't clear who the --this One-- is referring to. Is she speaking of herself or Sentaku? It sounds like Tiea since she --feels the difference--. The line could be written clearer to avoid any confusion.


It's an interesting chapter and I would definitely read on. You've some good hooks for those who enjoy Fantasy. It's written well. There is little to do in the way of tightening, and I mentioned what I noticed. The imagery is good. The emotion is realistic, and the characters are coming along well. I'm sure as the story progresses, the characters will grow and develop more individual personalities. You're doing a good job. I also believe you are showing a natural talent. The words read smoothly and I don't feel a hesitancy at all. That tells me you're confident and sure. It shows in your writing. It's an enjoyable read. *Smile*





** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
397
397
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
Hello, kiyasama

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

This is a well written piece. The scenes are described clearly and they're easy to visulize. The theme of a young man who is a bit shy, is presented well. I enjoyed the read.

I believe it could be tightened to keep it smoother. I also wonder if devoting a para each to the other three male characters is necessary. It is if this is only a chapter and they will play parts later, but knowing what they each do didn't seem necessary to me. It makes them more important to the story than they really are; I expected to hear from them again before the ending.

“You see our good buddy here.” There’s a slap on my shoulder causing me to wince and almost spit out my sandwich across the table. “See our good buddy here hasn’t even dated a chick in like…” I watch his mayo-greased fingers extend as he counts. One. Two. Three. Four. Five. “Five months. Five fugging1 months, man. Can you beat that?”

The first para has a couple of bumps that prevented me from being hooked at the onset. I suggest keeping it as tight as possible. For instance the first bolded line could be cut because --good buddy--is used again to show the situation. Beginning with the slap on the shoulder is a better hook, in my opinion. It catches the readers attention. Cutting --There's--and changing to --A slap--or --The slap--would keep it clear.

The bolded word --out--could be cut to tighten. It's an obvious result of -spitting-.

The footnote is interesting, but is it necessary? The word is self defining, and it draws the readers away from the story to read the footnote.


for the freak accident he had last year while riding a tractor on his dad’s farm.

This may be only a bump from this one reader, but, I wondered if he was riding or actually --driving--it. Since he's an adult, I wondered why he was riding along as a passenger. If he was working, he would be driving. And why will readers need to know this?


his current beau some hottie from Las Vegas, in his Communications class. I think she

I've only heard --beau--in describing a boy-friend, never a female. But, this may be correct in other languages. I just wanted to mention it.


or basketball nor do I love NASCAR, in case you haven’t figured that out by now.
Now, before you go screaming ‘nerd alert’,


It’s been three days since I saw her, and believe me, I’ve spent every waking moment thinking about
That’s one of my ‘problems’, you know. I never tend to quit

Speaking directly to the readers is advised against by many teachers. It can be done, but only if it's consistent and clear from the beginning until the end. It's a particular narrating style. Since it isn't used but a few times, it isn't consistent and it reminds the readers they are only reading a story. Their attention will be averted. Mine was.


Clay’s saying as he pokes his salad and then flourishes a lettuce in my face.

--a--can be cut easily. A lettuce shows me a -whole head of lettuce-. This is only a fork-full, so lettuce is a clearer visual.


My heartbeat is beginning to skip a little bit faster.
She smiles and darn if my heartbeat doesn’t skip a beat.


The repetition is noticeable, try to use a good phrase only once in a short story. It sounds awkward to me, too. Try playing with the phrase a bit. --my heart skips a beat--or --My heart is beginning to skip faster.-- My suggestion is to lose some of the extra words, and cut one of the phrases. Say it with different words.


Tom says as he all but shoves me out to the floor.

This is awkward to see and read. I definitely suggest cutting the word --out--.


“Then what’s my name?” she asks, smiling a little as if knowing I won’t know the answer to it.

These two bolded words could be cut for wordiness, to tighten.


"Stephanie!” I cry out in the middle of a Chemistry class,

Good showing of excitement and emotion. I was glad he remembered.
*Smile*

She rolls her eyes and shifts her book from her left to her right arm

I noticed that she carried a lot of English Literature books the last time, so it would only make sense for her to be around…

This is an inconsistency. -A book- is what the reader saw.


I like the theme of shyness winning out. You're a good writer, and are excellent with descriptions. Just cutting the extra words to tighten will polish this well.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
398
398
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello, Voxxylady

I found your item during a search for 'character tips'. Did you know there are only three items under these keywords?

You've some great tips on building good, strong characters. I especially liked your 'Live with your character' bit. I was going to comment on the 'while you're arguing politics' part, but your piece is rated E, so I can't. *Smile*

One more hint: be sure to people watch

I believe this is one of the best tips anyone can give. It's easy, natural and you can find some great characters.

I enjoyed the lesson.
Well done!



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
399
399
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Hello, Joy

I found your item during a search for 'character tips'.

I think you've a gold mine of material here. You've been building on it for a quite a while. I didn't see a header for 'character tips', but I know they're in here somewhere. I did see many other things that caught my attention.

Without paying attention to style, technique, or revision, an unattended work is at best an entry to a diary. In order to deserve to be called a writer, it is essential to understand and accept the enormous amount of work lying ahead of us.

I like that! *Smile*

Besides tips for us writers, you've adapted an open, friendly style that invites a reader to stay a while.

Well done!




** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
400
400
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello, Vivian

I found your item during a search for writing tips. You have several items listed there, good use of the keyword.

I was curious of how many of us used the keyword section effectively when we create new item, so I'm randomly researching. *Smile*

You've handily bundled your newsletters on the same page to make it easier for people to find their genre.

Well done!



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
1,519 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 61 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/storytime/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/16