*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mcgupta44/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/21
Review Requests: ON
5,852 Public Reviews Given
5,942 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 17 18 19 20 -21- 22 23 24 25 26 ... Next
501
501
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a beautiful poem. It concerns the theme that words and gestures may be faked, but eyes don't lie. There is much truth in it.

The beauty and uniqueness of your poem inspired to me to write a poem expressing the same theme--

THE SIXTH SENSE—"THE SIXTH SENSE, 4 July 2010
[Women’s life and survival are influenced by their sixth sense.]

Thanks for the inspiration.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
502
502
Review of the dance  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
It is a nice poem.

You have said very truly, and beautifully--

sometimes I think
the most valuable touches
were left by those
who didn’t even notice
and I think . . .
the reverse must also be true . . .right?

M C Gupta
503
503
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a wonderful poem about a little girl talking to a bird, and telling her brother about it, who said it was absurd!

The following lines in the last stanza are memorable--


The knowledge of a crazy fool
Can close an open mind;


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT

504
504
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a beautiful poem.

Just a few observations:

--We are eulogising here leaves and their sagacity / scholarliness. Labelling them as cunning in the opening line does not really fit.

--The second stanza is specially nice--

With whimsy, In jest
They flutter along
While we struggle to hear
Their beautiful song

--Your poem, I feel, will look even more beautiful if you maintain throughout the 6-5-6-5 syllabic pattern, which already seems to be the dominant one.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
505
505
Review of BLAVATSKY'S BUS  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is a very well written account. You have certainly had a consistent and focussed journey.

I don't know why, but I have a feeling you might like to write a story / novella / novel based on re-incarnation as a theme. In this connection, you might like to view

"THE TRUTH ABOUT REINCARNATION.

*****

Your writing is free of mistakes, which is the first pre-requisite for a writer. Your writing style has a distinct mark. . I was particularly impressed by the following:


.

--The more she fanned the flames of dormant curiosities, the more I began to see things with my heart and not my eyes.


--Two weeks after the funeral, I spotted the wife standing atop the stairs, looking down at me with a kind but forlorn face. It was only a moment, but seemed like an hour we stood eyeing each other in silence. She spoke naught, yet so much said with love in her eyes; she was worried about me, my grief. I too welled with emotion. My god, what if I’d lost her?

-- Carl Sagan once said something akin to: “one glance at a book and you’ll hear the voice of another person; to read is to voyage through time.”


M C Gupta
506
506
Review of Sunshine  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
I see this story as a symbolic protest against the concept of a non-loving, non-pardoning, punishing, over-powering lord demanding obedience from everybody, on the pain of death--the concept of god that one gets from the Book. After all, he created man, an innocent being and, like an innocent child, he tasted a fruit. The punishment was banishment from heaven!

If your story portrays symbolic protest against the Biblical image of god, it is a success.

M C Gupta
507
507
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
This is not exactly a poem, though titled as one. In any case, the 26 tips for a happy marriage are well listed. The one that I particularly liked was--

"YESTERDAY'S argument is just that. Let it go with the past."

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
508
508
Review of HER PATH  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a nice poem about a woman in reverie of her lost love.The full meaning became clear only after I read a second time. There are no mistakes. The imagery is vivid and vocabulary is rich.

****

The waves melody crashing below

>> The waves' melody crashing below

M C Gupta
509
509
Review of A CRY FOR A CHILD  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice. It is not eligible as per contest rules. You need to follow Rule 2 of the contest for your entry to be eligible. Currently, your rating is not visible.

Rule-2 states:

2. It must have been rated. Rating must be 5, if single; at least 4.5, if multiple. The rating must be visible to me. [The item should allow rating without any restrictions. Choosing the option-‘This item requires review along with rating’ hides display of the rating received.]

In any case, I am offering you a review.

**

It is a nice poem.

The following needs comment:

Crying out with soundless words.
Trampled by thoughts ancient herds.
Tumbling in frigid isolation.
Void of lovers compensation.

Second line--Grammatically hazy. Maybe you meant "thoughts' ancient herds", referring to the surge of old memories.

Fourth line-- This is "A story of a friend's resurfaced childhood memory". This line does not fit. There is no question of lovers; nor of their compensation (to whom? Lovers compensate each other, not a third party). In any case, it ought to be lovers' compensation. [However, if you mean one person, maybe a parent, it ought to be --lover's. But, we never refer to a parent etc. as a lover!]


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
510
510
Review of Winter's Waif  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

This is a wonderfully well written poem, in rhyme and meter, that describes the majestic march of seasons in a cyclic manner, using appropriate, rich and varied imagery.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
511
511
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem.

In

This is a poem for the lonely at heart.
Who all know the ending,

>> You need to remove that period.





M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
512
512
Review of Rapture  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.0)
What you have written represents an attempt to rationalise what is believed and spread by the theologists. But, should we try to rationalise every word of what is written in the Book, whether it be the Old Testament or the new one or the Quoran?

I understand that according to the Book, the Earth originated about 5500 years ago. Now, are we to believe that at that period of time, one day the fish, next day the fowl, then the beasts and finally man, and from his rib, the woman were created?

Why rationalise the irrational?
Why defend the indefensible?


M C Gupta
513
513
Review of My Blessing  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)

It is a nice account. I wish you could have more rhyme and rhythm to it so that it could look more like a poem.

The thoughts certainly are valuable for the emotions they evoke.

SUGGESTION--


they always say its a lie.
>> they always say it's a lie.

M C Gupta
514
514
Review of A Journey  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
It is a nice attempt. I suggest you pay a little more attention to writing correctly. Even poetry merits proper language.

************

This is just something i was thinking about cause my mind like to wander alot.
>> This is just something I was thinking about because my mind likes to wander a lot.

**

I look into it and seen visions of my daughters
>> see visions

**

Is this what to come or can I can change the outcome
>> Is this what is to come.......


M C Gupta
515
515
Review of Doomed  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
I can sense that it is good poetry. At the same time, I can sense that I have not been able to fully understand it. I am not sure how much of that inability is attributable to my own comprehensional limitations and how much to your expressional ones.

M C Gupta
516
516
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
It is a nice poem.

You have used punctuation, but not properly. If punctuation is used, it must be used correctly, the period used at the end of a sentence. You have used it randomly, as clear from lines 3, 4, 5, 7, and 8.

The last line is rather vague. The meaning does not come out clearly.

M C Gupta
517
517
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
This is a very good poem, told as a story, that conveys a good moral / lesson that is relevant for all times.There are no mistakes. The rhyme used is mostly abab. The meter is not consistent. It would add to the flow if constancy is maintained. This should not be difficult to do, without sacrificing other attributes of this nice poem.

EXAMPLE--

The syllabic counts in the first two stanzas are--

8978
7889

Some lines have 11, 14 syllables etc.

There are no mistakes.

M C Gupta
518
518
Review of MAD COW DISEASE?  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

I rate this excellent for the following reasons:

It has constant meter--tetrameter

It has constant rhyme, a difficult type--abab

It has humour, which is rarer than tears

It has no mistakes, flows well and brings a smile.

The last remark refers to--


“But hon,” says I, “I’m scared to death.
T’was you who said I’ve ‘alf a brain.”
“Oh, hush my luv, and save your breath;
a ‘alf-wit, yes, but not insane.

"They’re slipp’ry pitchmen, thick as thieves;
it’s how Gitano’s ply their gigs.
Why, you can’t catch mad cow disease,
cuz doncha know that men are pigs?”



M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT








519
519
Review of Deeper  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem.

SUGGESTED CORRECTION--

waiting for the day
that someone comes
to take me in their arms
and hold me till
The End.
>>>>

waiting for the day
when someone comes
to take me in the arms
and holds me till
The End.


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT

520
520
Review of The Guy  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.
It is a nice poem, on a theme that is not often, so vividly at least, the subject of poetry. You have portrayed well the longing, the day dreaming, the angst, the frustration, the jealousy and the hatred --all at the same time.


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
521
521
Review of Beach Scene  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem. You have displayed special skills in alliteration. The description of the nature's silent beauty is remarkable.


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT

522
522
Review of solitary rose  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a very good poem, basically. The thought behind it is great and the thought / idea have been beautifully and convincingly developed, maintaining the poetic flavour. It should have earned a higher score, but I am unable to be comfortable with the too many liberties you have taken here in the same genre as the following--

Stood alone against the elements, yet im destined to thrive,

>> I am destined......


I believe that good poetry is much more than a good idea or feeling. Proper language (grammar, spelling, punctuation etc.), rhyme and meter are almost certain to add beauty.



M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT

523
523
Review of Day Dream  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem but has too many mistakes. Just as a beautiful dame in an ugly dress, this poem needs to be dressed up. Hints are given below.


so loud it seemed to big for their bodies,
>> too big

stop do not move stay still,
>> stop do not move, stay still,

They made a bubble,
that laid in the grass,
>> that lay....


It was colored with rainbow,
pretty rainbows

>> It was colored with rainbows,
pretty rainbows

as I awoke from my dream daydream.
>> as I awoke from my dream, daydream.


M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT

524
524
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.0)
Ref:

"God, I am doing such and such -- and I do not even want to stop -- and I confess NOT WANTING to stop AS SIN and look to you to forgive me and cleanse me of ALL unrighteousness." AND HE DOES --

*****

The thesis you seem to be propounding is too brazen. You seem to be suggesting that if a sinner wilfully continues in sin, and wants to continue as such, without any intention on his part to do otherwise, it is OK for him to do so, without let or hindrance, without fear of suffering the consequences, without facing retribution, as long he posts a letter to God informing Him that he is doing the act and does not want to stop doing the act, but adds, as a footnote, that God may kindly forgive him and make him righteous.

If what I have stated above is correct (I have simply paraphrased your quoted statement), it does not motivate me at all.

I would expect God to come to the rescue of a person who says something like this--

"God, I am doing such and such. I know it is a sin. I want to stop continuing to sin. But I am weak in the face of temptation. I am unable to help myself. Please forgive me for what I have done and please give me strength that I may not do so again. Please cleanse me of unrighteousness."

M C Gupta
525
525
Review of The Spell  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Thanks for entering your poem in the "FIVE STAR POETRY CONTEST:editor's choice.

It is a nice poem. The scene you have managed to create through words, with an ambience of love and sorrow, is one of quiet but turbulent emotions.

M C Gupta

*********
"POETRY IN RHYME - RHYTHM CONTEST-winner
"SONNET AND GHAZAL CONTEST: Closed

"PLEASE REVIEW MY PORT
2,011 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 81 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mcgupta44/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/21